The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2001 Resolution No. 071RESOLUTION No.7L SERIES OF 2001 A RESOLUTION DESIGNATING THE 2734 SOUTH ACOMA STREET AS AN HISTORIC PROPERTY IN THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO. WHEltEAS, the Englewood City Council enacted a Historic Preservation Ordinance in an effort to praaerve, protect and pro me · · the value of historic properties located within the City of Englevtood; and WHT>REAS, the bouae located at 2734 South Acoma was erected in 1919; and 'N"dEREAS, this structure is representative of the "arto and crafts" style interior, and architectural type which is valuable for the study of this period; and WHEREAS , the fireplace is constructed with rock indigenous tc, Colorado and the windows throughout reflect unusual markings indicating a rare window-making technique which epitomizes a scyle of home built in early Englewood; and WHEREAS, one of the early owners of the property, George I. Sclieneman, waa a popular woodworker in Englewood and utilized this property as bis office; and WHEREAS, 2734 South Acoma Street meets all of the criteria set forth in the Englewood Historic Preservation Onlina.uce: it is at least 50 years old ; and it is a structure connected to a person significant to the history of Englewood; and it reflects the broad social history of Englewood ; WHEREAS, the Englewood Planning and Zoning Commission held a Public Hearing on August 21, 2001 and the Englewood Planning and Zoning Commiaaion recommended designation of 2734 South Acoma Street as a privately owned, Englewood Historic property; NOW , THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO , THAT: ~-2734 South Acoma Street be designated a historic property. ADOPTED AND APPROVED this !st of October, 2001. CITY OF ENGLEWOOD 3400 S. Elati Street Englewood, CO 80110 Historic Preservation Application For Individual Property Designation Applicant Information f""1 Name of Applicant 6-t I • Li:1i.rJ 'Bado ·11," Telephone Number 5'>3 7[1-7!{sS" Address of Applicant :n.14 .S . th1m19, I ~o"l '"wccd ) Cc lg;.uo Name of Property Owner -""~'-----£~------------ Property Information Address of Property Legal Description of Stru cture ___ {..,.,Ju...._.9_f:....:...;I0=---------.. -1Ld1.1l.,.os.:,•:.,,#::::.;..· __ _ ''71t!I t.,rCf"1Js Age of Structure .Jjfuverification r uired b as ' · · '' ~'.~ "::i.. 1- . . . . ....l,li.J.I...J-;llc,.L!'"-,J~~i.,...;i.:!Lc=ii<i.,-t!!!lU:lll-=1......IC......!,.:!,:Lll..~jl.f:i....!!!Z.;l:.f!e!!..U:L.llt....l.!1. l'P.$, ~ • Seioo<, ......_...._......,_"""'.....,..._ ...... 11.¥-....... +-'-...... ..,___......,_...._._...i ...... ""-'lc.......,....:.u;.....,=....=....,=.:;..,:"-6..;..1r rt<«II~ . •~ ], ~ 1,;1'1 ~j L /) .).• ''~~ 'fhL S.u." . •:~ -.; ,., l'c!J --• . • . • c~ ~ , •QI I\· . c $•~c-?!ao) <i!!-d_; ?;, .-' v .~) JSf #' ma,; .... ~sfil~' ;::;f:,~ ..... ~%~.a.,• 0,.,..,.,-.., ,,.k_ b•~~.'°"' • Required Materials : Reproducible photo of property be.~ "o 1:'.~~· Jv=p~ Check in the amount of SI 00 .00 pa yable to the City of Englewood .,w~...,,.__ Office Use Only c,-1/rt /o; Date of Application _;;;E'j(z'.q.1 -;J:.'~'5-:J:.}Qi?.1.1 __ Fee Paid ~?.,,.1.L't..,~tu·~L!l ___ ~.,_/-"c.._11_• _•"' __ Attachments : Criteria for Designat io n Public Hearing Date ~/ ,;J I/('/ 7 Check Number ;/pJJ t-' II~ ~ \\' 11 l '1 /.!fl~ 1 • 00~ 11 ll13 I, Louc:rilhia A. Ellia , City Clerk for the City of Enclew above ia a true copy of Re10lution No .21., Seriea of 2 · • • • • OITERIA FOR HISTORICAL ~ESERVATION APPLICATION 1. All buildings, structures or districts: The Pl1nnlng and Zonln9 Commission sh al l use '\le following criteria to determine whether a building, structure or district has archltecll ti or hlslcric significance : A. Only buildings or structures which have been in existence for at least fifty (SO) years, or di,tricts in which the majr ·ity of structures have been in existence for ~t least fifty (SO) years may be designateo . In addition, such building, structure or disbi~ must also meet one of the follow ing criteria: A building, structure , or a majority of structures within a district which have some connection to events or persons significant to the history of the City of Englewood, Arapahoe County, the State of Colorado, or the United States; or ii . A building, structure or a group of structures within a district which embody distin~uishing characteristics of an architectural type inherendy valuabl~ for a study of a period, style, method of construction, or of indlge~ous materials or craftsmanship ; or iii . A building, structure or a group of structures within a district which exemplifies or reflects the broad culture, political , economic, or social history of the City of Englewood, Arapahoe County, thl! State of Colorado, or the United States; or iv . Those buildings , structures or districts within the City which are listed in the National Register of Histo ri c Places shall be cons t 1Jed as having local historic designation, and subject to the same provisions as an y local historic building, structure or district 2. Districts : The Planning and Zon ing Commiss ion shall use the fo llowing additional criteria to determ ine whether a district has architectural or his to ic significance : A. Significance is determined by applying the criteria of subse cti on 1, of th is Section to the pattern (s) and unifying elementjs). B. Nominations will not be approved unless the application contains written approval from the owners of at least two-thirds (2/3) of the properties within the district bound aries . C. Properties that do not co ntribu ,e lo the sign ifi canc e of the historic distri ct may be included with in the boundaries so long as the noncontributing elements do not noticeably detract from the district's sense of time, place, and hi storical development Noncontributing elements will be evaluated for their magnitude of impact by considering their size , scale, design, loc at ion , and, or information potential. tlGOUP\aOAlDN't.AHCOMM\Slllf,..,_,\Sllff l-,ons!DCI IIHilaPfflo....,_.:n,.s ,._,._ o. Olslrict boundarltt ~ ba'~ lly Yllliil chanie,, hts\orfial aocumentadon of different associations or patterns of developmen~ or evidence of chaoses In site type or site density as estalillshed throush tesdns or SIIM!y. "" E. When dls1rlcls are deslsnated, applicable deslsn suldellnes and other appropriate restriclions may be induded as part 0 1' th• deslsnadon . F. The district could be exempt frorr .:,:: ase standard if the other slsnificant criteria are fat ,d exceptionally Important • • • CITY OE ENGLEWOOD PLANNING AND ZONING CO~M]J,.s,,Q.N IN THE MA TIER OF CASE #HD-2001-01 FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS RELATING TO HISTORIC DESIGNATION OF A PRIVATELY OWNED RESIDENCE AT 2734 SOUTH ACOMA, ENGLEWOOD, CO. INITIATED BY : Bill and Laun Bartnick 2734 South Acoma Street Englewood, Colorado 80110 n I FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF THE CITY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION Commission Members Present: Y..rieger, Lathram , Mueller, Stockwell, Welker, Willis, Waggoner Commission Members Absent: Rempel, Weber This matter was heard before the City Planning and Zoning Commission on August 21, 2001, in the City Council Chambers of the Englewood Civic Center. Testimony was received from staff and from the applicant. The Commission received notice of Public Hearing, and the StalTReport, which were incorporated into and made a part of the record of the Public Hearing . After considering the statements of the witnesses, and reviewing the pertinent documents, the members of the City Planning and Zoning Commission made th~ following Findings and Con- clusions . FINDINGS OF FACT I. THAT the application for Historic Designation of the property at 2734 South Acoma Street , was filed by Mr. and Mrs . Bill Bartnick, owners and residents of 2734 South Acoma Street. 2. THAT notice of the Public Hearing was given by publication in the official City newspa- per, the Englewood Herald , on August 10, 2001. 3 . THAT testimony was received from Senior Manager Lauri Dannemiller regarding eligi- bility of 2734 South Acoma Street for Historic Designation. K (;lOl..,eoAaDS.tt.AN(."OMMf......,.r~~I ror -11D :0111.0 1 •• lJJ•S A-.M 4. -I 1'11,\T te.'ltimony was rec~~ed 6-om applicant ltaunil!Urtnidlc, ownerand nilliilentfm 2734 South Acoma Stmt, regarding her desire to prcst.Ne the residence and to improve the neighborhood. t 11 II S. THAT no member of the general public was in attendance tb address t'·e Commissic!o on this issue. I ll. CONCLUSIONS I, .,, I II ! . THAT the application for Historic Designation of the 2734 South Acoma Stm:t was filed by a Bill and Laura Bartnick, owners and residents of 2734 South Acoma Sl1ect. 2. THAT proper public notice of the Public Hearing was given by publication in the Engle- ~ Herald on August I 0, 200 I. 3. THAT the 2734 South Acoma Street does meet eligibility requirements for Historic Dcs- ign.ttion: b. The structure must be at least 50 years old. This particular structure was built iff 1919. The building, str>tcture, or group of structures within a district which embody dis- tinguishing characteristics of an architectural type inherently valuable for a study of a period, style, method of construction, or of indigenous materials or crafts- manship. The stnichN r,prese11ts the "Arts & Crafa" style interior, an architectural type valuable for tlie study eftliis pmod. Additzono!ly, tliefir,plaa is constnicted with rock indigtnD11S to Colorado. The windows tliroughoul reflect unusual markmgs i11dicating a rare window-making itchniqut. c. The building or structure must exemplify or reflect the broad cultural, political, economic or social history of the City of Englewood, Arapahoe County, the State of Colorado, or the United States. 011e '![the earb• ou·ners eftl,e property, G,orge I. Scheneman, was a popular woodworker m //,e E11gle-.,,ood area a11d utit,zed tliis property as his office. DECISION THEREFORE, it is the decision of the City Planning and Zoning Cvmmission that the property at 2734 South Acoma Street , should be granted Historic Designation status. • The decision was reached upon a vote on a motion made at the meeting of the City Planning and • Zoning Commission on Aug~st 21, 2001, by Welker. seconded by Krieger, which motion states: H Gl Ol P 90.U.DS ,'LANC'OM .... fNlllp FN!llf' !UGI FOF ,. 110 :001-01 -!71' S AC,-,_ , ' . ,,.tr.:,, "The Plluuting Commission recommends historic~ fo 6734 SOUlll AcGllla SUcc1, Eualewood, Colo . " I L I AYES: Krieger, Lathnun, Mueller, Stockwell, Welkh, Willia, Wauoner ,, NAYS : ABSTAIN : ABSENT : None None Rempel , Weber These Findings and Conclusions are effective as of the meeting on Augu5t 2t~'ioo( BY ORDER OF THE CITY PLANNING & WNING COMMISSION H'(;IQU~'«:ONM'lr.....,. .... klOllfOf'-HDl00141 -l1MS Acaa.M PUBLIC .NOTICES Ellglewood Hnld -August 10, 2001 • P11ge 'rT -- .... ,,., ___ 1Y".11~Z... ~C..dCowt l'r: IIUUII'---- ,,,._. Oa,lulltll c.-1 , ......... A,U._ • ._,. .......... ~w...,. 0ono,w,. JlaC.- ,-.c=--111c.a · l'l':l'lll. ....... --fllol'~,Nlf'l1,2DD1 =-..:i.=I0.2D01 ~.~~ C...No.O'IPMln _ .. -~---... -.... ~....-__ ....,...., ____ ~,_.o,__,._ blll\ll o, ID lft,, !Ml~ Coun of AtaNIK~C, .. t;,Coto.NOOfl« Mi.r1 oec-1,. 2001 , ot 1M _._"'., .............. -L-... ,m';,,.,-r .-...COIDOtl --.... ,~.,c. t..a..lA.,..._,_,lt1MI ,._ ... ,.__ .... ,_. '4Cl1 s.a...S1.11cra o.-.cocm.-, --,.,,.,.,....__,_.. ""'"'-..... ''_, ..... 1'1.-. ... 24,2DG1 rn,..ooa""-■, ... £~~ C...No.01,-:71 -.. -·---All ... ,....~ ... .. ........., __ ,..... ~---------t111•eortotfte011tnctCoW'lot Ar1N11oe Cowmy. CMtNo Oft • "'°'• oec:..,.oer 10. 1001 . or 11te o.Ml'l-,IMi..-lllllTIG. ...,.._,...,_.,_ lZ!:k s.~a O--,C0111Z12 -· --Sailm.Maca&SllirNll'.,.c . DIWIFSl■lnc:lf ,No.,-, 3J:J:l 5 111rnx11S....1110 ~CO IO IIO m-rt, .... 900 ""°"""t2,,,,__,.__.... ,. .... ,.,........_.,.10.2001 F'11111~...-2•.zoo1 e,..._i~,.., .. -"· -:- f r: l'UILICNCITIC« L-.C0•n1:1 --_,,_ ..,t_.. ....... ....,.,.....,.___ --.... ~~10,2001 NOTICI II HIJIDY CJNIN tl'IM 1 ,__"-_.....: •• 200, pi.---,• -.......... ...... ~ ... __ ................ lft incl' ...... "--°""""'"''· 200111l:OOo.•.alllleAta$1MN ~ ............... S'Dtl. PUBLIC IIO'llCI! l'nnc1S1rNf,l1MH .. nnt,IOCM11 , N01'1CI TO CMDfTOM _ .__. C.. .... l"ll'flD'ffl' ,,_...,..~10.2001 -.. .....-i~•-----,_ PUBLIC NOTICI! ,....,_..,.... .... ~ NCfflCII TO CIIIDll0III C..Ne.01P'Mll1 .. ~---~-.....,,., 111W911,_IO :'ll lllflm'III,__. lltl'II Of to :f'!1 0 111ne1 Co1111 of -.. At11HIIN Co""", COlorlCIO on or ---~1ZD0t.«,-cs... DWJaT,Al.allllCHT ~----------Clflt0...10...li'C. ... ~,.,..~ ....... 7Sl5e.._...._,._,rn .. ..,...,... __ ,...... 0.-.COlfml ....,...,., .. ~~ _.,._ 1111.,, r:,, :o tlle 01 .. ne1 Co,m ot Ckiol&O-.•c. Araoanc,e Covnr,, ColotMO OIi Of t1M.:11e OeumMr 10, 1001 . o, rfte 1'531l."-'OWl-. . ._,o, -l!Wftle ....... llMal. 0.-.coa:11 ., ... -·-..._.,._~,___ QIIIIIZ...&---.,c. J7730..,C-No.Dr~,.. ""'-"'-'.,,....,0.2001 0.-.CC-IIWJil--.,,..._:M.2001 --~ ..... , .. .,., . ....,__,.,,ll7S ---ffl'3a.tyO-.... O,.,., PUBLIC IIO'llCI! o.-.coma NCfflCIITOClllllfflll!S ,......,, C...Na.O'I,_. ....,.,.,a,--"---· ,.,."'-,.,..10.2001 ,._,._,.,...a,.,aio, -.. ,,......_._ ........... -· PU■UC NOTICI! M~,-.dlillll ..... NCfflCIITO__,.,.. .. .,....._ __ ,......, c..-.01,..,0 ~---,.-~ -· ta""• o, ro •fie Dlttnct Coun ol A,an,toe eo..,.,.,, Coio,aao on o, -.. r>slo,eoec:-OerlO.ZOOl .or tM ~,...,tle.._taff'III, -------------J.tOMIMIISI. O.-.C01C121)1 .... _,,.,....,~.,..... --~ ............. __ ,__ID ... ,aa..;,c. ~t-1\IO .. ~,.-eoi-,c.~m:,o tah•• or ro l1MI 0111na Court :lit Aru111oec__.,.c o11,.d0 on o, 1mi......St.4IO be!Ore Oec:emOlr 10, 2001 . or 11'1• o.-.::oaazaz caor.....,11e___.--. -"""'-,lar,,._..,_.___,. SlncnA.AollClooffl :IICll)S,~-,,...~ ..... 1Q.JOC11 0-,.,lal ....... GO IOIIO ~,....,_.~2•.:001 --~---,1111 JOMJ ............ Ela. 114,wao........_s...2.ta .. CITY Of INGUWOOD NOT1C2 DI' AOOl"T10N 0,- .:00, ........ PUIUCNOTICI """'--cm..__ --.:..=-~~:i:::: , .... o.w. nte ci., ,._..,.. MO Z-.~11----lfl __ ..-.-i ____ .s..i~ ........... .._ .. _..,....11 .... ,. __ ~= .. -:::..::-:= --· :=-J.;.:1 "---~10.2001 .,,...._, ....... """ PU■uc NOT1CI """'---_..__ --Al'\aic,.......!'!M~_,__1 1or..-a,.aic11 .... nowo11011 i, M. NfOrl tlle Clf\l' Ptan11111t atl'J Zon1111 C~,..,_ 10 con....., 111 _._,,.~C>:...-.of ~edctrfl..0H2715Soutfl --Aff\'One..._...,lllltMICINl9Nlli1 -eG IOlffailldll'lefflNftftillftlM lf1911twoac1C.tyCOullCII~. 1000 &:"9~ ,,., ....... Oft 11'1• .,..._IS■-MClll!M~ -:wa,..,,.e1....,_. --l'l.oriln■o ...... 10.2001 l,..,....ai.-■11111 PU■LICNOTlCI! """'---cm..-..., --",,,.."---... ~~ 1ar.-...,21.n11,11tt1eP"OWaf700 1'.W. i,etor• ma Cit\' flt1n111111 aM ~~"'•----plicllnontorWtllO,ie ,.,.,..._,o, 111"ooertvlCJGl'11..0 .,,273,Sou111 Am!IDS...&,,,..-s.C-.. A.nyone..,.....,111'3'111 ....,,t tfl""ICIIO 1rtend 1n1 meetffl9111rt1e Eng1ewooo c.ry Counc,t Cl'lafnOert . 1000 c ... ,,_ 111 11•••1. on 111• ,,o,.,a,ou,.ano.11 111e.atoretald -t1GelffllOIU ,,,,_ --~~10.200, EJllilllW000__,•117'1 CITY OF ENGLl:WOOD NCTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING le,..,..,.. ...... Cly ... ca, .......... c.. COUNCIL COMMUNICATION II II J/1 ' DATE: AGENDA ITEM SUBJECT: Historic Property October 1, 2001 11 C ii Designation -2734 South Acoll)a INITIATED BY : STAFF SOURCE : Community Development Lauri Dannemiller, Senior Manager COUNCIL GOAL AND PREVIOUS COUNCIL AQ]ON: No previous action has been taken on this matter. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Staff recommends that City Council adopt the attached Resolution for Historic Property Designation for the property located at 2734 South Acoma Street. BACKGROUND: This application, initiated by p1operty owners Bill and L,,ura Bartnick is for the structure located at 2734 South Acoma. Erected in 1913, this structure is re11resentative of the "arts & crafts• style interior, an architectw .,I type valuable for the study of thh· period. The Arts and Crafts architectural movement was made popular in the late 19" Centu,y in Europe, sharing some elements of the Art Nouveau movemen~ based in organic shapes. The Craftsman Style is characterized by low-pitched, gabled roofs with wide eave overhangs, exposed and extended roof rafters, decorative beams under the gables, projecting balconies and second sto,y porches. Tapered square columns typically support the roofs. its concern for detail lends itself to planned "decor" with built-in furniture, stairways, windows, doorways, walls and floors all constructed in the same carved and polished wood. Na tural materials such as redwood, tile, and stone and earth colors accent the interiors. The fireplace is constructed with rock indigenous to Colorado and the windows throughout reflect unusua1 markings indicating a rare window-making technique. Additionally, one of the early owners of the property, George I. Scheneman, was a popular woodworker in the Englewood area and utilized this property as his office . Staff recommends approval of this application based on the criteria set forth in Historic Preservation Ordinance (E .M.C. 99-75) and is supported by documentation ass erting the structure is : • at least SO years old; • a building, structure or group of structures within a district which embody distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type inherently valuable for a study of a period, style, method of construction, o r of indigenous materials or craftsmanship ; • a structure that exemplifies the broad cultural , political, ec o nomic or social histo,y of the City of Englewoo d. On August 21, 2001 a Public Hearing was held beiore the Enilewood Planning and Zoning Commission. The Commission unanimously recommended this property for Historic Property designation. Findings of Fact were approved on September S, 2001 and support of this recommendation is being passed on to City Council for final authorization. EINANCfAL IMPACT; ...,OITI-)l~dlM/0 II '1 JO l None l'!tn Jt LIST OF ATTAQIMENTS: Resolution for Historic Property Designation Historic Preservation Application Public Notice -Englewood Herald August 10, 2001 Findings of Fact ll )/ . . HA1 • 18 r, 11/ IT Jl'l JI J IC )t JI , )