Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1986 Board of Adjustment and Appeals HandbookI I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I BOARD of ADJUSTMENT and APPEALS I Jo 3/?~. (..___) c ) (...___) ( ) ENGLEWOOD .COLORADO I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I This Handbook of the Englewood Board of Adjustment and Appeals has been prepared through the conscientious endeavors of the following Board members and City staff: Board of Adjustment and Appeals Members: Ronald H. Fish, Chairman Howard Brown, Vice Olairrnan Kenneth Ferguson Roger Gage Chester Halligan Lois Lighthall Donald Seymour Staff: Nancy N. Reid, Assistant City Attorney Beverly J. Brizee, Paralegal Dorothy A. Romans, Advisor Mary Alice Rothweiler, Planner I Sheryl Rousses, Recording Secretary 3/86 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION • II. MEMBERSHIP 1. Appointment and Qualifications of Members 2. Removal and Vacancies III. RULES OF PROCEDURE 1. Officers 2. Quorum 3. Meetings 4. Notice 5. Special Meetings 6. Attendance 7. Voting Requirements 8. Conflicts of Interest 9. Jurisdiction 10. Appeal Procedures 11. The Calendar 12. Final Disposition of Cases 13. Zoning Appeals 14. Adoption of Rules 15. Rights of Applicants 16. Public Record IV. HEARING POLICY AND PROCEDURES • A. Hearing Policy B. Procedures Outline .Meeting Procedures .Hearing Preliminaries .Public Hearing .Closing the Public Hearing .Deliberations .Findings of Fact .Further Meeting Procedures V. GENERAL GUIDELINES FOR USE IN DECISION MAKING • VI. POWERS AND DUTIES • 1. Duties Described in the Charter 2. Variance from Housing Code 3. Variance from Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance i 1 2 3 10 18 21 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I VII. APPEAL FROM BOARD'S DECISION • VIII. CHARTER, ORDINANCES AND STATUTES Art. VIII, Pt. III, Home Rule Charter • 1-10-2 et seq., Englewood Municipal Code 1985 16.2 et seq, Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance • 18-8-101 et seq., Colorado Revised Statutes • Variances IX. APPLICANT INFORMATION X. CITY ORGANIZATION AND OTHER COMMISSIONS AND BOARDS City Organization Chart Commissions and Boards Board of Adjustment and Appeals Board of Career Service Commissioners Election Commission Firemen's Pension Board Library Board Parks and Recreation Commission Planning and Zoning Commission Policemen's Pension Board Water and Sewer Board XI. CITY ZONING MAP 27 28 29 35 41 47 50 62 63 67 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I. INTRODUCTION The City Charter provides in Article VIII, Section 53, that Boards and Commissions shall be appointed by the Council and have such powers and perform such duties as are required by the Charter or by ordinance. Initial appointments by the Council shall specify the term of office of each individual in order to achieve overlapping tenure. All members shall be subject to removal by the appointing authority. Article VIII, Part III, Section 59, of the Home Rule Charter provides for the creation of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals to be comprised of qualified tax-paying electors of the City. Section 60 of the same Article provides for the powers and duties of the Board and states that the Board shall exercise its authority in accordance with State Statutes, except as otherwise provided in the Charter. These rules and regulations are adopted pursuant to 16.2-8 d Englewood Municipal Code 1985. 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I II. MEMBERSHIP 1. Membership in the Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall consist of seven (7) members appointed by Council, for overlapping terms of four (4) years. Members shall be qualified tax-paying electors, residents of the City at least one (1) year immediately prior to the date of their appointment, and shall hold no other office or position in the City Administration. If any member ceases to reside in the City, his membership shall immediately terminate. Art. VIII, Part III, Sec. 59, Charter. 2. Members may be removed by the appointing authority. 3. Council shall make appointments to fill vacancies for any unexpired terms. 4. The City Manager shall provide a recording secretary for the Board. Art. VIII, Sec. 53, Charter. 5. The City Manager shall designate a staff advisor for the Board. Such staff member shall be from Planning Division (pursuant to Administration Procedures) • 2 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I III. RULES OF PROCEDURE Officers 1. At the February meeting of each year, the Board shall elect a chairman to preside at meetings during the ensuing year and a vice chairman to preside at meetings during the absence or disability of the chairman. In the absence of both the chairman and the vice chairman, the member of the Board designated by the majority shall preside. The Board shall operate in accordance with Roberts Rules of Order unless it is in conflict with these rules. 2. The chairman, subject to these rules, shall decide all points of order or procedure, unless otherwise directed by a majority of the Board in session at the time. 3. The recording secretary shall be appointed by the appointing authority and shall sign all documents or communications from the Board, "By Order of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals." Officers and Meetings 1. The Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall choose its own chairman and vice chairman from its membership to serve for a term of one (1) year, with the provision for re-election. The Board shall operate in accordance with Roberts Rules of Order unless it is in conflict with these rules. 2. Regular meetings of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall be held on the second Wednesday of each month beginning at 7:30 p.m., provided, however, if the second Wednesday of the month falls on a holiday, or for other good cause, the Board will convene the following Wednesday. Date and time for meetings are set by the Board. Notice of change of date shall be published in the official newspaper of the City of Englewood in time for at least one publi- cation of such change in date. A business session of the Board may be held prior to hearings and executive session after hearings or on call of chairman or motion of members of the Board. 3. Special meetings and hearings shall be held at the call of the chairman and at such other times as a majority of the members of the Board may request. All members shall be notified by telephone or in writing of any such special meetings. 4. public. All regular meetings and hearings shall be open to the (Charter Art. VIII, Sec. 53) 3 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 5. The quorum for the Board of seven (7) members shall be five (5). When only a quorum is present; a concurring vote of four (4) members shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirement, decision or determination of any administrative official or to decide in favor of the applicant on any matter upon which the Board is required to pass. When six or seven members of the Board are present, a concurring vote of five members shall be necessary to affect the above. (16.2-9 Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) When there are abstentions, the quorum is reduced by the number of abstentions. 6. When a specific future meeting has been set for taking action on a proposal in whicq it is necessary to inspect a certain location, the members of the Board shall, if at all possible, view the location prior to the specified meeting. 7. The members of the Board shall attend the meetings in person. 8. The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings and show the vote taken. It shall also keep records of its examinations and other official actions, and such records shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk (Charter, Art. VIII, Part III, Sec. 60). 9. No member of the Board shall vote upon any appeal or variance in which he may have a personal or financial interest, in which case, he must disqualify himself. 10. An appeal to the Board of Adjustment and Appeals may be taken by any aggrieved person or by any officer, department, board or commission of the City of Englewood. Such appeal shall be taken within thirty (30) days after the date of the decision or notice, or, in the case of placarding a housing unit, seventy-two (72) hours from the time of placarding, by filing with the secretary for the Board of Adjustment a proper form of appeal specifying the grounds therefor. (8-2A-3 EMC 1985; 16.2-8 Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) 11. Other appeals may be taken from: a. Building Contractor's License Denial, Review (5-7-5B EMC 1985) b. Electrical Contractor's Certificate Suspension, Revocation or Denial (5-7A-6B EMC 1985) c. Auto Wrecking and Junkyards, 5-10-9, EMC 1985, Variances; Modifications d. Burglary Prevention, Appeal from Intrusion Detection Device Requirements (7-4-9 EMC 1985) 4 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I e. Building Code (8-2A-3 EMC 1985) f. Fire Code (8-2E-8 EMC 1985) g. Housing Regulation (9-1-9~1); Appeal Notice or Order h. Housing Regulations (9-1-9-3 EMC 1985) i. Streets and Sidewalks (ll-3A-4 EMC 1985); Appealing Decision of Public Works 5 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Appeal Procedures Cases before the Board 1. Every appeal to the Board shall name the owner and agent of the affected property on the forms specifically provided and shall include the date required in such forms, so as to supply all the information (including such plans or plats as may be necessary) required for a clear understanding of the case and intelligent action by the Board. 2. Any person making appeal to the Board shall deposit at the time of appeal a sum determined by the City Council as necessary to pay for the reasonable cost of such appeal. 3. At the time of filing matters of variances, the appellant shall be furnished wording for a sign not less than twenty-two inches by twenty-eight inches (22" x 28"), with lettering not less than two inches (2") high, to be installed four feet (4') above ground level. Such notice shall state the date, place, and nature of hearing and shall be posted conspicuously for fifteen (15) days immediately prior to the hearing and notice published in the official newspaper of the City of Englewood, at least once, ten (10) days prior to the hearing. (16.2-10 Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) The Calendar Each case filed in the proper form, with the required data, shall be numbered serially and shall be placed on the Recording Secretary's calendar. The calendar numbers shall begin anew on January 1 of each year and shall be hyphenated with the number of the year, i.e., #1-70. Final Disposition of Cases 1. Every decision of the Board on any case shall be by motion. 2. The final disposition of an appeal before the Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall be in the form of a motion, either sustaining, reversing, or modifying the order, requirement, decision, or determination from which appeal is taken. 6 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 3. The Board may dismiss appeals before them for failure of the applicant or his representative to complete fully all required questions on the application or failure -to comply with the requirements of these rules, or for failure to the applicant or his representative to appear at the scheduled hearing. 4. No appeal dismissed or denied can be considered again except: a. on motion to reconsider the vote; or b. on a request for a rehearing. No request to grant a rehearing can be entertained unless such request be filed in the office of the Board within thirty (30) days from the date of the original decision on the case, or unless new evidence is submitted in writing which could not have been presented at the previous hearing. If, on motion of a member of the Board and adopted by affirmative votes of four of a quorum of five members, or five affirmative votes of six or seven members present, the request for a reconsideration or rehearing is granted, the case shall be put on the calendar for reconsideration or rehearing and the parties appearing in the original case notified in writing or by telephone of date of rehearing. The Board may, on the motion of a member, review any decision that it has made and may reverse or modify such decision, but no such review shall prejudice the rights of any person who has acted in good faith upon such decision before it is reversed or modified. Zoning Variances and Appeals 1. Only in a specific case will the Board hear an applica- tion for a variance from the course prescribed by the Zoning Ordinance or an appeal from a determination made by the Department of Community Development on the ground that the proposed plan or use is contrary to the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance. 2. No appeal shall be entertained unless it is filed within thirty (30) days after the date of the action of the Department of Community Development. Said appeal must be filed with the Board in a proper form and specify the grounds therefor with data and plans pertinent to the case. 3. The Board shall not be required to hold hearings on proposals which have been denied within the previous twelve (12) calendar months unless new evidence pertaining to the case is submitted in writing by appellant. 7 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 4. Ex piration of Va r iance. Any variance granted by the Board shall automatically expire within one hundred eighty (180) days from the date it was granted, or within such other time as the Board may prescribe, unless a building permit for the action which was the subject of the variance is obtained within such period of time and work started or the approved use implemented. Extensions of time may be granted for good cause shown, but only if an application for the extension is made prior to the expiration of the variance. (16.2-8 f Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance; 8-1-7 EMC 1985) Adoption of Rules 1. Amendments to these Rules of Procedure may be made by the Board of Adjustment at any regular meeting upon the affirmative vote of four members of a quorum of five or with the affirmative vote of five with six or seven members present, and copies of such amendments shall be filed with the City Clerk. 2. The suspension of any Rule of Procedure not in conflict y1ith ordinance may be ordered at any meeting by unanimous vote of members present. 8 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I RIGHTS OF APPLICANTS 1. All interested parties have the right, insofar as possible, to have the members of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals free from personal interest or a compromising contact on quasi-judicial matters heard by them. At the commencement of hearing, any member of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals who has a substantial interest in the subject matter of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals matter to be heard, or who has been unable to avoid a prehearing contact with the applicant, any interested party, or staff member of the City with respect to the subject matter of the zoning or rezoning matter to be heard shall reveal such substantial interest or such prehearing contact. If such interest or contact impairs the member's ability to vote on the matter, the member shall so state and shall abstain therefrom to the end that the proceeding shall be fair and shall have the ap pearance of fairness. The staff report on each case is avail- able to all pa~ties and shall not constitute objectionable pre- hearing contact. 2. All interested parties have the right to a hearing conducted with professionalism and decorum. The members of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals should listen to the witnesses' testimony and ask relevant questions pertaining to the matter at issue. Members should refrain from arguing with or exchanging comments with the witness during testimony or offering advice. The Board members must be impartial. If a member's vote will be colored by his or her personal relationship or knowledge of the applicant, that member should abstain. PUBLIC RECORD Clarity of Transcript. If a case before the Board is to be litigated, a transcript of the meeting must be made from the tape recording of .the proceedings. All comments made by the Board members while seated become part of the public record and will be reported in the transcript of hearing. Members should be careful not to talk while another member is speaking so that the person preparing the transcript can distinguish what is being said. 9 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I IV. HEARING POLICY AND PROCEDURES A. HEARING POLICY All quasi-judicial hearings shall be conducted under procedures defined to ensure all interested parties due process of law and shall, in all cases, provide for the following: 1) The administration of oaths to all parties or witnesses who appear for the purpose of testifying upon factual matters. (1-10-1-7 EMC 1985, Swearing in.) 2) The right to be represented by counsel. 3) The right to present and rebut testimony and evidence. 4) The right of a party in interest to cross examine other persons giving testimony, provided that: a) such right is asserted at the meeting in which the · person is giving testimony; b) such right is asserted at the first available opportunity. 5) A record of the hearings, whether by electronic or stenographic reproduction. Any party who submits evidence or testimony shall be entitled to listen to the electronic reproduction of the proceedings at reasonable times, places and circumstances and shall be entitled to a copy of the transcript of the proceedings, or any portion thereof, upon payment of the required fees. 10 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I B. PROCEDURES OUTLINE 1. Meeting Procedures. .Call to Order: .Roll Call: • Quorum: OR • Votes Required: The regular meeting of the Englewood Board of Adjustment and Appeals is now called to order. The Board is author- ized to grant or deny a variance and hear appeals by Part 3, Section 60, of the Englewood City Charter. The Secretary will please call the roll. A quorum of members is present • A quorum is not present. *If there are 6 or 7 members present ••• There are members present; therefore, five affirmative votes will be required to grant a request. *If 5 members are present There are five members present; therefore, four affirmative votes will be required to grant a variance • • Approval of Minutes: We will now consider the minutes of the last meeting. *Entertain motion to approve or approve with corrections. *Receive a second to motion. It has been moved by and seconded by that the minutes of the last meeting be approved (with the following correction). All those in favor say "Aye", opposed "Nay" The minutes are approved as written (or with the following corrections). 11 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 2. .Findings of Fact: We will now consider the Findings of Fact from -the last meeting. *Entertain Motion to approve (or to approve with corrections) • * Receive a Second. • Continued Cases: It has been moved by and seconded by ~~~~~~~~-t~h.--a-=-t the findings in Case(s) No(s). and be approved (with the following corrections) • All those in favor say "Aye" •••• opposed •••• "Nay". The Findings of Fact in Case(s) No(s). and are approved as written (or with the following corrections) • Are there any continued cases? *If so, start wherever the Board was when it adjourned the previous meeting. HEARING -PRELIMINARIES • • The Chairman explains the procedure that is followed at the administrative hearings: We will have the staff identify the request. The applicant may then present evidence in support of the request. Finally, others who wish to speak in favor of or in opposition to the request may do so • • Announce opportunity to be heard: In order to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to speak, those who desire to speak at the hearing should (raise their hand) -or-(sign the pad) so that time can be allotted accord- ingly. If you are represented by counsel, please identify both yourself and counsel. 12 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .The Chairman announces agenda item: 3. PUBLIC HEARING. Case No. ,. · has come before the Board of Adjustment and Appeals for hearing. The Public Hearing regarding Case No. is now open. The Board is author- ized to grant or deny a variance by Part 3, Section 60, of the Englewood City Charter. .verification of Posting: (I have) or (do we have) verification of publication and posting of the subject property.(?) ********************************** [Oath given by Recording Secretary:] [Please raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm to ] [tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth ] [before the City of Englewood Board of Adjustment and Appeals) [so help you God?] ************************************ NOTE: Attorneys need not be sworn in unless they are testifying on their own behalf. Staff members need be sworn in only once. If they testify at more than one hearing, they need be reminded only that they are still under oath. .The Staff Presentation: Will the Staff please give your name and position with the City, and the Secretary wi l l administer the oath. Please identify the request. Are there any questions from Board members? 13 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .Applicant's presentation: The applicant may come forward to testify in this case. Please give your name and address to the Secretary who will administer the oath. You may now present the evidence in support of your request. Are there any questions from the Board? .Proponents' statements: Are there other persons present who wish to speak in favor of this request? *If there are several, look at list or hands and choose one at a time. Or, if all agree, a spokesman may be chosen. Proponent may come forward to testify in this case. Please give your name and address to the secretary and be sworn in. *If there is testimony: Are there any questions from the Board? *Repeat for all proponents. .Opposition Presentation: Are there persons present who wish to speak in opposition to this request? *Same procedure as above. .Recall Witness: Does the Board wish to recall any person who has given testimony? 14 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I *If so, recall and remind them that they are still sworn to tell the t;uth. .Rebuttal, Cross-examination: Does Applicant wish to make a statement in rebuttal? (or ask questions of the witnesses?) *The Chairman has the power to stop any extended rebuttal when statements become duplicated. *Applicant must be allowed to cross-examine witnesses if he wishes at the time they are testifying. .Staff Rebuttal: I would ask that the Staff Report be made a part of the record of this hearing. Does the Staff wish to make additional comments? 4. CHAIRMAN CLOSES THE PUBLIC HEARING: 5. DELIBERATIONS ON HEARINGS. What is the Board's pleasure in this matter? .Motion to: (choices) .Make a decision without discussion; -or- .Open discussion before the Public; -or- .Close the discussion before the Public; -or- .Recess or executive session; -or- .Continue the consideration to a date certain; -or- .Table; -or- • Reop~n the hearing; -or- .Grant or deny the variance. .Second • • vote. .Recording Secretary announces the number of persons voting in favor of, in opposition to, or abstaining. 15 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .Upon hearing the result of the vote, the Chairman rules on the Motion. .Motion and Vote. .Motion • • Second. *If the Board votes to make a decision. A Motion may be made: to approve, to conditionally approve, or to deny the request. *The Motion is to be made in the Aff irmat1ve, The Board will entertain a Motion for a decision. It was moved by and seconded by that . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The members of the Board will now vote on the motion and the Secretary will lock in but not report the results of the vote at this time. 6. FINDINGS OF FACT. The Members will now give their findings in this matter. *All five criteria must be mentioned in the Findings of Fact. It doesn't matter if each person has all five so long as all are mentioned by the end of the vote. (See pages 49 and 58 of this Handbook) If they have all been mentioned before a Member votes, that Member may "concur" with the reasoning of the other Board Members. There are four condi- tions for Sign Code variance. (See pages 48 and 57 of this handbook.) The Secretary will report the results of the vote. *Report of Secretary to the Chairman. *Chairman: members have voted in the affirmative and the request is granted/denied. 16 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I *Tell applicant to contact the Planning Division staff for any necessary information. (Repeat same procedure for each case starting with No. 3) 7. FURTHER MEETING PROCEDURES • • Unscheduled visitors • • Board's Choice. .Staff Choice • • Adjournment. 17 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I V. GENERAL GUIDELINES FOR USE IN DECISION MAKING In general, the situations that will need to be acted on by this Board are those where: 1. Through no fault of the owner of a piece of land, it is of such size, shape, topography, or has such other natural configuration that he would not be able to strictly conform to the zoning requirements. 2. The special requirements of an individual owner are such that he should be allowed to have some small adjustment to the requirements of zoning. 3. The use an owner may wish to make of his building, structure, or land may not be clearly enumerated in the zoning and some clarification needs to be made. 4. A zoning boundary line or interpretation of a statement in the text may not be clearly understandable and interpretation is needed from the Board. Many other additional types of cases will be found as the Board operates. But there will always be those who, warranted or not, will try to usurp for themselves more than their neighbors or the rest of the community has asked for in the way of special privileges or exceptions to the law. Thus, the members of the Board must be: 1. Persons who will evaluate fairly all cases brought before them; 2. Persons having no special interest that would benefit from their being on the Board; 3. Persons understanding thoroughly the principles of zoning and having a general working knowledge of the zoning text and map under which they are operating. 18 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I How to analyze Variance Requests: Variances and requests for interpretation will be found to fall into different categories. Following is a general classifi- cation list and a brief method for analyzing them as a guide for Board of Adjustment. These are not all of the types of requests that will be received, but the general reasoning that should be applied to each type: Dwelling Unit Size Height Should not be granted unless as an alteration to an existing undersized dwelling. Would it not be better to change the height requirements of the zoning, rather than grant a height exception? This type of request should be limited to unusual types of construction or buildings that are not common to the area. Landscaping Requirements should not be reduced unless it is established that extreme hardship exists. Loading Variations in off-street loading requirements for commercial or industrial uses should not be made except in very unusual circumstances. Lot Coverage Should rarely be granted unless lot is unusually small. Lot Size Could the owner not purchase additional adjacent property? Would the variance in lot size also mean additional variances later in yards, etc.? Parking Do not allow reductions below that required unless there are very unusual circumstances. Could additional property be acquired for parking? 19 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Signs What about traffic movement around the area? Many requests may be expected but few should be granted. Well designed signs, meeting requirements of the zoning, should be sufficient in most instances. Uses Not Listed Requests for uses not already listed should be handled as amendments to the zoning and not as Board cases. However, where the interpretation of a use description is concerned, the Board may be called on to interpret whether a proposed use falls within the classification of a listed use-by-right. Window Requirements An important health requirement. Should not be varied unless existing construction prevents meeting requirements. Yard Requirements Could the building be rearranged on the lot? Would it block light and air from the adjacent property? Would the building be in the way of road widening? 20 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I VI. POWERS AND DUTIES Article VIII, Section 60, of the Home Rule Charter defines the duties of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals as follows: The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings, show the vote taken, keep records of its examinations and other official actions. Every order, requirement, decision or determination of the Board shall be filed in the off ice of the City Clerk. The Board shall have power to hear and determine appeals from refusal of building permits; make special exceptions to the terms of the zoning regulations in harmony with their general purpose and intent; authorize variance from the strict application of regulations in such situations and subject to such limitations as may be set by ordinance. The findings and decisions of the Board shall be final, subject only to judicial review. The Board shall exercise its authority in accordance with State Statutes, except as otherwise provided in this Charter. APPEAL FROM DEVELOPMENT CODE REGULATIONS (Uniform Building Code, Uniform Fire Code Housing Regulations) 1. Any person aggrieved by any notice or order issued pursuant to the provisions of the Codes (Uniform Building Code, Uniform Fire Code) may appeal the same to the Board within thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of the notice of any alleged violation, or within seventy-two (72) hours from the time of placarding of any unit by presenting written notice of such appeal to the Recording Secretary. 2. In the determination of any such appeal, the Board of Adjustment and Appeals is hereby granted the authority to interpret, construe and apply the provisions of the Codes. No person shall have the right to assert any claim against any City employee or against the City of Englewood arising out of the enforcement of the provisions of the Codes, unless such claim has first been submitted to the said Board of Adjustment and Appeals in the manner as herein provided. 3. The Board may authorize, upon appeal in specific cases and subject to terms and conditions fixed by the Board, changes from the terms of the Codes as will not adversely affect the public health when, owing to exceptional and extraordinary circumstances, literal enforcement of applicable provisions wil l result in unnecessary hardship to the appellant. The burden of proof shall 21 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I be upon the appellant to show by clear and convincing evidence that: a. The changes will not substantially or permanently injure the appropriate use of the other portions of the dwelling or property involved, or any other property; and b. The changes will be in harmony with the spirit and purpose of the Codes; and c. The changes will protect, preserve, and promote the physical and mental health of the people of the City of Englewood in the same manner and to the same extent as would literal enforcement of the provisions applicable to each particular case. In no event shall any changes granted by the Board constitute, or be construed as a precedent, ground or cause for any other variation or modification by the Board. The Board's power to vary or modify shall be strictly construed. The concurring vote of five (5) members of the Board shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirement, decision or determination of the Chief Building Inspector or to decide in favor of granting a variation or change from the strict application of the provisions of the Codes. (If there is only a quorum present, the concurring vote of four (4) members shall be necessary.) The Board may designate one or more of its own members to act as a Hearing Examiner; however, this procedure may only be used when an appeal from the Housing Code is made. If no appeal is taken, the notice issued by the Director of Community Development or his designee shall become a final order. Any such final order of the Board may be enforced in any Court of competent jurisdiction, after the time for compliance with such order has elapsed. 22 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I VARIANCE FROM THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING ORDINANCE A request for a variance from the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance is considered only at a quasi-judicial hearing. The petitioner shall make application to the Recording Secretary within thirty (30} days from the date of the decision of the Building Official being appealed. The application form shall be completed giving necessary pertinent information, plot plans and building plans, if necessary, and contain the required fee. The secretary shall assign a case number, give a time, date and place of hearing; give wording for sign to be posted on the property; direct public notice thereof in the designated official newspaper of the City. The Board shall have the jurisdiction and power: 1. To hear and decide appeals from and to review any order, requirement, decision or determination by any employee of the Department of Community Development in the enforcement of this Ordinance, and to hear and decide all matters referred to it, or upon which it is required to pass under this Ordinance or any amendment hereto. Appeals to the Board may be made by any person aggrieved by the interpretation or decision in the interpretation of this Ordinance. (16.2-1 a. Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance} 2. To reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or to modify any order, requirement, decision or determination of an employee of the Department of Community Development and to make such order, requirement, decision or determination as in its opinion ought to be made and, to that end, shall have all the powers of the enforc- ing agent. (16.2-8 a. (2) Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) 3.' Public notice of time and place and purpose of such hearing shall be given by one publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days before such hearing. (16.2-8 a. (3) Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) a. No variation or modification of any provision of this Ordinance shall be authorized except after public hearing thereon. Public notice of time, place and purpose of such hearing shall be given by one publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days (Note: in conflict with 1-10-1-6 EMC 1985) before such hearing, and by posting the property affected for not less than fifteen (15) consecutive days prior to said hearing. (16. 2-8 b. (1) (a) Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) 23 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I b. There shall be substantial hardship in applying the strict letter of such provisions, provided that no such variation or modification heretofore or subsequently authorized or existing shall constitute or be construed as a precedent, ground, or cause for any other variation or modification by the Board, and that such power to vary or modify shall be strictly construed as specifically enumerated within the jurisdiction of the Board. c. In the matter of granting variances, the Board shall first find that all of the following conditions are present: (1) No variance or modification of any provisions of the Ordinance shall be authorized except after public hearing thereon. Public notice of time and place and purpose of such hearing shall be given by one publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days before such hearing, and, where appropriate, by posting of the property affected for not less than fifteen (15) consecutive days prior to said hearing. (2) In passing upon variances, the Board of Adjustment may vary the application of the regulations set forth in the Zoning Ordinance only if the Board finds that: (i} By reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness or shape of a specific piece of property on the date this Section takes effect or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of the piece of property, and the strict application of the regulation would result in peculiar and undue practical difficulties for the owner of the property. (ii} The variance, if granted, will observe the spirit of the Zoning Ordinance, secure the public safety and welfare, and achieve substantial justice. (iii} The variance, if granted, will not adversely affect the adjacent property or the neighborhood. (iv) The variance, if granted, will not substantially or permanently impair the appropriate use or development of adjacent property. 24 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I (v) The variance, if granted, is the minimum variance that will afford .relief with the least modification possible of the Zoning Ordinance. (3) In passing upon variances to the Sign Code, Section 16.4-19 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, the Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall determine that: (i) There are special circumstances or conditions, such as the existence of 'buildings, topography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent public right-of-way, which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions must be peculiar to the particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention, and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. (ii) The variance, if authorized, will weaken neither the general purpose of the Zoning Ordinance nor the regulations prescribed for the district in which the sign is located. (iii) The variance, if authorized, will not alter the essential character of the district in which the sign is located. (iv) The variance, if authorized, will not substantially or permanently injure the appropriate use of adjacent conforming property. (4) The Board of Adjustment may not grant any variance relating to the use of property unless it finds, in addition to the findings previously set forth in this Section, that: (i) The property cannot be used for any purpose permitted within the zone district applicable to the property. (ii) The proposed use is the use for the property most compatible with the standards and policies set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. (iii) The proposed use will not be detrimental to nor incompatible with other uses in the neighborhood. 25 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I (iv) The proposed use is the least traffic- intensive use possible which will permit some reasonable use of the property. (v) The alleged difficulty or hardship was not self-imposed. s. A variance for late registration of a nonconforming use may be granted provided there is evidence of legal documentation or other evidence that the use was allowed by the City or some agency thereof at some previous time, or any other agency having juris- diction at the time of the original construction. Examples: at the time of construction the use was permitted and made non- conforming by a change in the zoning ordinance; or a variance was granted by Board of Adjustment; or a use was in existence prior to first zoning ordinance of 1940; or a use was in existence prior to the area being annexed to the City. In addition, a permit or use issued in error by the City may be considered. 6. The Board shall have the authority to require any reasonable stipulation which might be necessary to properly protect the general welfare when granting a variance. (Ask appellant if he agrees to stipulation or if he wishes to amend his request to include the stipulation before granting.) (16.2-8 c. Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance) To enable the Board to discuss and argue the case without prejudice and away from the usual heated atmosphere of the public hearing, the decision of the Board can be discussed in executive sessions, either immediately after the public meeting or after further examination of the sites, where such examination is necessary. However, the decision must be announced at a public meeting and within thirty-five (35) days from the date of the public hearing. Since the records are especially important if a court review of the case is ordered, they should be accurate and complete. The record should be especially explicit in indicating what facts were found, the conclusions that the facts indicated and the reasons behind them. 26 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I VII. APPEAL FROM BOARD'S DECISION Any party aggrieved by the Board's decision, or the City itself, may apply to have said decision reviewed by a court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with the provisions con- tained within the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure, provided the action is commenced not more than thirty (30) days subsequent to the date of said decision. The cost of preparation of the record of the hearing shall be assessed against the appealing party. In the event that such judicial review results in a judicial declaration setting aside or reversing said decision, the members of the Board which rendered such decision may take such steps as may be necessary to obtain an appellate review of the same, either through the institution of original proceedings or through appeal, in their own names, in their representative capacities, as members of the Board rendering the decision. Should any party not comply with the decision of the Board, the members of the Board involved, or the City itself, may, in addition to any other legal remedies which may exist for compelling compliance therewith, petition any court of competent jurisdiction for the entering of a judicial decree compelling compliance with said decision. (1-10-2 EMC 1985) In Sections R-1-A, R-1-B and R-1-C, no variance for a use that was created or changed after May 1, 1985, or that became nonconforming after May 1, 1985, shall be approved without review by the Board and the City Council. First review shall be by the Board. If approved by the Board, the variance shall be referred to the City Council. The City Council shall review the record and a written decision of the Board to determine if the variance complies with the requirements of this Ordinance. No hearing shall be held before City Council. Should the City Council determine the variance does not comply with this Ordinance, the variance shall then be denied. 27 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I HOME RULE CHARTER not be binding on the Council; however, no general city plan, nor zoning ordinance, nor any modification amendment or revision thereof. shall be considered by the Council unless the same shall have been first submitted to the Commission for its examination and recommendation. The Commission shall conduct public hearings as they deem necessary. 59: PART Ill. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS BOARD CREATED Council shall establish by ordinance ·a Board of Adjustment and Appeals, consisting of seven (7) members appointed by Council, for overlapping terms of four (4) years. Members shall be qualified tax-paying electors, residents of the City at least one (1) year immediately prior to the date of their appointment, and shall hold no other office or position in the City Administration. The recording secretary shall sign any documents or communications from the Board, "by order of the Board of Adjustment and Appeals". (Amended 5·5-70) 60: POWERS AND DUTIES The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings, show the \tote taken, keep records of its examinations and other official actions. Every order, requirement, decision or determination of the Board shall be filed in the office of the City Clerk. The Board shall have power to hear and determine appeals from refusal of building permits; make special exceptions to the terms of the zoning regulations in harmony with their general purpose and intent; authorize variances from the strict application of regulations in such situations and subject to such limitations as may be set by ordinance. The findings and decisions of the Board shall be final, subject only to judicial review. The Board shall exercise its authority in accordance with State Statutes, except as otherwise provided in this Charter. PART IV. WATER AND SEWER BOARD 61: BOARD CREATED The Council shall establish by ordinance a Water and Sewer Board. The Board shall consist of the Mayor of the City, two (2) councilmen selected by Council, and six (6) members appointed by the Council from qualified tax-paying electors, serving six (6) overlaP.ping terms of six (6) years. A representative from the City Administration shall be appointed by the City Manager to serve as an ex officio non-voting member. (Amended 5-5-70) C18 3-25-73 -28- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1-10-2: HEARING PROCEDURES: 1-10-2-1: PURPOSE AND APPLICABILITY: The purpose of the rules of procedure contained herein is to provide a uniform, consistent and expeditious method of procedure for the conduct of all hearings held before the City Council or any board, commission or official of the City. The provisions of th is Section shall be applied uniformly in all such hearings; provided, however, that any board, commission or official may supplement the provisions of this Section by the adoption of further rules of procedure not inconsistent herewith . All rules adopted to supplement the provisions of this Section by any board, commission or official shall be reduced to writing and copies thereof shall be made available to the public. Nothing herein contained shall be construed or interpreted to grant to any person a right to appeal to the City Council or to any board, commission or official of the City, or to have a hearing before the same, unless the provisions of the City Charter, any applicable State Statute, or other ordinance, grants such a right, the sole purpose of this Section being to establish procedural rules for hearings otherwise required by the provisions of other laws. (Ord. 68 Series 1981) 1-10-2-2: DEFINITIONS: A. As used in this Section: AGGRIEVED PERSON APPLICANT Any person having a direct and substantial interest in the outcome of any quasi-judicial hearing, or any person having a right of appeal therefrom by virtue of any Charter provision, State Statute or ordinance . The petitioner, appealing party or complainant. -29- I I I I I r-'~/,('/ -r/1, --~'""-' I I I I I ~ ' I I 1-10-L2 1-10-2·3 Al CLERK The City Clerk or the secretary of any board or commission or other appropriate official. B. HEARING BODY OPPONENT The City Council or any board, commission or official of the City. Any person in interest opposing the applicant. Department heads or authorized officials of the City, or the City itself, may be applicant or a respondent, or aggrieved person as the case may be. (Ord . 68 Series 1981) 1 -10-2-3: NATURE OF HEARINGS: A . Quasi-Judicial Hearings : The provisions of Section 1 -10-2-7 hereof shall be applicable only to those hearings where the hearing body is called upon to exercise a power of a judicial or quasi-judicial nature, which, for the purpose of this Section, shall be deemed to include, but not be limited to, the following: B. 1. Hearings before the Liquor Licensing Authority upon application for the issuance, or hearings for the suspension or revocation of liquor or fermented malt beverage licenses; 2. Hearings before the City Council upon ordinances which zone or rezone realty, ordinances which annex property to the City, and upon all appeals from the decisions of any City official, board or commission where such an appeal is authorized by Charter, Statute or ordinance, and which requires an evidentiary hearing to determine such appeal; 3. Hearings before the Board of Adjustment and Appeals; 4. Hearings before the Board of Career Service Commissioners upon appeals from disciplinary actions against employees; 5. Hearings before the City Council or any board or commission or official respecting the issuance, suspension or revocation of any license issued by the City, or the imposition of any assessments or penalties; 6. Hearings before other boards or commissions that meet the requirements of a quasi-judicial hearing as established by the Colorado Supreme Court. Administrative Hearings: All other hearings before a hearing body shall be deemed to be administrative hearings, the purpose of which is to obtain information to enable the City Council to determine legislative policy or to enable any board or commission to make recommendations to the Council upon proposed or pending legislation. Such hearings shall be conducted in compliance with the provisions of Sections 1-10-2-4, 1-10-2-5 and 1-10-2-6, and in such a manner so as to enable any person desiring to be heard a reasonable opportunity for the presentation of his views, but there shall be no requirement for compliance with the provisions of Section 1 -10-2-7. -30- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 -10 -2 ·3 , -10 --2-7 C. Hw question of whether a hearing is administraive or quasi -judicial shall be raised at the hearing and the hearing body shall rule thereon or may adjourn the hearing for legal assistance. (Ord. 68 Series 1981) 1-10-2-4: COMMENCEMENl OF PROCEEDINGS: All proceedings conducted pursuant to this Section shall be commenced in the manner provided by the Charter, Statute or ordinance governing the matter. In any proceeding involving the appeal of a decision of a City official, board or commission, the appeal procedure shall be commenced by the filing with the Clerk or recording secretary of the hearing body involved a written notice of appeal by any party entitled to take such appeal upon forms to be supplied by the hearing body having jurisdiction over the appeal within a period of thirty five (35) days from the date of the decision being appealed, unless a different time for appeal is set by the Charter, Statute or other ordinance involved. (Ord. 68 Series 1981) 1-10-2-5: REFERRAL TO HEARING BOD\': Upon receipt by the Clerk of any · application, petition, notice of appeal , complaint or other instrument initiating a hearing, the same shall be referred to the hearing body having jurisdiction over the matter, and a date, time and place for hearing thereon shall be set by said hearing body, which shall direct public notice thereof to be given , if otherwise required; provided, however, that the hearing body may authorize its Clerk to set a date, time and place for hearing upon receipt of such instrument without the necessity for action by the hearing body itself. (Ord. 68 Series 1981) 1-10-2-6: PUBLIC NOTICE: If required, public notice of the date, time and place of the public hearing shall be given in the manner provided by the Charter, Statute or ordinance pursuant to which said hearing is to be held. 1 In the absence of the provisions specifically delineating the manner in which public notice is to be given, notice of the date, time, place and purpose of the hearing to be held shall be published once in that newspaper designated by City Council as the City's official newspaper not less than fifteen (15) days prior to the date of said hearing . In the event the public hearing is postponed, notice shall be given of the date, time and place to which the hearing has been postponed, either by causing further notice to be published, as above provided, or by publicly announcing at the date, time and place set in the original notice, of the hearing's postponement, of the new date, time and place when and where the postponed hearing shall be held . (Ord. 68 Series 1981) 1-10-2-7: QUASI-JUDICIAL HEARINGS: A. Rights of Participants: All quasi -judicial hearings, as hereinabove designated, shall be conducted under the following procedures : 1. All parties or witnesses who appear for the purpose of testifying upon factual matters shall testify under oath; 1 . See Section 1--10 -1 of this Cod e. -31- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1-10-· 2 .7 1-10-2-7 A) 2. The cross-examination, upon request of the interested parties, of all witnessns; B. c. D. 3. The stenographic, or other verbatim, reproduction of all testimony presented in said hearing; and 4. Within thirty five (35) days after a quasi-judicial hearing, a written decision by the hearing body which shall set forth the factual basis and reasons for the decision rendered . Order of Procedure: At quasi -judicial hearings , the following order of procedure shall be followed; however, the procedure may be modified by the hearing body when circumstances require the order to be changed: 1. First, there shall be presented those documents showing the regularity of the commencement of the proceedings and the due form of the public notice given. 2 . Next, the hearing body shall receive staff presentation concerning the issue before the body. 3. Next, the applicant's presentation of such material evidence, if any, as he desires . 4. The hearing body shall, upon completion of the presentation of the applicant's evidence, call upon any person present in support of the applicant's position to present such evidence and information as he may desire. 5. Thereafter, the hearing body shall call for the presentation of information and evidence from any person present at the hearing who desires to oppose the application, petition, appeal o r complaint. 6. The applicant shall then be given an opportunity to present any further matter in opposition or rebuttal to the matters presented by the opponents. 7. All documents, or other items of physical evidence, shall be marked as exhibits with such identifying symbols as may be necessary to determine the exhibit referred to by any witness or other person. Rules of Evidence: The hearing body shall not be required to observe any formal rules of evidence, but may consider any matter which a majority thereof conclude is reasonably reliable and calculated to aid the hearing body in reaching an accurate determination of the issues involved. Deliberations and Vote: Each hearing body is authorized to deliberate upon the issues presented at the hearing in private, nonpublic sessions, provided that no decision shall be effective except upon a vote of the members of the hearing body conducted in an open session thereof. -32- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1--10 ---2 -7 1-10-3 E. The pc.irty who appeals a decision of a hearing body shall pay for preparation of the verbatim record and exhibits of the hearing from which the arpeal is taken. F. Judicial Enforcement and Review of Decision: Any party aggrieved by a hearing body in any quasi-judicial hearing, or the City itself, may apply to have said decision reviewed by a court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with the provisions therefor contained within the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure. G . In the event that review results in a setting aside or reversing said decision, the City Council may take such steps as may be necessary to obtain an appellate review of the same, either through the institution of original proceedings or through appeal. (Ord. 68 Series 1981 I 1-10-2-8: PRESERVING ORDER: Each administrative body shall have the right to preserve order during the hearing and to take such steps, including the ejection of any disorderly or obstreperous person intertering with its proceedings, as may be necessary, and the administrative body may, prior to any presentations and as a condition to the taking of testimony or information from any person, require the registration of all persons desiring to be heard during the hear i ng. It may restrict the testimony of any person to the material issues pending before it and, to prevent duplicative or cumulative presentations, it may impose reasonable time restrictions on any person . (Ord. 34 Series 1967) 1-10-2-9: ADJOURNMENTS: After commencement of any hearing, the administrative body may, if it is deemed necessary to obtain a full presentation, adjourn the hearing from time to time by publicly announcing the fact of such adjournment and the date, time and place when and where the adjourned hearing shall recommence, without the necessity of any further published notice thereof. (Ord . 34 Series 1967) 1-10-2-10: HEARING FEES: Each administrative body is hereby authorized to require from each applicant requesting a hearing before the same, to pay to the City a reasonable, uniform fee therefor, to defray the expenses of the same; provided, however, that provision shall be made for the waiver of the payment of same in all instances of proven indigency. (Ord. 34 Series 1967) 1-10-3: AUTHORITY TO ISSUE SUBPOENAS: The City Council or any board or commission authorized to exercise quasi-judicial authority shall have the power to issue subpoenas to any person o r entity in order to carry out its duties and responsibilities. A . The City Clerk, Mayor, chairman of the board or secretary of the board shall have the authority to sign said subpoenas for and on behalf of the Council or board . -33- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1-10-3 1-10-3 B. c. D. The subpoenas shall be served in the same manner as a subpoena issued by a Municipal Court. Upon failure of any witness to comply with such subpoena, the City Clerk, or Mayor, or chairman of the board or secretary of the board shall cause a summons and complaint to be filed in the Municipal Court of the City and a copy of the complaint to be served on the witness/defendant for a violation of this Section for which the Court shall promptly set a hearing date and review evidence in support of or contrary to the issuance of the subpoena, and the Court may enter an order compelling the witness to attend and testify before the board or commission under penalty of punishment for contempt, in the case of unlawful failure to comply with the order of the Court. A violation of this Section shall also be a separate offense of the Englewood Municipal Code and shall be subject to all other penalties provided for in this Code. (Ord. 79 Series 1981) -34- I •r I I I I I I I f I I I I I I I I I 1 0-12-85 Section 16.2 Administration of the Ordinance. Section 16.2-1 Enforcement. a. Enforcing Official. The provisions of this Ordinance shall be administered and enforced by the Director of Community Development of the City of Englewood or by persons designated by the Director. Code Enforcement personnel will have all legal powers necessary to enforce this Ordinance. b. Stop Orders. Whenever the use of property or the construction of any building or structure is contrary to the provisions of this Ordinance, the Director of Community Development or a person duly authorized by the Director may order the use of the property or the construction to be stopped by serving notice in writing on any person, firm or corporation engaged in using said property or in doing or causing such work to be done, or by posting such notice in a conspicuous place on said property when no such person, firm or corporation can be served in the aforesaid manner. No oversight or dereliction or error on the part of the Director or any employee of the Department of Cornmunity Development, or on the part of any other official or employee of the City of Englewood shall legalize, authorize, or excuse the violation of any of the provisions of this Ordinance. Section 16.2-2 Building Permits. Building Permit Required. It shall be unlawful to commence the excavation for or the construction of any building or other structure, including accessory structures, or to store building material, construct entrances to parking lots or commence the moving, structural alterations, conversions, extensions, enlargements, alteration or repair of any structure, including accessory structures until a building permit has been issued therefor. Section 16.2-3 Certificate of Occupancy. After the effective date of this Ordinance, or any amendment hereto, a Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued for all buildings and property when there is any change in the use of the property, any change in the type of use of an existing building as stated in the Englewood Building Code, and prior to the use or occupancy of a new building. The Certificate of Occupancy shall be posted in a conspicuous place on the premises and shall not be removed except by the Director of Community Development or an authorized representative except in single-family and two-family residences, which do not have to post the Certificate of Occupancy. Section 16.2-4 Null and Void Permits. Any building or occupancy permit issued in conflict with the provisions of this Ordinance shall be null and void and may not be construed as waiving any provision of this Ordinance. Section 16.2-5 Interpretation. The Planning Commission is authorized to interpret the provisions of this Ordinance, and when deemed necessary by the Commission, submit reports to the City Council suggesting amendments to the Ordinance to clarify the intent and -35- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I purpose of any article, section, or paragraph on which it has occasion to rule. Section 16.2-6 Appeals and Variances. Any person aggrieved by any notice or order issued pursuant to the provisions of this Ordinance may appeal the same to the Board of Adjustment and Appeals for the City of Englewood, Colorado. Such appeal shall be filed within thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of such notice or order in the manner provided by the Rules of Procedure adopted by said Board. Section 16.2-7 Power of the Board. The Board shall have power to hear and determine appeals from refusal of building permits, to make special exceptions to the terms of this Ordinance in harmony with their general purpose and intent, and to authorize variances from the strict application of the regulations in this Ordinance as set forth below. Section 16.2-8 Jurisdiction of the Board. a. b. Appeals. In addition to such other jurisdiction as authorized by law, the Board shall have the jurisdiction and power: (1) To hear and decide appeals from and to review any order, requirement, decision or determination by any employee of the Department of Community Development in the enforcement of this Ordinance, and to hear and decide all matters referred to it, or upon which it is required to pass under this Ordinance or any amendment hereto. Appeals to the Board may be made by any person aggrieved by the interpretation or decision in the interpretation of this Ordinance. (2) To reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or to modify any order, requirement, decision or determination of an employee of the Department of Community Development and to make such order, requirement, decision or determination as in its opinion ought to be made and, to that end, shall have all the powers of the enforcing agent. (3) Public notice of time and place and purpose of such hearing shall be given by one publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days before such hearing. Variance. (1) The Board shall have the jurisdiction and power to grant variances or modify in speci~ic cases the strict application of the provisions of this Ordinance provided the following conditions are met: (a) No variance or modification of any provision of this Ordinance shall be authorized except after public hearing thereon. Public notice of time and place and purpose of such hearing shall be given by one publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days before such hearing, and, where appropriate, by posting of the property affected for not less than fifteen (15) consecutive days prior to said hearing. -36- I I I I I I I I I I( I I I I I I I I (b) (c) In passing upon variances, the Board of Adjustment may vary the application of the regulations set forth in this Zoning Ordinance only if the Board fings that: (i) By reason of exceptional nar rowness, shallowness or shape of a specific piece o f property on the date this Section takes effect or by r eason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of the piece of property, and the strict application of the regulation would result in peculiar and undue practical difficulties for the owner of the property. (ii) The variance, if granted, will observe the spirit of this Ordinance, secure the public safety and welfare, and achieve substantial justice. (iii) The variance, if granted will not adversely affect the adjacent property or the neighborhood. (iv) The variance, if granted, will not substantially or permanently impair the appropriate use or development of adjacent property. (v) The variance, if granted, is the minimum variance that will afford relief with the least modification possible of this Ordinance. In passing upon variances to the Sign Code, Section 16.4-19 of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, the Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall determine that: (i) There are special circumstances or conditions such as the existence of buildings, t opography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent public right-of-way, which would substantially restrict the effectiveness o f the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions must be peculiar to the particular business or enterprise to which the appl i cant desires to draw attention, and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. (ii) The variance, if authorized, will weaken neither the general purpose of this Ordin ance nor the regulations prescribed for the district in which the sign is located. (iii) The variance, if authorized, will not alter the essential character of the district in which the sign is located. (iv) The variance, if authorized, will not substantially or permanently injure the appropriate use of adjacent conforming property. (2) The Board of Adjustment may not grant any variance relating to the use of property unless it finds, in addition to the findings previously set forth in this Section, that: -37- I 1. I I I I I I I 1< I I I I I I I I (a) The property cannot be used for any purpose permitted within the zone district applicable to the property. (b) The proposed use is the use for the property most compatible with the standards and policies set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. (c) The proposed use will not be detrimental to nor incompatible with other uses in the neighborhood. (d) The proposed use is the least traffic-intensive use possible which will permit some reasonable use of the property. (e) The alleged difficulty or hardship was not self-imposed. (3) Whenever an enforcing officer has issued an order to cease and desist from the operation of dwelling units in excess of the number authorized by this Ordinance, which units have not been registered as Nonconforming Uses, and the Board of Adjustment and Appeals also finds that literal enforcement of the provisions of this Ordinance, by reason of unique and exceptional circumstances including physical condition, age, and/or other factors, will result in unnecessary hardship; then, and in that event, the Board may order a delay for a reasonable period of time not to exceed the total period of time which would have been permitted under other provisions of this Ordinance if properly registered. Any such variance granted by the said Board shall apply only to permit continued operation of uses upon evidence of legal documentation or other evidence that the use was allowed by the City or some agency thereof at some previous time, or any other agency having jurisdiction at the time of original construction. The payment of a business and occupational license fee or other similar fee or tax shall not be deemed to have legalized an illegal use. The Board cannot, by virtue hereof, permit the registration or continuance in use of an illegal use. Any such variance allowed by the Board shall be deemed to be applicable to the property and not a personal variance applicable to the person or persons applying therefor. All such actions by the Board shall be recorded in the office of the Clerk and Recorder of Arapahoe County, Colorado. (4) In Sections R-1-A, R-1-B and R-1-C, no variance for a use that was created or changed after May 1, 1985, or that became nonconforming after May 1, 1985, shall be approved without review by the Board and the City Council. First review shall be by the Board. If approved by the Board, the variance shall be referred to the City Council. The City Council shall review the record and a written decision of the Board to determine if the variance complies with the requirements of this Ordinance. No hearing shall be held before City Council. Should the City Council determine the variance does not comply with this Ordinance, the variance shall then be denied. (5) The Board of Adjustment and Appeals shall not grant any variance which will increase the density in any residential zone district. c. Authority to Require Reasonable Stipulation. The Board shall have the authority to require any reasonable stipulation which might be necessary to properly protect the general welfare when granting a variance. -38- I I I I I I I I I( I I I I I I I 1· I d. e. f. g. Responsibility to Adopt Rules and Regulations. The Board shall adopt, publish and make available such procedural rules and regulations as may be deemed necessary to carry into effect the provisions of this Ordinance, which rules and regulations shall be kept on file in the office of the City Clerk and shall be open to public inspection. Limitations on the Board. Nothing herein contained shall be construed to empower the Board to change the terms of this Ordinance or to effect changes in the Zoning Map of the City of Englewood. The powers of the Board shall be narrowly interpreted and strictly construed so that this Ordinance and Map shall be strictly enforced. Expiration of Variance. Any variance granted by the Board shall automatically expire within one hundred eighty (180) days of the date it was granted, or within such other time as the Board may prescribe, unless a building permit for the action which was the subject of the variance is obtained within such period of time and work started. Extensions of time may be granted for good cause shown, but only if an application for the extension is made prior to the expiration of the variance. Judicial Review. Any person applying to the courts for a review of any final and reviewable decision made under this Zoning Ordinance by the City Council, Planning Commission or Board of Adjustment, shall pay the cost of preparing any necessary transcript and any necessary record of proceedings. Section 16.2-9 Procedure. a. Representation at any Hearing. At any hearing, any party may appear in person, or be represented by a duly authorized person, or by an attorney. b. Meetings Open to the Public. All regular meetings of the Board shall be open to the public. c. Board Shall Keep Minutes. The Board shall keep Minutes of its proceedings, showing the vote of each member upon each question, or if absent or failing to vote, indicating such fact, and shall keep records of its examinations and other official actions, all of which shall be filed in the off ice of the Department of Community Development and shall be a public record. d. Render Decision Within Thirty-Five Days. The Boar d shall render its decision within thirty-five days after publi c hearing. e. Decisions to Be Based on Find i ngs. Every deci s ion shall be based on findings of fact and every finding o f f act shall be supported in the record of the hearing. All testimony shal l be presented publicly; the Board shall not take notice o f any fact and shal l not consider the personal knowledg e of any me mber unless the f a c t of which notice is taken is made part of the record, and unless the pe.rsonal knowledge of the member is presented publicly as testimony by such member. f, Required Number of Votes. The quorum for the Board of Adjustment shall be five (5) members thereof. When only a quorum is present, a concurring vote of four-fifths (4/5) o f such members shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirement, decision or determinat i on of any administrative official or to decide in favor of the applic ant on any matter upon which the Board is required to pass under this Ordina nce or to affect any -39 - I I I I I I I I I ( I I I I I I I I I I g. h. variation of this Ordinance. When six (6) or seven (7) members of the Board are present, a concurring vote of five (5) members shall be necessary to affect the above. · Appeals from the Board. Any person or persons jointly or severally aggrieved by any decision of the Board, or any resident, taxpayer, or other officer, department, Board or Commission of the municipality may appeal such decision by appropriate legal action to a Court of Record having jurisdiction thereof. Such appeal shall be filed no more than 30 days from the date of the Board action. Fees of Board. Any person making appeal to or applying for a variance from the Board shall deposit at the time of application a sum determined by the City Council as necessary to pay for reasonable costs of such appeal. Section 16.2-10 Public Notices. a. b. Notice shall be by one (1) publication in the official newspaper of the City at least ten (10) days before any hearing, or before consideration of any other matters about which notice is required. In addition, the property shall be advertised by posting for not less than fifteen (15) consecutive days prior to the hearing or consideration of the case; provided, however, that where there is no property to post, the aforesaid newspaper publication shall be deemed sufficient notice. (1) Such posting .shall consist of a sign not less than twenty-two (22) inches by twenty-eight (28) inches in size, located not less than four feet (4') above ground level in a conspicuous place, with letters not less than one inch in height in black ink, which letters can be read from the adjoining street right-of-way. -40- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I STATUTES RELATING TO PUBLIC SERVANTS (updated 4/a-5) PART 1 OBSTRUCTION OF PUBLIC JUSTICE J8-8-l01. Ddinitions. As used in this article, unless the context otherwise requires: (1) "Government" includes any branch, subdivision. institution, or agency of the government of this state or any political subdivision within it. (2) "Governmental function" includes any activi t y which a public servant is legally authorized to undertake on behalf of a government. (3) "Public servant" means any officer or employee of government, whether elected or appointed, and any person part icipating as an advisor, or consultant, engaged in the service of process, or otherwise performing a governmental function, but the term does not include witnesses. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p . 453, § I; C.R.S. 1963, § 40-8-101. PART3 BRIBERY AND CORRUPT INFLUENCES 18-8-301. Definitions. The definitions contained in section 18-8-101 are applicable to this part 3, unless the context otherwise requires, and, in addi- tion to those definitions: (1) "Benefit" means any gain or advantage to the beneficiary, including any gain or advantage to a third person pursuant to the desire or consent of the beneficiary . (2) "Party officer" means a person who holds any position or office in a political party, whether by election, appointment, or otherwise. (3) "Pecuniary benefit" is benefit in the form of money, property, commercial interests, or anything else the primary significance of which is economic gain. (4) "Public servant", as used in sections 18-8-302 to 18-8-308, includes persons who presently occupy the position of a public servant as defined in section 18-8-101 (3) or have been elected, appointed, or designated to become a public servant although not yet occupying that position. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 459, § l; C.R.S. 1963, § 40-8-301. 18-8-302. Bribery. (1) A person commits the crime of bribery, if: (a) He offers, confers, or agrees to confer any pecuniary benefit upon -41- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 18-8-~I .' ( 'riminal ( 'odt: u puhlil' snvant with thl' intt:nt to influl·nc·1.· the puhlil' servant'i. vote. opin- ion . judgnll'nt, l'Xl'ITis<.' of disnetion, or otlwr al'tion in his offil.:ial capacity; or • (h) Whik a public servant. he solicits. accepts. or agrees to accept any pl·cuniary hcncf it upon an agreement or understanding that his vote. opinion, judgment. exercise of discretion. or other action as a puhlic servant will thcrehy he influenced . (2) Jt is no ddensc to a prosecution under this section that the person sought to he influenced was not qualified to act in the desired way, whether because he had not yet assumed office, lacked jurisdiction, or for any other reason . (3) Brihery is a class 3 felony. Source: R & RE. L. 71. p. 459, § 1; C.R .S. 1963, § 40-8-302. Cros~ referenl'e: For bribery of persons other than a public servant. sec§ 1~-.'1-401 . Am. Jur. See 12 Am. Jur .2d . Bribery.§ 12 . C.J.S. Sec 11 C .J .S ., Briber y ,§ § 2 , 3. 10e 5ubstantin oflerLo;e of bri~ry of a judge can be committed by Ollf person. People v . lncerto. lt<O Colb . 31>6, .'Ill .~ P.2d 1309 (1973). ugblittivt Intent. Thr ~eneral assembly apparentl y intrnded to define bribery as the commission of any one of the following three act s: (I J offering to confer upon 11 public servant, (2) conferring upon a public servant , or (3) agreeing to confer upon a public servant . Although the statute doe s not spec.ify the per~on with whom the agreement mu st ~e made to be guilty of the third act , under a stnct construction, the agreement must be with the publi c ~rrvant, not a third pany , while a defc:ndant ma y be guilty of th" first two ac t~ evrn if the public official doc ~ not agree to be bribed . People v . Bailey, 41 Colo . App . 504 , .59.5 P.2d 2.52 (1978), rev'd on other ground s, 200 Colo . 549. 617 P.2d 549 (19l<O l . Definition of terms of former statute requiring both "t=ivilll:" and "recelvi~''. See Pe o ple v . lncerto , 180 Colo . 366 , 505 P .2d B09 (1973). Corporation or a corporate body 1~ not included in the definition of "i:onrnmmt' • in , section 18 -8-101 . Ba ilr y v . People. 200 Colo . 549 . 617 P.2d 549 (1980 ). · [k·finition of tl'rm "public sen·ant" I~ que~­ tion of la"' for court. Pcoplr v. B a iley . 41 Colo. App . 5~ • .'19.'i P .2d 252 (1978 ), rev'd on other ground s . 200 Col o . 549, fi17 P .2d 549 (1980 ). Emplone of the Colorado Springs urban renewal ~rrort is not a "public servant" per- formin g a "governmental function". on beh.a lf of a "government" a s defined m section 18-8-101. B ai le y ..... People, 200 Colo . 549, 617 P.2d 549 (1980). 18-8-303. Compensation for past official beha\•ior. (1) A person commits a class 5 felony, if he: (a) Solicits , accepts , or agrees to accept any pecuniary benefit as compen- sation for having, as a public servant, given a decision, opinion, recommenda- tion , or vote favorable to another or for having otherwise exercised a discre- tion in his favor , whether or not he has in so doing violated his duty; or (b) Offers, confers, or agrees to confer compensation, acceptance of which is prohibited by this section . Source: R & RE , L. 71 , p. 460 , § 1; C .R.S. 1963, § 40-8-303. Am. Jur. See 12 Am. Jur .2d , Bribery , § § 12, 13. 18-8-304. Soliciting unlawful compensation. A public servant commits a class 2 misdemeanor if he requests a pecuniary benefit for the performance of an official action knowing that he was required to perform that action without compensation or at a level of compensation lower than that requested. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 460, § 1; C.R.S . 1963, § 40-8-304. C.J .S. See 11 C.J .S ., Bribery,§ 7 . -42- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I' I 18-8-305. Trading In puhlk offict'. (I) A person commits trading in puhlic offic:e if : (ii) HC' offers. confers, or agrees to confer any pecuniary benefit upon a puhlic servant or party officer upon an agreement or understanding that he or a particular person will or may be appointed to a public office or desig- nated or nominated as a candidate for public office; or (b) While a public servant or party officer, he solicits, accepts, or agrees to accept m1y pL·cuniary hendit from another upon an agreement or under- standing that u particular perl>on will or may be appointed to a public office or designated or nominated as a candidate for public office. (2) It shall he an affirmative defense that the pecuniary benefit was a customary contribution to political campaign funds solicited and received by lawfully constituted political parties. 0) Trading in public office is a class 1 misdemeanor. Soun:e: R & RE. L. 71, p . 460, § 1; C.R .S. 1963, § 40-8-305; L. 72, p. 275. § 7; L. 73 , p . 539, § 6. J8-8-:W6. Attempt to influence a public senant. Any person who attempts to influence any public servant by means of deceit or by threat of violence or economic reprisal against any person or property, with the intent thereby to alter or affect the public servant's decision, vote, opinion. or action con- cerning any matter which is to be considered or performed by him or the agency or body of which he is a member, commits a class 4 felony. Source: R & RE , L. 71 , p. 460, § I; C .R.S. 1963, § 40-8-306. 18-8-307. Designation of supplier prohibited. (1) No public servant shall require or direct a bidder or contractor to deal with a particular person in procuring any goods or service required in submitting a bid to or fulfilling a contract with any government. (2) Any provision in invitations to bid or any contract documents prohib- ited by this section are against public policy and void . (3) It shall be an affirmative defense that the defendant was a public servant acting within the scope of his authority exercising the right to reject any material, subcontractor, service, bond , or contract tendered by a bidder or contractor because it does not meet bona fide specifications or require- ments relating to quality, availability , form, experience, or financial responsi- bility. (4) Any public servant who violates the provisions of subsection (1) of this section commits a class 5 felony . Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 460, § 1; C.R.S. 1963, § 40-8-307; L. 73, p. 539, § 7. 18-8-308. Failin~ to disclose a conflict of interest. (1) A public servant com- mits failing to disclose a conflict of interest if he exercises any substantial discretionary function in connection with a government contract, purchase, payment, or other pecuniary transaction without having given seventy-two hours' actual advance written notice to the secretary of state and to the gov- erning body of the government which employs the public servant of the exist- ence of a known potential conflicting interest of the public servant in the transaction with reference to which he is about to act in his official capacity. Source: Amended, L. 79, p . 744, § 1. -43- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I (2) A "potential conflictinr. inkrest" cx.ist.s when th~ publi.c servant is a director. president, general manager, or s1m1lar executive: off 1cer or owns or contrnls directly or indirectly a substantial interest in any nongovernmental entity participating in the tnmsaction. 0) Failing to disclose a conflict of interest is a class 2 misdemeanor. Soun·c: R & RE. L. 71. p. 461. § 1; C.R.S . 1963, § 40-8-308. Sc.-c.·llon dul' "·Ith form11l, uprts~ ronlr11cts. Frn mr1 sn·tion pwhihilin~ interest in contract hy officc1 had to do with such contract~ as tht l•fficcr is charged with the duty of makin~. and witlt thosr in the awarding of which he has a voice, or vote, and cle1uly means formal. cxprc:ss contr11c1s , whiclt arc in term~ agreed upon, or awarded on bids . Pwplc v. Bwwn, 60 Colo. 276, 152 P . 1169 (1915). PART4 ABUSE OF PUBLIC OFFICE 18-8-401. Definitions. The definitions contained in sections 18-8-101 and 18-8-301 are applicable to this part 4, unless a different meaning is plainly required. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 461, § 1; C.R.S. 1963, § 40-8-401. 18-8-402. l\·lisuse of official information. (1) Any public servant, in contemplation of official action by himself or by a governmental unit with which he is associated or in reliance on information to which he has access in his official capacity and which has not been made public, commits misuse of official information if he: (a) Acquires a pecuniary interest in any property, transaction, or enter- prise which may be affected by such information or official action; or (b) Speculates or wagers on the basis of such information or official action; or (c) Aids, advises, or encourages another to do any of the foregoing with intent to confer on any person a special pecuniary benefit. (2) Misuse of official information is a class 5 felony. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 461, § 1; C .R.S. 1963, § 40-8-402. Am. Jur. See 63 Am . Jur.2d, Public Offi-v . Heckers, 37 Colo. App. 166, 543 P.2d 1311 urs and Employees,§ 348 . (1975). Statute as basis for jurisdiction. See People 18-8-403. Official oppression. (l) A public servant, while acting or pur- porting to act in an official capacity or taking advantage of such actual or purported capacity, commits official oppression if, with actual knowledge that his conduct is illegal, he: (a) Subjects another to arrest, detention, search, seizure, mistreatment, dispossession, assessment, or lien; or (b) Has legal authority and jurisdiction of any person legally restrained of his liberty and denies the person restrained the reasonable opportunity to consult in private with a licensed attorney-at-law, if there is no danger of imminent escape and the person in custody expresses a desire to consult with such attorney. (2) Official oppression is a cJass 2 misdemeanor. Source: R & RE. L. 71. p . 461, § 1; C.R.S. 1963, § 40-8-403. Cross refrrt'nce: For the duty of officers to admit an attorney. see§ 16-3-404 . Am. Jur. Sec 63 Am . Jur .2d, Public Offi- cers and Employees,§ 347 . -44- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 553 Offenses -Governmental Operations 18-8-406 18-8-404. First degree official misconduct. (1) A public servant commits first degree official misconduct if, with intent to obtain a benefit for himself or maliciously to cause harm to another, he knowingly: (a) Commits an act relating to his office but constituting an unauthorized exercise of his official function; or (b) Refrains from performing a duty imposed upon him by lawior-ekariy ~herent.fn-the~M~re-of~~-off.ice;or Source: Amended, L.83,p710§1 (c) Violates any statute or lawfully adopted rule or regulation relating to his office . (2) First degree official misconduct is a class 2 misdemeanor. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p . 462, § l; C.R.S. 1963. § 40-8-404. Am. Jur. See 63 Am . Jur.2d, Public Offi- cers and Employees , § § 58, 346 . Purpose of section. The remedy for corrupt discharge of a district attorney's duties is in the criminal statutes. McDonald v . Lakewood Country Club , 170 Colo . 355, 461 P .2d 437 (1969). Section applicable although term of office had expired when Indictment was filed. Provi- sions of former section relating to malfea- sance in office were applicable to an official violating the terms thereof , although his term of office had expired when the indictment was filed against him. Whalen v. People , 74 Colo . 417, 222 P . 398 (1924). Definitions. Malfeasance consists of the doing of an act which is wholly wrongful and unlawful; it involves an act which the officer has no authority to do and it is readily distin- guished from misfeasance or nonfeasance . People v . Schneider, 133 Colo . 173, 292 P .2d 982 (1956). Elements of offense. Malfesance in office cannot be charged except for breach of a positive statutory duty or for the performance of a discretionary act with an improper or corrupt motive . People v . Schneider, 133 Colo . 173, 292 P .2d 982 (1956). Mere ownership of land by a county com- missioner, which land was later subdivided, would not constitute malfeasance. People v . Schneider, 133 Colo . 173, 292 P .2d 982 (1956). 1bere must be some direct allegation of facts which constitute malfeasance. To charge malfeasance without more is to state a conclusion which does not afford the defend- ant an opportunity to know the nature of or to meet the charge against him . People v . Schneider, 133 Colo. 173, 292 P.2d 982 (1956). StaMe as basis for jurisdiction. See People v . Lewis, 183 Colo . 236, 516 P.2d 416 (1973). Applied in People v. Enlow, 135 Colo . 249, 310 P .2d 539 (1957). 18-8-405. Second degree official misconduct. (1) A public servant commits second degree official misconduct if he knowingly, arbitrarily, and capriciously: (a) Refrains from performing a duty imposed upon him by law-tl'!' elearly- iftherent~~e nMtt~-of h~~; or Source: Amended, L.83,p710§1 (b) Violates any statute or lawfully adopted rule or regulation relating to his office. (2) Second degree official misconduct is a class 1 petty offense. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 462 , § 1; C.R .S. 1963, § 40-8-405. Am. Jur. See 63 Am . Jur .2d, Public Offi- cers and Employees, § § 58, 346 . . 18-8-406. Issuing a false certificate. A person commits a class 5 felony, if, being a public servant authorized by law to make and issue official certif- icates or other official written instruments, he makes and issues such an instrument containing a statement which he knows to be false. Source: R & RE, L. 71, p. 462, § 1; C .R.S. 1963, § 40-8-406. -45- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 18-8-407 Criminal Code 554 18-8-407. Embezzlement of public property. (1) Every public servant who lawfully or unlawfully comes into possession of any public moneys or public property of whatever description, being the property of the state or of any political subdivision of the state, and who knowingly converts any of such public moneys or property to his own use or to any use other than the public use authorized by law is guilty of embezzlement of public propert y . Every person convicted under the provisions of this section shall be forever there- after ineligible and disqualified from being a member of the general assembly of this state or from holding any office of trust or profit in this state. (2) Embezzlement of public property is a class 4 felony . Source: L. 77, p . 967 , § 45. F.dltor's note: Section 68 of chapter 224 , Session Laws of Colorado 1977 , provides that the act amending subsection (I) is effect ive July 1, 1977 , and applies to offenses alleged to have been committed on or after said date . Am. Jur. See 26 Am. Jur .2d, Embezzle- ment ,§ 34. Law review. For article , "One Year Review of Criminal Law", see 34 Dicta 98 (1957). Intent of section Is to prevent mlsappUcadon of i>ubUc funds. The intention of the general assembly is to prevent the misapplication and use of public funds for the benefit and profit of the officer and to strictly prohibit the use of the money by the officer for speculative purposes and for his own gain . This section is based upon and enacted for the purpose of carrying out the prohibition contained in§ 13 of art . X , Colo . Const ., and by reference to that, the intention becomes manifest and the limits of legislation defined . Moulton v . McLean, 5 Colo . App . 454, 39 P. 78 (1895); People v. Schneider, 133 Colo . 173 , 292 P .2d 982 (1956). It is the using of public money for the offi- cial 's own gain that is intended to be reached by this section. People v. Schneider , 133 Colo . 173 , 292 P .2d 982 (1956). It was not the Intention of the general assem- bly to prohibit the depositing of money In banks for convenience in safekeeping. Davis v . Dunlevy, II Colo . App . 344, 53 P.. 250 (1898). And bond covering money deposited In bank Is valid. A bond given to indemnify the clerk of a county court on account of money depos- ited in a bank is not void as against public policy, nor in violation of this section. Davis v. Dunlevy , 27 Colo . 244 , 60 P . 570 (1900). An essential element of the crime of "embezzlement" or "criminal conversion " is that the property must be owned by another and the conversion thereof must be without the consent and against the will of the party to whom the property belongs , coupled with the fraudulent intent to deprive the owner of the -46- property. People v . Fielden , 162 Colo . 574 , 427 P .2d 880 (1967). This section bti Implicit within Its language the requisite unlawful conversion and criminal Intent. People v . Fielden , 162 Colo. 574, 427 P .2d 880 (1967 ). Fraudulent Intent Is not an element of the offense under this section . People v. McKnight , __ Colo . App . _, 567 P .2d 811 (1977). It does not requJre that defendant be the custodian of the money in question or that he have e x clusive control over it . Rogers v . People , 104 Colo . 594 , 94 P.2d 453 (1939). Property was not misappropriated as a mat- ter of law where it was used by the defendant as it was int ended to be , on special order, with the knowledge of the hospital agent in charge that it was to be delivered to and used by the director himself , not for public use or at public expen s e . People v . Fielden, 162 Colo . 574, 427 P .2d 880 (1967). RequJred particularity of description of property embezzled. The general rule is that the required particularity of description of property embezzled is the same as in case of property stolen . If, however , the court can deter mine from the indictment that the prop- erty therein mentioned is covered by the statute and the jury can determine that it is the property identified b y the evidence , no mo re is mandatory . People v . Warner, 112 Colo . 565 , 151P.2d975 (1944). Statute of limitations applicable. The act averred in the indictment must appear to have been committed within the period prescri~ b y the statute of limitations or an excepuoo must be set forth . If the indictment avers two . dates , one of which is so remote as ''? ~ barred by t he s tatute of limitations , it IS defective. Bustamante v . District Court. 138 I I ( I I I I I I I 1 ~ I I I I 1. I I . VARIANC.ES IN PASSING UPON VARIANCES, THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MAY VARY THE APPLICATION OF THE REGULATIONS SET FORTH IN THIS ZONING ORDINANCE ONLY IF THE BOARD FINDS THAT: 2. 3. 4. 5. By reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness or shape of a specific piece of property on the date this section takes effect or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of the piece of property, and the strict application of the regulation would result in peculiar and undue practical difficulties for the owner of the property. The variance, if granted, will observe the spirit of this Ordinance, secure the public safety and welfare, and achieve substantial justice. The variance, if granted, will not adversely affect the adjacent property or the neighborhood. The variance, if granted, will not substantially or permanently impair the appropriate use or development of adjacent property. The variance, if granted, is the minimum variance that will afford relief with the least modification possible of this Ordinance. Section 16. 2 -Administration of the Ordinance. Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance in effect as of June 7, 1985. -47- I I I I I I I I ( I I I I I I I SIGN CODE VARIANCES IN CONSIDERING A REQUEST FOR A VARIANCE TO THE SIGN CODE, SECTION 16.4-19 OF THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING ORDINANCE, THE BOARD OF ADJUSn1ENT AND APPEALS SHALL DETERMINE THAT: 1. 2. 3. 4. There are sepcial circumstances or conditions such as the existence of buildings, topography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent public right-of-way, which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions must be peculiar to the particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention, and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. The variance, if authorized, will weaken neither the general purpose of this Ordinance nor the regulations prescribed for the District in which the sign is located. The variance, if authorized, will not alter the essential character of the District in which the sign is located. The variance, if authorized, will not substantially or permanently injure the appropriate use of adjacent conforming property. -48- I Ir I \ \ I I I I I I I I I I I USE VARIANCES THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MAY NOT GRANT ANY VARIANCE RELATING TO THE USE OF PROPERTY UNLESS IT FINDS, IN ADDITION TO THE FINDINGS PREVIOUSLY SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION, THAT: 1. The property cannot be used for any purpose permitted within the zone district applicable to the property. 2. The proposed use is the use for the property most compatible with the standards and policies set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. 3. The proposed use will not be detrimental to nor incompatible with other uses in the neighborhood. 4. The proposed use is the least traffic-intensive use possible which will permit some reasonable use of the property. 5. The alleged difficulty or hardship was not self-imposed. Section 16 .2 -Administration of the Ordinance. Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance in effect as of June 7, 1985. -49- I I I I I I I I I Ir I I I I I I I I I zw 'c.. a: c.. ,• '; I I I I I i I i I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I ' I I I I I ' -50- .1 I/. I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I City of Englewood, Colorado Application Board of Adjustment & Appeals (For office uee only) Variance (zoning) Fen ce Sign Encroachment Code Interpretation CaNNO.------------------- Fillng Datt----------------- Meeting Date ------------------ Potting Date Received By------------------ Petition la hereby made to the Board of AdJuatment and Appeala , purauant to the provlalona of the Municipal Code, 11 emended, for conelder1tion of the property and Intent herein deacrlbed. APPLICANT OWNER/LESSEE Name Ma ili ng Address----------------Malling Addre11 Phone ____ _ ---------------~Phone ___________________ _ ~equeat la to Permit--------------------------------------- Address of Subject Property ------ Legal Deacriptlon : Lota-------------Block ___ Subdivision ------------ Applicant 's Justification (See back of thia form) --------------------------- 1 ti.reby affirm that the above Information la correct to the beat of my knowledge . Co de Enf oree 111ent Dlvlelon 3 400 Sou th Elatl Strut Engl ewood, Colorado 80 I I 0 '761-11 40 119"•'"" of OwMr l L• ... , -51- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l"- I , .. DAT E PLOT PLAN Department of Community Development City of Englewood, Colorado DDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY ----------~...,.....----~~------~ Phon e Phone CORNER LOT D INTERIOR LOT D ZONE DISTRICT ~------------~ SQUARE FEET HEIGHT OF PROPOSED STRUCTURE LOT: WIDTH ---DEPTH --- CLASS OF WORK: New Addition Repair Alter Move Existing Use(s) on Property---------------------~ Propos e d Use(s) on Property ---------------------- Structures -Gross Floor Area: Existing -----Proposed ----- ALL of the following information must be provided on the Diagram below: 1. Adjacent streets and alleys. 2. Location of all easements on property, and dimensions. Other Lot Coverage Total ---- 3. Front, Side and Rear Setbacks of all existing and proposed structures. 4. Distance between all existing and proposed structures. 5. Dimensions of all existing and proposed structures. 6. Location of sewer, water and other service lines. ndicate ALL Existing Structures with a SOLID LINE and Proposed Structures with a DASHED LINE . ~ach Square below is 5 Feet by 5 Feet; One Inch equals 20 Feet. 0 0 50 ;; j ] Street or Avenue •• , .. ,., above site plan, indicating all existing and proposed structures, is j_n compliance a p plicable Zoning Regulations for this property and location. -52- DATE I I t' ~ I ,- "(r-1' . I I I I CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO Information for posting property for hearing on an application before the Board of Adj _ustment and Appeals, CASE ·NUMBER ------ Notice is to be posted on premises f . ftee n (15) days prior to the Public Hearing before the Board of Adjustment and Appeals. Include ALL information between the following two lines: I Englewood, Colorado, I To Whom It May Concern: I I I I I I I I Application has been made to the Board of Adjustment to permit All protests must be made at or before a Public Hearing on ~--------- at 7:30 p.m., in the Council Chambers, 3400 South Elati Street, Englewood, Colorado. SIGN POSTING REQUIREMENTS: The sign for the above notice must NOT BE LESS THAN FOUR (4) FEET WIDE and THREE (3) FEET HIGH with black lettering NOT LESS THAN THREE (3) INCHES HIGH on a white background. Sign must be on a solid backing, mounted on its own post(s) at least FOUR (4) FEET above ground level and within TWENTY (20) FEET of the front property line with an unobstructed view from the street, and weather-proofed. Any change must be approved by the Department of Community Development. Failure to comply with these requirements could result in a delay of the case. Sign MUST be removed within seven (7) days following the hearing. DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 3400 South Elati Street Englewood, Colorado 80110 7h l-ll40 Extension 429 -53- I I ~~-· ! I '. I I I I I I I < I I I I I I I I I ~ ': Department of Community Development Date ~~~~~~~~~~~~~- TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: The owners of the property located at ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-- Englewood, Colorado, and owned by ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-,..~~~~-- ~~~~~~~~~~~-' Colorado, are proposing to ~~~~~~~~~~~ I, ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ , the undersigned OWNER of the which is (adjacent to) (adjoining) the subject site to the (north) (south) (east) (west) have NO objections to this proposal. COMMENTS: NOTE: ONLY ONE (1) ADDRESS PER SH~ET ADJACENT: Separated by a ·street or alley ADJOINING: Separated by a property line -54- I I (~ 1. I D I ,o I CERTIFICATION Board of Adjustment and Appeals City Planning and Zoning Commission OF POSTING ATTACH PHOTOGRAPH HERE I CASE NO. __ I I I I I I I I I Attached is a photograph of a sign as it is erected on the following described property. I hereby certify that the above described property was posted continuously for a period of ---- to ------- Signature Relation to property Date -55- I I I I I I I I P-18 I I I I I I I I I I I ~;1 n t.c· (l f Co] or ado ) ) SS Cou nt"y of Arapahoe ) Subscribed and sw orn to before me this --------day of ___________ _ 19 ---- Notary Public Addre:ss My Commission expires ------------- A separate certification should be presented for each Notice of Hearing Sign. Such certification may be submitted to the Department of Conununity De velopment prior to the Hearing or presented at the Hearing. -55a- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . VARIANC.ES IN PASSING UPON VARIANCES, THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MAY VARY THE APPLICATION OF THE REGULATIONS SET FORTH IN THIS ZONING ORDINANCE ONLY IF THE BOARD FINDS THAT: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. By reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness or shape of a specific piece of property on the date this section takes effect or by reason of exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of the piece of property, and the strict application of the regulation would result in peculiar and undue practical difficulties for the owner of the property. The variance, if granted, will observe the spirit of this Ordinance, secure the public safety and welfare, and achieve substantial justice. The variance, if granted, will not adversely affect the adjacent property or the neighborhood. The variance, if granted, will not substantially or permanently impair the appropriate use or development of adjacent property. The variance, if granted, is the minimum variance that will afford relief with the least modification possible of this Ordinance. Section 16.2 -Administration of the Ordinance. Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance in e f fect as o f June 7, 1985. -56- I I ~~· ) ' 1· I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SIGN . CODE VARIANCES IN CONSIDERING A REQUEST FOR A VARIANCE TO THE SIGN CODE, SECTION 16.4-19 OF THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING ORDINANCE, THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS SHALL DETERMINE THAT: 1. 2. 3. 4. There are sepcial circumstances or conditions such as the existence of buildings, topography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent public right-of-way, which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions must be peculiar ·to the particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention, and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. The variance, if authorized, will weaken neither the general purpose of this Ordinance nor the regulations prescribed for the District in which the sign is located. The variance, if authorized, will not alter the essential character of the District in which the sign is located. The variance, if authorized, will not substantially or permanently injure the appropriate use of adjacent conforming property. -57- I I ... / I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I USE VARIANCES THE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT MAY NOT GRANT ANY VARIANCE RELATING TO THE USE OF PROPERTY UNLESS IT FINDS, IN ADDITION TO THE FINDINGS PREVIOUSLY SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION, THAT: 1. The property cannot be used for any purpose permitted within the zone district applicable to the property. 2. The proposed use is the use for the property most compatible with the standards and policies set forth in the Comprehensive Plan. 3. The proposed use will not be detrimental to nor incompatible with other uses in the neighborhood. 4. The proposed use is the least traffic-intensive use possible which will permit some reasonable use of the property. S. The alleged difficulty or hardship was not self-imposed. Section 16.2 -Administration of the Ordinance. Comprehensive Zon i n g Ordinance in eff e ct as of June 7, 1985. -58- I ·I I I I I I I TO: I I I I I I I I I I I ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT and APPEALS ( )PUBLIC ~ORKS ( )CITY ENGINEER INTER-OFFICE MEMORANDUM ( )UTILITIES DIRECTOR ( )FIRE DEPARTMENT ( )BUILDING DEPARTMENT ( >~~------~---------~ ( )~------------------------- ATTACHED ARE RECORDS OF RECENT ACTION TAKEN BY THE BOARD. If you have any questions, please contact the Planning Division. Sheryl Rousses -59- I I .v·· I BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT and APPEALS ACTION . I TO: I CASE NUMBER __ _ I MEETING DATE _____ _ I SUBJECT PROPERTY I The City of Englewood Board of Adjustment has considered your request for I 1:: I I It is the ruling of this Board, by a vote of_ ~o_, that your request be: I I I QGRANTED QGRANTED, with the following condition(s): THIS ACTION DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A PERMIT. VOU MUST CONTACT THE BUILDING DIVISION 1-FOR A PERMIT. IF NO PERMIT IS OBTAINED IN SIX MONTHS, THE VARIANCE WILL EXPIRE. __ EACH VEAR A QUESTIONNAIRE WILL BE MAILED TO YOU. IT MUST BE RETURNED TO I RETAIN THE NONCONFORMING USE STATUS. I CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO I Depa rtment of Community Development Planning Division Recording Secretary -60- I I ·;-· •' BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT and APPEALS ACTION I DENIAL I TO: I CASE NUMBER ---1 MEETING DATE------ SUBJECT PROPERTY---------- I The City of Englewood Board cif Adjustment has considered your request for l it is the ruling of this Board, by a vote of_ to_, that your request be: I QDENIED I I I I I __ YOU H AVE_ DA Y S TO BRING THIS P ROP E RTY INTO COMPLIANCE. ~11 Y OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO "b e pa r t me nt of Community Developmen t f ~: ~~~:.g 1 ~::~:ion Recording Sec r et ary -61- -- -- - ------ ---- THE PEOPLE MUNICIPAL JUDGE CITY COUNCIL ------------------ ------------·--1 I I I t : I I I I ---- I Eioaro of Ad1uSlrnents I d"<l Appeaos _J j Plannmg and Zunong J i Comm 1sStOn Library Board Parks CommissK.>n I Housing~~] Urban Renewal Authority Water and Sewer Board [Election C~ \ I °' !\.) I Career Set\11Ce B0ard Firemeri"s PenslOfl Board Pohcemen s Pensoon Eloard Retirement Board POLICE Ri!cor ds and Admon ostrallUl Pa1r o1 Coro. Coty Pa trot Ut!ltCll\le Lao Ari 1ma1 Conrrot PUBLIC WORKS Engon.,.,rong Trafloc Serv1~e Center St reels 8u1kl1ng Mam1enance Seno0< Surrey CITY MANAGER FIRE Records and Administration Fire Protection COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Planning and Zoning Codt! Enforcement F11e Prevention Rescue Traonong UTILITIES Admonistralion Waste Water Collection "Treatment Water Production " D1Stributoon Housing and Redevelopment PERSONNEL Records andAdmonistration Insurance CITY ATIORNEY LIBRARY School -City Joim Committee Coty Representati..e on DRCOG PARKS and RECREATION Recreation Parks FINANCE Admonistratoon ~ting-Automated Sys. Pulchasing Revenue Municipal Coort I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I COMMISSIONS AND BOARDS Board of Adjustment and Appeals Membership and term of office: The Board consists of seven members appointed by Council for overlapping terms of four years. Members shall be qualified tax-paying electors, residents of the City at least one year immediately prior to the date of their appointment, and shall hold no other office or position in the City administration. Meetings: The second Wednesday of every month. Duties: The Board hears and determines appeals from any decision of the Building Inspector and from the refusal of building permits; and authorizes variances from the strict application of the regulations of the Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance, Housing Code, Building Code, and other ordinances. The decisions of the Board are final and subject only to judicial review. Board of Career Service Commissioners Membership and term of office: The Board consists of five members, all of whom reside within the City. Two members are appointed by the City Council for terms of four years; two members are elected by direct secret ballot by all full-time permanent classified employees of the City for terms of four years; one member is selected by a majority vote of the four members pre- viously appointed by Council and elected by the full-time permanent classified employees to serve a term of four years from the date selected and shall be designated chair- man of the Board. Meetings: The third Thursday bi-monthly as necessary. Duties: A regulatory body governing the City employees. It recognizes appropriate bargaining units; conducts impasse hearings; acts as final authority in approving employee bargaining units; supervises elections regarding employee organizations; hears and decides contested matters involv- ing employee bargaining units; hears disciplinary and grievance appeals; appoints hearing officer for disciplin- ary appeals, clarification, or amendment of bargaining units; effectuates policies of charter and ordinances; adopts reasonable rules and procedures necessary to per- form its duties. -63- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Election Commission Membership and term of office: The Commission consists of the City Clerk, who shall be an ex officio member and serve as the chairman of the Commis- sion, and four qualified electors of the City, appointed by the Council, and serving overlapping terms of four years. Meetings: No regular meetings. Duties: The Election Commission extablishes precincts and appoints the election judges and clerks for each precinct as provided in the Colorado Municipal Election Laws and has charge of all other activities and duties required of it by law or the home rule charter. Firemen's Pension Board Membership and term of office: The Board consists of six members: the Mayor, Director of Finance, one member appointed by the City Council, and three employee-elected members. The four appointed and elected members serve overlapping three-year terms. Meetings: No regularly scheduled meetings. Duties: The Board administers the statutory and City Pension Fund. Library Board Membership and term of office: The Board consists of nine members appointed by Council from citizens-at-large with overlapping terms of four years. The City Manager shall appoint a member of the library staff to be an ex officio nonvoting member of the Board. Meetings: The second Tuesday of every month. Duties: The Library Board is responsible for assisting the City Council in developing and maintaining the Public Library. It serves as an advisory board to the Library Director and as a liaison between the Public Library and the community. -,.64- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Parks and Recreation Commission Membership and term of office: The Commission consists of nine persons to be appointed by City Council, two members of whom shall be Councilmen and two members of whom shall be under the age of eighteen years when appointed. All members shall be appointed for overlapping terms of four years with the exception of the two members under the age of eighteen years whose terms shall expire on October 1 of the year following their appointment. Meetings: The second Thursday of every month. Duties: The Commission considers and recommends to Council all matters pertaining to a community recreation program and is responsible for equipping and maintaining City-owned or controlled parks, recreational areas and facilities, both in and out of the corporate City limits. It may co- operate with other public authorities, organizations or individuals in or out of the City to implement the opera- tions of the programs. Planning and Zoning Commission Membership and term of office: The Commission consists of nine members appointed by Council who shall be citizens-at-large for overlapping four-year terms. The City Manager appoints an adminis- trative officer to be an ex officio nonvoting member of the Commission. Commission members shall be qualified electors, residents of the City at least one year im- mediately prior to the day of their appointment, and shall hold no paid office or position in the City Administratiqn. Meetings: Meetings are held on Tuesdays following the first and third Mondays of each month. Duties: This Commission prepares and submits for Council approval a master plan, and current modifications thereof, for physical development of the City; makes recommenda- tions to Council regarding all subdivision plats sub- mitted to it; submits a list of recommended capital improvements in order of preference to be constructed in the forthcoming five-year period; prepares and recommends a comprehensive zoning ordinance and amendments or revi- sions thereto; hears applications for amendments, modifi- cations or revisions of zoning ordinances and makes recommendations thereon; conducts public hearings as it deems nec~ssary. -65- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Policemen's Pension Board Membership and term of office: The Board consists of the Mayor, the Director of Finance, and one employee-elected representative of the police force serving a four-year term. Meetings: No regularly scheduled meetings. Duties: The Board administers the statutory and City Pension Fund. Water and Sewer Board Membership and term of office: The Board consists of nine members: the Mayor, two Councilmen selected by Council, and six members appointed by the Council from qualified tax-paying electors serving six overlapping terms of six years. A representative from the City administration shall be appointed by the City Manager to serve as an ex officio nonvoting member. Meetings: The second Tuesday of every month. Duties: The Board serves as an advisory body to Council regarding continued adequacy of the domestic water supply and system and sanitary sewer systems, protects domestic water, water rights, and water supply of the City from injury and pollution, exercises power over the stream or source from which such water is taken, initiates litigation necessary for prevention of stream pollution, determines necessity of purchase and acquisition of water rights for municipal supply, recommends changes in water and sewer rates, new districts to be served, and improvements for water and sewer service expansion. -66-