The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1991-12-02 (Regular) Meeting Agenda• " -. ' . • I ]- • ·~ • ' .. .. . ' - (, .. ·, • " • 0 • .,, I. • 0 ' 2 I ]- - • • t• • (, EIIILEIIOCID c1n COUNCIL EIIILEIIOCID, AUPMIOE COIIITY, COLOUDCI letular Session Decellber 2, 1991 1. Call to Order The regular aeeting of the Englewood City Council was called to order by Mayor Wiggins at 7:35 p.a . 2. Invocation The invocation was given by Council Melllber Bullock . 3. Pledte of Alletiance The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Wiggins. 4. loll Call Present: Absent: A quorua was present. Also present: 5 . Ninutes Council Mellbers Hathaway, Van Dyke, Gulley, Bullock , Habenicht, Waggoner, Wiggins None City Manager Fraser City Attorney DeWitt Deputy City Manager Martin Deputy City Clerk Ellis Director Hayes, Financial Services Utilities Manager Woika Director Barthloae, Adllinistrative Services (a) COUIICIL IIEIIIEI NATNMIAY IIOYED, -IT MAS SECONDO, TO APPIOV( TN( NIIIITH OF THE IEIULAll IIEtTI• OF _,EIIIO 11, lHl. Ayes: Council MNbers Bullock, Van Dyke , Hathawa y, Habenicht , Waggoner , Gulley, Wiggin s Nays: None Motton carried. 6. Pre-scheduled Vhttors There were no pre -scheduled vtsttors . • I . • • , I , ~ • • Englewood City Council Minutes Decetnber 2, 1991 -Page 2 7. Non-scheduled Visitors There were no non-scheduled visitors. • • 8. C01111Unications, Procl11111tions and Appointments (a) COUNCIL NEIIID VAN DYKE IIIOVED, AND IT WAS SECOll>ED, TO ACCEPT THE RESIINATION OF CLYDE E. WI.INS FRON THE OIILEIIOOD PARKS All> RECREATION CONMISSION. Ayes: Nays: Motion e1rried. Council Metllbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None Hathaway, (b) COUNCIL IIEIIHI HATHAMAY IIIOVED, AND IT WAS SECCNKD, TO ACCEPT WITH RE&Rn THE IESIIIIATION Of FUIICES SHAFFER FRON THE IOMD OF AD.JUSTIEIT AND APPEALS. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Mellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None (c) COUNCIL IIEIIHI HATHAMAY IIOVED, AND IT WAS SECCNKD, TO ACCEPT THE LmD FllGII FUIICES WFD IEC .... I. THE APPOIIITIIDIT OF MILTON SENTI TO THE IOMD Of MWUSTIEIT AND APP£ALS -TO D11£CT SUE IUDSIWI TO HIit HIM A Lmo -APPLICATION FOi THAT IOMD l(f-THE DODLI •• Ayes: Council Mellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Wa990ner, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: None Motton carried. 9. Publtc Hlartnt No public hearing was scheduled before Council. 10. Approval on Second lndtnt COUNCIL IUIO NATMIAY IIOVID, AND IT WAS SKGIIIO, TO APNOVE ON SECCIIID IUD- 1• AIElltA ITEM 10 (a) AS FOLL.Si (a) ORDINANCE NO. 69, SERIES Of 1991 (COUNCIL BILL NO. 75, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MENIER HATHAWAY) ENTITLED: A.N ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING APPROVAL Of THE STIPULATION ANO AGREEMENT rOR GROUNDWATER RIGHTS FROM THE PROPERTY BELOW THE SITE Of MCLELLAN RESERVOIR BETWEEN THE CITY Of ENGLEWOOD AND THE CITY Of LITTLETON. Ayes: Nay s: Motton carried. Council Nellbers Bullock, Van Dyke. Hathaway, Habenicht, WagcJOner , Gulley, Wiggin s None . ' • I . • • • I ]- • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 3 11. Ordinances, Resolutions and Notions • • • (a) Di rector Hayes presented a reco11111endat ion from the Department of Financial Services to a adopt a bill for an ordinance amending the Englewood Municipal Code to meet CML statewide reco11111endations for sales tax unifica - tions. The Deputy City Clerk was asked to read Council Bill No . 79 , entitled: COUNCIL BILL NO. 79, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HABENICHT A BILL FOR AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 4, CHAPTER 4, OF THE ENGLEWOOD MUNICIPAL CODE 1985 IN ORDER TO STANDARDIZE SALES TAX COLLECTION IN THE STATE. COIN:IL NEIIIER HABENICHT IIOVED, All) IT IMS SECOll>ED, TO APPROVE AGENDA ITEM ll(a) -COIN:IL IILL NO. 71, Ayes: Council Mellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: None Motion carried. ( b) Utilities Manager Woi ka presented a reconnendat f on from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bill for an ordinance annexing the property described in Suppleaent 118 into the Valley Sanitation District . The Deputy City Clerk was asked to read Council 8111 No. 78, entitled: COUNCIL BILL NO. 78, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER GULLEY A BILL FOR AN ORDINANCE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 18 FOR LOTS l, 2, AND 3 OF THE CLOX SUIOIVISION, ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO TO VALLEY SANITATION DIS - TRICT'S CONNECTORS AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL LANO WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. COUIICIL .... •uv IIMD, -IT IMS S(COll)ED, TO APNOVE MED ITEN ll(b) -COUIICIL IILL ID, 71, Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Mellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None Hathaway, (c) Uttl I ties Manager Wolka presented a reco..endatfon from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bf 11 for an ord I nance annex Ing the property described In Suppl ... nt 1119 Into the Valley Sanitation District. The Deputy City Clerk was asked to read Council 8111 No. 76, entitled: COUNCIL BILL NO. 76, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MENBER GULLEY A BILL FOR AN ORDINANCE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 119 FOR AN AREA APPROXIMATELY 9.698 ACRES WHICH JS OWNED BY RHS COMPANY ANO IS LOCATED IN ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO TO SOUTHGATE SANITATION DISTRICT 'S CONNECTOR 'S AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD TO JNCLUO£ ADDITIONAL LANO WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. COIN:JL .... •Ln IIMD, -IT IMS SICWD, TO ,VNOW( MED ITEII ll(c) • COIN:JL IILL NO. 78. • •. .. I . • • .• , 2 - • • Englewood City Council Minutes Deceaber 2, 1991 -Page 4 •, <, • • • Council Member Waggoner questioned whether this proposed council bill would have any affect on the flood plain. Mr. Woika stated it would not, as Arapa- hoe County has addressed the issue and made it part of the development plan. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Members Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None (d) Utilities Manager Woika presented a reconnendation from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bi 11 for an ord t nance annexing the property described tn Suppleaent 1120 to the Southgate Sanitation District. The Deputy City Clerk was asked to read Council Bill No. 77, entitled: COUNCIL BILL NO. 77, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER GULLEY A BILL FOR AN ORDINANCE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 120 FOR AN AREA APPROXIMATELY 36.790 ACRES WHICH IS OWNED BY THE PRESERVE AT GREENWOOD VILLAGE WHICH IS LO- CATED IN ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO TO SOUTHGATE SANITATION DISTRICT'S CONNEC- TOR'S AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL LAND WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. COUNCIL MENIER a,LLEY IIOYm, All> IT IIAS SECOlm£D, TO APPROVE MOGA ITEM ll(d) -COUNCIL IILL IIO. 77. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Metlbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None Hathaway, (e) Director Barthloae presented a rec0111endation frOII the Adlltntstra- t tve Services Depart•nt to approve by aot ton the 1992 contract for laundry and dry cleaning services for the Ctty. Ms. S.rthloae responded to questions frOII Council. She noted there ts a procedure tn place to ensure satisfactory workllanshtp. Dtscusston ensued. Council Metlber Hathaway expressed concern wtth btlltng probl .. s experienced a few years back when Quincy Cleaners was provtdtng cleaning services for the City. Ms. Barthloae acknowledged there had been probl .. s, however there has been a change tn ownership. COUNCIL NEIIIEl IMIIDIIEI IMO, MD IT 1111 SRWD, TO ACCE" THE IID FOi UUIINtY N DIY CLEMJ• SD¥JCU ,_ QUINCY CLEMOS JI THE MIUff OF SJl,Ul.00 • Ayes: Nays: Motion Clrrted. Council Meabers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, W~r, Gulley, Wiggins None Hathaway, (f) Director Barthloae presented a rteOlllendatton frOII the Adlltnlstra - t fve Services Otpart•nt to approve by aot ton the IH2 contract for purchase of non -... rgency, police and fire uniforms. D1scuss10ft ensued . -------·- • .. I . • • l ]- • • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 5 '· • • • ,. COUNCIL MENIER HATHAlfAY NOYED, NI> IT lfAS SECONDED, TO APPROVE THE BID PACKAGE SUBMITTED BY NEYE'S UNIFORMS, INC. FOR THE PURCHASE OF NON-EMERGENCY, POLICE ANO FIRE UNIFORMS FOR 1992 IN THE AIIOUNT OF $78,189.75. Ayes: Council Melllbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, lfaggoner, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: None Motion carried. (g) Director Barthl<>11e presented a reconnendation from the Administra- tive Services Department to adopt five resolutions establishing employee com - pensat 1 on plans for 1992. She noted a pay i ncreue of 3'l is being proposed for each of the groups. Ms. Barthloae clarified that these resolutions ad- dressed the 911ployees that are excluded frOIII representation in any collective- ly bargained systea; the City Manager and department heads are handled sepa- rately; and the pay 1 ncreases have been budgeted for 1992. The reso 1 ut ions for Agenda Items (1) through (v) were individually assigned numbers and read by title: (1) RESOLUTION NO. 79, SERIES OF 1991 A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR PERMANENT, PART-TIME EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992. COUNCIL IOID HATIWIAY MOVED, -IT lfAS SECONDED, TO APNOVE RESOLUTION NO. 71, SEIJES OF 1M1. City Manager Fraser noted the resolutions also cover insurance prNiut11s and the rates to be paid for the coaing year. He advised that the City will be realizing a SS rate decrease for the City's self-funded health insurance plan. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Nellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None (ii) RESOLUTION NO. 80, SERIES Of 1991 A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR CONFIDENTIAL EMPLOYEES OF THE C ITV OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992. COUNCIL IIEJIIEI VM DYi£ NOVED, -IT IMS SECGM>O, TO APNOVE RESOLUTION NO. 80, SEIIES OF lMl. Ayes : Nay s: Motion car ri ed . Council Nellbers Bullock, Van Dyke , Habenicht, Wa99ontr, Gulley, Wiggins None (ill ) RESOLUTION NO . 81, SERIES Of lMl Hathaway, A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR GENERAL SERVICES MANAGERIAL ANO SUP ERVISORY ENPt.OYEES Of THE CITY Of ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992 . . ( •, • I. • , ---• - • • Englewood City Council Ninutes Dec•ber 2, 1991 -Page 6 • • • COUNCIL NENBER HATHAWAY NOVED, AND IT WAS SECONDED, TO APPROVE RESOLUTION NO. 81, SERIES OF 1991, Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Mellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None (iv) RESOLUTION NO. 82, SERIES OF 1991 Hathaway, A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR FIRE DIVISION MANAGERIAL AND SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992. COUNCIL NEIIIO IULLEY NOVED, AND IT WAS SECCN»ED, TO APPIIOVE RESOLUTION NO. 82, SDIES OF 1991. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Netlbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None (v) RESOLUTION NO. 83, SERIES Of 1991 Hathaway, A RESOLUTION APPROVING A CONPENSATION PLAN FOR POLICE DIVISION MANAGERIAL AND SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992. COUNCIL IIEIIIEl IIATIWMY IIMD, _, IT IMS SECCN»ED, TO APPIIOvt RESOLUTION NO. 83, SERIES OF lHl. Ayes: Nays: Motton carried. Council Mellbtrs Bullock, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Wa99oner, Gulley, Wiggins None 12. ...,.al D1scusston (a) Mayor's Choice Hathaway, (1) Mayor Wiggins presented a letter appotnttng Council Mellber Waggoner to serve on the Englewood Urban Renewal Authority. COUNCIL IIEIIIEl MLOCI IIMD, _, IT IMS SECGMIO, TO APPIIOV( THE MYOl'S AP- POilfflDT Of COUNCIL IIEJIIEI lrll .. TO SO¥t • IIIOPIIED TON ON THE EJIIL[. lfOOD UIIM IEIIEIIAL ... SAID TUii TO DPIII ON FD11M1Y 5, INS. Ayes: Counctl Mlllber s Bull oc k, Van Dyk e, Hathawa y, Habeflt cht, lltgg0ner , Gulley, lltggtn s Nays : None Motton carrted . ( 11) Mayor Wi99h11 tft11tbd COUftCtl .....,.,. Habefl t cht for laytng th e groundwork for reapportt«Naeftt petttton tnv , and CouftC tl fo r ct r cu lat t ng th e pettttons . (b) Coun ci l Meaber 's Cftot ce • < •. • I. • • , - • • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 7 .. • • • ( i) Council Member Gul 1 ey requested Counc i1 be apprised, on a regular basis, of lawsuits pending against the City. City Attorney DeWitt assured her that he follows this practice. ( 11) Council MHber Waggoner requested an update on pol ice car expenditures. City Manager Fraser advised that once the figures were com- pi 1 ed, through the end of the year, an evaluation and COlllparison report would be forwarded to Council for review. Mr. Waggoner requested a status report at this time. (iii) Council MHber Habenicht: 1. She thanked Mayor Wiggins for his kind coaents and acknowledged all those who worked on the reapportfon•nt issue, including the Sheridan City Council and spectftcally Council Nellber Bullock. 2. She stated Council has received p&l"llfsston to petttton at Cinderella Ctty and she asked for volunteers. Dtscusston ensued. 3. She COllllented that Council had let her down, as well as the citizens, by rejecting her request to attend the NlC Conference and parttcfpate fn the FAIR Policy C0111tttee •etfng, •especially since the travel funds are available and others wtth less reason to go are being sent.• She noted she had secured funds to attend tn order to .. t her responsfbflftfes as a lltllber of the COll- atttee. She read the following letter into the record which she had received froa Colorado WOiien fn Municipal Goverraent reflecting their granting of funds: Dear Alex, Congratulations on your re-election as ...,.r-at-large of the Englewood Ctty Counctl. The ctttzens of Englewood are fortunate to have such a hard working, dedicated person such as you serving on their council. I • pleased to tnfol"II you that the Executive Board of Colltag •t this aorntng and voted to gtve you a scholarship to attend the National league of Cities 1991 Congress of Cftfes in las Vegas, Nevada in DecNlbtr, tn the aaount of Sl00.00. lie were sorry that we could not fund the total aaount for you, but our bud9et would not allow that auch of an expendi- ture. Hopefully, in the coaing years we would be able to do auch aore for outstanding WOiien to attend these conferences when their cfttes are unable lo afford to send th ... It ts truly a loss for the entire State of Colorado when qualified people are prevented froa attending these ... tings and representing the best interests of their constituency . AlH, I hope you can raise the rest of the aoney to attend . Englewood will surely be a loser ff you cannot attend . I will bt looking forward to seeing you fn las Vegas. Sincerely, lorraint N. Anderson .. I. • • , ]- • Englewood Ctty Council Ntnutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 8 ·, I. • • • She asked to meet with City Attorney DeWitt, prior to leaving, to discuss the preparation of a resolution to present to the Fair Pol icy Committee in the event "things break down" with ACCE. (iv) Council Metllber Hathaway: 1. She questioned if the City of Englewood has a pursuit policy. She COIII· niented on an article that appeared in the Rocky Mountains News regarding a pursuit in the City of Sheridan, where one of their pol ice officers refused basic assistance to escort SOllleone to the hospital. She noted one of the "pull-overs• was at Pennsylvania and Hallpden. She questioned if the City of Englewood had any involveaent or 11abi11ty in conjunction with the City of Sheridan. 2. She requested that Mr. DeWitt provide a copy of the City of Denver graf- fiti ordinance. City Attorney DeWitt advised he would provide copies of the Long Beach, California graffiti ordinance, which would provide a good perspec- tive, and he stated he wtll also trans•it a copy of Denver's graffiti or-dinance. (v) Council Metlber Van Dyke: 1. She urged Council to support a llellbership in the LAB 2000 prograffl In Cin - derella City. City Manager Fraser noted additional information would be pro-vided in the next Council packet. 2. She reainded Council that ACCE would be holding a aeeting at CML Wednes-day to discuss strategy for the NLC Conference. 3. She noted she had received a COllplaint regarding overgrOlffl weeds and the sidewalks not being shoveled at the parking lot at the northwest corner of CherokN and Floyd. She requested ownership clarification. 4. She encour19ed Counctl to support the appointant of Mayor Wiggins to the Urban Drainage and Flood Control. City Manager Fraser stated letters would be prepared offering support for his appointant. (vi) Council NNber Bullock: I. He coap11•nted Ms. Habenicht on her organfzatfon of the petttiontng ef-forts regarding reapportio....nt. Z. He expressed concern that the proposed graffiti ordinance granted a •judici al type of authority• to the City Manager which could present potential 11911 probl•s . He questioned if it was appropriate to give the City Nan19er penal power. 3. He reiterated c011pl1ints froa hoat CM!ers around Englewood Higti School and encouraged further study of the parking situation. Counct) Meaber Habenicht recoa.nded a review of the Planning and Zoning Coaprehenslve Plan in an 1ttt11Pt to resolve SOIII of the issues by tftforcing restrictions that are alr ady in pla ce. . . .. -. , .. I. • • • - • • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 9 (, • • 4. He declared his intention to work towards beautification of the Hampden corridor, between Santa Fe and Downing. He instructed the City Manager to approach the State Highway Connission with a request for matching funds. Council Member Habenicht noted the Beautification Committee had identif i ed several areas of concern, which included the corr i dor. Council Member Hath - away pointed out that this area has been studied previously and encouraged Mr. Bullock to draw on those resources . She also noted that Sl00 ,000 of the General Fund has been designated specifically for beautification. City Manager Fraser advised of previous attempts to work with the State De - partment on this problt111, as they control the median . However , the Director of Division VI has indicated a willingness to look into the suggested improve - ments and begin design work for aesthetic i111prove111ents which also addresses safety concerns. He noted the State has agreed to provide sOIIM! funding for the project . Council Hetlber Hathaway c01111ented that the Federal Aid to Urban Systelfts will occasionally assist in the funding of beautification projects . (vii) Mayor Wiggins: l . He urged everyone to attend the Decelllber 5th redistricting aee t i ng at th e County Adllinistration Building c01111encing at 6:00 p.•. 2 . He inquired whether any City funds had been allocated for Counc i l Netaber Habenicht to attend the NLC Conference. Council Neaber Habenicht noted she plans to use approxi.ately S450.00 of her discretionary funds. 3 . MYOI IIIIIINS IIDVED, -IT IIAS SKWD, TO • IITO DECUTlft SHSI• AFTEI THE IIEETI• TO DISCUSS A PDHIIIEL MTTEI. Ayes: Council ....,.rs Bullock , Van Dyke, Hathawa y, Habenicht, WIIJ90Mr , Gu ll ey , Wigg i ns Nays: None Notion carried. (v iii ) Counci l Neaber Gulley: l . She ca•1nded Council Nlllber Kaben i ch t's coait.nt to t he NLC and her po licy c0111 i ttee and f e lt the City shou ld f und the ba l an ce of her t r ip. COIIICIL NUIIEI UilY IIDWED, -IT IIAS SECOIIDO, TO _., COIIICIL ..,_. NUDIICHT $310.00 TO ,nm TIil at ca:EIIIU II IICOIIUTI• 0, IU EFFOITS TO OITAJI AS Miff FUleS AS NSSIIU TNIOUIN mu IIEMS • Council Netlber Va n Dyke explained she originally voted against Ns. Kabentcht 's travel requ es t only bec ause she s of the opinion that no -ore t han three r P· resentattves should attend t he NLC Conference. She ftels Ns. Habenicht rtP · r nt s the City 11 and she llfOuld SUPPOrt her attendance at th Pllrch con - fr nc In Washington O.C. tf Ns. Ha nlcht choos s to atl nd. . , •. I· • • , ]- - • • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 10 ·, • • • C• " Council Member Waggoner agreed that four representatives is excessive. However, because of Ms. Habenicht's membership on committees participating in the NLC Conference, he feels Council should support her. Vote results: Ayes: Nays: Motion defeated. Council Melllbers Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley Council Melllbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Wiggins 13. City Nanater's Report (1) Nr. Fraser provided an update on the status of the Larry Scott property whtch the Ctty received as Mr. Scott's beneficiary. He noted, in accordance wtth the State's probate laws, the Ctty wtll post notices for a 11intau11 period of four months to creditors and other persons tn interest on the estate. In the interia the City ts obligated to aatntatn the property and pay any bills in arrears. (b) He noted United Cable has recently had a nllllber of policy and rate changes. He advised Council of SOIII of the c011plaints his office has received, which the Ctty would be passing along to United Cable. The City's pen11it with United Cable expires in approxiaately 36 months and negotiations wtll begin tn April of 1992. 14. City Attorney's Report (a) Mr. Dellttt discussed the various graffttt ordinances and requested feed-back froa Council. He transaitted copies of the Long Beach ordinance. He noted representatives of the Eng18lf00d Chlllber of COMtrce have revttwd and agreed with the concept of a graffiti ordinance. Council Mellber W1990ftlr tnqutred as to the cost of rt11Dv1ng graffiti in the City of Eng18lf00d. Ctty Manager Fraser offered that a reasonable estiaate could bt given of the amount of labor and aaterials used in rt110vtng graffiti froa public property by Ctty staff. Discussion ensued regarding the probl• areas. (b) He discussed free spttch rights in ulls coaenttng that the Colorado Supr-Court recently ruled that ulls cannot absolutely restrict speech activities by aeabtrs of the public in the ulls. He shared infora.- tion on the court's decision. (c) He discussed the NLC Conference 9 ... plan and passed out copies of the ACCE Monitor Vol1111 l, Issue 9 and a handout discussing Superfund Policie s • Municipal Lhbflities. He asked to •et on Declllbtr 9th with all Nabers attending the NLC Conference . . , • . ' I. • • '- ]- - • Englewood City Council Minutes Dec: .. ber 2, 1991 -Page 11 15. Adjournment '· • ,.. • • COUNCIL IIEIIID IIAWY IIOYED TO AD.JOUM. The 11eeting adjourned at 8:50 p.m. . ' ' • I. • • crn CIIIICIL --STAm HPGIT Ftl TIE DUWI ,. INI crn COUIICIL IEETI• ~· Ort9t111lf119 It• 0.,.rtalftl Otscrtplton Aclton liken SA FIN SCRY COIIICIL flllllTES 11/11/91 APPROVED 7-0 IA ltECREA TICII TO ACCE'1 IIESI-TICII Of APPROVED 7-0 CUD( E. WUiCIIS FD PAlllS I ltECIEATICII CCIIIISSICII • CCIII DO TO ACCEPT 1111N l(Cl(T APPROVED 7-0 IIESI-TICII OF FIMCES SIWFER FD IIMII) Of MJ I AmALS IC CCIII DO TO ACC(,r LmER FD FltMCES APPROVED 7-0 SHAFFER IECCIIIEll)f• APIIOllfflOT or fill TIii son ro IDAIID or MJ I APIULS UTIL oe.Nt ...... STIPULATICII APPROVED 7-0 I MilEOIEIT fCII alUIDIMTER RIGHTS PDEIIY IELOW 111£ SITE OF fl:LELLM ll(S(ft011 IE1W£EI CO£ I COL FIN $[RY Cll7t MDIH• ~ 15 TITLE 4, APPROVED 7-0 CIMPTER 4 TO STAIIINDIZE SALES TAX COLLECTICII II 111£ STAT£ UTIL Clf71 AlfDI• Slffl.ODT 118 TO APPROVED 7-0 YALUl SMITATICII DISTRICT'S COlll£CTill'S MilEOIEIT WITN CO£ TO INCLI& ADDITICIIAL LAIi) UTIL Cll71 AlfDI• Slffl.ODT 1119 TO APPROVED 7 -0 SOUTNliATE SMITATICII DISTRICT'S COlll£CTOI' S ACIIEODT WITN COE TO INCLUD( ADDITICIIAL LAIi> -I - • , • ~ 0 • • ~ i Follow-up COPIES TO BE DISTRIBUTED ~ SUE BRADSHAW TO SEIi> SENTI LETTER & APPLICATION : FOR BOARD BEFORE DEADLINE r UTIL TO SECURE SIGNATURES & FILE COPY WITH CITY CLERK SECOND READING 12/16/91 SECOfl> READING 12/16/91 SECOfl> READING 12/16/91 t ' .. , ... I • , i..-i I , , • 'l I • • IID UTIL CM77 APPIDVllli SUPPLOIEIIT 1120 TO APPROVED 7-0 SOUTHliATE SMIITATICII DISTRICT'S COIIIECTOR'S MiREEIDT WITH COE TO IIICLII)( ADDITICIIAL LAIi) IIE AIJIIIN SERY IDTICII TO ACCEPT 110 FOR LAUIIJRY APPROVED 7-0 I IIIY CLEANllli SERYICES FIIOfl QUINCY CLEMERS/$33,161.00 IIF AIJIIIN SERY IDTICII TO APPIIJVE 110 PACICAGE APPROVED 7-0 SUINITTED IY IIEYE'S WIIFOIIIIS, IIIC . FOR PUICHAS£ Of D-OIER&EIICY, POLICE I FIii£ WIIFOIIIIS FOR 1992/$78,689.75 llGI AIJIIIN SEJtY 11£S0t79 APPIDVllli CCIIPEIISATICII Pt.All APPROVED 7-0 FOR PEIIWOT, PART-TINE OIPLOYEES FOR 1992 11,11 01• sen 1£SONO APl'Ullli CCIIPEIISATICII Pt.All APPROVED 7-0 FOR CCIIFIDOITIAL EIIP\OYEES FOR 1992 1 IGI 11 ••• sen 11£SOf11 APPDllli CCIIPEIISAT ICII flUII APPROVED 7-0 FOR COIEUL SERVICES NMMCERIAL I SUPOIISOIY EIIP\OYEES FOR 1992 IIGI• AIJIIIN SER¥ RESOl82 APPUllli CCIIPEIISATICII Pt.All APPROVED 7-0 FOR FIii£ DIVISICII IIMMCERIAL I SUPOYISOIY EIIP\OYEES FOR 1992 .. ,. MIIUI SER¥ IESOtll APPUllli allPEIISA T ICII Pt.All APPROVED 7 -0 FOR POLICE DIVISICII IWIAGERIAL I SUPOIISOIY EIIP\OYEES FOR 1992 IZA1 au IIICGIIIS: PRESEIITED LTR TO APPOINT CII IIMiGOIIER TO NIA APPROVED 7-0 -2 - ------------------.... """'""";;;;::;.;::;a:;:::=:~~ • • - • • SECOND READING 12/16/91 AllllN SERV TO PROCEED II/BID; COPY TO BE FILED II/CITY CLERK AIIIIN SERV TO PROCEED II/BID; COPY TO BE FILED II/CITY CLERK ' I ( I ., TERM TO EXPIRE 2/5/95 '-...l' , j ... r I • 7 ~ I • " • • IZA il CJliR IZI I au IZI II au IZlftt au IZIIY au CAm IZlv CIU • Ill GG IIS: TIWll£D CN INOUCHT FOR LAY llli ........ FOR ll£AIIPORTICIIOT PETITIOllllli l COIIIC IL FOR C llCUI.Allllli P£1 ITIOIIS CiULLEY: REQUESTm RECiULM ll'OAT£S OIi UIISUITS P£11>1111i A5AIIST THE CITY IMCOIO: REQU(STm ll'OATE OIi POLICE CAR EIP£11>1 TURES INOI ICHT: I. TIWll£D MYOI IIIGCIIS FOR K Ill> alllEJITS l ACICIDIUDliED THDSE _, IIOll£D OIi IPPPOITICIIOT JSSU( IICLll>lllli •RIIWI CITY COIIIC IL l SP£C1 Fl CALLY CN MUD Z. STATm COUIICIL 1111D 11£C'D PEJIIISSJOII TO PETITIOII AT CIIIDELLA CITY/R(QU(STm WOUIITEERS J. COIIDTm CGllltll 1111D LET ID DOIII AS WELL AS CITIZEIS IY DOIYlllli ID IEQU(ST TO ATTEII> ac ca£1TIOII l PMTICIMTE II THE FAIR POLICY CGIIIITTEE lllHTJllli; -STATm -IN SECUR£0 FUNDS TO ATTEII); IEC'D saaMSHIP FRIii Colllag, SHE READ THEIR LTl JITO THE 1£COII); -ASl£D TO NEET 111TH CA PRIOR TO LEAWlllli FOR ac CCIMIITIOII MTNMIAY: I. QU(STIOIIED COE PURSUIT POLICY I MY IIIOlftlDT OR LIMILITY II COIIIECTION IIJTN CITY Of •RIIWI 1£: IECOIT CITIZEN CONPLAINT Of SHERIIWI POLICE REFUSAL FOR BASIC ASSISTANCE Z. IEQU(STm COPY Of CITY Of DEIVER GRAFFITI OIIHIMl:E WM DYi£: I. UIGED COIIICIL TO UPORT NEMERSHIP II THE LAB ZOOO PIOliMI AT Clll>ERELLA CITY Z. ROUll>ED COUIICIL TMT ACCE IOII.D BE HOLDING A NT& AT Oil IIOlll(SDIAY TO DISCUSS STRATEGY FOR •c COIIFEIEICE -3 - ~-..,,.===;;;~~- • • l • ~ • CNGR TO PROVIDE STATUS REPORT CNGR TO PROVIDE REQUESTED INFORMATION CATTY TO PROVIDE COPY CNGR TO PROVIDE ADOITIONAL INFO IN NEXT COUNCIL PACKET I . r . , I . 7 ....,.; I • ~ • -· ~ I) ~ - I llv f Ollilt Jllvlf au I llv fl f Ollilt IJA Ill OliR au • • • .. l . ADVISED SN( IMO REC'D CCIIUIIT FR(JI CITIZEN 1£: IUtTHIIEST COMER Of CHEbEE I FLOYD -11££DS ARE OVERGIIOIII I 1ML«S AR£ M>T SflWELED 4. D1COURAG£o COlaCIL TD SUl'tlmtT APPOllffll(NJ Of MYOR IIICCIIS TO U11M DIAIIWiE I FLOOD COITAOl. IUll.OCl: I. CCll'l.lNDITED Of lNEIIICHT ON HER OISMIZATJON Of PETITIONIIIC EFFORTS RE: REAPPORTJCIIIENJ z. £lllREssm COICEIII It£: GRAFFITI ORD GRMTIIIC CITY "'11UG£R f'£JW. POIO J . ltEITERATED CONPt.AIITS FRON HIii( OIIIERS AAOUJI> OIGt.(IQI) HIGH 5CHOOt 11£: PMICING 4. D£CLM£D IITEITION TO 1a1C ON IEAUTIFICATJON Of IWIPD£1 CORRIDOR IOW(EJI SMTA FE I DOlllllli IIICCIIS: I. UIIGED EVERQ( TO ATTEII> IZ/5/tl ltEDISTRICTJIIC NTC AT COIIITY Alllfl 11.DG AT 6:00 P.N. Z. IIIQUl1t£D IIIETHER Of fMIDIICHT IMS USllli CITY Alms TO ATT(II) TH( 11.C COIIIF£ROICE l. •m TO co IITO EJECUTlrE SESSION AFTER NTC ON PERSGa[L MTT£R GULLEY: 1. fl>V£D TO A1MRD Of fMIDIICHT USO TO ATTEII> 11.C CCWEIIEIC£ II RECOGNITION Of HER EFFORTS TO OITAII FUNDS TIIIOUGH OTHER N£A11S ..... TC ON LAMY SCOTT PAOP£RTY ..... TE Of UIIIIT£D CAil.£ -4 - APPRorrD 1-0 DCFEATED l -4 (AYES: HAIEIICHT, WAGGONER, GULLEY) STAFF TO CLARIFY OWNERSHIP OIGR TO PREPARE LETTERS OFFERING SUPPORT FOR WIGGIN'S APPOINTNENT NATTER TO BE STUDIED FURTHER , . . ~ ~· \ ~~ ) r , . I . 7 . "' '--" I ,_ . ' .. , , ' • ~ ' .,. w N - 14A 148 14( CATTY CA TTY CA TTY • • • • ' orscussm VARIOUS GRAFFITI OflOINANcEs; TMISNJTTED COPIES Of LONG 8£Aat ORO DISCussm flt££ SPEECH RIGHTS '" ""HS; TRAlsN1mo COPY Of SUPRol[ COURT DECISION DISCUSsm file COIIF£RDIC£ 'Ml£ PLAN; "'5S(D OUT COPIES Of ACC£ -ITOR WOLCIIE J , ISSU£, • fWIJOuT 01scuss1• SUPERFUIID fl0l.lC1£S -.... ICIPAl LIA1ll1Tl£S; ~ TO flE£T JZ/9/91 111TH All NDaERS ATTDIDJNG 111.C COIIF£R0t£ All SOtl COIIICIL NDaEIS 1 :50 '·"· -5 - , CNGR TO PROVIDE ESTIMATE OF COST OF RE~VING GRAFFITI FRON PUBLIC PROPERTY '\ 1 /r,\ /' -;~ .:.\ ' -. ~ ,,,, ~ L-i r &..,..I I .. ,' I . • ~ 11. I - - • • • • • AGENDA FOR 'nlE REGULAR MEE11NG OF I • 111B ENGLEWOOD Cl1Y COIJNCIL DECEMBER 2, 1991 7:30P.M. 1. Call to order. 1·'3 c; jMv- 2. lnvocatJon. /b..d»-d__ 3. Pledge of Allegiance. 4. Roll call. r/ ~,,j- () .J.5. Mtnutee. ~'"lf,J ~ '1 "'~. L Mtnutee from the N~ 18, 1991 RegUlar Ctty Coundl MeeUD&, 8. Pre·~uJed Vlalton. (Pleue 1lmlt your praentaUon to ten ~utee.) /f l))L - 7. Non·Scbedulecl Vlalton. (Please Umlt your pnaentauon to ave mmuta.) 1/.fXi_ 8. CommunleatlOm, Proc1NMU0D8 and AppOmtmmta . • ,. ~ • . ' I· • • , • City Council Agenda December 2, 1991 Page 2 9. Public Hearing. (None Scheduled) 10. Approve on second reading. • • I• • a. Council Bill No. 75 approving the Stipulation and Agree~tt~Of.,, . / 11. At! groundwater from the property below McLellan Reservoli". ttVIU,U.~ / jp.Ja.6'!/t. 11. Ordinances, Resolutions, and Motions. (A a . Recommendatton from the Department of Ftnanctal Serv1ces to adopt a (' n,~L I \ J bill for an ordinance amending the Englewood Municipal Code to meet \., V ~ ~y CML statewide recommendations for sales tax unlftcation. ST~. ~, , j~ (1--01 ' SOURCE: Lornille Haye,, Director of l"blandal Semca. ~"llt-· ~ G b. Recommendation from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bill for an f'.'-' 7 '6 ~,ft ordinance anncxmg the property deacrtbed In Supplement I 18 Into the l. V r:1, Q alley Sanitatton 'f}:':V'f.l· ,T~ ,OURCB: Stewart Foada, Director 1 I of UtWUa. ~ ~J,/)0.AJ!Lf c. Recommcndatton from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bill for an '\ () !7 & l ordinance anncxmg the property deacrtbed In Supplement I 119 to the D 'i ~" Southpte Sanltatton Dis~. F.DJ/#OfP.tCS: .• t,-ut Foada. (J .. ') 'l' DlnctorofUtWUN. ):l.,du.y / ~---~-l V- (1 d. Recommendation from the Water and Sewer Board to adopt·a bd1 tar an rt L f)' f 1 ~ ordinance anncxmg the property deac:rSbed In Supplement t 120 to the c. P •• "'P , Southpte Sanltauon ~J 1~nAJ.,,~~:: ,tewut ......_ ~.A)' DlnctorofUtWUN • ., ~ /;,'-.u.,e,U'U-. ,.,L( /1,U ~ e. Recommendauon frrm the MmtnwtraUve Semcca Depar1ment to ... ,;. ,.A-~ ,.y· · 1t ,l 00 approve by motion the 1992 Contnct far laundry and cby cieenJnC (If f ~ 1fi ~~l ' L aerw:afortheetty. ffAff~~~DlnctN ~ '3. vlJf . .. MlldldatraU.. ....... • r ,. ..,·T ' /. / • I ' t. f. RecommrndaUOn from the AdmlnwtraUve Semcca Depar1ment to uP" ·• ~ approve by mouon the 1992 Contnct lor aon-emcremc,. ~ and 1? ·,': , 4 ~~i;rze:.:~:..~~Ul~,t~~~ ~ <1 ~ 'p 1,v , 'RIL f't.ll/llSt. J ;Jtt~ j b ·1 I l,l,~¥. • ' I . • , ]- - City Council Agenda • Oecember 2, 1991 Page3 . ' • • t• • g. Recommendatlon from the Admlnlstratlve Services Department to adopt five resoluUons establishing employee compensation plans for 1992. STAFF SOURCE: Randle Bartblome, Director of Admlni1traUve Semcee . "'~ - . 1.uo 11 t. A Resolution approvtng a compensation plan for pcrmanen~~#,.,.._ / ~ {~ ttme employees of the City of Englewood for the year 1992. ,~~iuJ 1~ [lrf rf\ U. . A Resolution approvmg a com~.~tion plan.for confidential . , / cf ~~J. , emP"-"of~eCltyof~forfb,,'JOMl992,{)tJA_~ 11,,0 t).,rT:., W. A Resolutlon approving a compcnsatton plan for General Services Z'J · I .' 11 JV'igl , managerial and ~:":!-employees of the City of Englewood for ~~ theyearl992.,.,~'1 /a/~1''1~ -, ,0 uf 1 Iv. A Resolutton approving a compcnsaUon plan for Fire DMalon r;t .?-: 1 managerial and syj>C~soiy~:~~e City of Englewood for -~~ Oft-'' the year 1992. Md.ewffl.LNJM/~ J :'_~ Q' l.~~-A Resolution approvtng a compcnsauon plan for PoUce Dlvlalon 'ffe O :,; managertal and supervtsory em~ea of the City of En&lewood for 1,0 the year 1992. ~f.UJ/ (/V'tJ...?~ 12. General DlacuUIOn. L Mayor's Choice. , . -~~ D I. Letter appolnttng Counctl Member KeUa Wl(Pltt ,_ ~ ~/ /;,// _ f I '1"' unexpired term on the Ur~~ Autbartty. ~ / Ptl.~ b, CounctlMcmbaa'Cholce, t{/'91'~~: y. t• , ~ IS, City~ Uflol , , . tr,ilZ,w,.I '-Ju4.J 14. CltyAttom~R . = t,}dtL 114t ~ Mi,,_ Ad~ t. ~~ t}U'U!-''-..,/ , • ~'),µ.,, a:tJt '.Z-.IJA:v . . (/ • The foDowln& lilnutea were tranamstted to Council from l l / 15/ll • l l/17111: • ' ~ • " I· • • , • ,. - ' -• t• ' . • ' ] .. . . I . • • . , - • • 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. • • t• . • ' AGENDA FOR 11IS REGULAR IBB11110 OF 11IS BNOLSWOOD CJff COUJIICD. Call to order. lnvocaUon. PJedle of AIJeglaace. Rall call. MIDuta. DSCBIIBSR 2, 1891 7:SO P.11. L Mlnuta rram the November 18. 1991 Re&Ular City Coullcll Mulml, " - 8. Pre-Scbeduled Vllllton. (Plew llmlt your pneentaUon to tm mlllutm.) 7. Non-Scbeduled Vlatton. (PleMe llmlt your pneentaUon to 8ve mlllutm.) a. CGmmunleatlam, ProdNMUom and Appamtmmta. L Letter rram Clyde 1: . .,.... lndlcaUDC 1m,..,.,,,,, rram tbe 7-0 J:a4ewood Para and Recreaaaa o, .. , .... b. Letm'fram l"nllcee .................. If n,wnon hm tbe BDlll'Clol A,dJuatmmt 1111d ..... . c. Letts rram ....... ....._ ...,., .. ,,......_ 1mt11ar IIIIP*ltlllent to tbe 8ollrd of MJm ................ . • ' I· • , - ( . • • • City Council Agenda December 2, 1991 Page2 9. Public Hearing. (None Scheduled) 10. Approve on second reading. • • t• • .. fl a. Council em No. 75 approving the SUpulaUon and Agree~ for / \ (j1 ty1 ..,.._,., &om the property below MoLdlan -...,. c:.-o ~ ~ 11. Ordinances, Resoluttons, and Motions. a. Recommendatton from the Department of Ftnanclal Services to adopt a C B rlU bill for an ordinance amending the EJlllewood Mumctpal Code to meet (I ckJ: CML atatewtde recommendaUona for aalea tax unlftcaUOn. 8TAn' D-0 /l{)h>,)1 ~ URC&: Lornlae Nayee, Director of Pblallclal llenlcea. · I /V ~ · b. Recommendatton from the Water and Sewa' Board to adopt a bill for an , ordinance annexmg the property cleecrlbcd In Supplement I 18 Into the ~t-1 i Valley Sanitation Dtatr1ct. 8TAn' aouac&: atewart ....... D1NctGW I/ I. ., VtUIUea. Recmuaendatlon frrm the Water and Sewa' Board to adopt a bill far an ordinance annextng the property cleecrlbcd In Supplftnent I 119 to the Soutbgate Sanitation Dt11tr1ct. nAn' rm: atewart P••••· DeNcter., uww... Recaauaa,ct,auon frrm the Water and Sewa' Board to adopt a bal far • ardmance an!M'Xlnl the p-operty deec:r1bed ID Supplement I 120 to the Soutbgate Sanitation Dtlltrtct. 8TAn' 80UIICS: ---...... . Dlncta o6 UUIIU.. U."'R:eCCJmmmendauon frrm the Mmmwtratlve 8el'Ylcea Depar1ment to lmnl'Dll'I! by motion the 1992 Contract far laundry and dry ..,...,,..,, :~ for the Ctty. ffAn' eouacss a ............. Dll 1D1• rr-Mllllldatratlft ......... , r. Recommenda tion frrm the MmlDwtratlve 8el'Ylcea Depar1ment to approve by motion tbe 1892 Contract far wa ....... aency. police and Ire Ulllbm =J. J ffAn' MIGIIC81 .................... .. ., Meetafott---......... I I) 1'5 't-~ l'A.L.d.- 7~() . ... • I . • , ]- • • • • t• • City Council Agenda December 2, 1991 Page3 g. Recommendatton from the Admtldatrattve Servleea Department to adopt ftve resoluttons estabUshJng employee compensation plans for 1992. STAPF SOURCE: Radle ButlllolDe, Director of~ llenlcee. ~q'· u. /}JµtJ w. A Resolutton approvtng a compensatton plan for permanent, ~n J n/AM time employees of the City of Englewood for the year 1992. f /-{) V,r ~ · A Reaolutton approvtng a compensation plan for conftdenu,L, ,IJ llhiYrJ(J( / employees of the City of Englewood for the year 1992. v/-U ,r · A Reaolutton approving a compensatton plan for General Serw:ee managerial and aupervtsory employees of the City of Englewood ff . /J {/p.,Q_,, the year 1992. v rv / I A Reaolutton approvtng a compensatton plan for Fire OlvtaloD manager1al and supervisory employees of the City of Englewood JII ~ the year 1992 . 'NW A Reeolutton approvtng a compensatton plan for Police Dlvtatoll managerial and aupervtaory employees of the City of Enpwaod"" _ the year 1992. /'Y) frd 12. General Dlacuulon. a. Mayor'• Choice . , . I. • • , • ,. - ' ' ' -• . . • . .... • . ' . ' ' r . ,. ] • • "' • I . . - • • • • • t• ·, • DIILEIIOOO CITY COUNCIL ENGLEIIOOO, ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO Regular Session Novlllber 11, lttl 1. Call to Order The regular 111eeting of the Englewood City Council was called to order by Mayor Van Dyke at 7:40 p.•. 2. Invocation The invocation was given by Council Metlber Bullock. 3. Pledge of Allegiance The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Van Dyke. 4. Roll Call Present: Council Mellbers Hathaway, Gulley, Wiggins, Bullock, Clayton, Habenicht, Van Dyke Absent: A quorum was present. Also present: 5. Minutes None Ctty Nan191r Fraser Ctty Attornty Dtllttt Deputy Ctty Nan191r Martin Ctty Clerk Crow (1) COUNCIL IIEIIIEI 111•1• ..... -IT IMS KCCIIDED, TO Ar ... ft TIii IIIIUTES Of THE HIULM IIHTJ• OF ..... t, INI. ~ts: Council Ntabtrs Gulley, Hathaway, lltggtns, Bullock, Clayton, Habenicht, Van Dyke Nays : None Motton carrted . 6 . City Clerk Crow rtad the 11st of newly eltcttd Council NNibtrs : Counc 11 NNibtr At · hrvt Alexandra Habenicht Council NNibtr At -larve Kell s ll199oner Coun c il Mtabtr , Dt s trtct I . . • I· • . , •' \ f • , ]- • • Englewood City Council Minutes Nove111ber 18, 1991 -Page 2 Rita Hathaway Council Member, District Ill Sheri Gulley • • • <. The newly elected officials were sworn in by the Honorable Lou Parkinson, Municipal Court Judge. 7. Members of the City Council were temporarily seated and Chairperson Van Dyke requested roll call. Present: A quorum was present. Council Members Hathaway, Van Dyke, Gulley, Wiggins, Bullock, Habenicht, Waggoner 8. The following assign111ents to boards and c011111isslons were announced: Clean, Green I Proud C01111ission Rita Hathaway Econ011ic Oevelop11ent Coalition Susan Van Dyke Kells Waggoner Englewood Downtown Oevelopaent Authority Rita Hathaway Fir ... n's Pension Board Clyde E. Wiggins Housi119 Authority Sheri Ciulley Parks and Recreation C011111ss1on Kells Waggoner Police Pension Board Clyde E. Wiggins Public Library Advisory Board (non-vot1119 llellber) Alex Habenicht Retlreaent Board Susan Van Dyke Swedish Task Force Tia Bullock Rita Hathaway Urban Renewal Authority Ke 1 ls Waggoner . ' • . I . • • . , I 1' , 2 - 1 • • Englewood City Council Minutes Nov111ber 18, 1991 -Page 3 Water and Sewer Board Clyde E. Wiggins Tim Bullock Sheri Gulley School/City Committee Sheri Gu 11 ey Clyde E. Wiggins • • ,~ • Denver Regional Council of Govern111ents Until January 1, 1992 -Rita Hathaway, Delegate Ti111 Bullock, Alternate After January 1, 1992 -Tim Bullock, Delegate Rita Hathaway, Alternate Colorado Municipal League Policy C01111ittee Alex Habenicht, De119ate Ti• Bullock and Sheri Gulley, Co-alternates Tri-Cities Group Alex Habenicht Susan Van Dyke 9. Council Mellber Wiggins presented tokens of appreciation to W1111a111 Clay- ton, Jr., retiring Council Metlbtr. 10. Mr. Clayton offered an extensive list of Council's accOllll)lishllents during tht last four years, of which ht ts very proud. Ht cited tht c01111it .. nt of Council, City Manager Fraser and staff to provide EngltlllOOd with tht "best, aost efficient, aost user friendly, and affordable govtrnaent possible.• 11. Chairperson Van Dyke called for n011inations for tht office of Mayor. COUNCIL IDIU HUDIIQIT •1MTED CLYDE Ill.INS TO SO¥£ AS MYOI, COUNCIL IDIU HATNMIAY SECONDED TIE -IMTIGN, COUNCIL ..a HATNMIAY IIO¥ED TIE •JMTICIIIS It CLOSED. Ayes: Council Metlbtrs Gulley, Hathaw-,, Wiggins, Habenicht, W199ontr, Bullock, Van Dyke, N-,s: None Tht Chairperson dtclartd tht mtion carried and Clyde Miggins duly tltcttd Mayor. Ms. Van Dyke txprtsstd pride in Council and its •111 KCOIIP11Shalnts since 1981, noting several specifically. Sht COllllftttd that Council had •nagtd to Mintatn current ltvth of Ctty ""tees Md, altlloulll on a ttglltly con- strained budget of rtVtftutl, had betft ablt to create Md provide MW levels of services to tht coaunity. Sht thanked City staff for contributing to htr "effectiveness as Mayor.• Ns. Van Dyke offered c0119r1tulattons to Mayor Wig- gins and presented tht offtctal gavel to hta. ,. ~ • - .. I . • 0 , - - • • • • ,~ • t• • Englewood C1ty Counc11 Minutes Nov .. ber 18, 1991 -Page 4 12. Mayor Wiggins thanked Ms. Van Dyke and commended her for her •excellent job" as Mayor. He called for nominations for the office of Mayor Pro Tem. COUNCIL NEMER BULLOCK NOIUNATm RITA HATHAIIAY TO SERVE AS MYOR PllO TEN, COUNCIL MEIIIER HABENICHT SECONDm THE NOIIINATION. COUNCIL NEMER VAN DYKE MOVED THE NOIIINATIONS IE CLOSED, Ayes: Council Members Gulley, Hathaway, Van Dyke, Habenicht, Waggoner, Bullock, Wiggins Nays: None The Mayor declared the motion carried and Rita Hathaway duly elected Mayor Pro Tem. 13. Pennanent seating was agreed upon and the llellbers assumed their seats. • • • • • Council Melllbers Van Dyke and Habenicht were recognized for their contributions to the City of Englewood for having served as Mayor and Mayor Pro TN respectively. • • • • • 14. Recognition WIS given to the faailies, friends and guests of the newly elected llellbers of Council. CGUIICIL IIENID •LOCK IIOVED, -IT IIAS KCOIIB, TO IECUS F• IIFIESIIIElffS, Ayes: Counc11 tlellbers Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, lfllt0"9r, Gulley, lf1ggtns Nays: None Notion carrted. The aeethMJ WIS reconvened at 1:35 p.a. Roll was called. Present: Al so present: Counc11 tlellbers Hathaway, Van Dyke, Gulley, Bullock, Habelltcht, lfaggoner, lftgg1ns City Manager Fraser Ctty Attorney Delfttt Deputy Ctty Man ... r Marttn Ctty Clerll Crow Dtrector Fonda, Uttltttes Asststant Ctty Atton1ey &rt .. Dtrector Esterly, Publtc Works 15 . Dn11Mtton of L•l _,.,... COUIICIL IIEJall M.LOCI ..... -IT IMI IBIIID, Tl IUl•Tt TIii -I'S• HDALD AS TIii LUA&. llllllNNI,.. TIii can., a, en•. Ayes: Counc11 .....,_r, Bullock, Van Dyke, Hlt"away, Habelltcht, Waggoner, Gulley, lf191tn1 Nay s: None Nolton carrttd. . , • . ' I . • 0 ' 2 I - • • Englewood City Council Minutes November 18, 1991 -Page 5 16. Pre-scheduled Visitors • • I • • (a) Cheryl Giordano, Accounts Payable Technician, Department of Finan- cial Services, was honored as Englewood's Employee of the Month for November. City Manager Fraser co111111ented upon Ms. Giordano's many qualities which con - tributed to her nomination. (b) Dorothy Romans, Holiday Parade Coordinator, presented a trophy to the City for the winning float entry in the 22nd annual Holiday Parade. Ms. Romans offered appreciation to all persons who give of their time and effort to the parade which is enjoyed by so many. She announced that the 23rd Annual Holiday Parade will be co-chaired by herself and Mike Woika, Utilities Man· ager, and it is anticipated that in 1993 Mr. Woika will serve as chair111an. City Manager Fraser extended appreciation to Ms. Romans for her dedication to this annual project. 17. Non-scheduled Visitors There were no non -scheduled visitors. 18. Coauntcations and Proclaaattons There were no Connunications, Proclaaations or Appointments to consider. 19. Public Hearing No public hearing was scheduled before Council. 20. Approval on Second llaMtnt COUNCIL 11811D NAIDICNT IMO, -IT IMS SUWD, TO UPIDft • SKGlm IDDI. --ITEIIS IO (a) n•• <•> AS FILL.Ml (a) ORDINANCE NO . 64, SERIES Of 1111 (COUNCIL BILL NO. M, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HATHAWAY), ENTITLED: AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING ISSUANCE OF A QUIT CLAIM 0£ED TO THE CITY OF LITTLE· TON FOR A PORTION OF THE REAL PROPERTY KNOWN AS STERNE PARK CITY DITCH ENCLAVE AS A RESULT OF THE CITY DITCH RELOCATION . (b) ORDINANCE NO . 65 , SERIES OF 1111 (COUNCIL BILL NO . 67, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HATHAWAY), ENTITLED: AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE SALE OF SIX PROP£RTJES WHICH WERE DEVELOPED FOR THE ·eulLD " PROJECT TO BE SOLD ON THE OPEN MARKET . (c) ORDINANCE II). 66, SERIES Of 1111 (COUNCIL IILL NO . 72, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MENIER HATHAWAY), ENTITLED: AN ORDINANCE ADOPTING THE IUOGET Of THE CITY Of ENGLEWOOD, COlOIIADO, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 1992 . . ' I . • , ] Englewood City Council Minutes Nove111ber 18, 1991 -Page 6 '· • • • (d) ORDINANCE NO. 67, SERIES OF 1991 (COUNCIL BILL NO. 73, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HATHAWAY), ENTITLED: AN ORDINANCE APPROPRIATING MONIES FOR ALL MUNICIPAL PURPOSES IN THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, IN THE FISCAL YEAR BEGINNING JANUARY 1, 1992, AND ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1992, CONSTITUTING WHAT IS TERMED THE ANNUAL APPROPRIATION BILL FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 1992. (e) ORDINANCE NO. 68, SERIES OF 1991 (COUNCIL BILL NO. 74, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HABENICHT), ENTITLED: AN ORDINANCE FIXING THE TAX LEVY IN MILLS UPON EACH DOLLAR OF THE ASSESSED VALUATION OF ALL TAXABLE PROPERTY WITHIN THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, AND ESTABLISHING A MILL LEVY FOR THE ENGLEWOOO, COLORADO, DOWNTOWN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY. Ayes: Council Members Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: None Motion carried. With regard to future appropriation ordinances, Council Mell· ber Bullock requested that the City Manager's office be 1dent1f1ed as a sepa· rate line 1te111. 21. ONl1nances, Resolutions and llotions (a) Director Fonda prestt1ted a recllllltndat1on froa the Water and Sewer Board to adopt a bill for an ordtnaftCe approvt .. the St1pulatton and Ag,.......t for groundwater froa the property below Mclellan Reservoir. Nr. Fonda ••- plained that as part of this 19reeaent, Littleton .ould receive 35 acre feet of water 1n perpetuity. The City Clerk was asked to read Council 1111 lo. 75, tt1t1tled: COUNCIL Bill NO. 75, INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MOIBER HATHAIIAY A Bill FOR AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING APPROVAL Of THE STIPULATION AND MREOOT FOR GROUNDWATER RIGHTS FROM THE PROPERTY BELOW THE SITE OF MCLELLAN RtSERVOIR BETWEEN THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD AND THE CITY Of LITTLETON. COUNCIL IIEIIKR HATIWY IIDVED, -IT IIAS SUOIIDED, TO APPIDWt MED ITDI 11(1) -COUNCIL IILL IO. 71. Ayes: Council Mellbers lullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, W199oner, Gulley, Wtgg1ns Nays: None Motion carried. 22. llnera1 Dhcusston (a) Mayor's Choice (1) Mayor Wiggins offered a rtsolutton authortzt .. a lease,,.... •nt for the Federal Ftrt Statton property. Assistant Ctty AttorMy rt• . ' • . I . • 0 I , ~ ]- • • . Englewood City Council Minutes Nov .. ber 18, 1991 -Page 7 ' • • I.• • presented information concerning the proposed lease agreement, explaining the lease ts triple net for a term of five years with the City retaining the right to sell the property at any time during the term of the lease. The lessee would retain the right of first refusal of any offer given during that tt11e fr1111e. City Manager Fraser provided tnfonaatton concerning alternatives available to the City tf the property ts not leased tn this manner; he con- finned that no additional parties had CON forward with an offer since the .. tter was last discussed with Council. Mr. Fraser explained the process thus far. Placement and approval of signs WIS dtscussed. Council Mellber Gulley expressed concern that approval of the lease, which ts favorable to the les- see, 11tght be viewed IS being a bit iaproper since the lessee is a fonaer council llellber. She suggested that the property be offered for lease in the general .. rket. Council Mellber Waggoner concurred; he questioned the tenas of the lease tn coapartson wtth the value of the property. It WIS pointed out that wtth the real estate .. rket being what tt ts currently, the Ctty would at least realize sonie income fre>11 the lease and would not be liable for the main- tenance, snow removal, heat, etc. It was confinatd that the Ctty would retain the rtght to sell the property during the lease period, with the lessee having the first opportunity to buy tt. Council Mellber Waggoner agreed that leasing does provide steady tnce>11e for the Ctty, and he suggested arrang8118nts be 111de to openly offer the property for lease. The resolution was assigned a nUlllber and read by title: RESOLUTION NO. 78, SERIES OF 1991 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD TO ENTER INTO A LEASE WITH GLASIOND, INC., OWNERS OF HOUSE OF GLASS TO LEASE FEDERAL FIRE STATION LOCATED AT 4065 SOUTH FEDERAL BOULEVARD, SHERIDAN, COLORADO. CGUIICIL IUID WM DYU IIOYED, -IT IIU SICGIID, TO APfilDWt IEIOWfl• •• 71, SDIES OF IHI. ~es: Council ....,.rs Hathaway, Van Dyke, Wtggtns Nays: Council Nlllbers Habetltcht, ll1190Mr, Culley Abstain: Council .....,.r Bullock Motton defeated. Council Nlllber Bullock explained hts abstention was based on a personal conflict of Interest. Mayor Wtggtns directed the Ctty Manater to proceed wtth edverttstng the lease on the open aarket. (tt) Mayor Wtggtns requested dtscusston concerning the appotnt11111t to ftll the vacancy on the National Le19ut of Ctttes Energy, Envtron111nt, and Natural Resources CoatttH. Council Nlllber Van Dyke, tn conjunction wtth Mayor Wiggins, proposed that the E119lewood Ctty Council support the appotnt- •nt of Susan Thornton, Littleton Ctty Counctl Prtstdtnt. She offered that Ms. Thornton hu bttn an acttve parttctp111t tn the ACCE l19tslatton, btt119 very knowltd9eable and tnforaed on the subject, and wuld reaatn Kttve tn the •tro ACCE coalttton. Ms. Van Dyke aatntatntd that Its. Thornton has n- recognttton and ..c,uld serve the Bt-Ctty plant wll on the SUPERFUND tssut at the NLC Convention. She noted that through thts support, E119lewood wuld bt rtlinqutsht119 tts appotnt .. nt to thts coatttH, but she ts of tht optnton tt ... ~ • .. I. • • ' ' , 2 ] • • • .. Englewood City Council Minutes Nov111ber 18, 1991 -Page 8 • "' - • • would be in the best interest of Englewood in the long run, and therefore justified. Council Member Bullock concurred that the appo1ntnient of Susan Thornton would be in the best interest of Englewood. Council Metllber Hathaway agreed, COlll- ment1ng that Englewood and Littleton do not have too many differences with the issues. Council Member Habenicht presented a different view, stating that she feels it is important to support an Englewood City Council Melllber as representative in an 1tte1111>t to retain the 1ppo1nt111ent. COIIICIL NEIIIEl VAN DYKE IIOVED, All> IT IIAS SECONDED, TO SUPPOltT TH£ APPOINTIOT Of 5USM THOIIITON, LITTLETON CITY COUNCIL Pl£S1Dm, TO THE NATIONAL LEMUE Of CITIES DIOIY, ENVIIONIIENT, All> NATUUL IESOUICES COIIIITTEE, Ayes: Council Mellbers Bullock, Yan Dyke, Hathaway, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: Council Melllbers Habenicht, Waggoner Motion carried. Mayor Wiggins directed the City Manager to notify Ms. Thorn- ton and Colorado Municipal League of E119letf0od's support of Thornton's appointment. (111) Considerable discussion of Council Members' requests to rep- resent the City at the upc011ing National League of Cities conference 1n Las Vegas, Nevada, took place. Council Mellber Bullock recOlllended Council Mellber Yan Dyke be allowed to at· tend as she has the political contacts and .auld be by far the aost effective representative llttllber of Council. Mayor Wfggtns noted Stu Fonda, Director of Ut111t1es and Rfck DtW1tt, Ctty Attorney would be attending. Council Mellber Gulley aafntafned that any Council Netlbtr who feels they could contribute should be encouraged to atttftd, that ft .ould be appropriate to show support for the NLC progr ... • t City Attorney DeWitt explained that NLC has endorsed the current ACCE legtsla· tton, however tt •ts not a dead Issue• and •there are coapett119 resolutt111s c011tng out of the .ood.ork. • Ht expounded on the taportance of this tuue aftd he c0111enttd on the efforts that are being llldt to garner support for the ACCE legtslatton. Council Mellber Yan Dyke revtllftd the conference agenda. Ofscusston tt1sued. Council Neabtr Habenicht noted Colorlclo Munfctpal League has a nUllber of their own vott119 delegates tn lddttton to Ctty del191tes. Council Neabtr Wiggins stated ht .auld recOllllftd that COUftcil Netlbtr Bullock be allowed to attend. • ' I . • 0 , ]- • • • • Englewood City Council Minutes Nov .. ber 18, 1991 -Page g Council Member Habenicht requested Council's support to attend the conference. She noted she 1s a me111ber of the Policy C011111ittee, Fair Pol icy Committee, Finance Administration, and Intergovernmental Relations. Ms. Habenicht dis- cussed various resolutions that would be considered at the conference and stated she has been a member of the Fair Policy COlllllittee for three years and is gaining knowledge and influence on that COlllftittee. In response to the previous discussion, 110tions were made as follows: COUNCIL MENIER HATHAWAY NOVED, Alm IT WAS SECONDED, TO APPROVE SUSAN VAN DYKE'S ATIENDMCE AT NATIONAL LEMU£ OF CITIES CONFERENCE. Ayes: Council Melllber Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins Nays: None Motion carried. COUNCIL NBIIER HATHAIIAY NOVED, Alm IT WAS SECONDED, TO APPROVE SNEii IULLEY'S ATIElltMCE AT NATIONAL LEAIUE OF CITIES CONFOENCE, SUIJECT TO RECEIPT OF FINNICIAL STATEMENT. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Mellbers Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Wag- goner, Gu 11 ey Council Mellbers Bullock, Wiggins COUNCIL 11811D HATIWIAY IIOVED, _, IT IMS SUCIIIDO, TO APPIOVE TIii MLOCl'S ATIEIIMICE AT NATIONAL LEMUE OF CITIES CGIIFDIIICE, Sl&JECT TO RECEIPT OF FIIIMICIAL STATEIIEIIT. Ayes: Nays: Motion carried. Council Mellber Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley, Wiggins None COUNCIL 11811D NATHMIAY IIMD, -IT IMS SECOmED, TO AMIOVE AUi NAIEIIICtff'S ATIEIINIIICE AT TIE MTIGML LEMUE OF CITIES CGIIFDIIICE. Ayes: Council ....,.rs Habenicht, Waggoner, Gulley Nays: Council ....,.rs Bullock, Van Dyke, Hathaway, Wt91in1 Motton defeated. Counctl llellber Habenicht questtOfted the vote and expressed her dtsappotntaeftt, explaining that she ts a duly appointed representative to one of NLC's c011111tt- t .. s, servtng on the Finance, Adlltntstratton and lntergovernaental Relations (FAIR) Pol tcy C011111ttt... She potnted out that her appotnt•nt to the FAIR C011111thH was supported by Counctl, therefore, she dtd not understand the posttton reflected by the negattve votes. Those aeabers vottng tn opposttton offered thetr reasons. Counctl llellber Wag · goner, tn support of lls. Habentcht's travel request, potnted out that by defty - tng her attendance at the conference, the Ctty ts sendtng a atxed .. ,sage to those tndtvtduals lllho are wtlltng to serve. (b) Council llellber's Choice I . • . , , - - • • . ' Englewood City Council Minutes Novet1ber 18, 1991 -Page 10 • .,_ • ,~ • ( i ) Counc n Member Waggoner inquired if the City ut i 1i zes the State bid list for patrol vehicles. City Manager Fraser explained the State bid list is a possibility and staff has been directed to analyze the police vehicle package. (ii) Council Melllber Habenicht: 1. Ms. Habenicht shared the results of the Colorado Municipal League Policy COtalittee meeting of Novetllber 13, 1991, which she attended as alternate. 2. She informed Council she had been approached by a lllelllber of the Board of Adjust111ent and Appeals about the possibility of another resignation fra111 the Board. Because of the Board's probleas in securing a quorum, she encouraged Council to advertise the vacancies and conduct interviews so that Board of Adjust111ent and Appeals appointaents could be •ade as soon as possible. Dis- cussion ensued resulting in a decision to advertise as quickly as possible all known vacancies as well as those appoint .. nts which expire in February, 1992. 3. Ms. Habenicht stated she has been advised of serious problet11s in the Project BUILD progr ... She requested the .. tter be discussed in study session soaetiae during Decetllber. City Attorney DeWitt and City Manager Fraser spoke briefly about the covenant restrictions, stating they have been alerted to possible financing probleas. Mr. Fraser stated that by 111id-Dectlllber they should be in a position to discuss the .. tter with Council. 4. She stated she would appreciate it if Council would reconsider their vote regarding her attendance at the National League of Cities Conference. (tti) Council Mellber Bullock: I. He offered congratulations to Mr. Wiggins and Ms. Hathaway as Mayor and Mayor Pro Tea, adding he looks forward to a cohesive Council. 2. He re11inded Council of the redtstricttng .. ting scheduled wtth Sellator Considine on Noveaber 26, 7:00 p.a. at the Malley Center; also, the ... ttng on the s-subject on Deceaber 5, 6:00 p.a., at Arapahoe County Adllltntstratton Building. Council Mellber Habenicht urged Council to circulate petttions con- cerning this .. uer . She stated she has petitions if anyone ts wtlltng to ctrculate th ... Mr . Bullock and Nr. Wt91tn1 also have petitions available . 23 . Ct ty llanatet'' I a.,ort (1) Mr . Fraser announced that the next Tri-Cities ... ting wtll be De· cetllber 4, 7:30 p.•., at Sheridan City Hall . (b) He announced that a laree porttOfl of the Buyer's Club butlding has been leased by Offtce Depot . Offtce Depot wtll ..,1oy 40 persons and plans to open after the first of the year. (c) He wtll be absent froa the City Novlllber Zl·H addreutng the 111W Mexico City Managers Association cOflCe"'ing collecttvt bart1tnt... ltlldl Mar · tin wtll be Acting City Manager . • . .. I. • 0 I - • • Englewood City Council Minutes Noveaber 18, 1991 -Page 11 ' • • " • (d) Mr. Fraser offered a list of prospective citizens to serve as Mell!· bers of a Privatization Task Force proposed by Council Metlber Gulley. Ms. Gulley explained the concept. Council was instructed to review the list and contact Mr. Fraser with suggestions. 24. City Attomey's lleport (a) Mr. DeWitt spoke briefly concerni119 the following topics: 1 He noted that the redistricti119 resolution has been approved by Sheridan, Littleton, and Greenwood Village. 2. He c01111nted about the Lakewood case regarding derelict vehicles. J. He advised that the National Association of Regional Councils of Govern- .. nt has endorsed S-1557. 4. He c01111nted regarding use of •nicipal funds for redistricting and will provide an opinion regarding this aatter. 5. He will provide a copy of the aost recent ACCE MONITOR. 6. Mr. DeWitt noted that Aaerican Insurance Group v. Pinkard was set for argument last Friday. 7. He provided information regarding a settl ... nt in the Ralston Reservoir aatter. 8. He c01111nted that the ... ting of National Institute of Municipal Law Of- ficials ts uncertain. t. He wtll be .. eting with Don Clay, EPA, regarding hazardous waste clean- up. 10. 111th regard to Project •nLD, he stated staff ts tryt119 to deteraiM the ext1t1t of problas bet119 noted. 11. Coptes of Council's Procedure lluual wtll be transattted shortly. 12. He coaented upon llalf"NII Co. v. City 111d County of Dlftver cCN1CeN1i119 sales and use tax aatters. 25. M,tounant CIUIICIL -u.Loat ... Tl .... TIie ... ti119 ldjoul'Md at 10:21 , ••• i~~~.~ "~ '' • ' ~ ' I . • 0 ' I ]- - Mr. Steve Neyer Chair.an . . • • • ... Noveaber 14,1991 Englewood Parka & Recreation Colllliaaion I hereby tender ay resignation froa the Englewood Parka & llecreation Coaaiaaion, effective this date. Being a aeaber of this Board since 1987 vaa an extreae enjoyaent to -· Each and every -ber of the Coaaiaaion I have served with has been a conscientious worker and an •••et to the City of Enalewood and I'• proud to have been a fellow C:0-iHion -ber. cc : Ccwa t sa1on lielllbe r A ...-En &lewoocl City Council Mt-. Jerrel Black leapectfully, ~kt..~ Clyde I. Vigiaa Council .. n, District IV . ' ' .. 8 a I. • 0 • - - • "' .• .. • -.. • . . .. 8 b Novellber 25, lttl Mayor Wl99tna Sn9lewood Colorado Dear Nayor1 3701 South Broadway Englewood, Colo. 80110 303/781-4004 I wtll be rHt9ntn9 froa Tbe 9oard of AdjuatMnt and Appeals after the Deceaber 11. 1111 ••tln9. It la with re9ret that I will no lon9er be reatdtn9 In the City of an9lewood, therefore. I WIii not Met the residence requtr ... nta necessary to continue on the Board. Tb I a off 1 ce. aa a Naber of tbe 9oard, baa been aoat I ntereat I n9 and reward I n9. Tbank you for tbe opportunt ty of ••rvtn9 on the 9oard. Yours truly, '"ln.r. ~//~!f ,- rrancea Shaffer "r---~::"I I Ji~J t,,.., •• '.,,__. .. ·" 1..£ l -·~Ui\wu 1. l . , ' • I • • • ]- - INDEPENDENT MEl.!!ER RROKE'R Noveaber 25, lttl City council Sn9lewood Colorado ·, ... • '' • C. • ... 3701 South Broadway Englewood, Colo. 80110 303/781-4004 8 C Plea•e con•lder Milton aentl for appolnt .. nt to the IIOard of Adjuataent• and Appeals. HI• yeara of ••rvlc:e and knowled9e pertalnln9 to ln9lewood would certainly be an HHt to thl• IOard. current Addre••: Bu•lne•• Addre••1 Thank you. rrance• abaUer 2t2t w. union Ave. Sn9lewood, CO 10110 Telepbonea 795-1502 NII ton ... ti CO,, •1 3701 IOUtll koadway ... lewood, CO IOUO . .. • ' , I. . - - ] • J • • • . ' • ~ BY AUTHORITY ORDINANCE N0(4 SERIES OF 1991 COUNCIL BILL NO . 75 INTRODUCED BY COUNCIL MEMBER HATHAWAY AN ORDINANCB Atrl'HORIZINO APPROVAL OP THB STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT FOR GROUNDWATBR RIGHTS noM THB PROPERTY BELOW THE SITE OF MCLELLAN RESBRVOIR lln"WEBN THB CITY OP ENGLEWOOD AND THE CITY OF LITl'LETON. WHEREAS, the Enpwood Cit.y Ceundl aldhoriald raliftcation and appnpriation fll a ript or all water ripta which may be withdra-from 1nc1e....r1 pound water well, by the adoption or Ordinanca No. 51, Seri• fll 1981; and WHEREAS, Bqlewood hu applied,-..U. to puap poundwater r,.,m the property below the McLellan Raervoir lite, 1uch lite Ila within Liwetal City bounclarie1; and WHEREAS, the City fll Littleton i1 claimifls the ript to UN the ume p,,undwater by ~t of a Littleton City Ordinance; and WHEREAS, Littleton MNI ..... to be in the Sauth Plalt.e River to ....-...t the flow of the river to compenuw ror cartain .,.,,..1 pit..._ evapentiln; ud WHEREAS, lncleweocl eouW ,....W. nplae••t.,.. from the poundwater or other aourcu in retum ror a ,..,,.,.._ ..w,art fl UUletoa'1 claim fl the balance ol the rroundwater; and WHEREAS, upon appnwal fldda-laMaa by thee.rt Bncle•eocl wiU deliver t.e Liwetal 36 acN fllt ., .... per ....... ,-r ia ......... _. .... replaetaent water ror evaporation olwatar in the LiUlltaa Olawl ....._ _. WHEREAS,11po11 .......... .rt111a-lrC: ............................. ..., McLellan Rnerwir i1 ...... ..a.ly by ....... _.--., be UNd he ti any ordinance or re1trirt ion ; and ..-,. -. WHEREAS, LiUlewn wiU witMraw III IH 11f&a t.e .......... 1 Wl-uillutary 8114 Nit non -tributary p,,undwater cun; NOW, THEREFOR&, H IT OIDADfSD BY TBS cm COUNCIL or THB CITY or ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, AS ,Ou.owl: Sec&ten l . hlncle• ... Citreew8 .................................. ~ ror .......... ,,.. &Ila ............... .rllcLellal INenoir, lllth Stipulation And ~t......., ,,...._ • ...... : A. En,ieweod huapplW .... ..._llt..a.wltll ................... .., r,.. lhe ~ .............. Nd,11111 .................... .., .... a.,., Bncle• .............................. a.., .............. 8 . En,i.weoct In._. le w die ... •••illlf llt wtet,11,.,,_. . ' ' 10 a ' .. I • • • , .• \ , ]- - • • • • • t• . • ' '· ( .1 , .~ • D18TRICT COURT, WATER DIVIIION 110. 1, •TATB or ~LOMDO CASI No. ,,cwo,a DI 'l'D IIA'l"l'D 01' TD APPLICATIOII roa lfAflll lltmlft 01' TD CITY 01' IIIGLllfOOD DI fllS IIO'r•IIOIITRHUTUtY DIDIVD, WMIIOa, MID LAIIUIIa-rox RILL8 AQU?nu, AIID Tim llOIITIIIIIU'l'AJtY LUANta-J'OX BILI.a IQUIPD IN AM•AROS MID DOUQLU COOll'l'IU Appltoant the City of lntlevoocl, • Colorado auniolpal oorporation (•znc,1evooct•), and tb• City of Littleton,• coloraclo aunlc1pa1 corporation (•Littleton•), tbroup tbeir Wlden1fMd rapreNntativu and their nepeotive attorner•, hereby •tlpul•t• and •tree•• followa1 l. Jpt,rA4Hat,lQDf 11:rtJU Inf IYDPl:II• 1.1 lnflevood bu applied for da••• for wlla v1t:ll wbiab to ,-p fr'OUl'Clvater tna the~ Nlow the alte of llal.ellu .... l'YOlr ducrlW on attadled aidllla1t A (the •na,ertr• and tbe •Gzoundvater-). 1.a 'l'M ,nperty 1• OWM4 a,, 1n11wooc1. . --··-- 1.l 1W or all .of tlle Property ta vttllln tlle aity Ualta of Littleton. 1., lnflevood lntenda to w tile fl'CNll..,.ter tor aunicipal purpoaee. 1.1 Littleton olalaa the rilbt of tbe uae ot tlle Grwndvater by virtue of Littleton Ctty cmttnanoe llo. U (lertu ltll) enaoted punun to co10. a.v. ltat • I J7•tO•ll7(1), lntlevood dleput .. ta.at claia on varioua 9rounu. 1., Littleton bae a IIMd for wur to M ,1...a 1n tbe louth Platte lliver, to aui,aent tbe flov of tbe rlYelr to ooapenaate for •v•rration troa oertaln tnftl pit labe, and for other nnlolpa uau. lft9levood la villi.at to ~We auctt replaceMnt vater froa tbe Groundvetu or fl'all otllec . . ,,_ ' I . • • ' •• ' I I • , ,, I - • • ,,. • ·~ • (. C. Littleton claims rieht of use or the Ground-ter by virtue or Littleton City Ordinance No . 41, Series of 1985, Enclewoocl disputes thi1 claim on varioua crounda. D. Littleton hu a need for -ter to be placed in the South Platte River, to aup,ent the f1ow of the South Platte River to compensate for evaporation from certain l"avel pit lakes and other municipal use,. E. Enclewoocl i1 willinc to provide 1uch ,..__t wa&er &om the Groundwater or other 11. IOUrcN, in retum for the favorable ..W.-t of Lit&letMl'1 claim to the balance or the Groundwater. F. Enclewoocl will deliver to Liu.let.on, from the Oround-ter utract.ed, or from the McLellan Reurvoir, Of' from odler _,_ available a quantity of water not to e1ceed 35 acre feet per calendar yur in perpetuity. G. The water will by used by Littleton for munidpel purpo1e1, lncludi111 to aus,nent the flow of the South Platte River to compenute for evaporation from sravel pit lakes. H. Said water will be delivered upon written requat to Enclewoocl from Littleton. I . Littleton acne• that the Groundwater is appropriable aolely by Enpwoocl, and Enclewood may withdraw and UN the Ground -ter fN or any ordinance or other restriction lmpoeed by Littlatea. J . Upon approval ofthi1 Stipulation And Atnement by the Court, and its inc,orpora&.ien by ref'ennce In thil danee, LiUlelan will witWraw Ila 1pp11IU.. ill thi1 IMUer, which ia daled.July 11, lNl. K. Thi, Stipulation and Acreement i1 •forceable, upon 1IIOtion of either party, by order ol the Court which ehall retain jurilllidiea fer Ilda ,.,,..._ lntroducecl, rad in lull, and ....... 111 ftn& ....... IM lltlt.., "•-••bar, llll Read by title and pened on ftnal l"Wlills 111 ... W.., .,Dm•er, lNI. ------ PuWkhed by tkle u Ord'--Ne. -leriae., INl. • Illa ldt day .,o .. , ... INI . ATTIIT : ----------·-------------Loucrilhla A. !1111, Deput.y Clt.y C1erll I, a..crilhia A. lllie,.,...., at, a.II., .. 0., .,::,I~ 0111 .... ....., Clfflat, that the .a.._. ... ,.,• ..... -we1111a _,.... _ ._. ._.., and publlthed by title ae ~ Ne . -..... el IIIL ·2· .J I I , . , I. • • , • • • • • I• • ( .1,,·. DllTRICT COURT, WATER DIVISION lfO. 1, ITATI: or C::OLOJtADO CAIi NO. 11Clf012 lfllUI.ATIOII AND AGUINSNT IM Tim NA'l'Hll 01' TIIS APPLICATION ro• WA'l'D aIGHTa OP THa CITY 01' DIGLIWOOD IX TIIS NO'l'•IIOlfflllllUTAllY ...... , au.ABOB, MID LAJWlla-rox RILU AQUil'm, AIID Tim IIOll'l'llIIIU'l'llY LAltAJIIB-l'OX BILU AQUIPD IN UAPAROII: AND DOUGLU COUIITIU Appltoant the City of Intl.wood, a Colorado auniolpal corporation (•Eft9levood•), and the City of Littleton, a Colorado aunicipal corporation (•Littleton•), tllrolllb tllelr undereic,ned repra .. ntattv .. and their reapeotlve attorney•, hereby atlpulate and •tr .. •• followa1 1. rat:ro4YA1i1on• 11n1u end PYansnn. 1.a fte Property l• OWM4 a,, 11111....a. . ...---- 1.J SOM or all .of the Property la vltllln 1:1141 olty Ualea of Littleton. 1., lnc,levoocl lntenda to ue tbe Groundwater tor 111.lnicipal purpo•••· 1.1 Littleton olaiaa tbe riwht of tlle uae ot tile Groundwater br virtue of Littleton City Ol'dtnanoe No. U (leri .. 1'15) enacted punuant to co10. aw. ltat. I >7-tO-ll7(1), lntlevood diaput .. tllat claia on varioua trounde. 1., Littleton bu a Med for Wier IO a. ,i .... la tbe lou~ Platte aiver, to a....-nt tile flow of tile rl~ to ooapenaate for evarration froa outala lft'IU pit labe, .... ror other aunicipa •••· bfl..,... la vuu .. to •rw&M auctl nplaceaent water froa tM ....... tar or fna oCMr ,, - - I . • , - • • • , . • aource•, ln return tor favorable ••ttlament of Littleton'• claia to the balance of the Groundwater. Therefore, En9lewood and Littlaton atipulat• and a9na· a• follow• a 2. lfAter to l>tl oe11v1uo u 1nairmcad, 2.1 ZftcJlavood will dalivar to Littleton, froa the Groundwater extracted, or froa KcLellan ... •rvolr, or froa other •ourc•• availabl• to ZftcJlewood, a quantity of water not to exceect 31 acre f .. t per oalendar year in perpetuity, 2,2 The water will be delivered praaptly after recaipt by ln9lavood of written raque•t froa Llttleton, 2.l Th• water will be uaad by Littleton for 111.lfticlpal purpoaea, inclu41nt to au.,..nt the tlov of tbe loutb Platt• aiver to coapan•ate for evaporation froa vravel pit lak•• located within th• pr•••nt boundari•• of Littleton. 2., Tb• water will be delivered to the louth Platte at the aonfluanc• of Dad Clark Gulch and tbe loutb Platte aiver, or at any other looatlon Hleotecl by lnflawoocl and ac~able to Littleton. Any other •uch delivery point. allall aoaply with th• requiraente of any teaporary •uetitute •upply plan approved by the ltata ln91neer or deane for a plan of autaentation for the 9ravel plt lakee vblcb 1• obtained by Litt.laton, and vbic:h ruulta in th• ... quantity of repleoeaent water•• ...... red at Dad Clark Clulob. In ... tint el&Cb a deer .. , Littleton v111 aau naNftabl• efforta to include th• outfall of tbe SNJ18VOOd•Llttleton aev•v• treataant plant (tile Ii-City plant) a• an all~l• point of delivery. Utt.leton atnu tllat lnglawoocl •Y ....- in anr proaaadlnt for aucb a decne to nquut variCM&e-. .. late of delivery, ln vbole or ln r.rt· rauure to ataln a point of delivery other than Dad C ark CIUlab eball not nduoe · lnflewood'• obl i 9atlon to deliver . sntlevood ahall a .. 1•t Littleton, by taath1ony, and by pnvidlnt lnfonatlon, u -, be rea•onaitly n•c•••ary to obtain approval of Enflevood'• •ouree of water for nplaceMnt • J.5 water delivered by lnflewood ahall be of• auitable quality for replacaaent ~ by Littleton ln tile aoutb tlatte aiver at the confluence of Dad Clark OUlOII. 2.1 DaUv•rl•• ahall coaaenoa vbenever .... an n1111nc1 by the ltate .,.1neer f'&nu&n~ to an approvee t..,orary •ub•titute •upply plan, or vllen required by an, deorM for• plan of eupentatlon for the tn•el pit 1..._ wllicb 1• oa.talMCI by Littleton, or wllen otMrvlH Hlll•MM a., Littleton . -a- I' - • . - .. I . • , , - • • • ·, • .. ... J. Apprqpriagiqp A( tbe qrgyndyatar, Provided Sntl•vood coapll•• with th• teraa of th1• Atra ... nt, Littleton •tre•• that th• Groundwater 1• approprlul• Mlely br bfllawood, an4 lntflavood •Y withdraw an4 UH t:lle aroundwter free of anv ordinanoe or othar rutr1Rlon ...._ ... br Littleton. 4. lltMrtYll IC APPUAt:APP• 1. •msdSN• "'rill• stipulation an4 A9reeaent 1• enforoealtl•, upoa aotlon of either part)', br order of thla court vblOb allall retain judedlctlon for thl• pupoeo. 'ftlta ltipulatlon le dated lov .... r _, 1111. IIUTCIIIIIIOII, 81ACX, HILL I C:OOlt "' - • IY-o.-~ ... l"'"'t-a ..... -.-.1 .... 11~,~.-o-. ""'1""'a""'1-- •tabaol a. Niner, lo. 11111 1111 lpnoe ftnot ----~---------layaond L. teu'N, ~r,, ,. o .... 1170 lolal~, CO IOJOI Tale,llonaa ,o,1,,a-111, AflGUIIIII ,aa UPLICAIIT cin or lllltallOOD ... .,., 1700 LlnDOln atreet aulte noo Dell¥W, CO IOIOJ TalefMMI IOJ/Nl-7000 1M llonOrule & iionon5ie Neyor ot tM city of sneiewooi .. ,. of the c·""l'!"'t,-... ,-u .. t""t .. l ____ _ . , • . -. .. I . • •J• 0 , ~ I ]- • • t,: • · .. • . . SR!IIISID Ar NJWII a1dnlaa a. llela, .... 110 1ttll at., 11th •loor ~, CD IOIOI 'flaothY 3. ...ton, .... HO unloD 11 ... , hlte 400 .. NS', CD IOIH Mlteft a. ICINHn, .... 707-Utll tueet, lo. HOO DwW•, CD IOIOI ...... L. MUN, n., .... 1700 Llaoola ft., 10. 6100 DI aer, CD IOIOi -- .. -··- ... an •· as1111e, ..... llN lleft Utll & .... DMwer, CD IOIN n.vea •• tTeHen, -· ,. o • ._ 1440 loQl._, CD IOHa-1440 uu ... IIQMN, .... 110 lltll at., 1ot11 ,i .. · .,..._, CO IOIOI --- "'~ . . ( ' ~ . --~---=--- • ., I • • • . ; , ~ ]- I ' • . .. • DllTllC'l' COURT, WATlll D1Vlll0N NO. 1, ITATI or COU>JIADO CUB NO. IICWOIZ u ftl D'ITIII OI' 'l'D AnLICAUOII roa lllfta nan or ftl ClTI 01' IIICILIIIOOD D 'l'D IIOT•IIOll'l'UIUl'AU WWWVD, UUAIIOI, UD tUAIIH•IOX mu.a AGUinM, UD nm IIOll'l'UIIU'l'AD i.uuaa-rox nu.a IQUll'D D WftllOS AIID DOUlltU cannD • I 'ftll c:aan, bavlnt n.t__. tbe etlpulati• 1a tllla. aatter betveen tM appllaant City of IIMJl__. UMI tbe City ot Littletoa, UMI Nini hlly &4¥1 ... , .... auaa tut tu otlJlllladaa lo banllr ~. DIUDI 911111 CGIIBI iii ff1rrl'IIIII• a,i ~ &. 11i1a1n ......... Dlvloia ... l -----· --...... . . , - .. .; I. . • • , ? ]- - • • • DBIBl'I' A LNAL aacail"l'IGII IICLSJIM WWWVOD I' - t• .. nat part of tbe aouth one-balf of secti-32 and n, 'l'OlfMllip I IIOUtll, llaftl9" ... t of tbe Ith l'rinoipal llaridan, cauntr of ~, ftata of Colorado and that part of tbe IIOrtll one•balf of aection 4, 'fOIIMbip I aouth, JtanlJe 61 ... t of tbe Ith l'rinoipal IIU'idian, county of DourJl••, ltata of Colorado,_. partloularlr dNCribed u follon• c~w1nai119 at tbe aouth one-qaarter oorner of aection H, t'allfflebip I IIOUtll, JtanlJe 61 ... t, tbenOe • oo• 32' 04• • alOIII ta. ...i Una of tbe 110UtMUt ane-quarter of Aid aectioa H a diatanOe of ,21.10 feet to tbe True Joint of ... 1nn1n1, -'l'llenCe oontimai111 • oo• H' 04• • alCIDIJ Nici ...i U• a cllatanoe of 1241.01 feet to a point lrinl 111 feet IIOUtll of ta. oentar of section 321 -~ • 11• 56' ,,••a diatanoe of 360.J feet, -ftellN • oo• 32' 04• • • tiatallOe of HI feet to• po!R • ta IIOrtll Una pf ta. awtllaar ~ of Aid aectlaa H, ..U po!R 1,1111 HO.J feet seat of tbe oaatar of aeatioa HI -----ftellN • 11• 16' ,,• • • cliatanoe of 1124.22 feet, -~ • 6J• 17' 1,• • a cliatanOe of 1,1.21 feet, •......,_a 77• U' 01• a a cliatanoe of SM.37 feet to a polat • tbe seat UM of aectioa H, Mid poi. 1,1111 40. 60 feet a..111 of tM ... t quarter oorMr of aectloa H, •~I at• IO' 11• • • cliatanoe of 241.21 feet, • tllHN I 7t• 01' at• • • cliatanoe of 4N. 41 feet, -tllaaa. • 60· 46' at•• a c11atanoe of a,1.11 feet• ----• 11· 17' 24• • • cliatanoe of Jtl.J4 ,.., 12' 11• • • cliatallDe of 411.61 feet• '' • ' I • • 0 , , ]- • • • • t• • <, -fllenoe • 25° 07' 42• If a diatance of 115.00 feet, -'l'llence • 11· 00' 49• w a distance of 332.73 feet, -'l'llenoe 8 u· 20' 41• w a diatanc• of 279.17 feet, -'l'llenoe 8 31 • 21' so• w a diatance of 390.45 fNtl -'ftellCa 8 72• 12' 35• I: a diatance of 579.U f .. t, -t'benCe 8 ,2· 41' 41• I: a diatance of 290.09 fNtl -'l'banoe 8 73• 41' 25• I: a distance of 477.16 f .. t, -t'benCe • 19• 54' 31• z a diatanc• of 253.54 f .. t to a point on tbe ... terly ricibt-of-vay line of the Hi9hline canal, -'l'bence aloftlJ the Weaterly ri9ht-of-va~ line of the Bitbline canal the folloviftCJ (9) cour•••= 1. Thence s 22• 35' 21• Ba di•tance of 352.11 f .. t, 2. Thence along a curve to the left havinca a radiua of 349.21 feet, a cenral a119le of 53• 43' oo•, and an aro lel'IIJth of 327.46 feet to a point of tanc,enc:yr 3. Thence s 11· 11' 21• Ba di•tance of 7.26 f .. t, 4. Thence s oo· 21• 20• w a di•tance of 25.61 f .. t, 5. Thence s 11• 11' 21• Ba di•tance of 170.90 f .. t, 6. 'ftlence alonca a curve to th• left bavinca a radiua of 621.33 f .. t, a central ancal• oft• 57' 15•, and an azo lenc,tb of 107.95 f .. t to a point of taNJenCY• 7. 'ftlence 8 16" 15' 43• a a di•tance of 95.,3 f~, .,.--.. -- 1. 'l'benoe • 09• 11• 43• a a diatnace of 93.24 f~, ,. thence alont a curve to tbe left bavinca a radl• of 525.21 f .. t, a central a119le of 02· 21' 34•, vboee .,._. beans 10· 29' Jo• I a diatance of n.63 f~, anlll an aro lencatb of 21.63 r .. t to a point on tbe 8Qutll UM of Section u, -'l'benoe continuinca alonca tM ... terly r11Jbt-of-wr Uae of ta. a11Jbllne canal SoUtheaaterly to the Nortll rlCJbt-of-war 11• of Comity Line ltoad f -nenoe .... terly and alont tbe North dtbt-or-wr 11• of c atr Line IINd to a point wbicb u .. JO r~ north anlll HIO.t IINt of tbe aoutbeeat comer of Section 32, TolfMllip I loutll, ..... A ... t of tbe 6th Principal lleridian, I . • • , ]- • • • • -'l'benOe oonUnuinrJ aloncJ tbe Worth dpt-of-way Una of ·county Lina JtOa4 • at• 54' oo• • a dl•tance of 200.35 feetr -~ • oo• 06' oo• • a dl•tanoe of 112.14 feet, -ftellOe • 57 • 03' ot• W a dl•bW of 134. H feet to tba ftue Jroil* of ... lnnlnl, oantaiainrJ 211.4 acrea _. or 1 ... llaLl .. 1 'I • .. I. • • '--~• ]- • • • • t• • COUNCO. COllll1JIIICAfl01' Date Dttanber 2, 1991 11 a Colorado Munldpal League Stall' recommende that City Council adopt the attached onltnence ""'""'blC Tltle 4. Chapter 4 of the ltn&k,wood Mmllctpal Code to add atandarcbsed deDamona md procedura devdoped by the Colorado Municipal League. None. 11118 aummer and ran . the Colorado MunlctpPI LeaCue WC11 keel wtth tta member ctaee tbrouCb a commlttft to ckvelop atandlrdlaed ...... far local aalee ta codea. TIie Intent of the ........ to atandardlae the vartoua tadMdual ... ta codea -tut lnMdneMel operatmc ID vartoua Colando dtlee wlll DO laaF bave to contend With cb8'erent aalea tax ddnlUona and procedura ID each city. TIie CML'a won reapoaded to compLelnta from the Colando Aa1Ddatlaa of Oni•nerce md lndaatry (CACI), wbicb repeeeuted IN8IDeNea operatmc ID ~ tbrou&bout the atate. TIie CML Wjed tta memben to mcarparate tbe aumd•dlaed ...... Into.._.. reepecttve codea by tbe end of 1991. If .ubataaaal coaperdaa wlda tblll dart la DOt exbbted by tbe ctaee. tbe CACI tbreatma to panue na ---. tbrou&b tbe Mllte ..... hare. ..... ... ' . ' I . • I ]- • • • ,. ~ .. ~ • . • ' - Tbe propaeed ordlD8DC#: accompllabea tbe pl of tbe CML by IDcludJDC tbe ataDdlladl&ecl J.aaCWtge ID our onttnence. Tbe ,,.,..,,..., Servlcea Dqa tment aad the City Mtarney'• omce will continue to review our ulea tax ord1rMmc:e durtn& 1882 to fw1ller illlmpllfy aad clllrtry our onttnance ID accardaDce with tbe CML'a policy and llltmt. Tuwad tldll end. we wll attlldy plll'1lclf81r with tbe CIIL and lta JIM'IDber cltlell to procluce a true "Model City Salea Tax 0rcttneare• tbat CIIII be adapted by aD 11ame na1e cmea. ftllAIICIAL Tbe attached ardlDaDc'e abould have DD meaaundJle flneDcta1 llllpllCt GIi tbe City • . ... . ' . .. I . • , I ]- • • • ORDINANCE NO._ SERJF.S OF 1991 • • . • ' BY AUTHORITY A BILL FOR t• AN ORDINANCE AMENDING TITLE 4, CHAPTER 4, OF THE ENGLEWOOD MUNICIPAL CODE 1985 IN ORDER TO STANDARDIZE SALES TAX COLLECTION IN THE STATE. WHEREAS, the Colorado Municipal Leque eatablilhed a Sale, Tax Committee whoae purpose waa to 1tandardiu and streamline administration or local 1alea and use taxes; and WHEREAS, the atandardiution i1 dnicried to provide uniformity to aale1 tax throuchout the State which will •icriifkantly 1implif'y ulea tu administration without aacrificinc ea11ential local control over local ulea tax revenun, tu baae1 and tax collection; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, AS FOLLOWS: Scg.jon l Title 4, Chapter 4, of'the Enrlewood Mun idpal Code 1985 are hereby amended to read H follow,: 4-4-1 : ADMINIITRA110N OP TAX: 'l'1le adminiatration of'all the provi1ion1 of' thi1 Chapter ii hereby v..a.d in the Diracter of' Financial Semc,u, who lhall, with the approval of' the City Manapr, preecribe f'onn1 and rea1C111able ruin and reculation1 in conformity with thi• Chapl,er f'or the maldn, of' ntuma, f'or the aecertainment, aa1111ment and collection of'the tu• ......... hereunder, and f'or the proper administration and enforcement henof', a copy of' which f'onnt, rules and N11Ulation1 lhall be made aveilable to the public. 4 -4 -2: DEPINfflONI: When lll9d in thi1 Chaplar, the followins word, and phraHI lhall have the f'ollowi111 -inp, uni.. from the contHl it clearly appeanTai · a diff'erent 19Nllffll 11 inclicat.ecl : ACCESS SERVICES AUCTION THE SIRVICIS PURNISHED BY A LOCAL DCHANGI COMPANY TO ITS CUITOMERS WHO PROVIDI TILECOMMUNICATIONS BDVICIS WHICH ALLOW THIM TO PROVIDE SUCH TIUOOIOIUNICATIONS SERVICES . ANY BALI WHDI TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPUTY II IOLD IY AN AUCTIONEER WHO II IITHD THI AODff POR THI OWNER OF BUCH PIIOPDTY oa 18 IN FACT THE OWND THIRIOF. , "' - • .. //a_ I· • 0 , , 2 ]- - • • · ... • '· AUTOMOTIVE VEHICLE ANY VEHICLE OR DEVICE IN, UPON, OR BY WHICH ANY PERSON OR PROPERTY IS OR MAY BE TRANSPORTED OR DRAWN UPON A PUBUC HIGHWAY, OR ANY DEVICE USED OR DESIGNED POR AVIATION OR FUGHT IN THE AIR. Atrl'OMOTIVE VEHICLE INCWDES, BUT 18 NOT UMrl'ED TO, MOl'OR VEHICLES, TRAILERS, SEMI-TRAILERS, OR MOBILE HOMES. Atrl'OMOTIVE VEHICLE SHALL NOT INCWDE DEVICES MOVED BY HUMAN POWER OR USED DCWSIVELY UPON STATIONARY RAILS OR TRACKS. BUSINESS AU. ACTIVITIES ENGAGED IN OR CAUSED TO BE ENGAGED IN WITH THE OBJECT OF GAIN, BENEFIT, OR ADVANTAGE, DIRECT OR INDIRECT . CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION MEANS ANY ENTITY WHICH: (I) HAS BEEN CERTIFIED AS A NOT-FOR-PROFIT ORGANIZATION UNDER SECTION 50l(Cl (3) OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, AND (Ill IS A RELIGIOUS OR CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION. AS USED IN THIS DEFINffiON, A "CHARITABLE O&GANIZATION" 18 AN ORGANIZATION WHICH DCWSIVELY, AND IN A IIANND CONSISTENT WITH DISTING LAWS AND ,oa TIIB BENBffl or AN INDUINlft NUDD or PU80NS. FUELY AND VOWNTARILY IIINl8TD8 TO THE PIIYBICAL. IIENTAL Oil SPOlfflJAL NEEDS or PDSONS, AND WHICH THUIBY LBSSENS THE BUllDINS or QOVUNMENT. ...~--- CITY THE MUNICIPALITY or THE City " !nt'ewood, CONSTRUCTION MATBRIALI TANGIBLE PIISONAL PROPERTY WHICH, WH&N COIIBINSD WITH OTHU TANGIBLE PUIONAL PIIOPUTY, LOSIS ITS IDINTITY TO Baa>IIB AM DffSOllAL AND INSEPARABLE PAIIT or A OOIIPUTBD STllUCTUD Oil PIOIBCT INCLUDING PUBUC AND PIUVATB IIIPIIOVDIDffl. CONSTllUCTION MATDIALI INCWDS. BUT AU NOT UNITED TO, IUCH 'ftlJNOI Al: ASPHAI.T, BlllCICI, BUii.DUi' HARDWAU. CAULKING IIATUIAL. CDIDIT, OONCUT&, CONDUIT, IUCl'IUC WIRING AND CONNICTIONS, 2 - . , .. I - • I. , • l • • , ') I ]- • CONSUMER DIRECTOR or FINANCIAL SERVICES OR DDmCTOa DRUG DISPBNIBD IN ACCORDANCI WITH A PIESClllnlON ~. • • • - FIREPLACE INSERTS, ELECTRICAL HEATING AND COOLING EQUIPMENT, FLOORING, GLASS, GRAVEL, INSULATION, LATH, LEAD, LIME, LUMBER, MACADAM, MILLWORK, MORTAR. OIL, PAINT, PIPING, PIPE VALVES AND PIPE nTl'INGS PLASTER, PLUMBING FIXTURES, PUTl'Y, REINFORCING MESH, ROAD BASE, ROOFING, SAND, SANITARY SEWER PIPE, SHEET METAL, SITE LIGHTING, STEEL, STONE, STUCCO, TILE, TREES, SHRUBS AND OTHER LANDSCAPING MATERIALS, WALL BOARD, WALL COPING, WALL PAPER, WEATHER STRIPPING, WIRE NETTING AND SCREEN, WATER MAINS AND METERS, AND WOOD PRESERVER. THE ABOVE MATERIALS, WHEN USED POR FORMS, OR OTHER ITEMS WHICH DO NOT REMAIN AS AN INTEGRAL OR INSEPARABLE PART OF A COMPLETED STRUCIURE OR PROJECT ARE NOT CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS . W ANY Jr"1 11\'l OUAL PERSON OR !Ill PERSON ENGAGED IN BUSINESS IN THE CITY WHO USES, STORES, DISTRIBtn'ES OR OTHERWISE CONSUMES IN THE CITY TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY OR TAXABLE SERVICES PUIICHASED FROM SOURCES INSIDE OR OUTSIDE THE CITY. ....... ..., .,,.1,.a ......... .., .. _ ..... , ........... lli11al ..... , ····" .......... TBS DIUCIOll OP FINANCIAL SERVICES or ,,.. cm or SNGUWOOD OR SUCH OTHII- PSUON DESIGNATED IY THE IIUNICIPAtlTY:. • -olDCTOll or rocAMCIAL IDVICES" SHAU. ALIO INCWDI SUCH PUSON11 DESIGNEE. DauGI DISPENIID IN ACCORDANCE WITH ANY ORDD IN nmNO. DATED AND mGNID BY A UCSNISD PltACffl'IONU OF THI ll&AUJIIO Aa'l'I, 01 OIVIH OIALL Y IY A PIIAC'lfflONU. AND IMMEDIATELY UDUCID 10 warrDIO IY THI PHAIMACIIT, AIIIITANT PHADIACIIT, 01 PHARMACY INTUN, IPIIClfflHO THI NANI AND ADDIIIIOFTHIPIDONPOIWHOMTHI IIIDICINS, DIUO oa POIION II OffUED AND DIDCTIONI. IP ANY, 10 II PLACID ON THI LAalL 3 • . .. • • • , ? ]- ·, ENGAGED IN BUSINESS IN THE CITY (1) (I) (3) <•> (I) IXBMn COIOIDCIAL PACKAGING MATBIIAU • . ~ • PUl'ODIIMG oa PIIOVIDING SERVICES oa SBWNG, L&AIDIG. UNTIMG. DBLIVDINO O& DGITAU.DfG TANGIIIU PUIOJCAL fiiurUI ! ,oa ST0aAGE. USI OR CONSUllfflON WfflllN nlE CITY. ENGAGED IN IIUIINl88 IN fflS Cl'IY INCWDIS, BUT IS NOT UMITBD TO, AMY ONE OF nlE ,OU.OWING AC'l'IVITIES BY A PERSON: DIRBC'l'LY, IMDIUC'n.Y, OR BY A SUBSIDIARY IWNTAIM8 A IIUILDDIG, STORE, omcE, SALESROOM, WAUIIOUSE, OR PLACE OF BUSINESS WITHIN THE TAXING JURISDICTION; SENDS ONB OR MOU EMPLOYEES, AGENTS OR COJOIISSIONED SALES PERSONS INTO THE TAXING JURISDICTION TO SOLICIT BUSINESS OR TO INSTALL. ASSEMBLE, REPAIR, SERVICE, OR ASSIST IN THI USI OF ITS PRODUCTS, OR POR DIIIONSTltATION OR OTHIR REASONS; IIAINTAIMS ONI oa MORI BMPLOYEIS, .AODft'8 OR COIOG8810NBD SALIS PIRSONS ON DUTY AT A LOCATION WfflllN THE TAXING JURISDICTION; OWNS. LUR8, Blffll OR OTHDWl8B BIDCl8D CONTIIOL OVD RIAL OR PIIIONAL PIIOPDTY WITHIN THE TAXING .nJmDICTION; O& ~--- IIAD8 MOD THAM ONB D&UVUY INTO THE TAXDIO .romlDICTION WITHIN A TWELVE MONTH PUIOD. CONTAINW. LANLI AND SHIPPING CAIII IOLDTO A PDION INGAGSD IN IWIUPAC'l'UalNO. COIIPOUXDINO, WIIOLIIAUIIO. .aaDIO, UTAIUNO, PACICAOIIIO. Dlll'lllllfflJI oa BOffLINO ,OR ML&. PIIOl'IT oa ua THAT MU'l'I ALL OP TIIS ,ou.owaeo CONDITIONS: (I) 18 uaao ff TIIS IIANUPAC'l'UDI. COIIPOUNDU. WHOLDALa. JOalD, ..,. ....... PACICMJD. Dll'l'IIIIUl'Oa O& IO'ITLlll TO CONTAIN oa LAia. TIIB ffllllllBD PltODUCT; 4 . . . ' ' ' I ; •. ., • • ]- FARM CLOSEOUT SALE FOOD GROSS SALES LICENSE UNIN SUVICIS • • • '· (II) IS TRANSFERRED BY SAID PERSON ALONG WITH AND AS A PART OF THE FINISHED PRODUcr TO THE PURCHASER; AND (Ill) IS NOT llETURNABLB TO SAID PERSON FOR REUSE. PULL AND FINAL DISPOSITION OF ALL TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY PREVIOUSLY USED BY A FARMER OR RANCHER IN FARMING OR RANCHING OPERATION WHICH ARE BEING ABANDONED . POOD FOR DOMESTIC HOME CONSUMPTION AS DEFINED IN 7 U.S.C. SECTION 2012(0) AS AMENDED, FOR PURPOSES OF THE FEDERAL POOD STAMP PROGRAM AS DEFINED IN 7 U.S.C. SBCTION IOU(H), AS AMENDED, EXCEPT THAT "FOOD" DOES NOT INCWDE; CARBONATED WATER MARKETED IN CONTAINERS; CHEWING GUM : SEEDS AND PLANTS TO GROW FOOD : PREPARED SALADS AND SALAD OARS; COLD SANDWICHES; DELI TRAYS; AND POOD OR DRINK VENDED BY OR THROUGH MACHINES OR NON-COIN OPERATED COIN.COLLECTING POOD AND SNACK DEVICES ON BEHALF OF A VENDOR. THE TOTAL AMOUNT RECEIVED IN MONEY, CREDIT, PROPERTY OR OTHER CONBIDDATION VALUED IN MONEY FOR ALL &ALBS, I.BASIS, OR RENTALS OF TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY OR SERVICES . .... ..... a•HRI Nali.N ill ....... ,, INlii&e; • __ ""'"' el ,Iller 11u1•n•li111, .al•• i11 ...... ,;=J;" -Ille 11tal aal• al rsllil •••• w •1i.1NII lly Ille ....... wilhill Ille Qi&, ... ,i ... .., ,.,...11, ,. ..... A CITY or ENGLEWOOD SALES AND USE TAX UCUIS. IDVICSI INVOLVIHG PROVISION AND CUAHING OP UNSNI, INCWDING IUT NOT UIOftD TO 1A01. UNIFODIS, COVERALLS AND DIAPUI. 5 • • I . . • , , ") ]- LODGING SERVICES MEDICAL SUPPLIES • • • • • ,. THE ruRNISHING OF ROOMS OR ACCOMMODATIONS BY ANY PERSON, PARTNERSHIP, ASSOCIATION, CORPORATION, ESTATE, REPRESENTATIVE CAPACITY OR ANY al'HER COMBINATION OF INDIVIDUALS BY WHATEVER NAME KNOWN TO A PERSON WHO FOR A CONSIDERATION USES, POSSESSES, OR HAS THE RIGHT TO USE OR POSSESS ANY ROOM IN A Hal'EL, INN, BED AND BREAKFAST RESIDENCE, APARTMENT HOTEL, LODGING HOUSE, MOTOR Hal'EL, GUESTHOUSE, GUEST RANCH, TRAILER COACH, MOBILE HOME, AUTO CAMP, OR TRAILER COURT AND PARK. OR SIMILAR BSTABUSHIIENT, FOR A PERIOD OF LESS THAN THIRTY DAYS UNDER ANY CONCESSION, PERMIT, RIGHT OF ACCESS, UCENSE TO USE, OR OTHER AGREEMENT, OR OTHERWISE . MEDICAL SUPPUES DRUGS, PROSTHETIC MEDICAL A.~U DENTAL APPLIANCES, AND SPECIAL BEDS FOR PATIENTS WITH NEUllOMUSCULAR OR SIMILAR DBBIIJTATING AIUIBNTS, WHEN SOLD FOR THB DIIIBCT, PDSONAL USE OF A SPEClnC INDMDUAL IN ACCORDANCE wmt A PUSCRlfflON OR OTHER WRITTEN DIUCTIVB ISSUBD IY A UCENSED PMCl'ITIOND or MEDICINE. DENTISTRY. OR PODIATRY; CORUCTIVE EYEGLASS LSN8U <DICUJDING EYBGLASS FltAJIBS), AND CORUCTIVB CONTACT LENSES, WHSN IOLD POR THB DIUCT. PUSONAL u• o,.._. - IPIIClftC INDMDUAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH A PUSCIUPl'ION OR O!'HU WRITTEN DIUCTIVB IS8UBD IY A UCENSED PRACTITIONER OF MEDICINE OR OPTOMETRY; WHSSLCHAIRS A.ND CRIJreHIS, WHDI IOLD POR THE DIUCT, PUSONAL USS or A SPEClnC INDIVIDUAL; OXYODI AND HDIODIALYSIS PllODUCTI POil UIS BY A MBDICAL PATIENT. HEARING AIDI, ll&AalNG AID BATl'DIU. INSUUN, IHSUUN MIASURING AND DUacTING DEVICES, GWCOI& TOH UUD POR TUATMENT OP INIULIN RUCTIONS, AND HUMAN WHOU BLOOD, PlMIIA. BLOOD PRODUCTS AND DDIVATIVSI. THIS UDlfflON acwoa ITDII PUICIIAUD POil UIS BY MEDICAL AND I - , , r • • . ' .. .. I . • • r ~ I - • • MOBILE MACHINERY AND SELF-PROPELLED CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT NEWSPAPD • • • DENTAL PRACTITIONERS OR MEDICAL FACILITIES IN PROVIDING THEIR SERVICES, EVEN THOUGH CERTAIN OF THOSE ITEMS MAY BE PACKAGED POR SINGLE USE BY INDMDUAL PATIENTS AFTER WHICH THE ITBM WOULD BE DISCARDED . '1110SE VEHICLES, SELF-PROPELLED OR OTHERWISE, WHICH ARE NOT DESIGNED PRIMARILY FOR THB TRANSPORTATION OF PERSONS OR CARGO OVER THE PUBLIC HIGHWAYS, AND THOSE MOTOR VEHICLES WHICH MAY HAVE ORIGINALLY BEEN DESIGNED FOR THE TRANSPORTATION OF PERSONS OR CARGO OVER THE PUBLIC HIGHWAYS, AND THOSE MOTOR VEHICLES WHICH MAY HAVE ORIGINALLY BEEN DE81GNED POR THE TRANSPORTATION OF PERSONS OR CARGO, BUT WHICH HAVE BEEN REDESIGNED OR MODlnED BY THE MOUNTING THEREON OF SPECIAL BQUIPMDIT OR MACHINERY, AND WHICH MAY Ill ONLY INCIDENTALLY OPERATED OR IIOVED OVD TH& PUBLIC HIGHWAYS . THIS Dll'INITION INCWDES BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO WHDLED VEHICLES COMMONLY USED IN TBS CONSTllUCTION, MAINTENANCE, AND UPAlll OP ROADWAYS, THE DRILLING OP' WBLLI, AND '111B DIGGING OF DITCHBS. A PUBUCATION, PltlNTED ON NEWSPRINT, INftNDD l'Oll OSNDAL CIRCULATION,Ni1!. _. PU8LIIIISD UOULAILY AT SHORT DITDVAL8, CONTAINING INFORMATION AND BDffl>alALI ON CURRENT EVENTS AND NSW8 OP ODIDAL INTEREST . THE TERM NSW8PAPER DOE8 NOT INCWDE: IUGAZINBI, TIW>B PUBUCATIONS OR JOUIJIIALB. CREDIT IUIJ.ITINS, ADVltllTIIIMO INID'l'S, CIRCULARS. DIUCTOIRI. IIAPI, RACING PROGRAMS, HnlNTI. NSWIPAPU CUPPING AND IWWIO 8DVICD oa UfflNGS. PUILICATIONI fllAT INCWDI AN UPDATING oa IIVIIION IDYICS, Oil lOOKS OR POCKET BDfflONS OP IOOICI. 7 . ' - .. I . • , , 'l.'l I - PAY TELEVISION PERSON PREPRINTED NEWSPAPER SUPPLifllENTS PRESCRlfflON DRUGS FOR ANIMALS PRICE 011 PUIICHAIE PRICE •, • • • (. SHALL INCLUDE, BUT NOT BB UMITED TO, CABLE, MICROWAVE OR OTHER TELEVISION SUVICB FOR WHICH A CHARGE IS IMPOSED . ANY INDMDUAL. nRM PARTNERSHIP, JOINT VBNTURB, CORPORATION, ESTATE OR TRUST, RECEIVER. TRUSTEE, ASSIGNEE, LISSU, OR ANY PERSON ACTING IN A f'IDUCIARY OR RBPRBSBNTATIVB CAPACITY, WHBTHD APPOINTED BY COURT OR Ol'HBRWISE, OR ANY GROUP OR COMBINATION ACTING AS A UNIT . SHALL MEAN INSERTS, ATfACHMENTS OR SUPPLDIENT8 CIRCULATED IN NBWIPAPUS THAT: (l) ARB PRIMARILY DBYOTSD TO ADVERTISING: AND (2) THE D18'1'818UTION, INSBRTION OR A1TACHMENT or WHICH IS COMMONLY PAID FOR BY THE ADVERTISER. DltUOI DISPSNSSD IN ACCORDANCE WITH ANY OIDD IN wamNG, DATED AND SIGNED n A PUCl'fflONII. OR GIVEN ORALLY BY A PUC'l'fflOND. anCJnlNG THE AN1NAL l'Oa WHJal TD IIIDICINS OR DllUG IS ornaDAND DIUCl'IONS. IF ANY, TO BE PLACD ON TD I.AUL ... ,._la .. II I 1a1l•i:1 sf-, M:1111• Ir 0111t .............. u,r1Mc .. ._ ... ,,,1 811 ..................... a,ulfalulllil ::: ===:=:===• -- .. ,,111 , ....... ,. .......... ••••••• .............................. ,,.., .......... ,.... TD PIICI 'IO TD CONSUIIU. IXCWSIVE OP ANY DIDCT TAX DIPOIID IY fflE flDDAL OOVIIINll&NT OR IY THIS All'l'ICLI. AND, IN,,.. CAA or ALL UTAIL IALII INVOLVING TD DCIWIOS or ,ao,an, ALIC> IICWIIVS or fflE FAIR IIAID'I' YAWS OP TD PIIOPDTY IIICIIAIGID AT TD MD TIME AND PUCI OI',.. mlANOII,, IP: I - ., I. • • . ' , ? I ]- - • • ·, • < 1) SUCH EXCHANGED PROPERTY IS TO BE SOLD THD£AFl'D IN THB USUAL COURSE OF THE RBTAILER"S BUSINESS, OR (2) SUCH DCIIANOBD PROPERTY 18 A VEHICLE AND 18 DCHANGBD POR ANOTHER VEHICLE AND BOl'H VEHICLES ARE SUBJECT TO UCBNSING, RBGISTRATION, OR C&lfflhCATION UNDER THB LAWS or THIS STATIC, INCLUDING, BUT NOT UNITED TO, VBHICUS OPDATING UPON PUBLIC HIGHWAYS, Off-HIGHWAY RECREATION VBHICUS, WATICRCLUT, AND AIRCRAn. ANY MONEY OR OTHER CONSIDERATION PAID OVER AND ABOVE THE VALUE or THE DCHANGICD PROPERTY IS SUBJECT TO TAX . PRICE OR PURCHASE PRICE INCLUDES: (I) (I) (I) THE AMOUNT or MONEY RECEIVED OR DUE IN CASH . -:REDITS . PllOPDTY AT PAIR MARKBT VALUE TAKEN IN DCHANO& BUT NOT POR RB8ALB IN THE UIUAL OOUIR or THB RETAILIR"S 8UIDfBII. Alff OONIIDUAftON VAWICD IN MONEY, IUC8 Al TIADINO ffAIIPI oa COUPONS warm, nm IIAXUPACTUm oa _. 11M DDIIIUl8B8 THE UTAILD taa PA&T OP 1'IIS PUIICHAIS PIUCS AND - Ol'IID IDDIA OP DCHANG&. -~-·- (4) TD TOTAL PlllC& CHAaGBD ON Cl&DIT SAUi DICWDING FINANCE CIIAJIQES WHICH AB NOT a,AaATILY ITATSD . AN AMOUMT CIIAIIOSD Al INIIDIT ON THE UNPAID MLANCS OP 1'IIS PUIICHAIB PIUCS II NOT PA&T or TIIS PUIICIIAD PIUCS UNLDI THE AIIOUJfT ADDSD TO ftl& PUaCHAIB PlllC& II JNCWDID IN ftlS PIIHCIPAL AMOUMT OP A PIICJIIIIIQIIY NOTS; acsn ftl& JNTIUIT oa CAUYINO CHAIIQ& 1ST OUT I UAJIATSLY ntOII ftlS UNPAID IALANCS OP TH& PUICIIAIII PIICS ON TIIS PACS OP THI NOl"I m NOT PA&T OP ftlS PUIICHAIS PIICI AH • . ' • . I. • , ]- 1 • . • • " • ' ., AMOUNT CHARGED FOR INSURANCE ON THE PROPERTY SOLD AND SEPARATELY STATED JS NOT PART OF THE PURCHASE PRICE. (5) INSTALLATION, DELIVERY AND WHEELING- IN CHARGBS JNCWDBD IN THE PURCHASE PRICE AND NOT SEPARATELY STATED. (I) TRANSPORTATION AND OTHER CHARGES TO BffBCT DIWVSRY OF TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY TO THE PURCHASER. (7) IMDIUCT nDDAL MANUFACTURERS' DCISE TADS. SUCH AS TAXES ON AUTOMOBIUS, TJUS AND FLOOR STOCK. (I) ftR GR08S PURCHASE PRICE OF ARTICLES IOLD Arra MANUFACTURING OR AnER HAVING BUN MADE TO ORDER. INCWDING ftR GROSS VAWB OF AU THE MATERIALS UUD, LAIIOI AND SERVICE PEIU'ORMED AND ,,.. nom THUBON. "PRICE" OR "PURCHASE PRJCr SHALL NOT JNCWDE : (l) A)lY IALl8 oa ua TAX JIIPOUD BY THE ITAft OP COLOIADO 01 BY ANY POlfflCAL IU8DM810N TDDOF. (I) TBS FAia IIAIIDT VAWS or PIIOPDTY DCIWIGSD Ir SUCH PIIOPDl'Y 18 TO U IOLD TIISUAPl'D DI TD UTAILUI UIUAL OOIJIIS OF IUIDIIII. ftlll 18 NOT LDlll'D TO DCIWIOB8 IN COLOaADO. OUT - OP ITAft TIADMNI AU AN AIJ.OWAlll4-. __ ADIUl'l'IISlft' TO TD PUICHA8S PIICS. (I) DIICOUN'l'8 FIOII TIIS OIUGDIAL PRICE IF SUCH Dl8COIJlff AND TIIB COIUSPONDING NCDAIII DI IALl8 TAX DUS 18 ACTUALLY PAiia> ON TO TIIS PUaCHAID. AN AN"l'ICIPATSD DIICOUN"I' TO U ALLOWSD ,oa PAYIIDIT ON oa aaoa A OIVSN OATS m NOT AN AIJ.OWML& ADIUITMDff TO THE PIIICS IN DIOllTINO OIIOl8 SAUi. 10 "' -. ' • ' ., I . • • • t ? I • . ' ]- • • '· • PRIVATE TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES COMMUNICATIONS FURNISHED TO A SUBSCRIBER, WHICH SERVICES BNTITLES THE SUBSCRIBER TO EXCLUSIVE OR PRIORITY USE or ANY COMMUNICATION CHANNEL Oil GROUPS OF CHANNELS, OR TO THE EXCWSIVE OR PRIORITY USE OP ANY INTERSTATE INTER-COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS l'OR THE SUBSCRIBER'S STATIONS . PROSTHETIC ANY ARTlnCIAL lJIIB, PART, DEVICE OR DEVICES APPLIANCE POR HUMAN USE WHICH AIDS OR .. llEPLACES A BODILY FUNCTION; IS DESIGNED, MAHUFAC'rullED, ALTERED OR ADJUSTED TO m A PARTICULAR INDIVIDUAL; AND IS PRESCRIBED BY A LICENSED PRACTITIONER or THE HEALING ARTS. PROSTHETIC DEVICES INCWDE BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO PRESCRIBED AUDITORY, OPHTHALMIC OR OCULAR, CARDIAC, DENTAL, OR ORTHOPEDIC DEVICES OR APPLIANCES, OXYGEN CONCENTRATORS AND OXYGEN WITH DLATED ACCESSORIES . PURCHASIOR TD ACQUISfflON POR ANY SALE CONSIDERATION BY ANY PERSON OF TANGIBLE PIRSONAL PROPERTY OR TAIAIILI SDVICIS THAT ARE PURCHASED, L&Ala>, u:N'nD, IOLD, USID, STORID, Dl8TIUBUTBD, OR CONSUMED, BUT IXCWDIS A IONA nDI Giff or PROPERTY OR IDVICII. 'l'IDIS TlltN8 INCWDE CAPITAL UAAI, INITAU.IIINT AND CREDIT SALa, AND PIOPDTY AND 8UVICIS ACQUlllE~. -- (I) TIA.Nina. lffllU CONDITIONALLY OR AIIOU11'ELY, OP TITLI OR POSSESSION OR IOl'H TO TANGIBU PUSONAL PltOPSJtTY; (I) A UA8&, LIAII-PUICHASE AGRIEMINT, • llllft'AL OR GIWff OP A LICENSE, INCLUDING IOYALff AGUDIINTI, TO UII TAHGIBLI PUIONAL PIOPIITY OR TAZABU IDVICII; (I) ....OIIIAHCS 0, TAXABLE SIRVICa: OR m IAITD OR IXCHANOI POR OTHU I • PIOPDTY OR IDYICa IMCWDINO • • COUPONS . , , 0 t n I ]- - • • Ill - • . • ' , ... .. THE TERMS "PURCHASE" AND "SALB" DO NOT INCWDE: (1) A DIVISION or PAllTNERSHIP ASSETS AMONG fllS PAllTNUI ACCORDING TO THEIR IMTBDSTS IN THB PARTNERSHIP; (I) TBS PORIIAffON or A CORPORATION BY THE OWNBIIS OP A BUSINSSS AND THB TRANSFER or THEIR BUSINS88 A88B'n TO THB CORPORAffOtf IN DCHANGB POR ALL THB CORPORATION'S OUTSTANDING STOCK, DCSPr QUAUrYING SHARBS, IN PltOPOllTION TO TIIS ASSETS CONTRIBUTED; (I) THB TRANSPU or ASSETS OF 81L\JlBHOLDU8 IN ftlB FORMATION OR Dl880Uffl0N or Plt()P'ESSIONAL CORPORATIONS; (4) THB DISSOUfflON AND THB PRO RATA DllftlBUTION or THB CORPORATION'S Al8fl8 TO ITS 8TOCIDIOLDBR8; (I) A ftAN8PD or A P.uTNDSHIP INTBUST; (I) ftD TUNUD IN A UOIGAJIIIZATION QUAUfflJIO mma IICl'ION -.u:u or ftD "Dft'aNAL UVSNUS CODS or 1114", AS AIONDBD; (T) TBS .oDIATIOII OP A PAlmlUBHIP BY ftlB ftAll8PD OP Allll'l'I TO THS PAll'l'NDIHIP oa ftANIPIII TO A PA1n'ND8111P IN ~ • -- DCBANGS ,oa PIOfOSl'IOJIIATS INTUDT8 IN TD PAnRIIIIIPi <I) TBS IDOllalKDI OP PUIONAL PIOPBRTY ff A CHATnL IIOll'l'GA08 HOLDSa Oil fODCLOIUD ff A USM ROI.DD; (I) ftD ftANlna 0, MUii PIOII A PAUNT coaPOaA'l'ION TO A IUIIIDIAaY COUOMTIOII Ga COUOMftOHI WHICH AIIII OWND AT LUii' IIOlffT PUCSlff BY TBS PAIIN'I' CQall!DIATIOII, WHICH ftANlna a IOI.AT IN IICIIAJfO& POI ll'OCK Ga 8CUlfflll O,TU IUIIIDWtY COUOIIATION; 12 . , . .. I . • 0 , ~? I - • • • • I• . • ' (10) THE TRANSFER OF ASSETS FROM A SUBSIDIARY CORPORATION OR CORPORATIONS WHICH ARE OWNED AT LEAST EIGHTY PERCENT BY THE PARENT CORPORATION TO A PARENT CORPORATION OR TO ANOTHER SUBSIDIARY WHICH IS OWNED AT LEAST EIGHTY PERCENT BY THE PARENT CORPORATION, WHICH TRANSFER 18 SOLELY IN EXCHANGE FOR STOCK OR SICURITIES OF THE PARENT CORPORATION OR THB SUBSIDIARY WHICH RICEIVED THE ASSBTS; (11) THE TRANSFER or ASSETS BETWEEN PARENT AND CLOSELY HELD SUBSIDIARY CORPORATIONS, OR BETWEEN SUBSIDIARY CORPORATIONS CLOSELY HELD BY THE SAME PARENT CORPORATION, OR BETWEEN CORPORATIONS WHICH ARE OWNED BY THE SAME SHAREHOLDERS IN IDENTICAL PERCENT.AGE or STOCK OWNERSHIP AMOUN'nS, l.UMPUTED ON A SHARE-BY - SHAD BASIS, WHEN A TAX IMPOSED BY THIS AJmCLE WAS PAID BY THE TRANSFEROR COBPORATION AT THE TIIIE IT ACQUIRED SUCH A88ET8, DCEPr TO THE EXTENT THAT THDE 18 AN INCRBASE IN THE FAIR 11.AJUCET VAWE or SUCH ASSETS RESULTING FROII TBS IIANUPAC'ft181NG, FABRICATING, OR PRY81CAL CHANGING or THE ASSETS BY THE ftANIPDOa CORPORATION. TO SUCH AN DTBNT THAT ANY TRANSFER REFUUD TO IN ftll8 PAJlAGMPII U U SHAU. CONSTfflJTE A IAL&. l'Oll THS PUaP08U or THIS ~ --- PAUOMPII (11), A CLOSELY HELD BU11m1A&Y COIPOaATION IS ONE IN WHICH THB PAaBNT CORPORATION OWNS STOCK POIIBIIING AT L&AIT EIGHTY PEltCICNT or THB TOTAL COIIBDRD VOTING POWEi or ALL a..wa or 8TOCK BNTITLED TO VOTE , AND OWNS AT L&AIT EIGHTY PUCDIT or THB TOTAL NUIIID or SHADS or ALL OT11D C1A11a or STOCK. 13 "' -. ( • - I . • •. ' r . • ' 2 I ]- • • RECREATION SERVICES HLIGIQUS. GllltallR'M ... •• BlaBBM98VH.tJI¥ INSTl'FlllFIQN • • (• . • ' .. ALL SERVICES RELATING TO ATHLETIC OR ENTERTAINMENT PARTICIPATION EVENTS INCWDING BUT NOT IJMITED TO POOL, GOU', BlLUARDS, SKATING, TENNIS, BOWLING, HEALTH/ATHLETIC CLUB MEMBERSHIPS, COIN OPERATED AMUSEMENT DBVICBS, VIDEO GAMES AND VIDEO CLUB MEMBERSHIPS. tw, iUJlia.tiM wllilh ie • ehari..We in11iNli111 -••• 1r .. 1 .... •111 ·,n ..... , t,he l1111rnal lallrnal •• IHI .;\el ,lt,he Uni ... a ...... RRAlla &Mill •••> •le,• h1Jein MA1111i, ...... er .. li.arell willlm tile ..... ill tltihe Gil) ea•,a • •le 11 • .. •• • • • .... ·-.... ---· ..... ,lt,he ..... .., ..... -· ............. 11 ........... ·-· · -· ·· -····· RETAIL SALES AIL SALES EXCEPT WHOLESALE SALES . RETAILIR .\ay ,.,_ ....... • .... ii •le. ANY PDION Sa.LINO, I.BASING OR RENTING TANOIBLS PUIONAL PROPERTY OR 8DYICl8 AT UTAIL. RETAILER SHAU INCWDIANY: RmJRN (l) AUCTIONII&; (I) IALIBPSIION, UPUSENTATIVE, PEDDLER oa CANVAIID. WHO MADS SALES A8 A DIDCT oa INDIUICT AGENT or oa OBTAINS IUCll ,_..I I oa AIMCD IOLD f'ltOlt+-· -· uu•n, Dlfftl9Ul'O&. BUPDYIIO• oa DIPLOYD; (I) ClldlTABLS OIIGANIZ,ATION oa OOVDJOIDTAL Ulln' WHICH MAKES MUI or TANCDL& PDIONAL PltOPDTY TO THI PUaLIC, NOTW1T118TANDINO THI Pl/Cf THAT TBS IIDCHANDIBI IOLD MAY RAVI IUN ACQUIUD ., Gin oa DONATION oa THAT THI PIIOCIIDI AIII TO Bl UUD POa ClldlTABLS oa OOVUNIIINTAL PUaPOID. THI BALD AND UU TAX Ul'OlfflNO POaM UUD TO IDOIIT BALD AND UU TAX. u "'~ . ' • . .. I . • , 2 I ]- SI.LB er &t,LB Mf9 Pl:IR8H.\8B SALES TAX SECURITY SYSTEM SERVICES SOUND SYSTEM SERVICES TANGIBLE PIISONAL PROPERTY TAX TAX DUICISNCY • • • f;. -· .......... ef ... , t, pe, i11eh1«li11c a .... re, ...... aa in•H111e11I • c,e•i• Nie, a11 e•eha11p a11cl •1 .eher k•wtie11, wherelty the ti~e or po ... 11io11 e( la..W• ,. ... .a ,,epe.t,, • ••• .. ,.. i1 he,1i11 ....... 11 111isr•• er kanlfarrN, ee1111i,ie11all1 er ........... ,., a -·-reti•11 ti ... , ....... . THB TAX TO BE COLLECl'ED AND REMmED BY A RBTAILEll ON &\LES TAXED UNDER THIS CODS. SUCTRONIC SECURITY SYSTEM SERVICES . SUCH TERM DOBS NOT INCLUDE NON-EUCTRONIC SECURITY SERVICES SUCH AS CONSULTING OR HUMAN OR GUARD DOG PATROL SIRVICES. SOUND SYSTEM SERVICES INVOLVING PROVISION OP BROADCAST OR PRE· UCORDSD AUDIO PROGRAMMING TO A BUILDING Oil POlfflON THEREOF. SUCH TERM DO~ NOT INCWDE INSTALLATION OF SOUND 8YITDII WIRU THE ENTIRE IYlftM UCOIOI 'ftlB PROPERTY OP THE BUILDING OWJlfD oa THE SOUND SY8TEM IUVICS 18 ,OB Paamn'ATION OP UVB PDPODIAJIICU. ....... pa I rl ,......, tlall -,,-. illala .. ns, wlll 111 II 1111hn: , ..... ieal ..... .,, 1J1 • IJIIJhFI, I IQ .......... leleuia "u •ruienl _. ..... ,.,1tt1 at11111 ....... .... ....... ... ....... I•• illal ... •*IIIIIFI• I I nu• 111 cl-111ai11 N fl IN 8 ,ll!e OOIPOUAL PSIIOIIAL PIOPDTY. •, ... , nliit, ...... ,...., ... r1sar 41 .......... t __ .............. h pa I ft P:""'11 • .. ._.,., •1 Rl afaanlu 1lurt1I .. • s ..... , a,: .._. .... ralllihr II )NJ Iii le FIi lie .. lllisutar afflMnaiel ... ,, ... 'l'IIB UH TAX DUI PIOM A CONIUMlll OI THE MUI TAX DUI PIIOII A UTAILD OI THI IUII OP ICffll DUI nDII A UTAILD WHO ALIO CONIUIID. AJfY AIIOU1ff OP TAX THAT 18 NOT IDOallD oa IIOI' PAID ON oa 8BPOU THE DUI DAfl. 15 .. -----.-----.!Ill\ ' ' ·- .. I. , . ' • • 2 • ,. ~ ]-• • I• . • ' .. TAXABLE SALES GROSS SALES LESS ANY EXEMPI'IONS AND DEDUCTIONS SPECIFIED IN THIS CODE . TAXABLE SERVICIS SUB.JECI' TO TAX PURSUANT TO SERVICES TITLE 4, CHAPl'ER 4, OF THIS CODE . TAXPAYER llilh• tile ,.,_. 1111.-.• tie,., tile._ lel'illll 19, tlli1 Gheple,, e, t,he ,.,.. ellliplell t.e eellee• an• ... 1111t fer Iha NIM• the Direeter ,I PiR•eiel Servi••· ANY PERSON OBUOATED TO COLLECI' ' ANDIOR PAY TAX UNDER THE TERMS OF THIS CODE. TELECOMMUNICATIONS TRI TRANSMISSION OF ANY TWO-WAY SERVICES INTERACTIVE ELECl'ROMAGNETIC COIOIUNICAnONS INCLUDING BUT NOT UJIITED TO VOICE, IMAGE, DATA AND ANY OTIID INPOIOIATION, BY THE USE OF ANY IIUNS BUT NOT UMITED TO WIRE, CABLE, nua OPTICAL CABLE, MICROWAVE, RADIO WAVE 08 AMY COMBINATIONS OF SUCH 11D1A. 'TSLBCOIOIUNICAnONS SERVICE " DICWDD IUT 18 NOT UMITED TO BASIC LOCAL DCIIAMOB TELEPHONE SDVICE, TOIL ftUPHONS IUVICE AND ~ SUVICE, INCWDING BUT IIO'I' LIIIJTSD 10 DIIDSNTIAL AND IUIDlal lDYICS. DIUCTORY ASSISTANCE, c:a.un.u MOall.& TSLEPHONE 01 TIL8COIOIUNICAffONS SUVICB, "9CIAI na> IIOalU llADIO AND TWO-WAY PAODI AND PMJDIG SUVICB. INCWDIJ6----- ,..., POUi or IIOBIU TWO-WAY 'TELICOIOIUNICATION OOIOIUWICATION . IDVICr DOD NOT INCWDE SEPARATELY ftAftD NON-'l'UHSIIISSION SIRVICES WHICH CONmTUTS COMPUTER PIIOCUIING APPLICATIONS USBD 10 ACT ON • TIIS IJIIPOIUIATION TO H TRANSMITTED . THERAPEUTIC DSYICD, APPLIANCD, 01 RELATED DEVICE ACCallOalD THAT AU SOLD 10 COIUCT 01 Tu.AT A HUIIAN PHYSICAL DIIAIILITY OR IUIOICALLY CUATBD ABNOIUIALITY; IP IUCII DSVIC&, APPUANCI OR RELATED ACCIIIOaY HAI A UTAIL YAWS or IIOU I TRAN ONE HUNHID DOU.All, IT M\JIT IE • • SOLD IN ACCOUANCI WITH A WlllTftN 18 • • , • "' -.. . . , ]-t" • . • " • • RECOMMENDATION FROM A LICENSED DOCTOR TO QUALIFY AS A 'THERAPEUTIC DBYICr POR PURPOSES OF THIS CODE. TOTAL TAX THI TOTAL OP ALL TAX. PENALTIES OR LIABILITY JNTBRBST OWBD BY A TAXPAYER AND SHALL INCLUDE SALIS TAX COu.BCTED IN ncr.ss OP SUCH TAX COMPUTED ON TOTAL SALES. USETAX TBB TAX TO BB PAID oa UQUJUD TO BB PAID BY A CONSUMER POR USING, STOIUNG, DISTRIBtmNG OR OTHDWISB CONSUMING .. TANGIBLB PERSONAL PROPERTY oa TAXABLB SERVICES INSIDE THE CITY. WATS/800 ANY OUTBOUND oa INBOUND INTBRSTATE SERVICE WIDE ARIA TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICE oa OTHO SIMILAR SDVICE WHICH SNTITLBS THB SUB8CRJBU, UPON PAYMENT OP A PERIODIC CHARGE. BASED UPON A FLAT AIIOUNT ANM>R USAGE, TO MAKE OR DCSIVB A IAIIGI VOWM& OF TELEPHONIC OOIIIIUNICA110N8 TO OR FROM PUIONS RAVIMO TIUPIIONS OR MDIO TSL&PHONI ITATIONI IN IPBCIPIID ARIAi WHICH AU OU'IIIDS THI TIL&PIIONS 8Y8TDI ADA IN WIOal THI auaacaam ITATIOM 18 LOCATSD. WHOLISAU IALll10 LICDl8D aTAILUI.JOUUB. BALD NA' PM oa WBOLDALPM ,oa an..a.a SAUi n WIIOI.Dt' m 10 OOIIIIUIIZlllld -- NOT WIIOLIIIAL& SAUi. IALII IY WHOLDAUlll 10 NON-UCDIUD aTAILUI AU NOT WHOLDAU IALBS. WHOLISAUR AWi PSIION ISWMG 10 aTAILUS. "° ...... DIA('"· oa OTHD • WIIOLIIALIII. POR D1AL1. AND Nor POii 1T011MJa. UII OONIUMPl'ION, OR D'1TR18UTION . ,; • I • • 17 , _, I -• • - 4-4-3: PURPOSE OP TAX, D18'11U8tm0N OP PROCBBDS: The City Countjl hereby declares that the purpoM of the levy of the tu8I impoeed by this Chapter i1 for the rai1in1 of funds for payment of the pnaral eparatinc ..,... .. of the City and for capital improvements; prowled, however, that all of thON ...,,... .. derived on the UM, consumption or 1torap of thole item, -tained in Section 4-4-5-38 of this Chapter, dealini: with motor vehicles, trailers or semi-trailers, buildinc material, and 1uppliea, shall be -,reptecl, held apart and deposited into a separate capital improvement account and shall be used solely to fund and ftnanea the capital im~ta of the City. (Ord. 74 Series 1985) 4-4-4 : 8ALl8 TAX DIP08BD: 4-4-4 -1: TAXAN.B l'l'ZM8: Then shall be collected and paid u a tu the amounll stated in Section 4-4-4-2 upon the followins: A . On the purdiaM price paid or charpd upan aJI Ntail ..... and purcha1e1 o( tan11ble personal property within the boundaries of the City, includin1 delivery within the boundarin of the City. B . Upon the amount paid for all ..as, includins eover charpa, if any, fumi1hed in any rntaurant, •tins houta, hotel,...._., chib. NIOrt or auch plam at which meals or W are sold ta the puWic. C . Upon the ... tat re., priee. or..._ rad•• 1lhn paW or...,,.. fllr the nntal or lea11 of any roem, rooe1, or.,.. a.-Irr ....... pmpo111 in any establilh_,t 1118kinc such 1¥lillllle • die,..._ (Onl. 74 8eriN llU) 4·4-4 -2 : IAUal TAX LEVY: A . fllere ii hlnby i..,.... upan ID ... .,. --.,.Win 8--4 ...... 1 above, within the.....,_., .. Cler, a ta.• ..... .«edive .,......, 1, 1•. inaceonlaneewiththeltl .............. : ~--- I .01 incluclinc I .14 a .ta iMluclinc a .ca I ... incluclinc I .71 I . 71 incluclinc I .ti 11 00 lncWi .. SUI 11 8 includ, .. IU7 11 ae 1nc1uc1 ,. nu 11 N lnclucli .. lt.00 Ne Tu S.Ol .. .. .... ... •• I.OT On ulN hi .... oft .. .Wlare (11.00) die tu IMII .. ...,.. 1a111 CS.0'7) • each '" IWlen (II.OO)tlthe .a.,,,.._ ...... tu ..... a die ............ Irr the appllcellle f'radilnal ,.,, ., .... ., ................ (CW. ...... ,..,, 11 "' - • ' I . • • , , ]- • • • • B . The foll-in1 tam an hereby levied upon the rental fee, price, or other consideration paid or received, upon the rental or leaH of any room, rooms or mobile homn for loct,in1 purpoNI in any hotel, motel, Jodee, resort, club, roo!llini: hou1e, apartment buildin1 or other Ntablishment, makin1 such rooms available to the public, where the period Ill Joc1sin1 for which auc:h rental fee, price or other conaidaration i1 paid or received shall be ln1 than thirty (30) days. Thoae taxes hereby levied are: C. D . 4-4-C -3 : A. 1. The aalet tax set forth in the p,-din, para,raph A hereof' levied in accordance with the achadula u ia aat forth therein. 2. Two percent (K) of'the ml& olthe rental f'aa, price, or other consideration paid or received for the lodcinl on uch full dollar Ill uid rental fee. The panon, partnanhip, corporaUon, or other entity makin1 such room, available shall, for all purpoeea olthi1 Chapter, be deemed to be a "retailer· u defined in Section 4-C-2 olthi1 Chapter. The retailer ahall add the tax impoead har-.o to the aala or charp olthe it.em aold, showin, aueh tax aa a aaparat.e and distinct it.em, and, whan added, auch tax shall constitute a part Ill IUch price or chal'I', shall be a deb& f'rom the purehuer to the retailer until paid, ancl shall be NCIOYffllb6e aL law in the aama manner aa other debts. For tranaadions con ... aat.ad ••after January 1, 1111, the City's aalaa tu shall not apply to the aala of'~ ,._.a pnpar1f a& ralail or the fumiahin, 111 aarvicaa if the tranuction wa1.........., IUbject.ed to a aaln or u11 tax properly and propordonat.ely i.,..... • tM punlluer • uaar by anodlar utu&oly or home rule municipality equal ta or in -of' liar• ,-a•l 6N.) TRUE AND ONE- HALF PERCENT (S.K). A Cl'Ni& ellall be ..... apmlt the City'a aalaa tu with rnpact to auch tranuctieft ....a ill a-t ta Iha lawflllly i......-1 local aalaa or UN tax pravioualy ,-1 by die ... lllr OI' 1INr ta tM pra¥Nllla lta&uUl'y W hoffle rule municipality. n.. ....,.& of'dla CINI& ...... ewed lilfN ,. •• fN.) THREE AND ONE-HALF PUCDIT (I.ft). (ON. 7' 8ariea 1115) -·--- &IDIPHONI TOMlaTM: Exempt lt.enla. n.. ala of'&ha ....... .._ of'Uftllble ,.,...J ....,..-ty are exempt f'roa the tu iapaaad by..._ 4-4+1. I . Mot.or vahicln. trailan and Na6-tnilen, ~ wlaW of' Iha City of' En,lewoocl . 2 . Salaa of'tan,ible ,.,...J,,.,..., ....... lill&II tM .. ..._. ___ , ... . a . The ........ ta,... ............. "· ................ Iha "* of'C--. ........... a«,,: .... b . Theartlclea...._. ................. ,...., ........ &ha City by-.,.., ... ·-w,aal ., ............ .. 11 ,, - • - I. • ' - • • • • • • (, 3. Sale of fuel used for the operation or internal combustion en(ines. 4. Sale or medicine, medical supplies, orthopedic brace, and appliances, dental appliance,, hearin, aid1, crutchn, wheel chain, eye claae1 or other mechanical contrivances when purchased with a licenaecl practitioner', written preacription. 5. Salea of food products which are t.o be con1umed ofl'the premiaes of the vendor. A. used herein "food" man, lood which i1 advertised or marketed for human consumption and told in the same form, condition, quantitin and packa,in1 as i1 commonly told by ,rocen. flie term include, cerul1 and cereal producte: milk and milk proclucte: meat and meat producu: n,h and fiah producu: eaa and ea products: veplablea and veptable producu: fruit and fruit producu; aupr, aupr produc:tl and aupr 1ubatitute1; cofl'ee1 and cofl'N 1ubatitute1: tMs, COCM and coeoa produda; aplcn. condiment.a, ult and oleomarrarine. 'nle term ·1ooc1· d-not include chewin1 ,um: splrituou1 malt or vinou1 liquon: cocktail mi11n; proprietary medicinn; no1trum1: loaenp1; tonice; vitamin, and other dietary supplement.a; water, mineral water and carbonated water marketed in containers; ice; pet foods; food or drink fumi1hed, prepared or Mrwd for conaumption at tablet, chain or count.en or ftoom trays; ........ dishes or other tableware provided by the retailer; prepared food or drink told by retailers who ,.....1arly NII for consumption on or near the pnmiNS or the rMailer even thoup IUch food or drink 11 told on a "take out" or "t.o p" order and is ....... packapd or wrapped and taken front the pre111iNI or die retailer; and food • drink vended by or th,..... machinea on behalf or a vendor. 6 . Sales or ,oodl -uractund within the City and eold diNCtly by the manufacturer t.o a _ _.. carrier operatinc In interstate comlllefft aa the ultimate consumer thenef. 7 . For transactions eenaa1a...t on • after January l, 1111, the City's salN tu ahall not apply .. the sale or eena&ruction and buildinc lllateriala, .. the ._. is UNd In MCdoft 21-1-lOI, C.ll.8., lflllCh .. teriala an picked ap~ • -• the purdlaaer and if the purchaaer or such ..a.riala p1'91111t.1 to the fflailer a buildinc pennit OI' other -...talion I f rptallle .. the City e¥idencinl that a local UM tu hu been paW OI' ii ,....red .. be paid. B. E11empt Taapayera. Sales t.o the r.Dowint cia-or tupayen ahall be eaempt r._ the tu impoeed by th11 Chapt.ar: 1. Sala to the United 8'ala .-,.....nt; te the 8ta&e orc.lcnde. iu depart.menu or intutudeu ud .. the ,.Utieal lllbdivitiont thenef, In their 19"ffllMlltal capacity •IJ: ill all talal .. Iha City; pnvWIIIC, ""'"-· that no eomlMr'Cial, ....._. or _..., •ld111 lllldludlll, wpnbed or chan.red by the United ...._ ...,_._I. an, ..-c, w depat1ae11t thenef, or by the._ efc.lorado. .a.au be IIDlidered a"""' ...... , lftautu&illl rw the,..,,... e11111a __ ,._ 20 ,. .. ' I . • I - 1~ C. A. B. C. D. • • • • • 2. Sale, to reliciou1, charitable and eleemoaynary in1t.itution1, in the conduct of their recular relisiou1, charitable and eleemoaynary function, and activitiea. 3. Nothin1 herein contained lhall be clNmed to •-pt from the tu levied by thi1 Chapter, aal• ofbuildin1 matarial1 or 111pplin to be uaed by a contractor f'or tha conltnlction of an improvemm& for any of the in1t.itut.ion1 or qancin anwrated in 1ubaedion1 l or 2 hereof. Burden of Providin1 Examptiona; Diaputa '111a burden of proof that any retailer ia axampt from collact.in1 a tu upon any poda aold and payin1 ume to the Director of Finance, or from makins return for the •-. lhall be on tha retailer under 111ch NU011abla requiremanta of proof aa the Dindor may prncribe. Should a di1put.e ariN betW9111 any purchaaer and Miler • to whether or not any retail ule i1 axampt from taxation hereunder, the Miler lhall, nnerthalau, collect and the pureh.._. ahall pay auch tax; encl the •lier llhall thanupon i11Ua to the purcha11r a receipt, or caniflcate, on fonna prwribed by tha Direct.r, llhowins tha na-oftha 111ler and purchaaar, the item1 purchaMd, tha date, priee, amount oftu paid, and a brief' 1tat.ement of tha clahn of 1U111ption. Thareafter the purchaaar may apply to the Directar for a raf'und of such tuaa and it llhall than be the duty of tha Diract.or to determine the qulltion of exemption. In u.1, w.a where the City refund& any tax11, it may collect from the N&ailer tha amount of tu• NUinad by him aa a f'aa which is aUributable to tha tranucuon . (Ord. 74 Seriaa 11111) It lhall be unlawful fll' any,...... ....... in die bulineu of makins retail ulea, u tha .... ii defined hen6n, wtt.heu& In&.....,.._.. a liem• therefor, which liea111 llhall be,,... ... _. ....a by tha City Liean• Offlear, and llhall be in force anti afrect until.,.,......•........_ No lieal11 llhaU be ,...... ltr-, ,... ....... euhuiwly ill the bulineu of Nllit11 CO....tidea which .. --ha ........... due CMptar. '111a liealee ,-.ai ... by ••natl• A .......... .--..-"'H ,,_. u NI fll'th "' Tide a. a.a,ear l ,ldlla cw.. '111a City ahall aua awailaWI .. -, n • 111""' ...._ a .._.. ..W. ahewins the ........... af'the Ci.,. Pw-11Jtl•1 I I rt • • • .... .lanuary l , ltM, tha , .............. ..,..., _ ............... .., ...... thanal, avail.W.taeach.....,,a .. 11,.... .......... ..._ • ..._ ....... . bo&h . Na paqlty ahall be,.,.... • ..., -.rMd1ac, .......... ••• wll • wander. in .... fallh ................. ,-& ........... , ........ IL (Onl. '74 .._ 1-) 21 ,,,_ I . • 0 , - • • • , . • 4-4-4-5: fflNERANT VENDORS; BOND REQUIREMENTS: Any retailer who does not intend to be actively enpaed in ullin1 for a period puter than three (3) conuc:utive months, shall, prior to obtainins uid licenu, deposit with the Director of Financial Servic11, a cash or surety bond in the amo11nt of sixty dollars ('60.00) for the benefit of the City, in such form as may be approved by the said Director of Financial Services, which bond shall be conditioned upon and IICllrity ror the payment of the retail sales ta11a due or to become due. Such retailers shall make reportl of the amo11nt ofta11es collected, shall pay the um, to the City upon IUch forms and at IIICh times u the Director of Financial Services may require. Any failure to make IUch report or to pay any tu due at the time specified shall cause an immediate llllPlftlion to the licenu and the forfeiture of the bond posted. (Ord. 74 Series 1985; amcl. Ord. 83 SeriN ltlO) 4-4-4-6 : BOOKS AND RECORD8 DPT: It lhall be the .iy of_,, pa1W11 required by the provisions of Section 4-4-4-4 to ob&ain a uln tu licen11, to keep and preserve suitable records of all uln made by him, and IUch other books or accounts u may be necessary to determine the alllOIIRt of tu for the collection of which he is liable hereunder. It shall be the duty of every IUch per-. to kNp and ,.....rve for a period of three (3) years all invoices of eoocl• and merchandi11 purchued for NNle, and all 1uc:h books, in\'oice1 and other records shall be open for examination at any time by the Director of Financial Services or his duly authoriaed apnta. (Ord. 74 Seri• 1985; amd. Ord. 63 Series 1990) 4 -4-4-7 : 8ALB8TAXREnJRN8: A . Every penon, partnenhip or corpll'ation ,..... ta lllltain a uln tu Hc.lM pursuant to the provisions of Section 4-4-4-4, lhall flle a ..... tu Nblm, will! payment of tu owed, if' any, apon the aundarcl Mwaicipal ..... and 1111 tu reportins ,_ a, adopted by the a.cum Di.-. tithe Colorado Depar1111111t., Revenue, not Im than once..-, thinr (30) tlaya r. the pr1ndint calendar month; provided, however, that ilth, ._...._ ........ ,...alarty .. ployed by the licenNcl NUiler in the tranucdon ofhia bulineea. • e&her eonditions, are ll&Ch that reports of sales made on a ealendar _.thty baaia will impose unnecesury hardship, the DiNCIOr may, upea req\lN& of ..W retaia., .._ reporta at auch intervals u will, in hil epinion, beUer IUit the 11u• l•11 of the .......,.,, -.'!I.--__ will notjeopardi u the eolleetion of the tu; and, pNl¥iM ftardler, Iha& a retailer doinc bulineu in two (I) or .... ,a-or locatien1 lallJ ftle .. Nblnl CO¥erifts all such businau activities in the City. (Ord. 74 S.-1116; a.._ Ord. U SeriN 1990) 8 n. Ntum1 • ftled ahaU eont.ain IUCh ..,.,.._ • _, enable the Direct.. te amaralely clelenalne the a ... t tltu ........ by the..,_, pannenhip or corporatien ftHnc the return, bu& la aD eaM1 lhaD Natul the lellewillc nformation : 1. The amount o1,,... tu.we ..... _.. by the re&ailer clurina the periell for which the rewm is ftW; 2 . The total aalet priee of all pnpmy......,... by the punhaeer •a,...,, of a rewm of ..... ..W by the Nlailer; ,...wW. tM _......a .... WM a tu.we tranuction ; 22 "' - . ' • ' I . • • ~-----·· , ]- • • • • 3. The total fair market value ,I any property received by the retailer a1 a result fll an exchanp fll property; provided the property 10 received i1 held by the retailer to be aold or leaad to a uMr or con1umer in the re,ular course ,I hi1 bu1ineH; 4 . The total amount of retail uln which are exempt from the tu impoaed by Section 4-4-4-2 by reaaon filth• provi1ion1 fllSection 4-4-4-3. 5 . The total amount or ulH made on credit. the obliption for which i1 not MCUred by a conditional aale1 contract, chaU.I mortpp or other MCUrity instrument entitlins the retailer to repa11a1 the item aold, which are round to be -rthleN and which may be deducted u bed debt.a on the retailer'• Ftcleral income tu retum. C. The retum shall be accompanied by an amount equal to the ulH tu required to be collected by the retailer but which, in no caae, shall be Ina than the amount actually collected, nor Ina than lh••• ,.,ee11, IK) THREE AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (3.5,L) fll the ftpre derived by aubb'actint from the poll taxable uln, u ref1ected on the retum, the total uln dacribed in aubeection1 82, 3, 4 and 5 above, •• reflect.eel on the return; proviclecl, however, the retailer may deduct from the total tax due an amount equal to one and li11-tenth1 J)elftnt (I.ft) fllthe uln tu required to be collected, which may be retained by the retailer u a fN for collectin1 uid tu. D. All other pel'Nftl. partnenhipa and eorporatiln1 lhall pay • the Di,.._ the amount fll any tu due under the ,...rtli•• tlS--4-4-6-3, Mt 1w dlan ftftaen (11) daya after the date did laid tu.__. .... (Onl 74 8eriea 11115) 4-4-1 : lJIIITAXDIPOIBD: 4-4-1-1: TAX ON 8TC>aAGS. CCJlaJIIPl10N AND lJIII: fteN 6a henby le¥ied and there lhall be eallec&ad from "917 ...-..... City, • &u ...... pmt .... " ltorins, ulinc er_......._ within the ......... tlllle ~-, arddea ti ........ penonal .....-t.J .......... retail,,.. __ ........ .,..... llaitlflltheCg_.:_ Such ta•. to ...... eftedwe.J•urJ l. ........ be,_..... .......... be.........,,,. .. the Direct.or fll Plnandal 8emeea ill aa•Nlanee widl ta.. ........ ....._: I .Ol lndudins I 14 I . ll lncludinl I .41 I .43 IMludlnt I . 71 • . '71 includinl .... 11 .00 lncludi• IUI II.It lnducli• 11.67 11.11 includi• 11.11 ..... includinc 11.00 23 ne&u l.01 ... •• l.04 ... •• . ., . . ' I . • , • • • • • • On 1torap or acqui1ition charp1 or co1t1, in exceu r,l two dollan (S2.00), the ta11 &hall be aeven centl (S.07) on each two dollan (S2.00) or such atorap or acquisition charpa or co1t, plus the ta11 shown in the above schedule for the applicable hctional part or a dollar or each such charpa or coat. (Ord. 61 Series 1987; amd. Ord. 63 Seri• 1990) For transaction• consummated on or after January 1, 1966, the City 11111 ta11 &hall not apply to the 1torap or construction and buildin1 materials. (Ord. 74 Series 1985) 4-4-5-2: A . EXBMPl'IONS TO USE TAX: The ta11 or e11ciH levied by Section 4-4-6-1 ia hereby declared to be supplementary to the ta11 levied by Section 4-4-4 hereof, and for this ,..._, the followin, transactions shall be exempt therefrom : 1. The atora,e, use or consumption ofpenonal property, the ule rilwhich i1 mbject to the tall levied by Section 4-4-4 . 2 . The atorap, UM or consumption rilany tanlible perlOftal property purch...ct for reule to thi1 City, either in its Of'icinal form or a1 an inlredient or a manufactured or compoundecl product, in the ncular coune tla bulineu 3 . The ....... UN or consumption of'mo&or f\ael upon which there hu accrued, ... hea llwl paid, the mow W tax preecrilled by the Colorado Motor Fuel Tu IA• el 1133, • any amenct-ta thent.e.l 4 . The ....... UM or conaumption tlt.ancible penanal property which wu ..... at a tiee when .... -OI' --......... a _....._t r,l ._ Cit,y; pnrided its uaa or conaumpda ia a. the beMftt ti aid UIII' or cea, ... r . 5. The ....... uaa or C0111Uaption ti_,.. ,.......1 property tithe Unked 8&a&ee ll"ffl_.t. or 11M 8'811 elc.londe, • ka inltkudona, or ka ~ _ _ euWiYiaiona, in their Pftffl-tal ..-idea •'1; or by rel.-., charilable or eleeffloeyaary lftldwdaae in the eoa4ud el their ncular relipMII er charitable f'unctioaa; prorillell. hewever, that no eo111mercial, indlal&rial or other bank.ins inaiwtioaa, e,pniaed or charwred by the the UaiYCI lllMN pvem...-. any a,aacy or ..... ftlNllt thenef, or by 11M Sule ., Celondo, .... be eealidered a pvemam&al lnl&itutioa rer the purpoae " thil ..... ptioa . I . The ....... UM• .aau ..... ,I .............. property by a ...... ......... "the buiftHI " ............ -,-..diac ......... pnlk. UM, any artkle, ......._ er -..ctity. which tanc'ble ...,....1 preperty ....u all ti the fellewln, CN4litieaa: a . 11 lldaally and factually tru.A..a by the,,_... ti •••11farlure: 24 ,. -. • . ' I· • 0 , - B. • • '· b . Becomes by the manufacturin1 proceu a nec:e1ury and NCllll'liuble inpedient, component or con1tituent part or the finished product; and c . lta physical pneence in the flnilhed product ia euential to the uN thereof in the Ilana or the ultiaat. -,. For tranledi•• conlWll-t.ed • or after .January l, 1111, the City'1 UN tu 1hall not apply to the ....... UN, OI' _,._ or any article ortan,ible penonal property, the aJe OI' UN or which hM abwly ... liJli1 *d to a aJea OI' UN tu or another l&atutory or home nale aanicipalit,, ....,...ty ad proponionally impoeed on the purchaNr or wr eqaal ••in -or•,. pawww, fRt THJlD AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (3.ft). A ~t lhall be ....... apinat the City'1 UN tu with rnpect to the...,_ ............ OI' ... ..,.. in the City ortaftlible penonal property, ~ amount or the credit ....... the t.u paid by him by ...... or the impoaidon ora aJea Ol' IIN tu or the ,...,..e ~ OI' home rule municipality on hit purchue OI' ... or the pnpert,,. fte .-t af'the credit shall not exceed lhr• pa •n• , ... ) THUi AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (3.&•>. C . For tranledion1 conaummat.ed • OI' after .January l, 1111, the City'1 UN tu shall not be impoeed with reapect .. thew or conauapdon orlancible..,..... property within the City which occun more than llm,c (3 ) yean after the moat ...-nt ale al the preperty ii, within the th,-(3) yean lolJowinc auch aJe, lhe property haa been aipiftcattly ... within the .... for the priadpel puwlNN for which it ... purcha..._ D . Nothiftc herein contained lhall be ........... ,..._ die tu lffled by 8ec&iln 4-4-6-38• the....._ ... or 11a11.,._ ti-, ....... ,..... property .. be Uled by a emuacta tar tM eastn&lllea ti• la,11.1••• tar any tithe inl&itudonl OI' ............ la I b d Al ..... (Orel. 74 8eriel 1111) 4-4-6-3 : PATIIDft' AND COll:W:IION OI' UIII TAZ: A. Payment "Tu. ~--- l . -,u1,..... ............................................ the ......... tlSectila ................. widaill the return ......... ... nw.,.......t•tM,awhh ,,,...._....._,,_...._..._. .. .., bl reqwred by tM D6 .... ,, ................ .., ...... hi• accurately to...,... the .... tt1 ... tu• ha aid nullorlar pun:h ....... by ............ which .... t.u ........... ...... ,., which auch ....... ftW. 25 . ' • . .. .; I. • , ]- • • • t• • ' 8. Payment and Collection on Specific ltem1. The followi1111pecial provi1ion1 ,hall apply t.o the payment or any uN tu due on the uN, conaumption or It.Grap of the followin1 item,: C. 1. Motor Vehicla and Trailen. Any panon, partnership or corporation who lhall purehue any mot.or vehicle, trailer or Hffli-trailer, whether new or med outside the City, with the intent t.o ncilter the ume at an addre11 inlide the City, lhall immediately, and prior t.o nci1teri111 and obteinin1 licenN platn thenf'or, make a ret.um lhowins auch tranuction to the Director or Financial Servicel and pay to him the UN tu applicable thereto U provided f'or in lubeection A hereof'. 2. Buildin1 Material, and Suppliea. Any penon, partnerlhip or corporation who does not maintain a permanent place ofbuain8N within the boundarin of the City and who lhall build, eonltnact or improve any buildi111, dwelli111 or other atructure or impro,ement to l"Nlt;y whauoeftr within the City lhall, upon application for a buildillf permit. pay u a depoeit f'or payment of the tu levied by Section '-'-5-1 an amount equal to lh._ ,eNIIII (K) THREE AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (S.K) offtfty percent (501l) of the ntimated c:o1t or the improvement, or 111 .. ,.,_., (K) 'l'HRBB AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (S.K) offtfty pet'Cfflt (501') of the tcul eontnct priel, if there ia a contract for the buildin, conltnaction or impr..,.....&; prowided, however, that if the ea&imat.d eoat of the impr ...... tor the t.lUl .atreet price ii in aceu oft- hlllldred theuaanll dlllan <1IOO,OOO 00) .. Dinlur, in hie ........ and upon application to him,_.,...._• wahw of eaid depoait and aocept the payment of aicl tu• a aathly, ...-,ly or edter baaia, buad upon actual parchuea of materiala, ..................... dich auch tu..., be due, aulied to_. nalea _. nphd-1 • ._ ..W Dinclar may adopL In all caw where the ............ .,, die ........ ofdlil ..... ii made, ifit ii cllt.erained at._ tiae of the u .. 1,dla of the ll8iWins, ._...., • other lltnlebare of improw ••••t "-die ilffllieN a4I llat.....,ta nllecdn1 the purchaN thenf'er, that ................ ,......, ....... with the actual paymenta to the Cit;y • a ..... tu, is in -of the actual tu clue therefor, the penon maki111 aaid depoeit .. paylns aaid tu .., .... ~ -- applicauerl t.o the Di...._ of n....a a.n-. 1w relucl of •Y a1110U11t paicl in .... oftheadul ........ in which eWll&t& ..... be ..... of the penon makins auc11 applicatien .. ,.,.... an .. m,..,. wn, _. inwieea ewlenclnt oww..,.,.., of die ........ ,, ...... .,.... ...... that then hu ..... auch .... ,,.,,_t. he ................ Hlfpay-..& .. the taapayer . C.llnldien .....-, which" ..... widlin ............. of .. Cit;y .. a period of..,. than thirt;y (JO) .. m'IIIM _,. lllaD be •'lri• d .. • the f\all applic.W. UN tu of the City. 21 ,, - . ' • • I . • 0 , - • • • • • I • • D. With respect t.o transactions consummated on or after January 1, 1986, construction equipment which i1 located within the boundaries of the City for a period of thirty (30) conaec:utive day1 or le11 shall be subjected to the City's UN tu in an amount which doe1 not exceed the amount calculated aa follows: th• purchue price of the equipment shall be multiplied by a hction, the numerator of which i1 one and the denominator of which i1 twelve, and the result lhall be multiplied by three pereent ~ THREE AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (3 .5 .. ). E . Where the provi1ion1 or subsection D or thi1 Section are utili&ed, the credit provi1ion1 or subsection 4-4-5-28 shall apply at such time u the aarepte ulea and uae tun leplly imposed by and paid to other statutory and home rule municipalities on any 1uch equipment equal three peree11, (Kl THREE AND ONE-HALF PERCENT (3.5 .. ). F. In order to avail himself or the provilion1 of subsection D or thi1 Section, the t .. payer shall comply with the followinr procedure: o . 1. Prior to or on the date the equipment i1 located within the boundarin or the City, the taxpayer shall file with the City1 Financial Services Department an equipment declaration on a form provided by the City. Such declaration shall state the dates on which the tupayer anticipates the equipment will be located within and removed f'Tom the bow ' · fthe City, shall include a clncription of each such anticipated piece of equipment, lhall ltate the actual or anticipated purchaN price of each IUCh anticipated piace of equipment, and ahall include such other information aa reaaonably daemed n-ry by the City. 2 . The tupayer shall file with the City an amended equipment declaration reflectinr any chanrn in the informat.ion contained in any pnvioua equipment declaration no i.. than once every ninety (IO) daya after the equipment i1 broqht into the bounclariN of the City or, for equipmant which i1 broupt into the boundariel olthe City tor a pniact ollea than ninety (IO) days' duration, no later than tan (10) daya aft-, aubetanlial completion of the projecL ~--. -• 3 . The taxpayer naecl not report on any equipment declaration any equipment r. which the 1Nrchue price waa under two thousand ftw hundred dollars (12,500.00). If the equipment declaration ia -'"" • p,9Vicled in lubNctioa r of thi1 Sectien, then a, to any item of conl&naedan ....-..t for which the cuuaary Pllrch .. price i1 under two thouund he ......... dollars (Sl,I00.00) which waa broupt into the boundarin of the City temporarily 1w ue • a _.llnldion pnject, k lhall be pruutMd that the ilefll wa1 Pllrchaaecl In a jurildie&'-havi111 a lecal •'-or uae tu u hlch a1 lh,.. ,.,x::1 (Ml THRO AND ONI-HALI' P&IC&NT (J.6 .. ) and that IUCh local ulel OI' UN tu WU preri1uly paW. 111 IUCh -Iha buNlen of preof in any .......U111 Wore the City the 1'11 r 1&1¥e D6.-. of &he Daparunant of' "-""ue, or the diltritt eourt. tlhaD be • the City te prew IUCh local ulel or u• 1.a1 ... Mt paid . 27 I . • I • • • • • • H . If the taxpayer fails to comply with the provi1ion1 of subsection F of this Section, the taxpayer may not avail himself of the provi1ion1 of 1ubtection D of thi1 Section and shall be subject to the provisions ohublection C of'thi1 Section. However, substantial compliance with the provision, of' subsection F of thi1 Section 1hall allow the taxpayer to avail him11lf of the provi1ion1 of' 1ub11Ction D of' thi1 Section . (Ord. 74 Serl11 1985; amd. Ord. 63 Seri11 1990) 4-4-6 : LICENSE AND TAX IN ADDfflON TO ALL OTHER TAXES: The license and tax imposed by thi1 Chapter shall be In addition to all other licen111 and tu11 imposed by law, except H herein otherwi11 provided. (Ord. 74 Seri11 1985) 4-4· 7 : TAX INFORMATION CONFIDENTIAL: A . Except in accordance with judicial order, or a, otherwi1e herein provided, the City shall not divulp any information pined from any return filed or a, a rnult of any inv11ti1:ation or hearinc held punuant to the provi1ion1 of thi1 Chapter. B. Nothini: contained in this Section 1hall be construed to prohibit: l . The delivery to a penon, or to hi1 duly authorized repre11ntat.ive, of a copy of any return filed in connection with hi, ta•; 2 . The publication of 1tatiltiet 10 elauifted u to prevent the identification of particular report.a or returns and the it.ems thereof. 3 . The inspection by the City Attomey, or any other lepl reprnentative of'the City, of the retum or other information relatin, to any tupayer who may become involved in litiption with the City in which the uid information may beco-material. C . ReporU and returns shall be preserved for three (3) yun ancl, th--"-until the Director of Financial Servicea, with the approval of the City Manapr, shall order them destroyed. (Ord. 74 Seri111INl5; amd. Ord. 83 Seri• 1990) 4 -4 -8 : ESTIMATED TAXES AND AM1'81MENT11DIUCOP: A. 8 . With respect to tranuetions eonsummatad before January l, 1111, W any penon necleet.a or ref'UIII to make a retum for, or ..,._,t of any of the IUN leried by this Chapter when the aame becoftM due, the Direetor of Financial ServieH shall, at some date aubtequent to fifteen < 15) days after the daY few the lllakiftc of such mum or the payment of' such talln, pve wriu.n notice to the,.,_. l'lliplnlillle for ma kins aaid return or payin, said taut er the lecll of &he fttinc ti such return or pay!Mftt of aa id tBll11, which notice shall MCWy the tupayer, wet.her penon responsible for the return of the tu. the& the .... mua& be paW wkhill MNn (16) day1 from the data of' the receipt of aaid notice . If the return i1 not fUecl, or the taut are net paicl, within M.Nn Cll) llaya aftff recei pt of aaid notice, the Director "'81 IMlie M .u ... , .._. .,... lllch Information a1 may be available to h i111, tithe a....,.t tltaue ... ler 1M pe,W er ptriod1 for which ta1payer Is delinquent and ahaD MIi then&e • ,_..ty hi en 28 • ,- •, I • • , - • • • l • • amount equal to ten percent ( lO'lo) or uid •t.imated tax, topther with intere1t on uid estimated tax at the rate or one percent (1 'll,) per month from the due date thereof, and may ane11 uid amount apinat the delinquent taxpayer by civin1 uid taxpayer written notice thereof', which notice 1hall require the taxpayer either to pay the amount a,aened by the Director or to petition him for a correction or uid eatimata within a period ofteft-ff4H TWENTY (20) days thereafter. Any auch petition ror correction ahall be in writin1 and any racta or ftprea in aupport thereof ahall be IUbmitted upon the oath of the taxpayer. The Director ahall con1ider the matten IUbmitted by the taxpay• and ahall make a decision u to the proper amount of tuea, penalty and intareat due, which decision ahall be final and bindln1, nc,ept u modifted by Stata ltatutaa. 11lll: TD1E PERIOD 8BT IOR111IN'111188EC'l10N MAY, IN 11lll: AB80Ll1TE DISCRE'l10N or 111B DIBBCTOR or FINANCIAL SERVICES, BB WAIVED ,OR GOOD CAUSE ON Wlll'l'n.:N APPLICAflON or A VENDOR OR TAXPAYER. C . With respect to tranuction1 conaummated on or after January l, 1986: l . If a person ne,lecta or Nfuae1 to make a return in payment or the ulea tax or to pay any tax when the ume becomea due, the Director or Financial Services ahall, at aome data aubw.-. .. ~••L IAI fifteen (15) day1 after the data for the makin, of 1Uch return or the payment of 1uch taxa, make an Htimata, baaed upon IUCh lnfwmadln aa aay be aftilable, of the amount of tun due for the period for which tha taxpayer ii delinquent and ahall add thereto a penalty equal ta the aua offtftea dollan <al&.00) for auch failure or tan percent (lO'I,) thereof and lnt.erat • auch delinquent taxn at the rata impoaed under IUbNction ca of thil 8ectia plua one-half' or one percent <.K) per month from the data when due, not aaedi111 eichtaen percent (1ft) in the ..,...ta. 2. II a per.-necleda or..,._ t. mali. a return in payment of the uae tax or ta pay any tax • requind. the DiNdM lhall aake an ...... baaed upon 3. auch information • may be available, of the alMWlt of tual clue for tht,-. __ _ period for which the taxpayer ii delinquent an4 than add then&o a penalty .... 1 ta t.en pereent ( lO'I,) thereof and iat.eNet • audl delinquent taxn at the rate, .. ,... under •beection ca of thil Sectia, plua -.hall of one pereent (.K) per IIIOllth from the dat.e when clue . The annual rata of inleralt •~&aw under aubeection1 Cl and C2 above ahaU be that ntabliahed by the lkata Cefflinillioner or Bankin1 pursuant ta Ndion lt-21-110.5, C.U . (Orel. 74 Series 1116; a ... Ord. 13 Serin IIIO) 4 ·4 ·9 : SALS or 8TOCX oa QUITl1NO IIIJIINIII: A. Any Nlailer who lhall aen out hia ............ " .... or whe ahall cauit butin ... , shall be Nqllired to,,....,. and file a •• tu 81141 uae tax ratum a1 provided in thl10..,.. within Ma. (15)..,. I .11 ldlFt ta the ... tithe -pladon of uid ult,• the......._ ti....__. 1M ,.,._, theraal, if any, 21 ,,, - • . •· • I - • • • • . . lhall be Nquired to withhold 1ufficient of the purchaae money to cover the amount or •id tu due and unpaid, until IUCh time u the Nici retailer lhall produce a receipt from the Director 1howin, that all such tun have been paid and that no further ta11naredue. 8. If the parchuer al a bulinHI or lt.ock al poclt llhall fail t.o withhold the purchue m-, u above provided, and the tu lhall be due and unpaid after the fifteen (15) day period aD0"9d. 111ch purchuer llhall be penonally liable for the payment al the tun unpaid by the former owner and the lien, cnat.ed by Section 4-4-14 lhall immediataly au.ch to the,.,....._ property• purchued; provided. however, that the retailer so Mllin, or quium, buainHI llhall not be relieved in any manner or hi1 liability for payment al any al •id tun due. (Ord. 74 Serin 1985) 4-4-10: DEnCD:NCY NO'nCBI AND RD'IJND8: A . Refund Procedure. l . A. refund lhall be made or credit alloW9d for any tu paid under protast by any purch ... r or uNr who has, or claim, to have, an exemption a1 in thi1 O..ptar provided. Such reftand shall be made by the Director after compliance with the followinr condition, precedent: I . a. Application. Application, for retuncl mult be made within ninety (90) days after the purchue or uee al the,_. on which the .... pdon ii claimed, and mua be ......... by the affldmt al the purchuer or UNI' accompanied by the oriplal paid invaiee • •let Nllipt and a certiflcata iuued by the eeller, ...... with each farthw inllrmatioll u 11111)' be .......... by the Dlnetier. b With....,_ t.o tranaactioll1 con-mated on• afterJ•UUJ l, llN, an appticetioll lw ...,_.al..._• uae &u paid under diaputa by a parehuer ................ ,tian .......... t ...... a..,.. llheU be .... within mty (IO) days after the purchue, ....... UN or -••ptien al the ...................... •••ptiee.. qi--. - claiae4. C. With f-,ec& .. lnnaecdenl __ ..... on• after Ja1U17 l, llN, an applicauen for...,.... ti IU-,. paid in enw w by ailuke, llhall be ..... within thrN (3) ,-n after the .... tlpurchaee, ...... . ... .. ............. tithe ..... ,_ .... die,.,_. .. ........ Decilion1. Upon reeeipt ti eacll ............ 11111 ,-y1nr ......._, the Di...., •n ...... the .... lrith an._.,... end lhall rive M&iN ta the applicant by • ....., in wrid111 ti hi1 decWen thereon . 30 ,- . ' I . • , -• • • 3. Hurin1. An accneved applicant may, within ~ TWENTY (20) claya after auch decision i1 mailed to him, petition tha Director (or a hearine on tha claim in which case the Director shall, upon due notice to the applicant, hold a hearin1 upon such applications, takin1 such information or evidence a1 may be material, and shall, thereafter, render his final cleci1ion upon such application, which decision shall be final. B. Deficiency Notice or Refunds. 1. With rapact to tranuctiona con1ummatad on or after January 1, 198e, in lieu althe proceclun providad for in 1ubaection A 1 above, the tupayer may elect a hearins al the Director'• final cleciaion on a defkiency notice or claim ror reftand punuant to proceclure Mt forth in thi1 Section. a . Al 1111d in this Section, "State hearinc" means a hearin1 bef'ore the Eucutive Direct.or al the Department al Revenue or delepte thereof' a1 provided in section 29-2-101.1(3), C.R.S . b . When the City uMrta that ulea or uae tun are due in an amount puter than the amount paid by a taxpayer, the City shall mail a deficiency notice to the taxpayer by certified mail. TIie deftciancy notice shall state the additiona l i.alea and UN tun due. TIie deficiency notice shall contain notiflcation, in clear and conspicuou1 t,pe. that the IUpayer hu the ,.tit to elld a 8taa heaf'inl on &he deftciency punuant .. aaction 29·2-lOl.1(3), C .R.S. TIie taxpayer lhall alao haw the ript .. elect a Stat.a hearin1 on &he City'• denial al IUCh &upayer'1 claim for a reftand al •lea or UN ta• paid. e. TIie taxpayer ahall requn& the 8lale hearinc within thirty (IO) deya aft.a, .... tax,.,.,·, ----al loeal .....till. TIie &ope,-ahall ha,,e no richt to IUCh hNrint if he hu net ahauatad loeal ......_ or ifhe fai1a to,..-. Midi hearifts wkMn the time period ,......._ Por ...,.... tlthia •b11c1-. ............ allecal ......... -= ~--- (1 ) 'Ille ......,., • tiaely ,., ..... la writinc a .............. &he ~_.die City.._ heW _. ...... and illllad a ftnal . ................................... _ lnaecrlp&. "'* al erid•ca, er flffac al brW'I lhall ba ,......; 111111 the tupayer aay elact te ..a.At a briaf', In which -lhe City .., IDbait a brial. 'Ille Ci9 ..... Wd IUCh .......... 6- lhe flNI ~ thena wilhie ._., (to) da,a aft.er lhe City'a ....... tithe......,., .......... ,..... .... --the City .., ai.d each parW lithe...., Ill......, the hNrilll or ._... the ded .... ....._ WM 11mh11d by the......,_, but, In any auch event, the City ahal heW lllcla hearlnt • ,_ the ............. withia .............. ., (llO)deya tithe t,up11yer'1 ,.._. ,n wrtdnc ~ er 31 ,, - ' I. • . , , - • • • • • (2) The taxpayer hu timely requel&ed in writinr a hearinr before the City and the City ha, failed to hold such hearinr or has failed to i11ue a final decision thereon within the time periods prescribed in aubparar,aph (1) above. d. If a taxpayer haa exhausted his local remedies as provided in subsection B le, of this Sec:tion, the taxpayer may request a State hearinc on such deficiency notice or claim for refund, and such request &hall be made and 111ch hearinr &hall be conducted in the ume manner as set f'orth in section 29-2-UMl.1(3) throuch (7), C.R.S. e. If the deficiency notice or claim for refund involve& only the City, in lieu of requestinr a State hearinr, the taxpayer may appeal such def\ciency or denial al a claim for refund to the district court of the County of Arapahoe u provided in section 29-2-106.1(8), C.R.S., provided the taxpeyer complies with the procedure& set forth in aublection Blc of this Section. f . Noth inc in this Section &hall prohibit the taxpayer from pur1uin1 judicial review of a final decision of the City u otherwise provided in this Chapter. 2 . With Nll*t to transactions con1U111mated on or aft.er January 1, 1988, within fifteen ( 15) clays aft.er fllin1 a notice al appeal as provided in IUbaectien Ble, tha taxpayer ahall ftle with the dil&rict court a surety bond in twice the amount al the taxas. internt, and other charpa stated in the final decision by the Director which are contel&ed on appeal. The taxpayer may, at hil option, utisfy the surety bond requiffllleftt by a uvinp account or depoait in or a certificate of depoait iuued by a S&ate or National bank or by a S&ate or Federal uvinra and loan alNCiation, in aeeordanoe with the pl'O¥iaiona al Nd.ion 11-36-101(1), C .R.S., equal to twice the amwnt al the laUI, interea&, and other charpa stated in the final decision by the Direct.or. 3 . 4 . fte taxpayer may, at hil option, depoait the dilputed .-nt with the DifliE&f · -- in lieu al plll&iftl a surety ......_ If IUch .-nt ii so depoaited, no further intefftt &hall a«nae on the deftciency contel&ld duriftl the panclancy of the ecdon . At the mndusion of the acdan, after.,,... to the aupr9IM CGUrt or the CGUrt of appeals or aft« the U-for IUch .,,... hu nplred, the ftancls dapoaited &hall be, at the cliNCtion of the eou,c. either rewnad by the Direcl.or and applied apinlt the deftciency or returned In whole or in part to the wpayer with interest at the rae. ... ,._. punuant te •llaecdori 4 .. 4-1 CCX3>, of this Chapter. Na clai• r. raf'uncl of UNIUMI tlapoaited with the Director need ba mecle by the &upayer in ardar for Mich UIOUnl.l to ba repaid in -,dance with the diNdion al the eourt. Ally perMn claimins te heft paid a tall for the purcha• or UN of tanp,la parsonal property in 8IICIIU ti the rat.. ee&abHahad by this Chapler, may apply f'or a refund of uid elCfll in the 111a11w PNtCribacl above . 32 "' - ' I . • , • • • • • • 5. Refund Not Aaaicnable. The rieht of any penon to a refund under this Chapter lhall not be auicnable, and application for refund must be made by the aame penon who pun:hued or uaed the pod, and who paid the tu thereon, u lhown by the invoice or the aale thereoC or other appropriate document. 6 . The Director shall have the authority to waive part or all or any penalty and/or interest a,_lld if the cin:um1tance1 deem such. (Ord. 74 Series 1985) 4-4-11 : EXAIONAflONS OP RETlJRN8; RBftJND8. DEFICIENCIES: As IOOll as prartic11ble aft.er any aaln or u1e tu return i1 flied, the Director lhall eaamine it, and if it then appean that the COl'TICt amount aftu to be NllliUed i1 sr-ter or leu than that lhown in the return, the tax lhall be recomputad. If the amount paid exceeda that which i1 due, the ucna lhall be refunded or credited apinat any 1ubeequent remittance from the aa-tupayer. If the amount paid i1 l111 than the amount due, the difference, &opther with interest thereon at the rate or one percent (11') per month from the ,;_ the return wu due, 1hall be paid by the \•endor within ftftNn (15) day1 aft.er written nouce and demand to him from the Director. With reapect to return, flied on or after January 1, 19N, the annual rate of'interut on delinquent tu• lhall be that ntablilhad by the State Commiui-r of' Bankinc punuant to aection 35-21-110.5, C .R.S. (Ord. 74 Series 1186) 4-t-12: INVE811GAflON OP IISTAILD1I BOOD A . For the purpoae ol aacertaininc the CIOITIC&IIIII of' a n&um, or for the purpoae of' det.ermininc the amount el tu chae ha any &u..,..., the Director 11U1J hold invntiption1 and heerinp C9MafflUII any aauen -nc1 by thi1 Olapwr and B. may naffline any relnant bolb, ,.,...., ..... or .....,...da ol any auch ~ --- perMn, requirinc the aum..._ el auch _..,... or •Y effleer or .. p1oyee ol 1uch taxpayer, or of' any ,.,-haWII bewlelllt el IUCh •IN and &akinc IUch testimony and proolu aay a.._.., .. .....-,ty ...naia any taa li.Wlity. The Di...aor lhall have power u adainilur N&ha to any ,.,_ in the eoune of' such invntiption1 or hurin,. COORDINATED AUDIT PROCBDUUS : 1. COORDINATED AUDIT : a . ANY TAXPAYER UCENHD IN THIS CITY PURSUANT TO TITLE POUR. CHAPTER POUR or fllS ICNOLSWOOD MUNICIPAL CODE 1186. AND HOLDING A SDIJLU &\LIi TAX UCICNSI IN AT LEAST POUR OTHER COLORADO MUNICIPALITISS THAT ADMINISTICR THEIR OWN BAUS TAX OOu.acnON, MAY UQUIST A COORDINATED AUDIT AS PllOVIDBD HIUIN. 33 "' - ' I . • , • • b. • . (• • WITHIN 14 DAYS OF RECEIPI' OF NOTICE OF AN INTENDED AUDIT BY ANY MUNICIPALITY THAT ADMINISTERS ITS OWN SALES TAX COLLECTION, THE TAXPAYER MAY PROVIDE TO THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL SERVICES OP THIS CITY, BY CERTIFIED MAIL, RETURN RECEIPI' REQUESTED, A WRITTEN REQUEST FOR A COORDINATED AUDIT INDICATING THE MUNICIPALITY FROM WHICH THE NOTICE OF INTENDED AUDIT WAS RECEIVED AND THE NAME OF THE OfflCIAL WHO ISSUED SUCH NOTICE. SUCH REQUEST SHALL INCLUDE A UST OF THOSE COLORADO MUNICIPALfflES tn'IUZING LOCAL COLLECTION OF THEIR SALES TAX IN WHICH THI TAXPAYER HOLDS A CURRENT SALIS TAX UCENSE AND A DECLARATION THAT THE TAXPAYER WILL SIGN A WAIVER OF ANY PASSAGE-OF-TIMI BASED UMITATION UPON THIS CITY'S RIGHT TO RECOVER TAX OWED BY THE VENDOR FOR THE AUDIT PERIOD . c . EXCEPI' AB PROVIDED IN 4-4-12-B-l-G, ANY TAXPAYER THAT SUBMITS A COMPLETE REQUEST FOR A COORDINATED AUDIT AND PROMPl'LY SIGNS A WAIVER OF 4.4.17 E .M.C ., MAY BE AUDITED BY THIS CITY DURING THE TWELVE MONTHS AFTER SUCH REQUEST IS SUBMITTED ONLY THROUGH A COORDINATED AUDIT INVOLVING ALL MUNICIPALITIES ELECTING TO PARTICIPATE IN SUCH AN AUDIT. d . •• IF THIS CITY DESIRES TO PARTICIPATE IN THI AUDIT or A TAXPAYER THAT SUBMITS A COMPLETE REQUEST FOR A COORDINATED AUDIT PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH (3), THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL SDVICES SHALL SO NO'l'ln THE DIRECTOR or FINANCIAL SERVICES or THI MUNICIPALITY WHOSE NOTICE or AlJDIT PROMPTED THE TAXPAYER'S REQUEST WITHIN TEN DAYS AffU ucs1n or flll TAXPAYER'S REQUEST FOR A COORDINATED AlJDIT. THI DIUCTOR or FINANCIAL SIRVJCIS SHALL TH&N COOPERATE WITH OTHEfl--·-- PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES 1M fllS DEVa.c>PMSNT or ARRANGEMENTS FOR THI COORDINATED AlJDIT, INCLUDING ARRANGEMENTS or fllE TINE DUIUNG WHICH THS COORDINATED AlJDIT WILL BE CONDUCTED, THE PUIOD or TIME TO BE COVERED BY THE AUDIT, AND A COORDINATED NOTICE TO THE TAXPAYER OF THOSI UCORDS MOST UKELY TO BE REQUIRED FOR COMPLETION or fllE COORDINATED AUDIT . IF THE TAXPAYER'S REQUUT FOR A COORDINAT'ID AUDff WAS IN RESPONSE TO A NOTICE OF AUDIT ISSUED BY TH18 CITY, THIS CITY'S DIRECTOR or FINANCIAL auvrca SHALL FACILITATE ARRANGEMENTS BITWSIN THIS CITY AND OfllU MUNICIPAUTIU PARTICIPATING IN THI COORDINATED AUDIT UNLESS AND UNTIL AN OfflCIAL FIOM IOMI OTHU PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITY AGUES TO AIIUMI THIS RISPONSIBIUTY. THI DIRICl'Oll or FINANCIAL IUVICES 34 • I . • , J - • • • r. • • • SHALL COOPERATE WITH OTHER PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES TO, WHENEVER PRACTICABLE, MINIMIZE THE NUMBER OF AUDITORS WHAT WILL BE PRESENT ON THE TAXPAYER'S PREMISES TO CONDUCT THE COORDINATED AUDIT ON BEHALF OF THE PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES. INFORMATION OBTAINED BY OR ON BEHALF OF THOSE MUNICIPALITIES PARTICIPATING IN THE COORDINATED AUDIT MAY BE SHARED ONLY AMONG SUCH PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES . IF THE TAXPAYER'S REQUEST FOR A COORDINATED AUDIT WAS IN RESPONSE TO A NOTICE OF AUDIT ISSUED BY THIS CITY, THIS CITY'S DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL SERVICES SHALL, ONCE ARRANGEMENTS FOR THE COORDINATED AUDIT BETWEEN THE CITY AND OTHER PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES ARE COMPLETED, PROVIDE WRITTEN NOTICE TO THE TAXPAYER OF WHICH MUNICIPALITIES WILL BE PARTICIPATING, THE PERIOD TO BE AUDITED AND THE RECORDS MOST LIKELY TO BE REQUIRED BY PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITIES FOR COMPLETION OF THE COORDINATED AUDIT . THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL SERVICES SHALL ALSO PROPOSE A SCHEDULE FOR THE COORDINATED AUDIT. 1 · THE COORDINATED AUDIT PROCEDURE SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION SHALL NOT APPLY : (l) WHEN THE PROPOSED AUDIT IS A .JEOPARDY AUDIT, (2) TO AUDITS FOR WHICH A NOTICE OF AUDIT WAS GIVEN PRIOR TO THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SECTION, (3) WHEN A TAXPAYER Un1SIS TO PROMPl'LY SIGN A WAIVER OF TITLE 4, CHAPTER 4, SECTION 17, OF THIS CODE OR, .---- (4) WHEN A TAXPAYER FAILS TO PROVIDE A TIMELY AND COMPLETE UQUBST POR A COORDINATED AUDIT AS PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH Cb). 2. INTERCITY CLAIMS POR RECOVIRY : •• b. CLAIMS FOR RECOVERY . THE INTENT OF THIS SECTION IS TO STREAMLINE AND STANDARDID PROCEDURES ULATBD TO SfflJATIONS WHERE TAX HAS BEEN REMITTED TO THE INCORRECT MUNICIPALITY. IT IS NOT JNTENDED TO REDUCE OR ELIMINATE THE HSPONIIIILmBS OP THI TAXPAYIR OR VENDOR TO COllRECTLY PAY, COLLICT, AND UNIT SAi.a AND UH TAXES TO THE CITY . AS USED HERE •• "CLAIM POii RECOVDY" MEANS A CLAIM POii 35 • ,. - •· • , • ,--• . ' • I • • REIMBURSEMENT OF SALES AND USE TAXES PAID TO THE WRONG TAXING JURISDICTION. C. WHEN IT IS DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL SERVICES OF THE CITY THAT SALES AND USE TAX OWED TO THE CITY HAS BEEN REPORTED AND PAID TO ANOTHER MUNICIPALITY, THE CITY SHALL PROMPTLY NOTIFY THE VENDOR THAT THE TAXES ARE BEING IMPROPERLY COLLECTED AND REMITTED, AND THAT AS OF THE DATE OF THE NOTICE THE VENDOR MUST CEASE IMPROPER TAX COLLECTIONS AND REMITTANCES. ' d . THE CITY MAY MAKE A WRITTEN CLAIM FOR RECOVERY DIRECTLY TO THE MUNICIPAIJTY THAT RECEIVED TAX AND/OR PENALTY AND INTEREST OWED TO THB CITY, OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, MAY INSTITUTE PROCEDURES FOR COLLECTION OF THE TAX FROM THE TAXPAYER OR VENDOR. THE DECISION TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR RECOVERY LIES IN THE SOLE DISCRETION OF THE CITY. ANY CLAIM FOR RECOVERY SHALL INCLUDE A PROPERLY EXECUTED RELEASE OF CLAIM FROM THE TAXPAYER AND/OR VENDOR RELEASING ITS CLAIM TO THE TAXES PAID TO THE WRONG MUNICIPALITY, EVIDENCE TO SUBSTANTIATE THE CLAIM, AND A REQUEST THAT THE MUNICIPALITY APPROVE OR DENY IN WHOLE OR IN PART, THE CLAIM WITHIN NINETY (90) DAYS OF ITS RECEIPT . THE MUNICIPALITY TO WHICH THE CITY SUBMITS A CLAIM FOR RECOVERY MAY, FOR GOOD CAUSE, REQUEST AN EXl'ENSION OF TIME TO INVESTIGATE THE CLAIM, AND APPROVAL OF SUCH EXTENSION BY THE CITY SHALL NOT BE UNREASONABLY WITHHELD. •• WITHIN NINETY (90) DAYS AFTER RECEIPT OF A CLAIM FOR RECOVERY, THE CITY SHALL VUJn TO ITS SATISFACTION WHETHER OR NOT ALL OR A POfflON or THE TAX CLAIMED WAS IMPROPERLY RECEIVED, AND SHALL NOTln THE MUNICIP~--- SUBMITTING THE CLAIM IN WRITING THAT THE CLAIM IS IITHER APPROVED OR DENIID IN WHOLE OR IN PART, INCWDING THE REASONS FOR flll DICISION. Ir fllE CLAIM 18 APPROVED IN WHOLE OR IN PART, flll CITY SHALL REMIT THE UNDISPUTED AMOUNT TO THE MUNICIPALITY SUBMITTING THE CLAIM WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS or APPROVAL . Ir A CLAIM 18 • SUBMITTED JOINTLY BY A MUNICIPALITY AND A VENDOR OR TAXPAYER, THI CHICK SHALL Bl MADS TO THI PAJlTISS JOINTLY . DENIAL or A CLAIM FOR RECOVERY MAY ONLY Bl MADE FOR GOOD CAUSI. r . flll CITY MAY DENY A CLAIM ON flll GROUNDS THAT IT HAS PRIVIOUSLY PAID A CLAIM FOR UCOVIRY ARISING OUT OF AN AUDIT or THI Sit.Ml TAXPAYER. I flll PERIOD SUBJECT TO A CLAIM FOR RICOVERY SHALL Bl • • •• 38 0 • I - . . • • 4-4-13: • • • LIMITED TO THE THIRTY-SIX (36) MONTH PERIOD PRIOR TO THE DATE THE MUNICIPALITY THAT WAS WRONGLY PAID THE TAX RECEIVES THE CLAIM FOR RECOVERY . CONDUCT OP HBAIUNG8 : A . Subpoena, and Witntu Feet. All 1ubpoenu iullld Wider the tel'llll of'thi1 Chapter may be Nrved by any ,.,._ of' full ap. The r... of' witnelHI for attendance and trial ah all be the •ma u the f'tet of' witneun Wore the Di1tric:t Court. auch r .. to be paid when the witneu it ellCUNd f'rom further au.ndanca. When the witneu 11 aubpoenaed at the inti1taMe of'tha DiNCtor, auch r... lhall be paid in the 1UDe manner u other aapanNI under the tel'llll of'thi1 Chapter, and when a witn•• 11 aubpoenaad at the inliltaftee of' any part.y to any auch proNadint, the Director may require that the coat of'NIWII of'the aubpoana and the r.e of'the wit.neu be borne by the party at whoaa in1iat.enea the witn .. i1 aummonad. In auch cue the Director, in hi• diacretion, may require a deposit to cover the mat of' 111eh Mrvice and witnau fee. A 1ubpoana i1aued H aforeuid 1hall be MrYacl in the ••• mannar a1 a 1ubpoena i11ued out of' a court of' record. B. Judp Compel, Attendance. Any judp or the Di1trict Court of' tha Eichteenth Judicial Di1trict or the State of' Colorado, either in tenn time or vacation, upon the application oftha Director, may oompal the attendance of'witneuat, the production or booka, papen, reoorda or lllltlloranda and the pvinc of' t.aldmoay Won the Direct.or or any of'hi1 duly au&horilad apn&I, by an attach ... t f'or oontampt., or otharwiae, in the •ma manner a1 production of' evidence may be eompallad before •id Court. (Ord . 74 Series 1185) 4-4·14 : UNPAIDTAXAPRIGal..mN: A . The tHN impoaed by 8actiln 4-4-1-1 thall eoutillat.a a ftn& and prior lien upon any tanp,le ...-W pnparty whieh ii tha .... fl My tranaadion Dpall whieh 1Aid ta• 11 dua, until the .... ii paid. B. The taua impoaad by 8al&'8a '"'-4·1-U be a fin& N prior lien upon the....,--· C. and..._ ftaturN ..... • ... by may re&ai• ,.._,.. by die pnviaiona ti Section 4-4-4-7 te MIiak a,.,. ....... ,.,..,t1tha .............. ... the ltock of' poda held ... _.. in tha....., _ tlllla._, until •id taua are paid in full . flle lian1 created by A and I...._ lhaD be...,... le be tiw N ......_. upon the apeciftc llaal t1,.,....i....,.,., thaNia • ........ • lhall lalie preeadenee over all l&her lien1, w.allraneaa • clam, ti .taa111r,er !WUN and lhall hnmaclialaly auach le auch "-8 wkhe.t Ille _..., ,I Ille fW .. ti any notice of' lien thareef. ((M. 7' lleriaa 1111) 37 ,. - • .. I . • • , ] - • • • • • • 4-4-15: ENJl'ORCEMENTOFTAXESANDFORECLOSUREOF LIENS: A. If any taxes, penalty or intereat impoaed by thia Chapter and ahown due by return, filed by the taxpayer, or a, shown by a11111ment duly made a, provided herein, are not paid within fifteen (15) days after the same are due, the Director ahall i11ue a warrant under his official seal directed to any duly authorized revenue collector, or to the aheriff' of any county in this State commandinc him to leyy upon, aei&e and aell 1ufflcient personal property of the tax debtor which is aubject to tha lian1 created by Section 4-4-14 found within his county for the payment of the amount due, to(ether with interest, penalties and coat.a. B. Simultaneously with the iuuanca of said warrant, the Director aha II i1111a a notice of tu lien, aettinc forth the name of the taxpayer, the amount of the tax, penalt.iN, interest and colt.I, the date of the accrual thereof, and that the City claims a first and prior lien therefor on the tan(ible penonal property of the taxpayer subject to said liens . C. Such notice shall be on forma prepared by the Director, shall be verified by him and shall be filed in the office of the clerk and recorder of any county in this State in which the taxpayer owns tan(ible peraonal property subject to said lien,. D . Upon the filinc of uid notice of lien, the eff'ectiva date of uid lien shall relate beck to the dat.a of'tha fint taxable transaction for which any tu is due. (Ord. 74 Serial 19815) 4-4-16 : NOTICES SENT BY MAIL: All notices required to be (iven to the retailer or vendor under the provision, of this Chapter shall be in writinc and, if mailed, postpaid by certified or ra,i1tered mail, ratum receipt requaated, to him at his lut known addreu, shall be aufflrient for the purpoaa ofthi1 Chapt.ar. (Ord. 74 Sariu 1985) 4 -4-17 : A. LIMITAffONS: The taxn for any period, tGp&har with int.Iran thereon and penalt.in with raaP',.;--- thereto, impoaad by this Chapeer shall not be auaued, nor shall any nouaa of' lion be filed, or diatraint wanant be i•uad. or nit for collaetioa be inaiwt.ed, or any other action to c.llact the ..... be eo1111111Mad -. &han three (3) years after the•• on which the tax was or is payable. Nor shall any lien continua aft.er such period, eacapt for taxes a1NIMCI before the expiration of' such period, notice of lien with r•pact to which hu bean filed prior to the expiration al IUch period; in which caM1 such litn shall continua only for one yur aft.er die filinc al notice thaNGI' . B. In the cue of' a fal11 or fraudulent ra&um with int.ant to wade tu, the tax, ......... r with Interest and ptnalt.iN the,-may be uaHIICI, or procNdinp for the collaction of' such taxn may be baclan at any time. C. Before the expiration al Nch period of' limitation, the taxpayer and the Dlrenor may acrea In writ.inc to an aai.n1ion thereof', and the period ao acrMd on may be Htenclacl by subaaquant ............. in wridftl. (Ord. 74 SeriN 1116) 38 • , . I • • , ]- • • • • • I• • 4-4-18: SERVICE CHARGE ON RE'nJRNED CHECKS: If a check in payment of any ulea or use tax i1 returned unpaid, a proceHin, eharp ofA,e •ellen EM.98) FIFrEEN DOLLARS (Sl5.00) will be added to any amount due and owin1. (Ord. 74 Series 1985) 4-4-19: A. UNLAWFUL ACTS: Advertise Absorption of Tu. It lhall be unlawful for any retailer to advertiH, to hold out or to 1tate to the public or to any consumer, directly or indirectly, that the tax or any part thereof' impoaed by thi1 Chapter will be auumed or ablorbed by the retailer, or that it will not be added to the 11llin1 price of'the property aold; or if added, that any part thereof' will be refunded. B . Di1ttprd for Rules; Penalty Al1111ed. If any part of a deftciency in tax payment i1 due to n11li1ence or intentional di,,...rd of authorised rule, and reculation1 with knowledp thereof, but without intent to defraud, there lhall be added ten percent (l°') of the total amount of the deficiency; and in 1ueh cue, interest shall be collected at the rate of one percent (1'11,) per month on the amount of the deficiency from the time the return wa1 due, from the penon required to file the return, which interest and addition ,hall become due and payable within fifteen (15) day1 after written notice and demand by the Director . (Ord. 74 Series 1985) C . Fraud; Penalty AIH1aed. If any part of'the deficiency 11 due to fraud with the intent to evade the tu, then there shall be added fifty percent (5") of the total amount of' the deftciency, and in such cue the whole amount of' the tu unpaid, includin1 the addition,, lhall become due and payable fifteen (15) day, aft.er written notice and demand by the Director and an additional one percent u,i per month on uid amounts lhall be added from the date the return wu due until paid. D . Fal11 Statements. It lhall be unlawful for any penon to willfully make, prepare or submit a tu ntum, or other docu-t, -tainin, any f'allt 1tatemMt, OI' to willfully make a fal11 1talt..,t In any lnve1tiption OI' hearin,, which may aff'tct the tu liability of' any penon. ~--- E . Annual Interest Rate; Deficiency Amounts. With respect to tnnuctione _ conaummaltd on or aft.er January l, INI, that result in ~ amounts a1 defined in thi1 Section, the annual ralt of' inltNlt lhall be that lltablilhtd by the State Commi11ioner of' 8ankin1 pursuant to MCtion 31-11-110.5, C .R.8 . (Ord. 74 Serie, 1985) 4-4 -20 : PENAL TY: In addition to or in lieu of' any other penalty OI' punishment preecribed in &til1 Chapter, &tit followin, penaky may alto be lapottd r ... Yioladtn of' any of' &tie provi1lon1 of' &tii1 Chapter: five hundred dollare (8500.00) fine or one hunclrad tipty (180) days impri10nment, or both MCh fine and l111prl10n111mi. A ..,.rate ...... lhall be deemed commiu.ed upon each day or portion thtnof' duri111 or• which any Yieladtn of' any of' the provilion1 of' this Chapter ocaan or contin-. (Ont. I 8eriel 1N1) Introduced, read in full, and puetd Ofl fire& .....U...111 &ht W day of' Decnlber, lNl. 39 .. I· • . , , - - • • . . Published ua Bill for an Ordinance on the 61.h day of December, 1991. ATTEST: Clyde B. Wlain1, Mayor Loueri1hia A. BIHi, Depat, City Clerk I, Loucrilhia A. lllia. DlpulJ City Clerll of the City of ........ Colerado, h.., certify that the above an4 ftlnlllinc le a true eon of a BOl r.r • OnllnaMe, intl'odueed, nail in full, and palNCI on flnt ....un, en the tnd day of Deeember, ltlL Louerilhia A. Blli1 ----- 40 'I • . . . .. I. • • . ~ , , 2 ]- • • • • • C O U R C I L C O N N U N I C A 'r I O N Deceaber 2, 1991 11 b l:ftCJlewood Water and S-r 8oard Valley Sanitation Diatrict Suppl ... nt Ill Stevart Pond&, Director of Utilltiee Ilona Council appro,,al of Valley Sanitation Diatrlct Ill. ™· A requeat waa aade by the Valley Sanitation Diatrlct ~tlftCJ the -r/ deYeloper for aruwaation to the Valley Sanitation Dlatrlct. Inoluaion of thla land doea not increa .. the tap allocation to the Yalley Sanltatloft Dlatrlct. a. suppl-t Ill la for aa u.a appnalaatelr l.H acme. The -iatl119 _...,, la •1:• -ll9ht induatrial and will reaain the ..... b. Le9al1 Lota 1, 2 and J, CLOX SubdlYlaion, Arapalloe countr, COlorado c. OWnera, lenj•ln T. and Marlon 1:. DelahaJ • d . Plnanclal Detalla, None Pl IIIAIIC I AL None. asca1 •1 HTIOII At t he llon illll u 12 , lttl -1:lft9, the .. ter .... a.-w a..n H O fd tllat U. Cltr counc u a....-tlle aMUatlon of tlle ,ntenf ,...ru.t 1• .._i~ Ill te tlle Valle, lanitatlon Diatrict . ,. - .... I • • 0 - • ORDINA.-...CE :-.:o . _ SERIES OF 1991 • • • BY AUTHORITY A BILL FOR COUNCIL BILL XO . 78 INTRODUCf; Bl.tOu':'\.CIL I MDmER / ~< r.,,;\,"iPftDISA. .... CE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 18 FOR LOTS 1, 2 AND 3 OF Tl IE ~ SUBDIVISION, ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO TO VALLEY SAI~ITATIO'.'I DISTRICTS CONNECTORS AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF EXGLEWOOD lO 1:-.:CLUDE ADDITIONAL LAND WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. WHEREAS, Valley Sanitation District desires to annex an additional area approximately 1.56 acres located in Arapahoe County into ill District; and WHEREAS, said area i1 now zoned "E"' -llpt ind111lrial; and WHEREAS, said annexation of'this additional parcel of' land will not increase the t:ip allocation to the Valley Sanitation District; ~ow, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY CO~CIL OF THE CITY OF E!'\GLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: Scctjon 1 The Apeement betw..-i the City of' Enpwood and Valley Sanitation District entitlf'd "Supplement No . 18 To Connector·, Acreement • Sewer Contract ~o. 2". for nn nren 11pproximately l .~ acre, which i1 owned by Benjamin T. and Marion E. Delahay to the \'alley Sanitation Di1tricf1 Connector·, A,nement f'or aMeaation i1 hereby appro,·f'd . A copy of said A6:rffment i1 auached hereto and incol'1)0rated herein by reference. ~cctjon 2. The Mayor and the City Clerk are hereby a11thoriaed to lien and attest, respecth·ely, the said Acrffment for and on behalfof'the City Council and the City of Eni:lewood. Introduced, read In f\all, ancl paaeecl on ftn& l'Ndinf on the 2ncl day of' 0-mber, 1991 . Publi hed H a Bill f'or an Ordinance on the 8'h day of' Dlamber, 1991. Clyde E . Wii:;ins, Mll)'Or ATTEST : Loutri hia A. Elli1, Deputy City Cler\ I , Lou er! h,a Iii,, Deputy City Clerk of'the C,ty ol Eni:S.v.'OOCI, Colorado. her h. ~rt,(\ th ot the , e and foreco1111 i1 a true top)' ot a B,11 for an Ordinanet>, ,ntrodu~. r nd 1n rull., nd p on lim r ad1n1 on the 2nd day o/ O.C..b.r, l l . .. I· • • , """' ]- - • • • ~ • ' ., SUPPLE11EIIT 110 . ...J.8._ TO COHIIECTOR'S ACREE11EIIT sewer contract llo. ~ TIIJS ACREF.11F.IIT, •ad• and entered lnto by and between the CITY OF F.IICLEWOOD, actinq by and throuqh its duly authorized Mayor and City Clerk, hereinafter referred to as City, and VALLEY SANITATION DISTRICT, Arapahoe county, Colorado, hereinafter referred to as District, WHEREAS, on the lSth day of Novellber, 1914, the City entered into a Connector'• A9ree .. nt with the District concernillCJ th• connection of the District sewer collection facilities to the City'• seva9e syst••, and WHEREAS, said Agree .. nt provided that additional service areas could be included within th• li•its of the District with the written consent of th• Cityr NOii THEltEFOltE, in consideration of the Pr-ls•• and of the autual covenants of the parties hereto, it is .•greed as follows: 1. The City does hereby consent to the inclusion of the additional area described on IXbfblf. 9Dtl hereto into Valley Sanitation District and agrees that said additional area .. y be served with the saver facilities of the District, and that the City will treat the seva9e discharged into the District' sanitary seva9• syst•• and into the City'• tnank line froa .. id additional area, all in accordance vith the Connector'• Agroa .. nt dated Novftlbar U, HH lliatwen the City and the District. AccordintlY, parqrapll 1 of .. id connector'• Agree .. nt ls hereblt aaended to include the additional real property deacrllled on Jsb&b&g 9Dtl hereto. Th• -r• of Hid property are .. njaaln T. Delahay aftd Marlon r. Delahey. J. hcept for the &9r-nts ••t forth in par&9rapll 1 heroinabove, each and every ftller prowlslon of said c-tor'• a.~nt rwlna ••• .. •• and -il- l.ft full force and affoct, and tM ... u1-1 area heroin l11eluded shall Ille ... , .. te au of tM i. .... aftd qreooonts -tained in said ~·• Aofl'IHlftt. IN VITWUI VNPIOF. the partlN hereto ..... caused their na-and saal• to be hereunto o.-oerllled and affbed this day of , 1•--· ATl'DT I c1n or ac:L&MOOD city clerk ay, _____________ ~ ... ,.... ATTUT I YALLIY IAIIITATIOW DHftlCT lec:reterc; ~'----------....... -.......... frulrn ~., .. , II'~ . , • . .. I • • ]- - • • • • . . IQIJIT QQ ProP«rtv P11crlPtlon: Lota 1, z and l, CLOX Subdlvlalon, Arapah-County, Colorado . ' ,. • • I • • 0 • ,- 'I -• • - VALLEY SUPPLEMENT •18 ' • • LOCATION MAP I . • • , - - • Dec:eaber 2, 1991 l•ITIATD a,r llone "'~ • • , . ,, • <. • COUNCIL CONNUNICATION 11 C S119levood water and ...,.r aoard S0uth9ate Sanitation Di•trict Suppl ... nt 1119 Stewart Fonda, Director of Utilitie• Council approwal of louth9ate Sanitation D1etrict 1119 • ...... w A reque•t va• aade by the louth9ate Sanitation Oi•trlct repreaent1119 the owner/ deYeloper for anneaatlon to the Sout"9ate sanitation D1etr1ct. lnclu•lon of th1• land doe• not 1ncrea .. the tap allocation to the louth9ate Sanitation D1atr1ct. •· Suppl-t lllt 1a for an area approalaatelr t.698 acrN. The eaieU119 aon1119 1• a 2.1, a.21 and a.11. b. IA9el1 ... attached &ahiblt a. c. e>vnera, aNa Collpanr c/o Gretc hen Maller. d , P1nanc 1al Detall•• None PIIWICIAL None . ~, .. At t he OCtober 11 , lttl Netlnt , the Water and .... r IIOaN H CI w ....... that the Cltr COUM U a ppl'Off the anM .. tlon o f t he pnpertr dNcru-1 1• hppl-.t IUt to tlle 1cNth9at e 8aft1tat1oa 01at r 1ct, , .. I • • 0 , - • • ORDINA.~CE NO._ SERIES OF 1991 • • • BY AUTHORITY A BILL FOR COUNCIL BILL !\'O. ·s INTRODU~ou:,.;c11. ME.\mER.,.~~----- AN ORDl~ANCE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 119 FOR AN AREA APPROXIMATELY 9 .698 ACRES WHICH IS OWNED BY RHS CO?tf PANY A,-.;O IS LOCATED IN ARAPAHOE COUNTY, COLORADO TO SOUTHGATE SANITATIO:-J DISTRICTS CONNECTOR'S AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF E!l:GLEWOOD TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL LAND WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. WHEREAS, Southpte Sanitation District deairea t.o annex an additional area approximately 9.698 acres located in Arapahoe County int.o ita District; and WHEREAS, said area i1 currently zoned Raaident.ial and •·ill remain Residential ; and WHEREAS, said annexation ofthi1 additional parcel of land will not increase the tap allocation to the Southpt.e Sanitation Di1trict; ~OW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF E:-.;GLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: S,ctj90 1. The Ap9ement between the City ofBnclewood and Southpte Sanitation Di strict entitled "Supplement No. 119 To Connect.or's Apeement"for an am approidmately 9 .698 acres which i1 owned by RHS Company t.o the Soadipte Sanitation Diltrict.'1 Connector"1 Acreement for annexation i1 henby approved. A copy of aaicl Acreement i1 attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. Section 2. The Mayor and the City Clerk are hereby a1&thorized t.o lip and attest. rnpectively, the said A,reement for and on behalf'ofthe City Collncil and &lie City of Ena:lewood . Introduced, read in full, and paued on flnt rNdlnton &lie 2nd day ofO.C.mber~a'ffl: Published II a 8111 for an Ordinance on the 5th day of December, 1911 . ATTEST : Cly .. E. Wigin1, )la) or Loucri hla A. Ellis, 0.puty City Clerk I, Loucri,h ia A. Ellis, 0.puty City Clerk of &lie City of Enclewood, Colorado, htreb • c rt 11\ thot the abo\•e a nd forf101n1 11 a we copy of a Bill f'er an Ordinanoe, 1ntroducecl, r eel 1n full, and pa1Md on nrat rudin1 on the 2nd day ofo.c..ber, lNl . Lol&Crithla A. Elh . ' 11~ ' I. • 0 , ]- 1 • • • • ' .. SOPPLEK[!IT NO. !...!1.. TO CO~"'ll!CTOR'9 AGll!!K!IIT THJI 1'Gll£EKENT, 1',ade and entered into by and betveen the CITY OP tNGLEVOOD, acting by and through it• duly authori&e~ Mayor and City Clerk, hereinafter called the •city," and IOOTIIG>.TI IUIT>.TIOlf DIITRICT, Arapahoe and D0u11la• counties, Colorado, hereinafter' called the •oiatrict,• WITIIElll!TII nnu.1, on th• 20th day of .1une, 19'1, the City and the District entered into an A11ree-nt in which the City a11reed to tc-eat aeva11• ori11lnatln11 fro• the District'• sanitary sever 1yat•• within the area served by the Diatrlct, vhlch A11r•e .. nt vaa aoat recently reneved by connector'• A11r•e .. nt dated Nov .. ber 11, ltlll and naue, aald con:1ector'• A9raa .. nt provide• that the Diatrict .. y not enlar11• it• aervic• area without the vrltten conaent of the CitYI IIOW, TIDIPOal, in conalderatlon of the 911tual covenant• and undertaki"II• herein set forth, the parties a9r•• a• follova1 1. Ttla City hereby conaanta to the inclualon of certain additional area located in Arepah-county, Colorado, owned by na IISI coapaay, a Partaersbip, and aora fully daacribad on Exhibit A attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference, into loutl\vata Sanitation Diatrlct. Th• City a,r .. a that .. id additional area aay be aerved vith the saver facilitl•• of the Di1trlct, and that th• City vill treat th• aeva11• di1char11ed into the city•• trunk llne fr• aaid additional arH, all in a_.ance vith the CoMector•a At~nt dated Novaabar 11, 1111. AccordlntlY, Exhibit A raferr .. to in Par .. raph 1 of the co~or'• A11r-nt dat .. Novea!Mr 11, 1111, la hereby aaen,ed to include 9'ICh additional area. a. lach and every other pro¥lal011 of th• .. id c:.inector'• "9r-nt dat .. llov9allar 11, 1111, Aall r-ia unabaftted. 1• nnaa nD9DI', tM pertl .. Mve Ht their haada and ••ala thia ~-day ef , 1991. Clfi KBi (HALI CHALi Clfl __ _ eonMAn 1a111n•1• •1nun. ~aaoe ua DON&.aa ooan•. COLOUDO -~--- 6' ~ ' ' • - .. • I • • , ]- - • ,. ::. .. . : t. •,•: . . ···:·· _.£ • "~ . ,... • ~ • (, "tX\llllT A" LEGAL DESCRIPTION A TRACT or LAWD, iCJ~O A PORTION or A PARCt:L o, LA~D Al DISCltlltD IN IOCK .,. PAGE SZl or THt orrlCIAL AIIIAPAHOC COU~Tt Mt:COMDS. AND Ut:ING LOCATl:D wn,uM TKt: NOl'TIIEAIT 01'£-0UARTt:~ C)t' THt; r.ORTlft:4ST OtiC•OUAIITtA or SECTION 11, TOWJ.SNll' 5 ,ouTM, IIAt,Ct: U t.'CjT o•· THt; IIXTH PJlltfClt'AL "t:IIIDIAN, CITt Ot' CIIE£N\l00D VILLA.Ct:, COUIITY C't" AllAPAHOt, STATt! or COLCMOO A~D UIINC MORt: PAICTICULAML\' Ut:SUlOt;U AS FOLLOIISa COKl\t:NCING AT THr. t:ORTKCAST C~ltKCll or SAID MORTllt:AST ost:-OUAl'TU ot· Tit£ t:OlTHt:AST ONE-OUAll7Us THENCE, SOUTH u•u•20· ..-nr, ALOHG 1Ht: N:)f.TH Ll"11: OF SAID r:o~THEAST ONE-OUARTU or THr. UOllTHEAST 0~£-0UAATU, ll20.IJ rnr TO TIC£ NOMTHWUT COR:ft:lt OF SAID NORTHEAST ONE•OUAIITER OF THE NOiTNEAST OKC•OUARTtM: TH~NC~, SOUTH 00•01•z4• WEST, ALONO TKI WEST LlNt or IAID NOIITHCAIT O!IC-OUART£K or THE NORTHEAST OltC-~UART£11, ,o.oo PICT, TO TK~ SOUTH lllGHT•OF-WAY OF £,\11' HLLEVIEW AVENUE A!CD TMt: IM POJNT OF IIGJNNJNi or TH£ HtAIIN ocsca11tD TJV.CT1 THtNcr. ~'OITil it*4i 1 Jb' 1¥, AL NG IAIO 50UTN lllCHT-OF•WAY, t)t.lt r~IT TO THt NORTM~E$T COltMER or A T~CT o, LAND AS DtlCaJIED WITlllN oooc 1s,,. PAGE 22J or TNC Arou,n~NTlOKl:D lrCOlDSr TNCHCE, SOUTII 00•01 • u· W£ST, A&.oa:Q THI Wl:IT LINIC or SAID TRACT, t&O.H IUT TO TIIK ICOltTH LINC or Tm: SOUTH OKC-NALF or THI SOUTN ONE-IIALr or SAID NOKTHF.AIT OICt-0\iAITU or TNE NOlTIIEAST ONI-OUAllTEI, TNtNCI, IOUTII at•o•n· WUT, ALO::c • IAID NOllTN LIIIE At DCSCIIIID UI IIOOlt Hit, l'AGr. "' t\F TMC ~,oaCIICNTIOIED RCCOIIDI, Ot.H HIT TO TIii SOUTHU~'TC'Oa:ttR o, TNE lfORTN OKC•NALF or THe IOUTN OIII-NALF or TNC NOlTNWl:IT OICC•OUAlTEll or THC 1-"0ITICtAST OICt-OUAltTCR, or IAID HCTIOfl II: TNl."ttCE. lfOIITlf 00•01 • u· CAST. ALOltG TtlC EAST LUtt: or TIO: fll)lt'ftr,l',:$T OWt-OUARTU or Ttl& NOltTNrAST Oltt-OUUT£1l or IAI U ll~CTION JI AIS uuo I HD 1 N SAID DOOIC Sitt AT PAGE ,u. HO.to nr.T TO Tm: nut: POINT ~·, ltEGINIIING • CONfAINIWG A TOTAL or, •• ,, ACRCI NOii 01 LEIS • • . . ' • I . • , 2 • ' ' -• • • . . (, - SOUTH HOLLY STREET l ; ,~,~ft.~~-12~-u-~ -· · J--~-~;;.--.-~-~~~~=~;_-;;;::;;;:.;::;;;;==-•.n,, t ,, " ,, :.•:;, • o·, ' I a, ---I-z: 5 ...J Q, Q, .. f;: .... I- I I • • .,. ,~~- \ ·1 I : I " I i lli ., .... ii.. .. ~. I!' • I "--' ·- . 1' ·U --... ' •I I ., • '' ~ . 1 } 11 i' ! I ~ •I :11 -i ii ii'~: \J • • - l • • • \ .. • • ,. COUNCIL CONNUNICATION DAD Deeaaber 2, 1991 INITI&m H NSYIOUI COU.C:IL ACTIGa None 11 d S119levood Nater and S-r loard SO\lth9ate Sanitation Diatrict luppl ... nt 1120 Stewart ronda, Diraetor of utilitiea Council approval of 10uth9ate lanltatlon D1atr1ct 1120. A requeat vaa aade by the lollth9ate lanltatioll Dlatrlct repre ... tlnt the own.r/ developer for -•ti-to the lollth9ate laaltatioll Dletdct. Iaoluai-of tbia land doe• not increaH the tap allocatl-to the lollth9ato laaltatl-Dlatrlct. a. luppl-t 1120 la for an area approaiaatelr JI. 7to aone. TIie ealetlnt -1111 1• • 2.1, a.21 and a.11. b. Le9al 1 a .. attached S•hibit a. c . Ovnera1 The PreHr-at GrNMIOOCI Vill .... d. Financial Detail•• None PUIAIICIAL None. At the OCtober 11, lttl ~lnt, the Nater aftd ,-r 8oel'd rH dd tbat tlle Cltr Coul\CIU approve tlle aaMUti-of tlle ,...,.rtr ,._rlN41 l• ..,.,_ IUO to tM louth9ate lanltatl-Dletrlct. . , • ' I • • 0 'a ]- ] • • • BY AUTHORITY ' ,.. II t1,___ ORDINA.'\CE l'\O . _ SERIES OF 1991 COUNCIL BILL :-.o . ii INTRODU~:--Cll. !\1DmER~~....c...~.,._--__ _ A BILL FOR A.'l ORDINANCE APPROVING SUPPLEMENT NO. 120 FOR AN AREA APPROXIMATELY 36.790 ACRES WHICH IS OWNED BY THE PRESERVE AT GREENWOOD VILLAGE WHICH IS LOCATED IN ARAPAHOE COUSTY, COLORADO TO SOUTHGATE SANITATION DISTRICTS CONSECl'OR'S AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL LAND WITHIN THEIR DISTRICT BOUNDARIES. WHEREAS, Southpte Sanitation District desires to annex an additional area approximately 36.790 acres located in Arapahoe COWlty into ill District; and WHEREAS, said area i1 currently zoned Residential and 111;11 remain Residential; nncl WHEREAS, said annexation ofthi1 additional parcel of land -.·ill not increase the top allocation lo the Southcat.e Sanitation District; :-.ow, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUSCIL OF THE CITY Of' E:-.GLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: ~t£liPD l. The Acreement betwNn the City ol EncJey.ood and Southpte Sanitation District entitled "Supplement No . 120 To CoMector'1 Acreement" for an area approximately 36 .i90 acres which i1 o-.-ned by The Preserve Al Greenwood Villqe to the Southpte Sanitation District's Connect.or', Acrffment for annexation it hereby approwd. A copy ol aaid A&:,eement i1 au.ached hereto and incorporated herein by ref'ennce. SecOoo 2 "nle Mayor and the City Clerk an h__, aothoriud to lip and attett., re1pecti,'lly, the uid A,rNlnent for and on blhalf'olthe City Ccluncil and the City of Encle••ood . lntroduted, rud In f\all, and pueed on fin& ,....on the Ind day olDecember~.'991 : • Publi htd II a 8111 for an Ordinance on the 5dl dey oll>ecember, 1991 . Clyde E. Wi111n1, !\la) or ATTEST . Loutrhhi, A. Elli1, Deputy City Clerti I. Lou n h, Ellis, Deputy City Clerk ol the Cil,J el lnclewood, Colorado, he,..t,,, c.. rt ,fy 1h t 11,e bo• e and for 111111 a true copy el a Ball f'w an Onlinanee, introduNCI, r ad ,n rull, And pa on n,n r ad"' on the 2nd day el D•alier, 1Nl. Leumlhla A F.lh . ' • I. • • , I ]- - • • • <, IOPPLl:MEHT HO. /20 TO CONWECTOR'8 AGREICHEHT THI8 AGREEMENT, fflade and entered into by and between the CITY or ENGLEWOOD, acting by and through it• duly authorized Mayor and city Clerk, hereinafter called the •city,• and 80UTMGAT8 81U11TATIOII DllftlCT, Arapahoe and Dou9la1 Countie1, Colorado, hereinafter called th• •ol1trlct," WITll!HITIII nau.1, on the 20th day of .June, 11'1, the Clty and the olltrlct entered into an Agr•e-nt ln vhlch the Clty agreed to treat sewa9e originating froa the Oiatrict'e sanitary aewar aystea within the area served by the Dlatrict, vllich A9rH-nt waa -•t. recently renewed by Connector•• Agree .. nt. dated Noveaber 11, 11111 and nnua, said connector'• A9rH .. nt. providH that t.11• Dhtrict aay not. enlarge it• 1ervlce aria without t!le vrlttan consent of th• CitYI ... nnuoas, in conaideratlon of t.M autual covenant• and undertakift9S herein set forth, the parti•• AIJl'H •• follov11 1. Th• City hereby conMnt• to t!le incluaion of cart.aln additional area located in Arapah" county, Colorado,_.. by n. Pr•••r-.r• at areeav-• Ylllaf•• a colarada ...... al Partaar••l•, and aora fully dascrlbed on Exhibit A attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference, into Southf•t• Sanltat.ion Diatrict. The City 19ra•• t.llat. aald additional area aay bl ••"9d wlth the •-r facUlt.111 of the Diatrict, and that t.M City will t.r .. t the •-If• dildlargod into th• City•• trunk line froa ,aid additional area, all in accordance with the connector'• A9reeaent dated Novallller 11, 1111. Accordingly, llbdllbit A referred te in Par19rapt\ 1 or t.M connector'• A9rH .. nt dated "-bar u, 1111, i• hereby , .. nded te include slldl edditlonal ar ... J. bell and every MMr aw-i•l• of the Nld c-tor•a A91'H .. nt dated NOYellNll' H, 1111, shall ,,_in IIIIClaft99d. 1• anaa ....-., the parti•• haft Mt t.Mir hand• and Mala t.11l• __ day or , 1111. Clff • -•a11 .;. .. --... -. ., . ......... --------------- ATftn'I CIHW (IIALt (HJ.Lt _..,. unnT1• •anasn • ....._ ... NNl-'8 ooawsr. =~---... ----I • • • , 2 I ] • • • • I~ • D::nsIT "~" LIQAL PESCRIPtIQ~ THS PR!GIRVZ: At ORJl~"YOQD YJLLAQX PILI~a EQ, 3 GQDTHOATB PXiIBICr ,,, - .. A psrcel of land located in the North Half of section 18, To~n&hip 5 South, Range 67 We•t of the Sixth Principal Y.eridian, county of Arapahoe, state of Colorado, de•cribed •• follow•: a.;1nnlng at a point on the north line of the South Half of the &outh Half of th• Northeast Quarter of the t.ortheut Quarter (61/2, 81/2, NEl/4, NE1/4)of said Section 18 bein~ l0.00 feat waat of the eaat line of the Northtaat Quarter of aaid Section 11, aa meaaurad at rl9ht 1nqle1, aaid point al•o baln9 on the vest ri9ht-of•way Un• ot South Holly strut, thence s a,•u •,a•• w, alon9 111d north line, a di1tanca of 1290.44 faat to the a11t line of th• Horthve1t Quarter of the North•••t Quarter (~"'K\, NE\) of •aid Section 11, thence N 0•01•20 11 E, along th• af'oreJr.antloned east line, a distance of 880.71 fHt to a point beinq 110.00 fHt aouth of the north Una of th• Northeast Quarter of ••id &action 11, •• :ea1urad at ri9ht angl••r thane• alon~ a curve to th• ri9ht, the tan9ent of vhlch bear• s 0•01 1 20 11 w, havlnq a central an;l• of 31'33 1 00" an4 a radlua of 21,.00 feet, an arc len9th of 111.11 feat to a point of tanqancyr thence s l6'H 1 20 11 w, a dhtanc• of 40.00 feet, thence s 2l'11 1 1l" w, a dlatance of 175,01 f~etr thence s 5J'40 1 0t" W, a distance of 200.00 fHtr thenca S 35'40'09" If, a diltenc• of 1041.00 feet to a point of non•tan9ant curvature on the northerly right-of-way lln• of the Hi9hUne Canal H HtabU1hecS b)' dead recorded on K&y :a,, 1113 in Book 17t at Paga 563, Old Arapahoe County Record•, thane• alont the northerly ancl aaat•rl)' ri9ht•of-V&)' UnH of said Hi9hUna Canal the follovlnq tt.ree ()) cour1111 1) 2) J) alon9 a curve to the rlv?lt, the tan91nt of \thich beara a 17'52 1 0)" •• havift9 a central en9le of o•u•u• ancl a radius of 111.,, feet, an arc length or 1'1,H re-.~.-to a point of tanq1ncy1 1 ·u•n 1 io" a, a dbtance of Ut,02 feet to • point of curvature, alon9 a cur.·• to the rlqht havln9 a ce ntral an9le of 4•31 1 2:,11 and a radlua of 1441,11 feat, an arc len9th of 113.77 fe,tr tht,nc• N 6t'10'C6" s, a dlltance of 220.44 feet, thence N 54'05'12" •, a dlatanc, of 174,16 r,,t, thence N 4J'J7•2,• 1, a dlatanca of 74,62 feet, thence N 11•c1•21• s, • dlatanoa of 161,00 fHtl thence I 74'02 1 41" 1, a dlatanc• of UO,U fHtl thence "11'53 1 11" E, • dlatanc• or 11.12 feet, thence N 74•37•11• I, a dhtance of 11.,2 faetr t.J\enca N u•u•si 11 I:, a dhtance of 101.u fut, t.J\anca " u·u•n11 s, a dbtanca of 104.0S fHtr thane• N 21•21•11" I, a dletance of t5.2S fae\r thence N s2•1s•cs• I, a dletance or 171,11 feet, thence N 74"04 1 07 11 I, a dfatince of 1,.,s fHtl thane• N so•51•n11 z, a dhtenca or 10,06 faetr thence N ,1•aJ 1 15" I, a diatance of 52.71 teetr thence N 11•,,•22• 1, a dletanca of 10.10 feat, thence N ll'IJ'>S• I, a dletanc, or 72.74 Pap I ef J • . ' ' I . • , - - ....... • • "' - . , . • . . .. ( feet, thence 8 1,•a51:;a211 z, a diatanc• o~ 90.40 Ceet, t.henca S 70"12'16 11 E, a dlatancc of 215.81 feet, thane• 8 lt"G7'26" B, a dlatanc• of 114.6> feet to aald w••~ rl9ht-of-~•r line of South Holly strHtr t.hence H o•oa 1 2s11 E, parallel with th• eut Hn• of the Northaa•t Quarter (NE') of aa!d section 11 and alon; Hid WHt ri9ht-of-way Un•, • cU1tanc• of 274. Jt feet to the Point of 119inningr Containin; 36.710 acraa, nor• or 1•••· CJIHUCl!J'.OM 1 •repanll •r• t'rlConaultant•, Jno. • o7un, ao, lttl tTifl l).HO,OI / IZOAU JP/pla UCO••o>.,at P119 I ef 2 :.')-·. -. . , ' ' I . . ' • 0 • -• , . • - - SOUTH HOLLY STREET l • • ,. - 0 N -- I . . . ( ' I. • • , ]- l • • • • • <. SOUTH HOLLY STREET ·ir· :u~~----··-··-. ' ,U ·1.01 OQLJ.Jt. ,.u,, .. ,,L,. .~• - 0 N -.. • . ' I· • - l • • • • ,.. . ,~ • <. COUNCIL COMMUIIICA'l10Jlf Date December 2. 1991 Aeendaltem 11 e llaltject 1992 Contract for Laundry & Dry Cleanmg Services IJlfJ'l'IAffD BY Admtntstrattve Servlcea BT.An' 80URCB 188UB/ AC110Jlf PIIOP08BD Approval of 1992 Laundry and Dry Cleantng Service Contract with gutncy Cleanera. PDVIOU8 COUNCIL ACTION City Council reviewed and approved the Bid Proposal and Agreement for Laundry and Dry Cleanmg for the year 1991. wtth Payleu Cleanera. BT.An' AIIALY818 Blda were sent to eight local vendon and reapomea were received from two (Quincy Cleaners & Kwtk-Way Cleaners) Payleu Cleanaa cbd not aubmtt a bid. Bida were evaluated baaed on estimated quanUtlea for the year and Quincy Cleanen la the lowest bidder. An on alte evaluation wu made and both vendors were conaldered technically acceptable to provide the City with Laundry and Dry Cleaotng Se:rw:ea for the year 1992. Baaed on the overall evaluation we recommend the contract for 1992 be awarded to QuJncy Cleanera. IIACKOROUJIID The 1991 contract for Laundry and Dry Cleaotng exteoaioD year wu exercteed and awarded to Payleu Cleaners which exptra December 3 l, l 99 l. Tbe blda received for 1992 are extended on eaUmated quanUUea cleaned and the yearly tot.ala are u followa: Quincy Cleaners • 833,861 .00 & Kwtk Way Cleaners -839.272.28. PIJUJIICIAL Monlea are available for Laundry and Dry C1eeo9n& 8emce ID tbe approp11te department~ for the year 1992. . , . ' I . • \ ' I , I t "7Ei, A-. ,:,..2 J. .. J .. - A-5 ~ ,.. .:..a S.i 9-2 8,3 1M 8-5 N c;.: Cl C-1 C-<I C 5 C6 C.? Ci Cl c;.,o • . "· • • J :SC::i.?TC"- -·c;.se"" ~ ."l • ~~i S.ec.-e .s~ .-· ,:;,,-;-: S ee.e '" ... :~--~ -'"."l,·t,: -• -, ~&.e«e1. s.--:11 · • -C"' r-' T~• S:,:,t ~ -. ,O~f.... > ... Pan,s :,,..s., °No"ir~ WortS'I '1,-"'yJa.1 91Ma· -OTAl. ·~·· s~.r.. Le-.; s- ~ -~ Sft,n • Shan S--• v.;; Pu,ta C...ie-a.'ls·Cwg~ ar • .;~u· • Feg\;!&r Un:1,r.. =-:::, 5!1 ,, • S'loft S ,eeve ,. s·,.,. S'lo-s··-=-=--, · :,a.i«:ed or-L.,11ee Cap . Ba.; T~;o -:r..AL. -.~~:-OT,;._ C~ C:..:Ar-.i!\G l LA'J 'D~ 3 10 EVJ.LU ATlON O l.,!'.cY Ct.E,4",IERS CR"' ClfA.'11 C 65 095 095 2~ • 40 CIO ;: 95 095 DIS 015 0 15 015 u: OS! Pa2e1 :.J.LI NOR"' 0.65 1 0.85 0 85 i 10 1.10 0 85 0.85 1.60 1.60 0.75 J.VERAGE MO . CUA~TlTY 523 329 321 1 1 2 122 130 122 130 1 1 326 326 734 2 2 75 37 2 4 1 , AVERAGE YR. QUA,-.TITY 6.276 j 3.948 3.!Ma 12 12 24 12 12 1.464 1.560 1.~ 1.560 12 12 3 .912 3 .912 8.808 24 24 90v «4 24 46 12 AVEA.4GE "'R. l COST I 5.33 "4.60 1 3.750 50 21sc sc i zs a:1 'E a,:I 1: 20 : : ~of I I ~r, I S i 2.92340 II 1 ::~4 ,:;; '.48 2 C;l .2£4 . .:::-, i."?2CQ1 5801 11 .:-:1 ss .. e1 Jo I I 3.:?25 .201 3 325.201 7.<~6.ci OI 26'10 26.40 1 76 5.00 1 377.4CI 3& . .1 :-1 1s.ac, 9 .00 1 s, 5 .456.50 I I I I I $33 86 1.:0 I i-i I ..... , .. r I • • 7 '- • I I D~' ;::,.,SAN ,;,G 1 :.>,:J l\1QRY B.:> E\'ALUAilO N ~"'·'"' ••"' ~....,....,,.._r--., --' AVERAGE MO. AVERAGE YR AVEP.AGE Y R. , :Y ""~s :::,=,-c·, A·· --o..s•·· ,:. .. 2 .::--: .. _c·;S,e~-~e -3 -• n · Snort S e.,-.ie ~ • , __ ... w .... -..~ A-5 -~~.-. ... r.-S.-"'!'e · ;_.,o -ii•• o,t-:;•& Tf",A 1,.7 I S:ic-t C:;a• .. & j T .. I I -oTAL e-· ! :>rdl~~ 8-2 C·aaSt--; ~ 1t::rc Pa.-~ 8--! Ylc" S:1 8-5 T1..•,.1.:.· !Mi ,._ I TO"'."AL c , v .... c :;• --~ s-·· C2 No •• Sft:rt • S~!>t" SleiiiVe C,3 W°"'Pa.'* ~ eow.ra::,. ~-ar cs ~ac,o,.: • i=leg\..ar lJ11l .~r.: Cl Po,; Sh ,~. s•on Siee\19 C7 I -. :i,1n · &IOft S1-' I Cl . Col.. &.'ls • :,,. • l.:.d I Cl ' ..K11111 • L Md c,o I ~-Ba.lTy-.,e I -OTAL -=¥'1 ::To-;,._ ' C?.YC..!:.,,. I L.A L,'\'O;:;Y OUANTl'TY QUANTITY COS T I 1 .! I 523 6 .276 7.217 40 ' I 1 •c • 329 3.946 4.540 20 ! I , :s i I 329 3.94o 4.:40 20 1 I 2(.0 1 1 12 2400 ' I 1'51 1 12 17 40 1 , c,c 2 24 24 00 1 I 1 ,s 1 1 12 17 40 I oeo , i 2 9.60 1 I I I S16 .3rO 20 I I ' , 'SI I 122 1.464 1.68360 ! I 1 ·s I 130 1.560 i.7 9.;.oo l I , ·c 122 1.<6 41 1.610 40 1 •ol 130 1.S6C 1.71600 2 o:I I 1 12 2.;c:I u s , 1 12 17 4 0, I se.a.;s.40 ! I I I I I C.69 326 3.912 3.43 1 66 1 0.69 326 3 .9121 3.48'. 58 I 0.69 734 8 .808 7.639 .~2 , 1 25 2 24 , J O.CO 1'5 2 :I 348CI 0.75 75 675 CO 0 .75 37 333.00 1 I 2.35 2 24 56 .40 I 2.00, 4 48 96 .00 I 075 1 12 9.001 ' I I $16.036.56 I I I I S39 .272.28 I i ,· I . r • 7 ~ .... ~ Page l • , .._ . \ ; ~ 0 • - Date December 2, 1991 • • • '· COUNCIL COIDllJllflCAflON 4&endaltem II r 8ubject Contract ror Non-emergency, Police and Ftre Uniform• DlfflATBD BY Administrative Services BT.An' 80URCS Randle Barthlome, Director or AdmtnSatrattve Services 188US/ AC1101f PROPOIISD The acUon propoaed ta to approve Non-Emergency, Police and Ftre Uniform• for 1992 to be supplied bu ~m·• Un!fbfm•. Inc. ["Nt;EV '~) PRSVIOU8 COVllaL AC110lf City Council revlewtid and approved the Bid Propoeal and ~ent for Non-Emerpnc:y, Police and Fire Uniform• for the year 1991 wtth Neve'• Unlf'orma, Inc. BT.An' AIIAL~ Bid packages were aent to aeven vendon (one or which .... an En&lewood Vendor.) Reaponaea were received hm three vendon (one ~ whk:b wu a 9No Bkr. The Enatewood vendor did not respond. Technically acceptable blda were received ft'om Neve'• Unlfonna, Inc. and Tuxall Uniform• and Equipment, Inc. Neve'a Unlf'orma, Inc. hu performed well for the City In 1990 and 1991. Baaed on the overall evaluation we recommend the contract for 1992 be awarded to Neve'• Uniform•. Inc. The 1991 contract for Non-Emergency. Pobc:e and Fire U........ extalalon year wu rmdlled and awarded to Neve'a Uniform•. Inc. and expua Decmlbu 31. 1991. The blda rece.lYed for 1992 are extended on eatlmated quanUUea purc:haaed and the yearly totala are aa followa: Neve·• Uniform•. Inc.· 878,689.756 Tuxall Unlfonn• and Equipment, Inc .• 881.090.30. Monlea re avail ble for Non,£mtt1tncy, PoUce and Fire Unaforma ln the appropriate d~partmmt buctcet.1 for the year 1992 . ... ' ' • . .. I . • 0 J - • • a. A me.nc. ~. l. 1- s. • " - • ~ " • < 8 ID PROPOSAL~ TABULATION A Date Opened __ 11 /'7 /91 I . I Item ($) O• )I fi:, c oo C o ·,,6:iru:t T,i..l J/o 8,J.: "· ~---·------... ------t-------;i------+------i 1. 8. h.__ ______ ~ ____________ 1 ..... · ----, ' • I ... ' .. I . • 0 ]- • • r • · ... • "· ... .. I, Loucri1hia A. Elli,, Deputy City Clerk for the City or Enclewood, Colorado, hereby certify the above i1 a true copy ofRnolution No.---• Seriea of 1991. Loucriahia A. Elli, 2 . , .. I. • , I - - • • RESOLUTION NO . 1/;; SERIES OF 1991 .. • • • 11 g V A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR POLICE DIVISION MANAGERIAL AND SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES OP THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992 . WHEREAS, by Charter amendment efl'ective April 13, 1981, City Council provided for the e1tabli1hment of manaprial emplo,Ma within the Nrvica of the City of En1lewood; and WHEREAS, by virtue of IIWlq8rial dutin uafped to th-positions by Ula City M11na1er, it haa been determined that they an manaprial and therefore excluded from membership, participation, or repnN11tation in any collectively barpined employN system of the City of Enpwood Police Division; and WHEREAS, under the Compenaation and Beneftta Plan for Police Division manai:erial and supervisory employees, Citr Council dnin1 t.o 81tablith Ula pay rates and insurance rates for Ula year 1912; NOW, THEREFORE, BB IT RESOLVED BY THB CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: Std,jpn 1 The pay for mana,mal and supervisory emplOJMI of tha City of En1lewood Police Division for Ula calendar year lffl shall lncreaN by K. Scc&iAD 2 The City will pay U. per month oftha pnnalum COit for dependent and 1in1:le coverap. Employees will pay 1ft of tha monthly pnlllium cot& for tins!• and dependent coverap. The COila t.o be paid bJ ulcl emp..,... for haalUI and dental in1urance coverap shall be u follows : City Sc1C·r»o4t4 · Nedkal · 121 .95 /month for sincle coverap . S64 .98/month for family coverap. Camerccere · 119.37/month for 1insl• coverap. $M .9~month for family coverap. CilY Stlf·fvo414 .. PID&el · 13 15 /month for linale coverap. 19 75/month for family co-. . ADOPTED AND APPROVED thl1 2nd day of Dec1111ber, 1•1. ATTF., T · Cly41 B. Wlaint, Mn)·or Lout:ri h1a A. Ellie, Deputy City Clerll ., _ , I • • I . ' . • 0 , ? 1- - • • .. · ... • '. ' <. I, Loucri1hia A. Elli,, Deputy City Clerk for the City al En,lewood, Colorado, hereby certify the above i1 a true copy alJINolution No. __ , Sarin al 1991 . Loucriahia A. Elli• 2 " -, ,.. • . , ~ ' .. • I. • I ]- • • RESOLUTION NO . 82:- SERIES OF 1991 . ' (. • • I• • 11 g iv A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR FIRE DIVISION MANAGERIAL AND SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992. WHEREAS, by Charter amendment efl'ectifl April 13, 1981, City Council provided for the e1tabli1hment of manaprial employNt within lhe Nrviee of lhe City or Enclewood; and WHEREAS, by virtue of........,W dutiea .......... to 111 ... polition1 by lhe City Manapr, it hu been cletarmined that they .,. manaprial and lhenlon excluded f'tom membership, participation, or ...,......tatiea in MY eollec&iwly barpined employ• system of lhe City of En,leweod PIN Division; and WHEREAS, under Iha Coap1nutien and lleneftta Plan fer Fire Division manaprial and supervisory emph,.., Cit, Council ..._ ta ll&allliah Iha pay ram and inauranee ram for Iha year 1112; NOW, THEREFORE, BB rr USOLVBD BY THB CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: Sec&ifMI 1 The pay for iuftllllrial and -,.maory employeaa of the City of En1lewood Fire Diviaion for lhe ca_._ year lttl lhall incnue by ft. Seaiea 2 The City will pay .. ,-_.di lftlla,...... eel& r. ••p1ndent and sine'• coverqe. Employftl will pay 1K lflhe ..ehly ...--eel& ror lifllle and clepanclent coverap. The eeala ta be ,-1 by ..W eaph, ... r. heahh and dental insurance coverap ahall be • ...._.: Cjt.y a,11.r,,n4eet · Neftiel· S2l.N hnonlh for •• ......... 164 .Nlwlh for tuaily ....... Ceeemen· 119.37/lnonlh for liftlle ...,.._. IM.t61-nlh for laaily ., ....... Citx Sell·FModed · Desai · 13.15 /monlh for lifllle cove,..-. 19.76/monlh for fa"'ily.......,.. ADOPTED AND APPROVED this Ind day of l>ecefflber, ltll. ,\TTF. T Loucri hie A !Iha, Deputy City C1erll "' - • ' I . • • , 2 ]- • • • • .. I, Loucriahia A. Ellia, Deputy City Clerk for the City of Enclewood, Colorado, hereby certify the above ia a true copy ofRnolution No._, Seriea of 1991 . Loucriahia A. Ellia 2 ,,_ . , • ' • I. • • , ]- • • . ~ • '. 11 g 111 RESOLUTION NO. iL SERIF.8 OF 1991 A. RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR GENERAL SERVICES MANAGERIAL AND SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES or THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THE YEAR 1992 . WHEREAS, by Charter amendment efl'ectiw April 13, 1981, City Council provided for the Htabliahment o( maneprial employeea within the Nrvice of the City of Enslewood; and WHEREAS, by virtue ti manaprial du&iN Ulipecl to theN poeitiona by the City Man ... ,, it hu bNn determined that the, are ........,W and thenlon ucluded from -mbenhip, perticipation, or ....,.....tatioa in any eollectiwly barpined employ• aylUffl ti the City of Enpwood; and WHEUAS, qndar the CoalpeMatioa _. BIIMftta "-f'er General Service maneprial and aupervieory empl1, .... Ci9 Ceacil daairel to ea&ablilh the pay rain and inaurallff rat.. f'or the year lltl; NOW, THEREFORE, BB IT D80LVBD BY THS CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY or ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: Sec&iPD 1 The pey f'or ............ and -,.rvleory ....,ao, .. , tithe City of Enclewood f'or the calendar year 1111 lhall incrNN by ft. 8ec&HMl a The City will pay .... -· If the,._.. col& f'or dependent and 1incl• coverap. EmployNI will pay 1" If the -•'1 ~ col& f'or aincl• and dapenclent covenp. The COlta to lie put by .W ..,a., .. 1w health and dental inauranco rovenp lhall lie u ...._.: Ci&r SttH'vnded · Nedke!· 121.16 hnonth f'or ...... ...,.,.... SIU81month f'or f'aaily eeftNIII. Comencen · I 19 .37/month f'or •• ...,.... 1$4.15/month f'or f'aaily .....-. Citx Stll·hnded · Qeetel · 13.16 lmonth f'er •"lie..,.,.... It. 75/month f'or f'a•lly ..,.._ ADOPTED AND APPIOYSD &Ml W.., 11Dm••u, lNl. TTE T . , ' - • I . • t ~ I • "~ -.. • . • ' (. - I, Loucri1hia A. Elli1, Deputy City Clerk for the City of Englewood, Colorado, hereby certify the above i1 a true copy ofRnolution No . ___ , Seriea of 1991. Loucrilhia A. Elli1 I. • • 2 , I ]- • ,. - • • (. 11 I ii RESOLUTION NO . .ai SERIES OF 1991 A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPENSATION PLAN FOR CONFIDENTIAL EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD FOR THB YEAR 1992. WHEREAS, by Charter amendment eff'eetive April 13, 1981, City Council provided for the eatablilhment of confidential employNI within the Mrvice of the City of En1lewoocl; and WHEREAS, by virtue ofmanqllrial duties auiped to th .. poeitiona by the City Manapr, it haa been determined that they .,. eonflcllntial and thenf'ore eacluded from membership, participation, or repraNDtation in any eolleetively berpined employN 1y1te111 of the City of En,lewood; and WHEREAS, under the Coapenutien and BIMftta Plan f'or confidential employeea, City Council dnina to eaubliah the pay rat.I and inaurance rat.al for the yur 1992; NOW, THERBJl'ORB, Bl IT RBSOLVED BY THB cm COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ENGLEWOOD, COLORADO, THAT: Secticm l The pay for confidential employeee of the City of Bnslewood for the calendar year 1992 lhall innu• by ft. SectiAo 2, The City will pay_. par -th of the pNIDio• col& for dependent and 1in8'• cove,.... Employeea will pay lK of the -thly pnaiua col& for line!• and dependent cover .... The -at t.o be paid by uid emplo,-. for health and clafttal inaurance coverap lhall bl u follows: Ci\r 8eK·hDde4 · Nedkfll· 121.95 /month for ainp .,.,..._ NC.Ill/month for fa•ily ..,.,.... Comencen · Sll.37/month for ainp eownp. S54 .~th for family eeverlll'9. Citx lell·fvoded · Oen&et · 13. ll/laonth for aiftlle eevenp. St. 76/month for faally co,,enp. ADOPTED AND APPROVED thla Ind day .roeca ... lNl . ATTE ST Loucnahia A 1 1111, Deputy Cit, Cllrll ' • I ' • .. .. I. • • , I - . I ·.) • • • . . • 11 g i RESOLUTION NO . ~ SERIES OF 1991 A RESOLUTION APPROVING A COMPBNSATION PLAN FOR PERMANENT, PART- TIMB BMPLOYEBS OF THB CITY OP IENOLBWOOD FOR THB YBAR 1992. WHBRBAS, ii hu been ............ that ,........t. put.time employ ... olthe City ot Eftllewood lhall be allowed to participete in the health encl clantal in1unnce procram, oft'e...cl by the City ot Enpwoocl; encl WHBRBAS, penunml pan-time ..,ao,w are cllftnecl to be thw workin1 an ave,... otto or more houn per welk .._. a 11.-.. period with no break in Mrvice; ancl WHBRBAS. the City Coaneil .._ ta lllallUIII die PQ ...._ encl inaurance rata f'or h•kh ucl cllntal i .................... lltl; NOW, TIRUFOU, BB ff UIOLVSD ft THS CITY COUNCIL OP THE CITY OPENGLEWOOD,COLORADO,THAT: 8ectien l 'nle pay for permanent. pan-ti .. ..,.., .. ot the City ot En,ttwood for tht calenclar ,-, 1992 lhall incnue by K. 8ectien & 'nle total ,._.iwn preml11111 eom to be paicl by alcl emplo,-1 for hNlth ancl dental lnaurance ahall be • fttllowa: Cv ltK·h ... · Ned"'1 · SM .llllaonlh....,. ............. ................ ,-o, ........ Qty lel(.r,, .... Pense!· Sll.07/aonlh....,. ..... ....,.... uu, ........ ....,.,....,....,.... ADOPTSD AND APPltOYSD dm W .., ,ID1 I •• , llll. AffllT : Llucriahla A IIHI. .,.._., a.. C'-' ------ I, lacrilhia A. ... 0..... at, a.. .... ae, .,..., ...... c..-. ._.,....,,._.._.ila1Na...,,ll111D SI Na, ..... .tlllL L1mi1t:1A.llil . ' ' I. • - • • • "~ • ,.. . • ' <. Tbe Qty of Englewood, by Cbllrter Amemment. podded for the eatabllabmeDt of -=••sr1al and confidential emp1ayeee wltbln the eemce of the City. 1beae e,n.,...,_ are excluded from aepreeentatkm ID -. callectlvely barplDed .,.um. Tbe Council, tba'efore, appiOUS by reaoluUOll a 0Ji11pematl0a and Beodlla Pim tar tbeee employeea. .. 111 IICCClldlmce with the bud8et pepalltlall tar 1982, tbe po,poaed pay mcr11•11 were tncarparatecl Into the pl-opoeed IJudlet. l•n•H 1D tbe bale..,. are • falloa: , I 1981 BMeW ... ~ 1Dcr11•e Total • llla'e•e l"lre Msn41 oent $348.117.20 ft •10,sas.u *538,384.18 ft •1e,1ao.N •1,al.lS?.M -tll,071.1S Oi:IIIMmtl b *567,419.N -•ae.a...ae NOl.141.20 -•12.117.M TOal, •110,1e1.11 . , • . . • I . • , ~ I • • • Date December 2. 1991 • . , . • COVIICO. COIIIIVIIICA1101' Al•--•tea 11 g 8altject Reaolutlona Eatabllabtnl 1992 Compenaatlon Plana Department of MrntntstraUYe Sentcee Randle L. Bartblome, Director of MrntnwtraUYe Sentcee ... US/ AC'IIOII l'llOPOll&D ,, - Approval of reeolutlom eatablllblnl a campemaUml plan b: General Serw,ee ..,.n...,... and aupervlloly employeea: Pobce DMllon me.,.,.. and aupervlllary employeee; Fire Dlvlalon :nensaimai and aupervtaary ~: con8dentlal employeee: permanent. part-time employeea. Coundl, each year, appovea by reeolutloa compenutloa and bendl1a fcJr tbe above pupa. ffAn' MAl.ftl8 A pay lncreW of 3~ per annum w bdnC P'opoeed far each of tbe ...,..... Tim caat- of-lMn& tncrew w comparable to OCber tncre•n far wc,upa ,e .. eaented by barp1D1n1 units -3~ for Enfewaod Emphyeea Aaeodation: 3 .21' far Eztlewcod Pobce Bendt ANoctauon (tmtattvet: and a net tncre•e of2.84~ far Eztlewcall P"lrelCbten Aaeodatloa. The pll)'lllmta far dmtal IDlur1mce and CGmprecare far 1992 remain the aame • for 1181 . Tbere baa been a decre•e of 5~ In tbe City lnaunnce premlWn for 1992. The -,,pt,yeea· all.Ire far .... covenee baa decre•ed from 823.10 to t21 .85. Far depe.-t CCMl'IIIB · tbe ......,,_ •• all.Ire baa decrewd from 888.40 to 884.98. ..... .... •. •· • I - • • • " . • ' <. 1'. City of Englewood 11111 ..... c-.11 ...... M IMl9 .... ...., c.-1 ...... DIIIIIIII • ............... c.-1 ...... M IMl9 a.-V..IJWl!e c.-1 ...... DIIIIIIII I Kalla ...... c.-1 ...... MIMl9 .. ......... • eJ I f Oillll* ........ LE'n'Ek OF APPOIN'IMENT WHEREAS, Tim Bullock has resigned from the Englewood Urban Renewal Authority and his t.erm will nol expire unlit February 5, 1995; and WHEREAS, il is the authority of the Mayor lo appoint members of lhe Englewood Urban Renewal Aulhorily; NOW THEREFORE I Clyde E. Wigins, Mayor oflhe Ci Ly of Englewood, Colorado do hereby appoint Kells Wagoner lo serve an unexpired lerm on the Urban Renewal Board, aaid t.erm shall expire on February &, 199&. . . I"~ . , ' ,,; I . • • • - - • Alexandra Habenicht 515 W. Tufts Avenue Englewood, CO 80110 • • • .. Arvada counc1lwoman. o,srncr •3 5645 Dudley Street Arvada . Colorado 80002 Phone 422· 1013 or 424-5664 November 25, 1991 ,. " Dear Alex, Congratulations on your re-election as aeaber-at-large oC the Englewood City Council. The citizens of Englewood are fortunate to have such a hard working, dedicated person such as you serving on their council. I a• pleased to infor• you that the Executive Board 0£ CoWiag aet this aorning and voted to give you a scholarship to attend the Nationol league o[ Cities 1991 Congress o[ Cities in Las Vegas, Nevada in o~ccaber, in the oaount oC $300.00. We were sorry that we could not fund the total aaount Cor you, but our budget would not allow that auch o[ an e1penditure. Hope(ully, in the coaing years we would be able to do auch aore for outstanding woaen to attend these con(erences when their cities are unable to afford to send thea. It la truly a loa• (or the entire State of Colorado when qualified p~ople are prevented fro• attending these aeetings a nd r preaenti•I the beat intereata of their co n tituency. Alex, I hope you can rai a the re t of the aoney to attend. Engl wood will ur ly be l oser if ou c nnot atl nd. I will be looking {orward to a e1n1 you n Laa V 1••· H. And r on -- II -. • ' ' , . .. I • • • • • - • • I I I I ) I U'° I • • • The Brief Times Reporter Cite as: 15 Briel Times Reporter 1437 (Colo. 1 [)91) No. 90SC433 Uch:011 Bock and Patricia Lawless-A11t:lar, Petitioners, v. Wettmlnster Mall Company, Respondent. Decided October 7, 1991 Certiorari to the Colorado Court ol Appeals Tim Atkeson. Arnold & Porter; David H. Miller, American Civ~ Liberties Union, tor Petitioners. James L. Aab; Elizabeth DriU Nay, Robert Steven Caldwell, Lewis, Rice & Fingersh, tor Respondent EN BANC JUSTICE MUUAAKEY delivered the Opinion ol the Court We cran1L'd ~rtiorari 10 rc"i~· Bock y Wqamiollct MllliA, 797 P .2d 797 (Colo. Arr, 1990), in whld11hccoun or appeal held 1ha1 indi,idual mcmbcn or "The Plcd&e or Rcsls11ncc· did no1 ha"c I pro1«1cd ri&hl 10 dis1rlt>u1e leaOctJ in &he rommon areas or \\'e51mins1er Mall ("Mall"), • prha1cly.()11111Cd CIOfflmcrcial and mail ttn1cr. 111c: iuue here Is : ·w11e111c, Ankle 11. s«tlon 10 of 1hc Colorado on,1hu1ion pf nt the prl,ate o•ncr or an endoled II ppin& m:,11 from c,dudin& chi,cM cnpp In n,,n , i I n1 I'<''" al rc«h rr m 1he romm n ar~ r 1hcm:a11 r 1 For the rca50M 1a1cd Mlow, •e rC\ene lhc judp1Cnl r ,11~ un or appeal . Wnhin the puhhc JIIICC1 or 111c Mall, Ankle II, s«tion 10 prot«I pcli1lofler1' rlpu to d111nbu1e ro&n I ~1r1r111c1 and "' Mlllci1 i.11111wm rk'dJin 1101Miok111 d 111 fmm 111e fcJcr.al r11mc111'1 r r 1e11 rot..: 1 arlJ ,·nu.11 Amen( I informalion and to i.olici1 1ipa1ura from Ille public as denied by respondent. Follollin& dilCO\-ery, thc panics filed crou-mo1iotK ror summary judpneat. 111c district coun denied pc1l1iown' motion and panlcd rapoodcnt'I motion. After •e denied • pctltloll t'or writ ol certiorari ulldtr C.A.R. ,0, the coun of appals affirmed tlle distrln coun', judpnan. We lllen paalCld certiorari pwr1u:111 to C.A.R.49. T1lc Mall Is I rcponal sllopp6., ttnter. 11, pri1r11ry seoc,apbk ICl\icc 10IIC ls IOI 1111.iled IO the Cily of We11min 1er {"Clty1 1'111 Includes numcrOU1 Dcll\'Cr ,ubllrbs and mends lo Boulder, Colorado. T1lc Mall ls one of1•osudlcntcnaadlocedbyfhcllrFdepan-1,tora in Ille Den,.:, IIIClropolil .. IIU, •• ldclitioll 10 the rl\'C alldlor stores, 111ou1 I JO OIiier mall alld ICl\ice atabh1llrncn11 arc tenant of 1111 Mall, lnctudi•a I fil• 111c11rc. Since an Hf'IIINOII • 1916, tlle Mall.,,...... O'fl appN)\lrnatcly 111 1CTC1, lnctwllli., puld .. fol aore lllaa b ca~ The 111111 Mall ar , rou111i111 &he anc r IHI,; , I I.al mor.: 1han I '4111:tre r«t Of'"' I I I, 1 ia.~ Mfu.m: r,-c:1 rompo..c 1lle M.all 's , rnmot1 arc;a Thc:M: nlduft Ind COMVWnn lkll oaly fac11itatc Ille n.-,. I f lh.: .,,., ... ,., nd ·,11 .. II) na rut>l11; t>ut .~, ''"" (11 u n 1,11n • rl.iftl ful1.1Jt, IIW tin& Ii r Ilk' r D\,;n TIit M.a1r, Wfflllltll a, a, OflCll ~ 111e F"""' rut>I' 1111t1liluul CUrft, llld IIO pw,dlalc • lle(ftUIJ IO Ctll r or nit tlllc ~laU. '111 opca IO Ille Mall p,offttd ) MO.lld, klweff I IIMft of 10. a .... 9ft) pa , ... ., ' I • • • .• , , - • • . ·! • • ,,_ • • .. .. The Brief Times Reporter MonJay 1hrough SalurJay, :inJ hc1wccn noon anJ 6 :00 p.m. on Sundays. These public hours arc c,lcndcJ during more r1ofilable ~hopping sca~ons, such as Chri~lmas. In years pa~,. rclail ~aks in the ~!:ill h:m: acc.:iu:i:cJ for more 1han 1cn pc1ccnt of such sales i:11hc City. Rcgu!Jting the use of 1hc Mall's common uc:,~ i~ "'hat 1he Company has called a "no solicita1ion" policy. Wilh it.is polky, 1he Company purporls suictly 10 prohihit contro\·e~ial or poli1ical acti\·itics, the Jistribution of leancts and hanJbills, and/or solicitation of any kind. Petitionen sought but were denied permission to distribute political leaflets within the common areas of 1hc Mall. The Company relics on the City's trespass ordinance to enforce its policy. In practice, however, the policy has not b:mcd a variety of public entitles and private groups from ta kin& advantaec of the common arcu to communicate their messages. On the contrary, the Company has spent several thousand dollan each year to promote these activities. The Jefferson County Oerk has sponso~ mtcr rc&istration dri\-CS in the Mall's common areas. The Company bas all~'Cd a salute to the armed forccs, 11.ith accepted displays of equipment and literlturc by various armed forces agencies. Reprcsenlatl\'CS of these agencies 11.-ere permitted to answer questions from the public and to pro\·idc them other information. There bas also been a f.:llutc to the prcsldenll of the United States, 11oi1h a display of praidcntlal por1rai11 and information l\a1l1blc to all. Art bu been exh ibited in the comm n areas, and dance has been uaged there u 11.-ell. Community bauan hl\-C been permitted. The Boy Scouts and the Girl Scouts u d the Mall for acti\itics includin& cookie Jalc$. 111c Sal\-ation Anrry •-al permiucd to M>licit funds in the Mall. Tlltrc arc hnks lltt•ttn the Company and IC\-eral eo-unmental e11111 and public monies . TIie City opuat r nt-fr«, a pohc:ic IUNUlion with a desk and a holJ11111rea 111 Ille ~II Froa this 111bl1a1lon, Ciiy policlO t I 1, r f •l"'nd 10 rllint 011cina1Jn1 an).,.·herc in the 11:,. The ~ II c urs :1 pom:ncn1 location in the City I) I IJ'I llhl ui;h the ',1m ~ny l mrlo) I r,1 •tC Ullt) M'I' C, tY.0 h) four ity police om.: ·n p:ur I the ~1111 durin& puMic houn. In addition, C\?llliUlr Un.I draiu,e imptl>' IIICIII \'alucd II O\Crl-0 m,11 11 dolb,s ,.c,c 111"11 by Ille 11y frotn Ille O>nlpuy . 'I'll purlhaJc,. ft11111CM llfldc:f Ille l)''l lloM IUti.ority II. that in\·ol\"cd in this c;isc, occurics a preferred posilion in this country and this state. A Concurring in WhjJncy v Ctlifornj:, 27-4 U.S. 357,375 (1927),2 Ju~licc BrJndcis wrote a most eloquent defense of the freedom or speech and press: "Those who won our independence ... believed that freedom to think as you will and 10 speak as )'OU think arc means indispensable to the disco\·cry and spread or political uuth; ... 1ba1 the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people; that public discussion is a political duly; and that this should be I fundamental principle of the American GO\'Crnment." The role of rrcc speech was re-emphasized in MmJl.Y. Alablml. 326 U.S. SOI (19-16), where the United States Supreme Court held that • 1111c could not punish a person ror distributing religious pamphlets on the lidcwalk of a company town contrary to the company·, regulations. In striking the balance with other constitu1lo111l ri&hll, the Minh Court was unequlW>Cal: "When 11.-c balance the Constitutional ri&hll of ownen or property against those of the people to enjoy rrecc1om of prcu and religion, as we must here, we remain mindful of the ract tba1 1he laucr occupy a preferred position." Mmll. 326 U .S.11 S09. TIie rip1 to speak and to publish under the Finl Amendment, prevailinf In Maull and other Uailed Slates Supmnc Court c:aa, bas been similarly preferred by this rourt. B. In Psoplcy YIIIND lllColo.«),49,514P.2d 1318, 1323 (197)), we declared u11COM1i1utioaal a 11atu1e crirniulida& Ille alllllatioa, ddace••• or clcftlcmCllt of Ille Aacnca• llai-TIie llatc'I l•tcnlll la praavi. the ,ya1,o11 of ckraonKy ~ MIUIII die appn,pnate 11•111 of dislclll, •llllc 11ndalialtly iaportNC, were a..ffldalt 10 PfCIC""C Ille 1111 ... ,. ...... of die pmerlN paaltioll of frccdoffl of lpeedl I• tlle United SU. eo.&ltlldoa. • J1L TIiis ii iO C\"Cft thollp Ille Fiffl Aaaldanlt ii fnaed IOkly lntllcncp1i\t: noaa.,11aUbcinadc1bridpa1111cfrudom " (ll: l 'I ,·r. r rr, " In nua,1, ArtK"lc II, Scaiorl 10 of Ille Colorado Con$11lu1ion aclvl.a lle)IOlld tlle ncpdvc a>aaand of ill flffl daUIC IO 1111b u 1ffln111iYe dedaratloll ia tlle sec:oed c1n1e. no ~ tc111 of ow r.ee 1peec11 anlcle 11 11 foloM: .. I • • • •' , ]- • • .. • • • '· The UricfTimcs l(eporter poli1i,al power, and st·curc 10 lhc w hok people a full and free discussion of puMic affairs·· (quo1ing C!'l'rc r v Peer•.:. 13 Colo. 337,362, 22 P. 790, 798 (ISS9)). Thus, 1hc scrnnd clause of Ankle II, Scc1i o n 10 o f the o,t,,radu ConMilulion ncn·ssarily enhances the already rrc fcrrcJ position or speech unJer 1he Firsl ,\mcndrnen1 of the United Slates Conslitution. Ill. Consistent with 1hc Uni led Stales Cons1i1u1ion, we may rind 1hat our s1a1c cons1i1u1ion guaran1ecs grca1er protections or pe1i1ioners' rights or speech 1han is guaranteed by the First Amendment. The Uni1ed Stales Supreme Coun's First Amendment jurisprudence on 1hc scope or free speech in 1hc race or privale power has had a ra1hcr 1onuous his1ory, wi1h speech In nominally pri,-a1e spaces at 01'51 accorded protection, food Emp~ y I-OPP Y•Jley Pbn 391 U .S. 308 (1968), then eclipsed in LJQ)'d Corp. y. Tanner 407 U .S. SSI (1972), and finally surrcrin& a rejection In Hydp:ns y NJ RB 424 U .S. S07 (1976). Respondent urges us to ro11ow the 111-ists and 1urns of 1his rcderal roaJ to 1he end and deny petitioners' daims. We decline. We arc unpersuaded by the United States Supreme Court's various rcasonlnp In this line or cases, especially wllc,1 gi\-cn an invitation by that Court in a ubscqucn1 asc, PruneYard Shopplo& (.:01cr v Rollin, 447 U .S. 74 {1980), treated llclow, to forse our Ol>'ft path. The federal Jbou1-raa: w:as, 1hcrdore, no11he United States Supreme Court's la 1 11-'0rd on free spcccll in 1he se\'cral 1a1e . 111c delinili\'e 11-'0rd 11-as lcR 10 Ille state COU!IS 10 write. A. . .. • pri,atc shopping crn1cr owner h> pr,wi<.lc a-ccss to persons ucrcising 1hcir cons1i1u1ional righ1s of free sprcch and pc1i1ion "hen alternative avrnuesorcommunica1ion (were( avail:.t,k." -t-t7 U .S. al SO. This means 1ha1, by i1s rnnsti1u1ion, a slate may afforJ indi\'iduals 1hc right of ~p<·cch and pc1i1ion in commercial and rclail ccn1ers otherwise pri\'alclyowncd. The First Amendment isa floor, guaranteeing a high minimum off rec speech, while our own Article II, Section 10 isthc"applicable law• undcrw·hich 1he freedom or ~pecch in Colorado is runhcr guaranteed. PryneYard 447 u.s. at 81. B. Colorado's 1radi1ion of emurin& a broader liberty of speech is long. For more 1han a cicntury, this Court has hekl 1ha1 Aniclc II, Sccllon 10 p!O\ides pcater protection or rrce speech lhan docs the First Amendment. li&:11 ~ fmd. 773 P.2d IOS9(Colo.1989): Pacrisb y J.amm 7S8 P.2d IJS6, 136S (Colo. 1988): People y Seyrn JbllLY·ElYe f,51 ColfA Jnc, 697 P.2d 341. 3S6 (Colo. 1985): People y Bu#l, ISS Colo. SS, S2 I P.2d 1244 (1974); Jg Re Hqrinp C.000:co,01 Oooo ,~ 132 Colo. S91, 296 P.2d "6S (19S6); Coopcry Pmple 13Colo.337.22P. i90(1889). Earlier In this opinion, 11-'C noted ~"s rccopilion ur the dual 1uaran1cc In Article II, Section 10. 'That early 111emcn1 or principle, contained in an opinion iuucd 11-i1hln a rcw )cars aRer 1hc Colorado Constitution -..u adopted and while Its draRin& 11-111 a IMn1 memory, Is pcrsuask-c evidence of 1hc Intended broad scope or Article II, Section 10. In C,-,~ Nncernin& a blanket c,~1llliotl or pras photopapllcrs rrom the munroom, rcferc11tt1 10 1he First and Fourteenth Amendment -..-ere om111cd ·ror the reason 11111 Ille provision !Art. II, Sec. IOI o r our Cok>fldo Cou1i1111ioll ii 1110rC lndlllk'C In 111 ell' ·nee of 1he subjca and Is eqully blnclln1 upon u .• 1.32 ~,lo. at S9Z. 296 P.ld 11 *-67. In Bala. mhin& a COll\1Ctioll for prolllOlioll of «*cene -tcria&I la ,iola1ioll of I IIIC WIIIIC, 'A'C MJd tllal! >--0 11-t m~ 0114 not Ollly 11111 the ol>sttnlty 111ndank n( 111c 1,1111e, .a '" trued ulld« the Ar,.i Amtfldm :it. are 14 . ' I • • 0 • , - - • • • • • . . The Brief Times l<c1>?rkr_ .. -----I IV . Petitioners argue that Allicle II. Section 10 of our constitution guarantees fri.:c speech r.ot only as ag:iinst <1atc or governmental action hut also as again~! ce11ain e~crci<~s of private power. Rc~pondcnts on the other hand argue that the second clause or Section 10 is limited by the fim dau~c and both apply only to direct state action which infringes an individual's right to speak or puhli~h. TIie facts or the case here. however, belie this simplistic division or the uni,·enc into public and private spheres. Indeed, one consequence or the larger measure or protection conferred on specch by our state constitution is the judicial recognition or the impact on constitutional liberties by the many h)·brid forms or poernmental in,'01\-ement and/or by priv:11e interests performing the equivalent or public functions. Where p-cmrncntal entities or public monies arc shOll'R by the racts to subsidize, approw: or, or encourage private interests and such private interests happen also to restrict the liberty 10 speak and to di~wnt, this a>urt may find that such private rcstrictibns run aroul or the pro1ec1"·c scope or Article II, Section 10. It is possible for interests, otherwise private, to bear such a close relationship with iow:rnmental entities or public monies 1ha1 ,uch interests arc affected with a public interest. MorCO\oer, "ith or "ithout the benefit or that relation hip, a private project may dc\-clop and operate in a manner sucfl 11111 it perrorms a , inual public runctlon. • B. Our 1inJir.g that gowrr,mcnt:il involvement Clists here is not t,~~.:J <'n any ~ingk ra~tor. :-.en:nhclc~s. we find signifk:tnt the City's !\\O million dollar purchar.c, financed through the sale of munkipal ronJs, or impron:ments whic:h the Company made to adjacent ~•rccts and drainage S)Stcms. II is now common for governmental entities to 4:om~tc, by prmiding financial subsidies or inducements, to attract private business so as to reap the benefits or an im:rea~ tax base. Economic necc:ssity, howc,'Cr, cannot pro"idc the cover for i;o,·ernment.supportcd infringements of speech. Alsosignilican1 is the fact 1h11 thcCityoperatesa police 5utistation in the Mall from which the police respond to mmplaints throughout the City. The C.Ompany plO\idcs the space rent free to the City and, In effect, the Mall thus provides a municipal service. TIie presence or the substation In the Mall con~ the lmpres5ion that the City participates, either symbolically or aC1!11lly, in what arc in effect a>ntent-bascd restrictions ohpcech by the C.Ompany. That t"'O to four City police omccn routinely patrol the common areas or the ~tall does notllir.1 10 dispel 1h11 impression. The enrorccment or the Mall's "no sollci1111on• policy throu&h th.: City·, trcspus ordlnanc~. pouibly by those nmc offlttrs patrolling the Mall, 1ri111rorms the Impression into experience. Thus, t~rc 11 an ongoing mutual sub&idlzation betwctn the C.Ompany and the City. The necculty or keeping the pcMlC likewise cannot camoulbcc p'ClnlllCIII-Jiid.)d suppression or DOD·\~olenl political spc,cch. 1 Anally, tllerc ii a llllply ,iMblc pcn1111calll prCK:ICC in the MJIII . TIie Affly, Nl\y aad the Mat1ae Corps mainuin rtcnlll•& offlcCI I• Ille Mall . The Jcffcnon Coun:y Clerk coaduaa ,oecr rcpsua1ioll driWI III lllc Mall, rcailldi .. cklaeM ol tbcir political ,.... , ..... lbc flnandal panldpatioll ol llle City la tlllc MIii .. propt11.1bc amn,rme:iLS •11111 tlle Oty police ul»Utioll, ud tlk: act I\.: r K'DCC r r t~ r 1nmcn111 a~ndn 111 the a,mmon Jr•., l'f the \I I., n 11 1;1 c ~ .. rnn~nl.11 in,ol-,.:~, :1 1 • 111c opu11io11 uC' 1111c t.lalL C We arc allo pcrwaded 111111 the Mall l'IIIIClions II tile tqlli\'alcM ol I dolrllluWII buAllttl dlMrtu . M we IIOICd, tllc MIU • YIM •rt.ct, nowmnc1i-.~ r IOOams. TIie I caa•tdal '*' ffllal '*'*dllMcall aituled In the \I II I "" I • \I.I Jr. I C '~" I '.'OJ)OO t qU.lre f-:(1 ,., _.11,.. n ;J ~ :< Ulk . W.,l~r. • ' , .. I I • • • , - • • • \ ... • I~ . • ' (. ___________ ·_n_1e_l~ricf Times Reporter I planning, or the lack thereof, Ill prevail o\cr oun:1lucJ Ji:ion of free speech? The range of acti, i1ie~ pcrmillcJ in the wmmun areas 1hc !\1~11 ~lso indilatc~ the c,tcn1 lo "'hich the !\!all ..:cti,cly funClions as l l:,11a-JJy public forum . The ,mpany allows a varkty of groups ;icccss 10 the \"isiting Mic through the u~ of the rnmmon areas of the Mall. e ha,·e noted that, for example, the Sal\'ation Army 'kits dona1ioni from the public strolling the Mall. The ,,rc:ssi,·c conduct or artists and dancen has t-ttn all~'Cd. ligious expression hai not been denied. The common :as arc used by a market research firm 10 survey the bllc's likes and dislikes. Surc:ly the Mall's theatre hu h ibited films or poli1 ically controninial content, sparkln1 ely debates amon11hc Mall's patrons. to Thc C.ompany's \lhibilion of petilioncn' non-violent political speech, if 'owed 10 stand, would amount therefore 10 a non-neutral, n1en1-based tulliction. Oi,-en that other groups :cctlvcly cxpras lhemscl\'CS in the Mall's common areas, se open areu can ea1ily aa:ommodale pctilioncn' .:rcise of their liberty or speech. Under these cums11nces, 1he common areas runc1ion u \·inual public 3US. We emphulzc thal there has been no showin1 thal titionen' activilics •ill adYCrscly arrcc1 1he Mall's ,sincss operations. l'e1i1ioncn' cholcn mode of speed!, 11ibu1ln1 leaflets and oollcc1ln1 Jlpcd plcdFS, is well thin the mainstream. The con1en1 of their specdl is ,ssically political. In addition, the size of the Mall, tbo ,mbcr or \isitors the Mall rca:iYCS, plus the already 1cfli\c use of the common areas of the Mall by Oilier JMduals and poups. dcmoM1ra1c 1ha1 pclilloncn' 1M1la can be conducted •illloul ln1etferin1 willl Ibo all's normal operallQftl and 111crcrorc •111 IIOI affect tile ,mpeny'I propeny riptL Sm tfMDCYv4 2J ca1. ld 11 _,S92P.Ma1~7 ..... ISJCII.Rpu.11 _(~447U.S. 1) (1W)e do IIOI ha\'C under a>11$1dcra1ioll 1he propeny or i\-acyrip11olan lndl\1ch1a l home ncrorthe prorriclnr .1 modctll'~t11I 1al\l i-hm,nt."). Furth r , 1M Comrany ~ "~ 10 Im~ r a ,,n .. t :..: 1111w, r'"" a nd manner 1ric:tioftl on the n.luct of pc:htlOn.:"' 1ctl\i1y, simabr thole l•poted on 11\e 01 r Ul\llk •hlcll ii hu r111llled la Ille L issue: ·whether ankle ti, section 10 of the Colorado Constitution prevents the pri,·ate owner of an enclosed shopping mall from cxduding citi1cns engaged in non-, iolcnl politic;,I speech from the common arc..s of the mall." Weare not c.11lcd upon 10 decide whether the United S1a1es Constitution extends protection to the pctitioncn in this case. As the majority notes, the linl and fourteenth amendments or the United States Cons1i1u1lon do no1 extend 10 the distribution of political lileraturc Inside a privately a..11cd shopping mall. Maj. op. at 2 n. I (cillng Hu4&e05Y NLRB 424 U .S. S07, S18 (1976)). Thefrccdom of speech clauses of the C.olorado C.onsti1u1lon protect Individuals aplnst unwarranted intrusion by Ibo s111e. Because Westminster Mall ls not an en1i1y of the state nor clothed with stateauthorlty, I respcctfullydlsscnund would affirm the Judsmcn1 of the coun of appeals. I Wa1mlns1er Mail opened for buslnas in 1977. Respondent Wes1mins1er Mail C.ompany (mall) dcrlvca 111 profil from lcasina space 10 mall Slorcs and takin1 a pera:n11gc of crou sales from the stores. The common areas or the mall, lncludlna the Interior a>rridon connce1ln1 Ille Slorcs,are prlvalclyowned by the mall. Mall security ls provided by a prlva1c security firm and a few Wes11nlns1u police ofllcen wllo patrol 1he mall durlna buslnas houn. Since M:uch 1917, the aiyofWa1mlnstcr (Westminster) has operaled a small police subs1111oa 10 respond 10 cillzcn complalnll. /iJ pan of an expansion project, the mall made various Slreet and drainap lmp10YC111C11111ha1 were Iller paid for ti, Wes1ml1111cr •i1ll funds oblailled from municipal bondL TIie mall maintains a polity pn>llibl1l1111he soUdtatlon of lboppcn 111d 1he dislribu1lo11 of lcallcts and llalldbills. la adcUtloa, tile mall bas IIIIUl•led a permit procedtn for IIOIICllllllaCf 1t1hiua w11crebJ It ftlllulCI cadl application by wrio.-laclon, lad11CHa& 11le llJad of aaMly a~ ptlrpoae. Ille •lllllbn of penldplnts, IN rilk ot lnjiij; and Ille risk l'f unreasonable lntcrfcrcna: •itll 111111 tenant~. Un.lcr th i prN' (!ur.:, the null has apprO\'Cd ctlllln communuy nd ,halllJl>lc ~t1!,hlcs, indudin1 a n 1n1iquccu mow, a rare bfud q511ow, 1 Jcffcnon O>unty ,utcr rc&blralioll drl\c. a Sal\'llioft Almy Cllr!JIMII rund drl\-e,1sal1t1e to law~nforcclllc111 and lllcanied lorca,llld a 8or Scoltl pUIC wood de,_, . •• J1tly 1915, pelilloaffl Neltoa Iott lad Palrida Lav. ·A tar, IIICJllllc,1 ,'If Tilo Pleil. ot lt•lltlllCle, u,h1 rtr,:11 n tu ,id 111 •11c1 t ure .and I 1 \ &ft tUI, \ f I~ (,\11 111~ r J •· ·ir th• in,.1,k , Mt>-, •o..ftJ ,·m ~ I 11, , o r en• ntly lat Ill lalm ··"' I• N ,IIJ,u "I H ,,, ,t, r. I r• ... -..i 10 J '" 0111.:" ,,, IIUII\ •k n1 ruhll<.'. rh •I \ I J IU ' lu tJH lhl and llhU lr,rnpf~I ' In order 10 Pf' Ill Of UII l'vrtlltr dc:1111 Ind dcslAAlit>n In air I "-er . Tlleaalldcnic\lfl'.'lllloacnpttlllillloalOcl11ltrleeftel or Kil l pal1tftl ..W. IM •H. Pelkloaen ftlN 1 1441 II - • . • I • • 0 , ? I -• • • ________________ T_l_,e_B_a:_~efTlmes Reporter ,·,,mpl:sint in the kffi:r,on County District Court ~,·eking <1.:dara!o1y a:id injunc1in: r.:lic:f, alleging th.!t 1hc:}' had a protc,11:J right 10 hanJ oul poli1ical znd public inlcr~I kalkls unJ,·r 1hc c.,1oraJo ConMilulio:i. ,\ft..-r .!i •,w.cry, t-mh parties filed cross-mo1ions for ~umm~r; j11dg1.1,n1. The J~lrkt coun denied the pc1i1ioncn' mo1ion and gran1cd the mall"s mo1ion dismi.•sin& 1hc case \\ith prejudice. On appal, Ille coun t'r appeals affirmed 1he ummary judamcn1 blued in ra,-crorthc mall. In rny,icw, summary juclpacnt •• rropcrly cn1ercd by the district oourt. Aa:ordingly, 1bc a,un of appeals should be affirmed. II 1be ftnt WIG dames of 1r1icle II, section 10. or 1ho Colorado Coatilutioll Mate: "No law shall be passed lmpairiag 1lla Cleedoa of speecti; C\'CfJ pcnoa 111111 be l'rce 10 •peal!. write or pulltilll wllalC\-cr lie will oa any subject, bcin& raponsillle for all abuse of 1lllt liberty . . . . • Petltloncn Boclrud u-1cu-A,darcontend 11111 these tllO dausa are ladcp t'eal and 11111 Ille 11a1e aC'llon rcq11imacn1 fond la die pllrasc. "No law sllall be paucd, • docs not carry CMr to die second clause. 1'111•, pc1itioncn rca5011, Ille secood dame appllcl 10 pmate bclraYior. We ....... ., llcld lllll Ille purpme of article II, ICC'lioll 10 is 10 "'panl Ille praa •ptw ... !Afflede g( poll!IAI pPICI ... WIINI IO Ille wbole people a flan .... free dhnNIOJI ot public affafn.'" ra.. v Bd, m P.2d IOS9, IOl56 (Colo. I~ (quotiagPqcn ... llColo. l37, l62, 22 P. 790,971 (ISIP)) (CIII addccl). TIie boldlag 111 Ba waa anlwtt at after we spectftcallJ .,.. tlllt "fo)ur aJlllli&ulioll coaiai• WIG pnJ'fuoa prolffl tllc frcedola of cxprcaioll." Jill.al 1°'5. 11ladDle. •1letllcr 111a ftnl a., dalllCI are rad • .,.... or jDIM ...,.....o1Cleedoaotlpeedl.l ....... I tlla I'*, or • prtwaae ndty :flll I dale ... ,11e ...... • ,..,.,, , ..,.,. r n no ra,.,19U.S.MS.l51(197,).beaaacw .......... .._ ol 1 """tlCfcn........, 111 •e clwaC'lcrulcd antde II, .ipnn the ~crl'f tale Cl'.Wl11U11 Caoo1 u ,,c tltt:.r,o, :11 .,, ....... IL.Iii, ....... Colo. 591, WJ, 296 P.2d ~ • .;67 (I ). Ow 1441 Bro;11.lcaslin1 Sl,u:m Joe, v QcmocLJJic Nalianal Comm 412 U.S. 94 (19731. Thus, while statutory or common law m3y in some ~iluations cxtc:nd pro1c:c:1ion or pl'O\ide redress :,gain~• a pri\-ate corporation or pc:rson who seeks to abridge the fret: c"<pro~ion or othc:rs, no such protcc:tion or redress is prO\idcd by the Constitution itselr.• Hyd&rns y NLRB, 424 U.S. S07, Sil (1976). HY4&a1 n:vlcwcd 1he relevant c:asa relating 10 whether a 1lloppin1 CJCatcr Cell under Ille •company town c:xcq,cioa• to 1be 11a1e ac:doa doc:lrinc. ne Coun flnt rccoplml 11111 111cre was aa caq,tioa 10 1he 11a1e action req•iremcnt la ill ftnt amcadacat jurisprudcllcc la Mmh v A'9beN 326 U.S. 501, S02 (1946), wllcro ii dcflncd a mapa., IOWII • a privatea, oa'IICd area ~ •an Ille c:llaraClafsdcl of u, otlller Alncric:u tan.• Q\,er die ~ dllleat of Ylall'I alllllor, J.ab Black, tlle Collfl la :!NI-W fcAlfa.., uwv • •• YIDcr ,,_,,. U.S.lOI. 311 (ltlil), ..... die mapaa, IOWII doc:utN 10 a llloppiaa cuter by swtq lliat a..,..._.,. die "faclloule1tllivalat"ofdle.,.._cHsutaofamapa-, IOWL Jlllltce Bladt fell IMI Ille aejarilJ ud ........._. dlecaadalclemetlllofa..,.., ton: .... Ya WII .a lalellded IO.,,., 10 ddl ldlld of ..................... ., ............ of. ca f -,.ornaedton.mmplelewllll......_...,......._ ..... Nl6dcaa,udewaytlllacello ...... to .... . IOML • • • I cu 111111 very Utlla ra1111thecw ...... die .......... enter IIMllwld la tllll aee • Oli:t rrw, Alllilaa. 111ere are ao lloaa. rllcre II ao--.....,.... lllcN II aot M'a a pall ollm OJI dlll ,,_.. propertJ wlllcll llleo.t flCllltCOJIUdal dle .. 111 ••• ofa 'IOwa.' • II .• . . ' • • - • • • II - • I• . • ' ,c , ,, The Brief Times Reporter attempt, in I~. by fi\'C pcr,ons to <.li,tril•utl', in a Punlan<.I, Oregon, shopping center, haml1'il1\ protesting 1he invoh·cmcnt or 1he UnitcJ States in Vietnam. Securily guarJs a~kcd the handhillcrs to lc:i\'C . They .:omplied an<.! subsequently hruught suit . The Supreme Court rcvcrscJ the Ninth Circuit's affirmance 0C1he 1ri;1l mun·s ruling that the Constitution protected the <.limibuti,1:1 or hanJbills at a shopping center. Arter noting that "it must be remembered that the First and Fourteenth Amendments safeguard the rights or rrce speech and assembly hy limitations on ~ action, not on action by the owner of private property used nondiscriminatorily for private purposes only," Lll:l):sl. 407 U.S. at 567, the Court obscl\·cd: "Respondents contend ... that the property of a large shoppin1 center is 'open to the public,' Kl\'CS the 5ame purposes u a 'business district' or a municipality, and therefore llas been dedicated to certain types or public use. The arcumenl is 1ha1 such a center llas sidewalks, streets, and parkln1 area which are functionally similar to facilities customarily provided by municipalities. II is then uscned that all mcmbcn of the public, whether invited as customcn or not, lllw: the 5ame rlpt orrree speech as they would have on 1hc1lmllar public facillllcs in 1he11reetsof 1ci1yor town. °TIie ar1umen1 reaches 100 far. The Constitution by no means ttquircs such an attenuated doclrine of dedication of private property to public use. The clolcsl decision in theory, MJr::;h y i\lolbl!DI uqa. lnYOIYed the assumption by a private enterprise or all or the attributes or a state-cri!'ated municipality and the exercise by tlllt enterpri5e of scmi-0fflcial municipal functions as I delcpte of the State. In err~1. the o-11er or the company town was performinc1hefullspcctrumofmunicipalpowenand51ood in the shoes of the State. In the instant cue there is no comparable auumption or exercise of municipal power.• lilllllSIL ,24 U .S. 11 S19 (quotin1 IJad. ~ U.S. 11 561-69). The Supreme Coun explicitly 111ted la Ulllllal that 1.111d O\'erruled the ntionale I• I opp V,Hcy Id. 11 SIS. 111c lmpon of the tlloroup and aumtlve rcww or cases in ~ is ahat, althoucll there still cxisu coapuy-to..-n etcrption to ahe fcdtral free pc«II tate u l nr qcir<'mcn a,:i,horplngc nicrdc • nu t me under this exttption. Therefore. 1 slloppln1 center is ouislde the s.afepardl fnmcd in the first amcndmeat . lllit. I btlicve, is the proper approach to the intcrpr 111loll oft be Color* Coastilutloa In the case before us. TIie Wat•l•ter Mall, • 1 p,watc slloppln1 center, Is not wltllla tlle 1.a,t1 or ankle 11, s«tlon 10. Ill The m.1J<'rit y • tJl. n ,hrrcrcn t t, lk 10 1 I l.l'<.'. hh 11 •h ii do.. n 111ir c1ly dJr ·, ,,. h 1hcrthu • i ,a~•c IICIIOII r .. -qum:m nt rnhc1cn1 in 1hc rr .. c p..~lh I 11 ,,f arak1e II , « t lon 10, the majority an31yle1 the -c lhtlUC l re "l,t\J. U,',JU,' If, IC ,lie \J I IR• tn I.In "'' cuy .inJ u ,unt )' in,nh .. 111 .. 11 1 li t •he m:i tl .,nJ 11 de\ lopmcnt, ahem jorlty comlu.J 1h 1th r • 1 urlkifnt ~late action to in\'ol:e the Ct,forJJo Constitution. While the majority, arter citing the United States Supreme Court decision in Burton v Wilmiocroo Parli;io1 AuabctilY 36S U.S. 71S (1961), fil maj. op. at 14, concludes that "the historical connection between the market placcoridcas and the market fur goods :ind ser\'iccs is not sc\'ered because goods and scl\·iccs today arc bought and sold within the confines ofa modern mall," ill.at 18, it does so \\ithout fully examining the clements of the Ccderal saate action doctrine. The fundamental issue in the Supreme Court's state action calc11lus is the degree of state in,'01\-cment. • As a general mancr the protections or the Fourteenth Amendment do not extend to 'private oonduct 1bridcin1 indMdual rights." Naliaoal a,nc1ll1c A1blc1iG Ass'n y I1ckloian _ u.s. _. _. 109 s. c,. ,s.a. 461 (1988) (quolln1 llul19D. 365 U .S. 11 722). The Court fnmcd the issue in the followin1 manner: ·rn the typical case nisin11 state action issue, 1 private pany llas liken the decisive step that caused the lllrna 10 the plalntilr, and the question Is whether the Slate was sufficiently lnvol\-ed to treat 11111 clecislve oonduct u 1111e action .... Thus in the usual case we ask whether the State provided I mantle of authority that enhanced the pc>Yo'Cr or the h1rt11-causln1 individual actor.• ld.11_.109S.CUl462. ~f4DK>DSODY l&cmlle A>DQ'CICQ> U.S._,_.111 S.Ct.2077,2082(1991) (" Althou1h the oonduct of private panla Ila beyond the Constitution's scope in most instances, COYCmmental authority may dominate an acllvity to sucllan extent tlllt its panicfpanll must be deemed to let 11itll theauthorltyolthe p-ernmcnt and, u I result, be subject to oonstitutional constnints. "). The Coun round state action on the pan or a prl\·ate party cxerasin1 1 peremptory challenp la f4lMDIOD y UCIYille Concrrtc Cp. In E4nnnon tlle Coun used 1 two-part tal IOCWluatUIIIUClion: 1F)int(,l•11ctllertlle claimed oonstitutlonal deprivation ra.lted from tlle cxettlle of I rl&llt or prMletl lllwl& 111 MMlffll I• 1111e IUlboril)': Ind second. wllclller Ille p,Mle pll1J dwpd wltll the deprivation muld be dacrAlcd ill 1U r..... 11 a 1111e actor.• _ U .S. II -· 111 5. Cl. II 2082..&.\ (ci1in1 Lusar Y E4DNO!&D Ojl Co 457 U.S. 922 (1982)) (d1a1ions omitted). The rlrst pwn1 ·us .aai fi~J l<.:1.Ji.10: the peremptory challeap 11 sue ia E4moeeon v."trc curci1cd puBuant to a kdcral '1at11te. 1'1le ICICIOnd test .• •'lletller. p,Mhl party COllld ,...., lie ........ IC10t •• WM a-ed Oii tlllee lKlon: 1111111 alnl IO Midi Ille aaor rella oa paa....a •• ., .. ud bcadlla; 121 •ilctller Ille IC10r ii pcrbllliaa I trldltloul puamtnUI functk,n: and l~l • llcahtr the injutycauscd 11 IIPll\"lttd I• J unique v.':ly by the 1nud nu r '°\i!'rn nut . u11\, 1,1 , • hi. "' _, 111 t.:t . J I ~1 ( t1.at l<1n , 1"1111 J ). ~, percmp«ory challcllca nnot abt v.itllolt the °' n and ,,,n,n,. n, p. raidr; 111111 f1 •. i , rnffli!'nt , th· oun ,•i 1 l hJ I the '4;\II IIJ pwnc J Jf-.l ~"''"J. IJ. ~· -· 111 . , .• , :ocu.a.a . 1443 . . ------~~" - ' , • ' I • • • . •' \ ' , I - • • I \I ,, II ;( i i I ,j I i r '! 1:- 1. '. t • • 1 i : 'I l • • • • ·, ,. The Brief Times Report ~----·-------- The question before this court is no t whether •governmental entities or public moneys arc ~hown ... to s ubsidi1e, approve of, or encourage private intcrnts." ~ maj . o p. at 1.i . Rather, we mus t determine "'hcthcr this subsidization, appro\'al, or encouragement rises to a signilicnt level, transforming the act of a private entity into that orthc state. On the record before ui, I bdicve the state has not suflicicntly clothed the mall in a mantle of state authority. While I agree with the majority that a 4.letermination of s tate action must be made on a cse by case basis,~ maj. op. at 14, the type of governmental inmlvcment triggering such a determination must be narrowly construed. As the Supreme Court has said, "although the factual selling of each case will be significant, our precedents indicate that a State normally can be held responsible for a private decision only when It hu exercised conci,-e pot4-er or has provided such significant mcourngm,cnt, either ~nor coven, that the choice must In law be deemed 10 be that of the State.• Blum y Y,accukY 457 U .S. 991, l<XM (1982) (emphasis added). 1ltc same analysis should be used to impute state action 10 a private party. In ~ the court of appeals held that state action was present w·hen medical discharge decisions were made by physicians and nuning ho mes because New York adjusted the patient's Medicaid bcnelitS accordin&Jy. The Supreme Court rejected this characterlution, rcuonin1: "That the State responds 10 such actions by adjustin& bcnelitS does not render it rrspo,uiblc for those actions. The decisions about which respondcnll complain arc made by physicians and nunin& home admlnistraton, all or whom arc cona:dcdly private panics. T1lcre Is no sugatlon that those dcdslons were inQucnccd in aay dcarc,c by Ille State's ol>llption 10 adjust bencnu .... • Id. Simple action by the state In ICIDONlaace witll the allcaed con 1it ut lonal ,iolai lon ls, the refo re. insu ffldc nt 101urn 11\e actions f a p,i,111e pa rt y 11110 tale actions. There mu I t,c nr\u "•'"'''" t h.: ·ru n r .ncou1a,em,'n1 tJtcn y t he ,1:a 1o: and th.: action 1h11 is the s ubJCCI or the com plaint. The rac ,ua l sc 111n1 tlf Buuon Y, Wllml n11on P;ul!io& Au1b9!:hy it in 1ruc1lve in cvalua1 in1 Ille 11c&rec of ilale IR\'OMfflC nt •i lh prl\'lle pan ics ..... ffllY al\'C riM 10 51a le actioa . In BJwma. a ra 11ur111 1 praalci•& racia l Jlscrlmlnatlon wa1 loc:a ted In• pa rk l .. bulldl 111 ov.ncd arul ~r IN by I te 1gency. 'The r3rklll!: au1ho1hy "n,11u,tlJ th · r ... 1111 , 111.,"J otfk J I I n ,•11 thc utl,J1n • tnJ1-. 11n • n I ulllt • 1.h , t r, ~nJ n... >IJh! ,1ml 11 ,11<10.,I flap frt1m the nta thc:ich o n the roof. 365 U 1 7111, 7~0. In j ll4J i11 n. t • I tnd .1nJ l>ul hl in " r • pu I ,h o r ,J J r. t thd•utlJ1n II "' ,\J J,J1, .. 11:J t ·, ut-111: u,,,: hi. J I 11 \, The Uri t houchl ii 1o\ ulJ bll • f ny 1'11()11111111110 fJ\C lljUII ·~· n l)IIO pa n or a 1111c Utlctllll, f IN 1rwJ MIIIIII IICd 11\ I ll pMllc (lilldll !Ir H ap-y or I N Sa.le 10 ..,,. a public purpaM, au PfflOM equl rlp11, •Mte in another p1111i11n, al so se rving the publ ic, a l'\egru is a ~ccond-cla~s ci1i1cn. • Ii.tat n.i. Such is no 1 the ca~e her.:. Wcstmiri~tcr !\fall "as built by prh·ate funds and has n.:,c r t-cc n held out as a puMic buil4.ling. Appa rently, the majority believes a pri\'ate facility becomes pi:blic if it is "dc\'clop(cd) and opcrat(eJJ in a manner such that it performs a virtual public function .• Maj. op. at 14. Such a rule would impose state action based solely upon the use ofa facility rather than the actions oh he i;overnrnenl. As a result, private businesses would become slate actonwhencver their ac1i,itiesscem "public" to a court of law. This conOiru with the stricter requirement of cocrci,·e power or signiliant encouragement in ~ Furthermore, the mall fails both prongs of the f4monsog test. Flnt, there Is no specme s1a1u1ory authority, other than trespass laws, for the mall's refusal of petitioners' application to distribute lcaflcu. Second, the mall cannot fairly be described as u1a1e actor. E\'en though the mall has obtained some governmental assistance in the form ofs1rcc1 and drainage improvements and the provision of police omcers 10 patrol the mall, there is nothin1 In the record 10 suggest that the mall relic:s on this assls1ancc. More sipifican1ly, the mall neither performs a traditional governmental function nor wu petilio ncn' injury auravated by the incidcnll or Hate authority. Unlike 11\e peremptory challenges at Issue in f4mon,on !he mall can ex is t without the o,-cn and si1nlOcant partk.i pa1ion or l()Yemmcnt. Thus, on balance, the mall fails the second part ofE4mgp,ag At 1he hcan or the UnilcJ Sla1a Supreme Court rcuonin1 Is 111c Jona held fact that 11)ndMdual I-ion or lnd~idual rlpu Is not the subjc,ct--tter or the (founccnth) amendment,' ... and 11111 private conduct abrid&tna individual rtp11 docs no ,ioltna: to the Equal Pro1«11ott<lauscunlcu10so-upiflculC111C11ttheS1a1e 111 any or 1u rnanires1a11on1 hu bcca found ao uw bca>mc in,'01\cd in it." J!!itlCJI , MS U .S . II 722 (qllOl lna the Ori! B l&blS c~. 109 U .S. l (1883)). I llcllC\-e t he •Ame rc:i , n•ni: ~r I!" "' . rt ide II, .cuio n II) o r ur ••~te con 111u1 ion . Ill The ret'Ord presen ts nu r1e11 showi1111 ha1 Wo 1mlnstu tUttfscd iu po,,,1:r O\ff the mall wllcn Ille ma ll made 111 dedllotl 10 ~j«t tlle pca ltionffl pc,alt app1ica 1lo11. '111crc re, OIi t he Ot~r hand , a few facts 11111 ial&111 ra ise Ille iuue o r •hcthcr w,. 1mlns1cr I IOca ntly tllfflllraaed them. II m ., n l 'l r'.u t'l ,1 11 ulJ "'• ,,:111h • mall into ;a 1:11 e , to r I ,r ,. Ir. r 1 ,: m.1 11 n1:i<lc 11, ·1 J nJ dt 1n.11, • lm pM\'ITk.11 1 """''m'"''"' p:ald "" ,a.ac mprO\cmcntS 11.11h m11nk'lr,i l N nd . Thi, hn.C\ r, h a ,r 1. t ti , r t' .,11 • ,,11, ,n t, ·:rh •tir "°'mnt ,•I , .. •n,111,.; ik,, I r11kll l 1n W" t mln I t . II Is IIOIC'IIIOl l ltJ tha t I hde ,~ lmrr mcnl N'ncflll J 11"' d ty as •d i II Ille IUIL I ~kl ROI hokt that IIICN fllQ)WI.MCal of PfMIC t•ICtpl'fM tltl'Oll p s...,••loa • 1M IINab ,..,. a IMlllw 11110 a ..... ICtOr. Mol_., 1111N II IIO 11CA1 . ' •. ' ,. I • • • , - ) • • • • • <. The Brief Times Reporter between 1hc ~,reel anJ Jrainag.: pruj«·ts aml the mall's all.:gcd deprival ion or spcc«.:h rights. ScuinJ, Wcs1mins1cr has 3 police station in 1hc mall and provides police orriccrs 10 patrol the mall during bu~incss hou~. Were 1hc,;c omccrs responsible ror ejecting 1he petitioners rrum the mall, this might be deemed significant encouragement of the mall's speech policies. When the petitioners, hm1,·e,·cr, requested a permit 10 pass out lcallcts, it 11.-as the mall administration, not the Westminster police, who rejected the application. There is no evidence in the record 10 suppon a nexus between the cxiitence of the police station and officers and the oomplaincd of abuse of free spcccb. The majority only notes a pouibillty thal lhe mall's policies oould be enforoccl by tbe Wcstmlnsler offiocrs. ~ maj. op. 11 16. A mere pos51bility of state action, however, ii insuffldent to tum the mall into a state 1e1or. Finally, the mall allowed a Jefferson County voter registntion dri\'C. By usin& county IClion in addition to city atlion 10 reach its ooncluslon of state IClion on tbe pan or tltemall,amaj. op. at 17, the majori1yblurs 1hellneofjus1 what "state" is at1in1, Under this analysis, one mvld tbrow Colorado and federal oonnec:tions into the same mix. This tactofspcciOdty in applying the 1111eac1lon dotlrine would create an unwarnntcd and undesirable expansion of the law. Bcause the record is \'Oid of any evidence shol!.in& a nexus bct,i,un Wes1mins1er's 1C1io11S and thole li51Cd In the petitioners' complainl, the mall's actions belon& to it alone as a private pany and arc not oo-ned 10 thole of the state. Aaordln&ly, Ibo free speech clausa of tho Colorado Constitution do not rcac:11 tlleacu of the mall,aad sununary judp!Cllt ia its favor -proper. CHIU JUfflCE ROVIIA and JUfflCE VOLi.ACK join In this diucnt. 1 The court of a prcals anal)7ed th.: quc~tion o r pctitlollcn' ri&hll under both Ille United States and Colondo Constitutions, but •'C panted rcniorari 10 addrca tllc i5suc only under tho Colorado C.O.Cltutloll. The UailCld Slales Supreme Coun 11111 lleW 1h11 lllc Finl a nd Foertecntll AfflcadlllCftlS 10 tho Unlled States 111111 ion do noc protea 111c d k 1nbu1ioa of lcalk11 ,11h ln a prk rcly-c.,...ncd m II . Ullil 11.n.tLL, b! t I 4H U 5u7, I (l 'Ji t.). l ~ 11,he rc Ille '""'' 11<1 n~ r,i11 l:11 ing 1h• 1.11 ·· ,11r1 inJ I )"'"·'"'Ill 1 1, "·'' 11n • ,,1 fou r 1 .1 ·~ ir1 11,· 1•1.1 111 :11,h 1h .,,u n nnou nccd b ut l hc n rc1 :t d t lkl lkar ond r r nl d.ln~r • 1. 'Bra ndeis's , win fur ooncvrr ln1 ra1hcr tha n d ...... 11111 Wh tncy had IIOI properly ar1ued IO Ille ltfonlla aour111ha1 lllclr failure to lrwotc tho••• a.a WM cm,, ••.• • Manin Shapiro. I• DI f1Al Awr!re• Lcon3rd W. Lc,y, tLi1.L. cd~. !\1ad\1illan (1990) I'· 135 . ~ was overruled in Brandcnbure v Ohjo 395 U.S. 444 (1969). J ~ '-£. Boos y Baell', 48S U .S. 312, 318 (1988), acknowledging thal speech which is "classically political" has long been afforded the highest possible protections. ~ abll Ic:m v Jobmon 491 U.S. 397, 411 (1989), and Frisby y ScbyUz. ~7 U .S. 474, 4i9 (1988). ~ w Aw>cialcid Pn:ss y. Unjtqt State, 326 U.S. I, 20 (1945) ("Surely a command 11111 Ille government ilSClf shall not impede the free now of ideu docs not afford non-governmental combina1ions a refuae if they impose rcs1rain11 upon that constitullonally pannlced freedom ...• Freedom or Ille press from ~nlll interference under tbc Finl Amendment does not unction repression of 1h11 freedom by privale interall. "). 4 Herc. the parties agree tbat the sca>nd clause is the rclcvanl clause. 5 Fotkwoin& PruocY1c4 s111e couru ha,-e divided on the issue. SC\-cnl states have held that speech activities similar 10 thal in,'OMICI bcrc were pro1ce1ed by their state consti1u1ions rcprdtess or whether tbc activity may ha,'C been protected by lite Finl Amendment Robjns y PruoeYar4 SbQppjo1 C&o1sc 23 C.aL 3d 899, S92 P.2d .341, IS3 Cal. Rpt,. 854 (1979); $1110 Sd!mkl M NJ. SlS, 423 A.2d 61S (1960), IPll(II djJa,iaod syb nnm Pring;Jon VniYCDIIJ Y Sdla,jd ffl U.S. 100 (1912); AWCcmx14 Avodt!CI Y W1H,a11oe Envtmewnul AleMil 96 Wasta. 2d 2.JO, 635 P.2d IOI (1!111). B11Uf. P>k>&oc y wwc,rw Awn 192 O>nn. 41, 469 A.2d 1201 (1984); . SI.ate Y &IM 273 S.E.2d 70I (N.C. 1911); WM9CQ Penn SodtPW WadFcn 1912 <>mpelp v AanW!kM! Qca Life ~11Ur..l-512h.2l.S1SA.2d 1331 (1916):Jambsy M_,, ll9Wis. 2dffl,<407 N.W.2d&lZ (1917). Eacboflhcca<a holding 1h11 the srcxch ~ pr 1cc1cJ und r th.: <IJ le constitution de.alt v.itb a .UIC Wll'litulional provi ion similar la wordin& 10 Artlde II, Scaloa 10. The California Cons1i1111ioa, at i5sue la P[UNYpd prowled: "E'-'CIJ pcnc>11 -, freely .,-.. write ud ,_... Ills o, Ila IClllimcats OIi aU sullptl. beta& rapomillle fo, Ille abuse ol tbil rlpt.• FDIMYW 2l Cal. 3d at __. S92 P.211 at ~ 153 Cal Rptr . at _. TIie New .JcncyO>•tl1u1lon,11 ue 1n 5.\11.mid. pr«I\ 1Jcd : "I \ ry rcr,o n m:l )' f11 l ) ';",°' ~. ,1 .I • 1n dpuhli It h i ·~nr11111:n1 1>n .a ll uh ,:ct , ini:r,•r,"1,,t r.: fu n hcabll5C hh.a1 righ1 .' ~~NJ .a 1.::._,4 B, ~ :11 fi.26. The Wn hlnc1on O>nst itut l •n con1 :,incd imi lAr ,,11Ji ng: ·1~,~ry p.r,,,:i niay fr,: ·It I" J ' •I ti . ~!:•I r .iM,,'1 , 11 II uh1''\.I ,l>o:ing r • r un 1Me k1rt hl!Jbl&k!11 f1h t 11 ,hl.' AJ!knwood ANt!OatCI. 96 W11h . 2d 11 _, 6).5 P.:=11 :at 114. 6 la Lkd, tlle O>un addnaed Ille •UOMloll "111 IO tho rlpl ol a p,MldJ oned ....... CIIIIICf IO prollllNt 1111 ,..,...._ ol ......... -Ill "°""' ..... ... ' I • • ·' \ , ]- • • .. • The (Me•:' ':-iml?s Reporter ----------------- handt,illing i~ unrclah:,1 10 1hc ~h1•1,rin~ cc·1:l'r'· , ~ Co~~iJcr Jfudi;cns Y. NI RB 424 U.S. at S39-.SO opcra1ions.• UO)ll.407 ll.S. a, !1!12. The rci,r,o~,lc:,t, :11 · •. , ,\4,~,h;,11, J ., Jis.~nling) ("!Tjhc Olll·ncr of the modern case haJ dimil>uleJ wi1hin a large ~h.-ppini;,·, flh ·r h:int:l•;li , ·-l1<1ppini; cc:ntcr complc:ic, by dcdicuin& his property lo in, i1:11ions 10 a mc:c:ling 10 prutc~• 1h.: ,t1;,fl .11 ,,J \'i<-tn.i:,. 1ut-h.: u<c au l>u~incss diMri1:t, 10 some extenl displaa:s the War. Jd.at SS6. Security guards inrormcd 1hc re.r,inJ ... ::1, ·s,a:c· fw:n control ofhis1orical First Amendment forums, 1hcy were tres~in& and would l>c arrntcd uni~ ~ thq, and m:sy acquire a ,;nual monopoly of placa sullablc for stopped distributin& 1he handtiills. hi. The Cn urt ,-....11.'tl cffectk-c rommunka1ion. The roadways. parltla& loll. ud an Injunction srantcd 10 rcspondenlS whkh rcrmined 111:-m ~-aln'l)tohhe modem shoppln&centcr ffllYbe•eueatlal 10 dlilributc 1bc bandMIII ~i1hia 1he shoppin& ,-cn1cr. hi. for dfccti,·e speecll as 111e streets and lidewalb la the at S70. municipal or c:ompany-owned town."). 1 Slace PglC)'u,L It lsappalCllt tllJt 1bc United S111cs Supmae OMln's varied aulyla of "state 1e11on• in Ille coatat of a Finl Alncadmcnt dalm, ahllou&ll lastructl\,e. are noc dllpolltlve of free speedl casa arisfD& under our s111eCDMdtllllDII. 447U.S.atll. Wkft11111econstl1utlo1 lllrc01111 II..,,. pn,ICClheofl'reespeecll t!lan Is tilt' federal c:omtlt•tloll. a lladia& of "ltatc IClion" aca,rdlna to fNeral doctrlac II unneoaury. la 1nya-cn1, Supreme Court ·ca~, deddln& wllca private Kllon m1&111 be deemed that of tlk: state lla\'C DOI been a model of C0111lilenc,.• t;dDIORlQI y I #Pillo 0Wn:et 0,, Jae. _ U.S. . __. _ __. 111 S. Cl. 2077, 20lt (1991) (O'Connor, J., dlacntln&). 111111 ~r example. Jmtlce Manlla11. concurri111 I• Pm111Y1nl, round state aaioll pracnl la all rbrec of the "llloppf n1 center" C11C1, ~ J gpp Y•llc, Ula1I, ud ~ .«7 U.S. at 90 (ci1ln1 $bclkY y Kw:mc:t m U.S. I (19olll) allll ~ VorltDIDCIY SyHb19 376 U.S. 25-l (196-1)). WcDUlc that none of allele cues llad tbe p-crnmcntal ID\'Oh 111en1 1'1lidl ii pracnt llcre. 1.- 11 "(Tjbc Finl Aanllaeal ud Ankle II, Seclloll lOol the Colorado Oonltltatioll afford protealoa IO all baa of communkatlons. lncladbt& _,.. ..... m.., wlllcll ,uempt to coavcy • tllottpl or_,. IOIIIOdier penoa. • liPMVOP y. Mancdri& IIS Colo. 1, 6, S21 P.2111 166, 161 (1974). 11 Altllollp Ill re Qinoa ss ... tecMkallr tllll report ofa relcrec, wespedftcallJappnMIII IIIII..,,... die report !11 Its entirety. Ira 132 Colo. 11-. 2tl P .2d at 471 , , . , • • • - • • • 8.56 .200-8.58 .010 8.56.?00 No dumplq-Propeny may be posted. A . The buildina official may post a "no dumping" sign on any public or private propeny ifhe finds that such propeny has been repeatedly subjected to dumpina in violation of Section 374b of the Penal Code. B. The siari shall read: NO DUMPING (Pfflal Code Section 374b) Violators Will le Prosecuted In additinn, the sip shall contain an appropri- ate city telephone number daipated by the buildina official. (Ord. C-6407 t 1. 1987). 1.56.210 a.u ,-11y~ .......a aan daoace. If the buildiq official finds that the city had previously remo* weeds from the same ~ eny after nociceto the same owner, heshall aam a civil penalty blled on the followina schedule when weeds an apin mlMMd by the city: Civil penalty: for previous removal of weeds by the city once within the precedi .. live yean -fifty percent of the city's administrative COil for removal iDcludi• procaliftl fees; for pre- viOlas removal by die city two or more times witbin the sncedina ftw ,_. -oee bUlldred percent or the city's admilliltrative coa for removal inc:ludiat procaliftl .... The city will pw DOlice oflllit civil penalty 10 all propeny OWDffl .... weed abalemeat ~ cedures an illllitulld ...-their pn,pe1 lies. The impmitiaa o( dlil civil pnalty may be appealed IO dle.,_.,o(e-iMII, appealslDd coedemudoa. • prorilllll ill Secliaa 1.56.llO. The civil peulty c--... .... oldie .... SOD cfwlld IO the city of I.oat leacb aad ii collecta"ble by the city • an obliptioa or liability aeated by-· (Ord. C-6t91 f I, 1911). ,.._ ........ ,. -• . , . • '( -. , . L I. ·' I I Jl., Chapter 8.51 f1r---,- GRAFFITI ABATEM~~--.• I : . !{ffr ; l D , ·' . ·~. -Sections: 1.51.010 1.51.020 1.51.0JO 1.51.141 1.51.850 1.51.168 Pllrpose. Deflaidoas. or.r., ·. "?91, .;··l J06 Nlliluce. Sodce-Fera. .: (··IEillOCI ...._; 1.51.070 1.51.ca 1.51.0,0 1.51.100 1.51.110 1.51.120 1.51.130 1.51.140 1.51.150 1.51.HI 1.51.170 1.51.1. ,. ·'/ Nodce-Semce. ~ . A ..... llearlat-Senice otl .' .. aodee. A.,..._H ____ ....._ ... o..........alllldce. City ,......_Alltllarlzed. CIIJ reaowal-Gnffld ••••••t Iffy coa......_ City .......a-Gnffld ah11•1•t Iffy,-,_. lllldce. 1'--1 -...... ..... of ..... n..r. of c:ielllcdoa. MetW of celllcdaa. Tu-SeW .......,. Tu-SeW'""'11-......... ErNr ca1eaJ11 Aa•-•••t r1111r t'M 1.51.ltl ._ ..... wldl 1al1m•11t ..... 11 • 1.51.211 <M~......a ... ...... 1.51.211 D I z 11 _,...._ 1.51.111 ..,__ nil cbapler ii eaaclld for the purpoae of providina a syaem IO mp al privuely .,._ _, propeny widlia .... city he o( pdhi IDd providina a syaem for levy IDd callactioa to cover lbe COIi of IUCb mDO¥II by the city. Tbe mcrea. ol pafthi OD boda private aad public buildiap ud llnlC1Uftl c:naMl,a coadi- tioa ofbtialn ...:U .. iD adelaionlioa of~ eny aad bulialll Vllua for ad,iaceDt propaun / 'I ' I • • • .• , 1- • • • • • • .. all to the detriment of the city. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan). 1990). 8.58.020 Definitions. For the purpose of this chapter, ccnain terms used shall have the meanin& provided in this section: A . "Lot'' means a lot. parcel. tract. premises or piece of land. improved or unimproved, in the city. 8. "Graffiti removal levy" means the charJe made by the buildin& official for rcmovina paffiti from a lot plus all penalties for nonpay- ment of the char&es which have accrued. C . "Graffiti" means any unauthorized inscription, word, fiaurc or desi&n which is marked. etched. scratched. drawn or painted on any suuctural component of any buildin& stnac- turc, or other facility rcprdlm or the nature of the material of that stnactural component. D. "Owner" u used in this section, means any pcnon so desi&natcd on the lul equalized auaunent roll and also any pcnon havin& or claimina to haw any lcpl or equitable interest in the premises. (Ord. C-676911 (put), 1990). 1.51.lll N.-.. The CJtislcDce upoa aay lot of a,afliti is eaprmly dedued to be a public auilaace. and it lball be the duty ofbodl die owaer oftbe lot and any penoa who may be ia II mu · DD or who has a ri&ht to such poa Ilion. to at aD times keep such lot cleaa and frN from pafflti. (Ord. C-676911 (JIM). 1990). 1.51.. Nedct---r... ~-buildiaaofflcial ftadsoa aay lot pafflu whicll cu be ... by IDY pcnoa utiaa uy public ript-of-way. he lball c:ute a notice to mao,-e pafflti to be II~ 10 tbe -..C of tbe lol aa lhowa upon the cumat equaliud .... 1Det1t roll. and die -... be cleetDed IO be Ille llfflt of the OWllff and leUDt for Ille purpoee olNCelvi lll ~ ofdle .... Tht DOlice shall be .. subManlially die rolowalla form: I • 8 .58 .020-8.58 .050 NOTICE TO REMOVE GRAFFlTI To • as owner: Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 8.58 of the Lona Beach Municipal Code. you arc hereby notified to remove from ---- (Description ofpropcny) AKA------------ all arafliti u defined in the Municipal Code, within~ days from the date of this notice. If such araffiti is not removed within that time. the City will cause it to be removed and the dwaes for removal shall become a personal obliption and a lien upon your property. If you intend to remove such paffiti your- self. you are required to obtain from the City a certificate Slatin& that the paffiti has been sat- isfactorily removed: otherwite if the City is disaaisfied with the manner in which the work has been done, the araffiti will be funbcr ~ at yourupeme. If you object to the removal of the paffiti from your pmnises. you may appeal to the Board ofEumiaen. Appals and Condemna- tion by ftli111 a written notice of appeal in tbe office oftlle UDdeniped widlin ft,ie clays hm die dMe of lllia naac:e. Failure IO appeal sball be c:ouruect • your accep1anCe or the luild- i111 Offlc:ial's determination and any and all remedies provided by the Lona Bach Munici- pal Code. Dalecl; ______ _ Supenntndmt or lwldi111 and Safety -City or Lons lada (Ord. C-676911 (pan). 1990). ,. ..... ~. T1II DOlic,e IO 11111CM pdlti tball be~ ........................... ODlbe J06.I ............. . . .. I . • , - • • • 8.S8.060-8.S8.090 current equalized assessment roll as the owner of the premises involved. Such service may be made either by personal delivery or by depositin& the notice in the United States mail, postqe prepaid, as cenified, first class mail, return receipt requested. addressed to the owner at the most recent address appearin1 on the assessment roll, or if no address appears thereon, such sen.ice may be made by postiq the notice in a conspic- uous place upon the property. Proof of the service of the notice shall be made by affidavit of the pmon effcctin& the service, and the affidavit shall be sufficient for all purposes. (Ord. C-6 769 § 1 (pan), 1990). 1.51JNO A,,-1 ~ olaodce. A. If there is an appeal, the buildin& official shall serve on the owner who bu appealed, a copy of the notice of hearina by certified mail. B. The notice of hearin& shall be served at last ten days before the hearina. Proof of service shall be made by declaration filed with the board of euminen. appeals and condemnation. C. Service shall be compleled at the time of the deposit of the notice in a recepcade main- tained by the United States Postal Scrvic:e, with postqe fully prepaid. D. Tbe failure ol any pmon IO receive such DOlice ol i.rina shall DOI affect the validity ol any proceedinp under tbi1 chapter. (Ord. C-6769 I 1 (pan), 1990). 1.51.1'71 A,,..._Hwilla ...... ,. A. At tbe time staled in tbe DOlice. the board shall hear and consider aD relevant nidence. objectiom or procem. and shall receive tali· moey &om OWDffl, wh r iadudinacity per- 10Dncl. ud interaled penom relalivc IO the allepd public nuisucc ud to lbe proposed removal of the pafflti. Tbe bearina may be coa- tinued without funbcr DOlice . 8. Upon conclusion of the bearina, the board shall determine whether the premises. as main• 1&1ned. constitutes a public nuisance • defined in this cbaptet. lflbe baud ftadl tbal IUCb public I L..,. .... MOI ,. -• . ,~ • nuisance does exist. it shall determine bow tbe nuisance is to be abated and shall establish a time, not to exceed seven days, within which removal shall take place; and in tbe event the owner fails to correct the nuisance within the time prescribed. the city shall cause the nuisance to be abated and the cost incumd by tbe city shall become a pmonal obliption of the owner and tenant and a lien on lbe propeny. C. A copy of tbe board's determination shall be served by mail upon the owner of the affected premises. Scrvic:e shall be compleled at the time of ill deposit in a recepcacle maintained by the United States Pos&al Service. with postqe fully prepaid. D. No lepl proceedina or action lball lie apimt the city or any officer, aaent or employee of lbe city IO enjoin the enforc:emcnt of ill deter- mination or orden made pursuant IO this~ ter, unlal IUCb lepl action is commenced within thirty days after lbe decision of the board. (Ord. C-6769 I I (put). 1990). 1.51.111 a.-,.....a .... Ewry OWDCr served with a DOlice or Older IO remove paffiti who upon bis own account removes the pafflti from bis lot shall upon com- pletion ol the work immediately pvc wrian notice thereol' IO the buildiq offlcial. Suell DOlicc shall be either delivered or mailed IO the office ol lbe buildina official. Upon reccipc of such DOlice the buildina offlcial sbaD c:aUII tbc lol IO be impected. and if DO paffiti WIii thereon be lbaD mue the owner a ceniftcMe '° IWina. If pafflti still exisu OD tbc lot. be shall came it to be rcmoWld and the COit will be aaued apinst the owner alld tceut alld become a liea OD the propffly M if DO such DOtice of removal was remvcd from the ownu (Ord. C-6769 I I (put), 1990). 1.51.MI CIIJ,......_A...._., If uy owner mved with a notice fails ao remove the pafflti hm bis lot whlliD dlt lime IWed in tbc nodce. or Older ol tbc bad ol •. ' I • • .. , ]- • ,,. . ~ •, • ~. examiners. appeals and condemnation after appeal, he shall be deemed to have consented to such removal by the buildina official who shall thereupon be authorized, to enter upon the lot involved and remove the paffiti. (Ord. C-6769 § 1 (pan), 1990). 1.511.100 Ory reao..a-Graffld abatemeat leyY coa,...doL The buildi111 official shall. after completina the removal of pafflti f'rom any lot. compute all expenses IO incumd by the city, includina the applicable proc:essina fees as m forth by city council resolution: All expenses lhall be chaqcd to and become an indebtedness orthe owner and tenant of'suda premises. (Ord. C-6769 § 1 (part), 1990). 1.51.110 City .......a-Gnffll ........ , ..., .. ,.. ..alee. Upon computina the expema. the buildina offlc:ial sbaU 1CrW upon the ownen or all lolS where paffiti wu removed. as the ownen are determined f'rom the curmat ...anent roll. a DOlice to .. y the paffiti abatement levy wbic:h notice lhall be in subltaatially the followina ronn: NOTICE TO PAY GltAFFITI AIA YEMENI' LEVY ID acconlance widl die pnMliom of 0. tcr UI of tbe Loaa lleadl MUDicipal Code. the luildiDa Offlc:ial ... C8lad the a,dbi upon ___________ _ (addrea) to be remowld at City apew. You are hereby DOli&ed dW the IOlal COil of ----ii DOW due and .. yable to die City of Looa lacb. 8.58.100-8.58.120 Section 8.58.120ofthe Lona Beach Munici- pal Code provides in pan. that the property owner. tenant or any other interested person may demand a hearin& within fifteen days of this notice before the Boald of Examiners, Appeals and Condemnation on the reason- ableness or the ctwaes. Sucb demand sba1l be in writina, flied with the Buildina Official and sba1l describe the property involved, the rea- sons ror objectina, the name, address and interest of the appellant. If DO bearilll is demanded, this .. yment shall become delinquent tbirty days f'rom this notice and if tbe amount da is not Olberwise coUec:1ed. a lien ror this UDOUt. plus a ree ror preparation or the lien and uy civil penalty shall be attacbed OD the aft'ecled property and tbereafter bear interest at ... rate or twelve peraat per annum UDtil paid. An additional ree will be inc:umd in the ewn1 dW .-ymcnt is DOI recei• before die end ofdle filcal year (June 30) and lralllf'er t"orc:allection to the City Treasurer becomes~ (Ord. C~769 f I (pan). 1990). uu• a..,... clllrla- Wdbin fifteen days f'rom the date of the DOlice to .-y, die property owner, Wt or uy Giber iam111111 penae, may demud a bariDa as to tile nuonablenea or sudl clwps. Sucb demand lball be iD writi111 aad flied wilb die buildilll oftlciaL It lball delcrille die property iavo&-. .... die lalOIII ror objec:ti111, and iadudetbeaddrmoldle wNcat formvice of DOlices iD c:onaectioD widl .... a.ri111, The buildi111 official lball the1up• 111 a date ror lillMiaa IIICII pn,lllt br die baad of aamieen, ....... ad coedemnedoe wilWa. fWlble time. TIie buildilla official .... 1111d wrinn DOtice ofsucb balriaa iD tile w pn,vidld in s.Clioa 1.51.060. At die time I" for sucb ..... ... dlebaaldlllll llllllral...tdl-peniaeat to die IWCIMlll1n• olsucbm1111Saadllllll tlleD eilller COlllrlll or modify die...._ Tbe dec:i- lioa oldle .................... dlelluildilll ~) •&ae ........ . .. -.. ·- .. I. • - • 8.58.130-8.58.180 official shall give notice to the panics affected in the manner provided in Section 8.58 .070. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan), 1990). 8.51.130 IDlensl ol cllarps. lfthc amount of the char&cs as determined by tbc board of cxamincn, appeals and condemna- tion bas not been paid within tbiny days of its decision. the payment shall thereupon become delinquent and if the amount due is not other- wise collected. a lien apinst the real propcny, and the amount so determined shall thereafter bear interest at tbc rate of twelve ~nt per annum until paid. If no hearina is demanded u to the rasonablencsa oftbc cbaracs, the payment shall become delinquent and if the amount due is not otherwise collcc:ted, a lien apinst the real property thiny days after the notice of clwles for abatement is served by the buildina official; and such amount shall thereafter bear interest at the rate of twelve percent per annum until paid . (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan), 1990). 8.51.140 liud• of collecdoa. The buildina off"ICial shall certify a list of all delinquent cbaraes for paffiti abatement to the city tralllm who shall submit the list to the city council for confirmation. Each parcel of~ eny sbaU be dacribed sufflc:ieady to identify it in aa:ardaDce with tbc records ol tbc county cu collec1or. The amount ol the cha,aes indudina sucb intftal • has accrued after the delinquent dale to July •• ol the )al sbaU be set forth oppoaite tbe dacria,lioa by the city trasurer. (Ord. C-6769 f 1 (pan). 1990). 1.51.151 MetW el CIII um. Upon receipc olthe lilt. tbe county cu collec- tor shall cater the cba.rJes lbowa thereon for each parcel of property upon the cumnt tu roU and shall proceed to collec1 the cba.rJes in tbc same rnaancr u ad valomn iun. and penalties and interat for nonpayment thereafter shall anach u dloup tbe amounts were ad valomD tues: pro, vided. bowcwr, that no receipc for payment ol ad ............. • 0 I• • valorcm taxes appcarina upon the tax roU as against a panicular parcel shall be issued unless all such char&cs for coUcction for araffiti abate- ment and penalties tbcrcon, entered upon tbat tax roll apinst the lot arc first paid in full. (Ord. C-6769 § 1 (pan), 1990). 8.58.160 Tax-Sold property. Upon the sale ofany lot to the state for non- payment of taxes, all characs for araffiti abatement for the parcel appcarina upon tbc cu roll, toactbcr with tbc penalties tbcrcon. shall be added to and become a pan of the same delin- quent tu record. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan), 1990). 1.51.170 Tax-SOW '""'11-...._,.__ No c:cnificate of redemption from sale for delinquent tua shall be itlued until all cha,aes for paffiti abatement. and penalties entered on the delinquent tu records lpinst the propeny involved. have ftm been paid in full. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan). 1990). 1.511.IN Enw corncdaa A111ss r• .......... A. The buildilll official may, prior to c:enify- iq any sucb unpaid dmael to tbe city.....,., comet aay erron witll rapect to sucb levies appeui111 upon bis reconlL a. After IUCb levies bave been certified to tbc city ........ and confirmed by the city council. tbecouacil. byonler.....,..oa its miaute1, may caacel aay cbaraes for pafflti abatement, or penalty. or aay ponioa ol either tbfflo(. appear. ina oo tbe m rec:ords. whidl. becaUle ol cnor, ii dlaraed _... tbe wroaapropeny, or wbicb bu been paid but sucb payment bu not been recorded upoa tbe cu rec:ords. or which ii lmed upon a clerical error in such records, or wbicb WU Charted apimt property acquired IUbll- Qllelll to tbe lien date by the United S&ata. by the swe. or aay city, or aay ICbool dillrict or odwr political lllbdi.WOO and. becaUle ol this public •. I . • 0 .• \ , - • • • • • . ' ownership, not subject to sale for delinquent assessments. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan), 1990). 8.511.190 laterfem11 with enforcement prohibited. No person as owner, lessee, or a,ent or person in possession of any propeny within the city shall allow a public nuisnac:c, as defined in Scc:tion 8.58.030, to exist within the city, or refuse to allow the buildina official to enter upon any propcny durina the hours of dayliabt where any such nuisance exists, for the puri,ose of inspect· ina or abatina same, after notice bu been pms as provided in Scc:tion 8.58 .040, or after appeal is concluded or time for appeal bu e•pired, or interfere with the buiJdina official in any manner wba~ in the abatin1 of the nuisance. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan). 1990). 1.sa.• a.u ,-.11y-a1y reaowa1 ... tlluoace. If the buildina off'ac:ial finds that the city bad prcvioualy removed paffiti from the same prop- erty after notice IO the same owner. be shall U1CS1 a civil penalty baled on the followina schedule when paffiti is apin removed by the city: Civil penalty: for previous removal of paffiti by the city once within the precedina ft~ years -fifty pen:cat ol'dle city's total COil for mnoval includina pn,c:mina fees: for pcevious mnova1 by the city two or more times within die prec:ed- ina five yean-one hlllldnd percent of the city's tocat cosc for removal includina proc:ellina fees. The city wiU p~ notice oftbil civil penalty IO aU propcny owaen wben a,afflli abalemcot pro- c:edura are iDllituaed apimt tbeir propenies. The imp•• o( Ibis civil penalty may be appealed IO die board o( euminen, appeals and condemnatioD. • provided ia Seclioa 1.51.120. The avil peaalty coastituta a debt oftbc per- son chuted IO the city of Lona Bach and is collectible by the city as an obliptioa or liability created by IWUIC. (Ord. C-6 769 f I (pan), 1990). " - t• 8.58.190-8.58.210 8.58.210 Delepdoa of duties. Whenever this chapter dcsipates duties to be performed by the "building official" or "superin- tendent of buildiaa and safety," those same duties may be performed by the director of pub- lic works when authorized by tile city manqer. (Ord. C-6769 § I (pan), 1990). SectJoa: 1.60.010 1.60.028 1.60.IJO 1.60.IMO 1.60.151 U0.8'0 U0.070 1.60 .. U0.8'1 1.61.IN ........ ....... la.Ill 1a.1• 1.61.158 U0.1'8 1.61.1'71 ....... ....... 1.a.- uo.110 U0.121 1.61.lll 1.61.Ja 0.,..1.60 llEFUSE' Deflal ...... ......._ ... .__ ~ c.... ............. w..,,.. ....... ....... far cellK1ila. n..e1,-,., •• ,. collecdea. n..,.tadaa ..,..._ .. , ...... ,....,........,..._ s.,, .......... ..... Vellldelcaw, .. rtfw. ................... .,.,.... .... .... "11111.i --.... .. ........ IIZl\al... IL Ctl1 UIN dlflla. .... w Mlull.. • .. ,, ...... . [ , .. ,,. c, ... ...... Dain I die ti ...... . 5'aclal ..... ,.., .......,,. .. ,...., .......... ......,. IT I 1•1¥ ~ I ltl "u1.i.-. .U 1111...._ Matldfal_.__ 1141l .. I 1111 ''-' ... I . • • , - • • 8.60.010-8.60.020 8.60.250 8.60.260 Accumalatioa rime limit. Maiateaanc:e or clean sidewalks. 8.60.010 Deflaidoas. A. ·· Apanment" means each dwelling unit in a multiple-family dwelling containing three or more dwelling units. Three or more dwelling uniu constructed u separate buildings but located on a common lot or parcel shall be con- sidered as apanments for the purpose of this chapter. B. "Buildin1 construction refuse" means waste matnial resultin1 f!Om the l."ndst:apir.1, construction, remodelina, repair and demolition operations on houses, commercial buildinp, other structures, and any sunoundina grounds. C. "Daily cbarse" means the daily cost to each classification of dwellina unit or commer- cial unit as prescribed by the rate schedule applicable to that service. D. "Dupleif' means any dwellina containin1 only two dwellina units. Two dwellin1 units con- structed u separate buildinp located on a com- mon lot ur parcel shall be considered u duplex units for the Pllfl'OIC or this chapter. E. "Dwellina" means any buildina, includina one-family. two-family, and multiple-family dwdlinp. daiped or 1111d exclusively for resi- dential Plll"PC*I by oae or men penoas. F. "Dwellina unit" means one or more rooms desiped as a unit or occupancy by not more than one family for livina and lleepina pwposa. 0 . "ilffllle" means ._... Wale malCrial and prt.ee acaamulaliJII or raultina from the 111C or occupancy ol buildinp or pmnilft. H. "Refuse DOI collected by the city" includes buildina collllructioD rd\aae, refuse from any m&nUfactUftftl plant. food proceuina Wutel Or larae quantities or condemned food products. explouves, pouly conwninated hospi&al WUIC, liquids or all sons. dad animals and subaancn that are radioacti e or hazardous such that exposure to them can cautt sickness or damaae to humans. animals or plant life. I. "Siqle-family dwdlina" means any dwell· • • • ing containing only one dwelling unit located on a single lot or parcel. (Ord. C-SS9S § I (pan), 1980: prior code§ 5220). 8.60.020 Receptacle-Reqldred. It shall be the duty of every tenant of any real estate in the city, in connection with which refuse is accumulated, to provide, maintain and use receptacles for refuse in accordance with the type set forth in Sections 8.60.020 throuab 8.60.070 in the manner provided by this chapcer. The terms of Sections 8.60.020 throup 8.60.070 shall not apply lo> any t:nant occupyina any real estate in the city, the owner or which provides and maintains. u prescribed in this chapter, receptacles for holdina refuse, or who provides and maintains. in accordance with the terms of this chapter, a refuse and disposal syslem. (Ord. C-SS9S § I (pan), 1980: prior code§ 5220.l(a)). .,, - ' I· • , ]- • • • VOI.UMI 1, IIIUI 9 • 0 - A CC!E MONITOR American Communities for Cleanup Equity NOVEMIIII 1991 ACCE Steerina Committee Chair-pace, outracoous expe~!l.and quatioa- man Kt,·ln Murohy Testifies Btrore able quality of Supcm,nd claaups Con1ress on ~lunidpal Liability recei>·ed the majority of the aneatioa. All told, 1'ovember 12 ~'U a roufb 0a Sovember 13, 1991, Kevin day for I~ coverumeats. Willi ~,t- Murpby, City Maaa1er of Alhambra, nasa from eaviroamental croups California, and Chairmu of the ACCE ,taunchly defendin• the Superfund Steerin& Comminee, testified before the ~-------~ liability Kheme a;ainst any tillkerin& Hovse Comminee on Public Works & Tranlipol1a· and corporate repreuotati,·es ur;in& a complele tioa Subcomminee on lnvei.ti1a1ions & O,·enicbt. overhaul of the proeram, I~ a;ovemmenll were Mull)by uplained the MN for rapid lea;i,lative .queued from both cods . Our OP['Oliitioa ~idlia relief IO proto.:-t local ;ovemments and their citizens the petrochemical and insurance indulitries ar111ed from unfair liability under Superfund. WI local co,cmmeats lfo'c:R )O('ILiD& for ,~ial At tbc bea;innina; of bis testimony, Kev in Mur-treatment, 1,11 "exemption," from Superfund habili• play descril'oed bow third-party liuits acaiCit local ty. D-. f . ._,. ,_,._ aovenuaeata are Nied oa the propo,itioa dlat -.. resenta11,·a rom ma.)Or 1uwustry .....,. asso- iadivldllal citiuu cu be strictly, jointly aDd sever-cia&iou like the Chemical Muufacturen Auocia- ally liable under Superfund for billions of dollars tioD (CMA), the National Auociatioa of Muufac- for takia& their trasb to tbe curb . He stated: turcr1 (NAM), the Amcricu Petroleum lutitutc (API) aDd tbc National Paint aDd Coatin11 Auocia- tion (!1-PCA) did DOI put fonh a united proposal OD wbal should happen to die Superfuild liabiliry ldleme. Howev«, they all a,...a tbal die e1arren1 1ystem posea major problems ud tbal ~=-- IIIHIIIII should DOl ~ill relief before a gom ve overtiaul of die pro1rui tak• pi-. ~-ly, DODe of diem embraced or aaadtlCI 1M of die Americu Jlllenlatioul Group ( ) IO lllr9 ~ad iato • larp·ecale public worts Jll'C)ll'a, Local aoveruiee11 farid ...... -Novta• bar IJ, Ille MCODd day of lroeariao. ~ ltoblr1 Torricelli (D-~l). 1M lad Dlaoenlic apouor oflM Touc Cleanup f.qllity aad Acalln- tioa Act (TCEAA), aade a cc•r lli91 .,..:II aboul 1M INd for NUOUble leaillali" c:uaaa . Ha remiadld .. ~--... -of .. ---of Coqrw *'cl p111iclprs 1 la~ aad Jl&IURI IM~ 11w "9W ....._. 10 .. " local ~wer'DIDCIIII. aid ... iadividlial c:ili- -· liable for llleir ~ ........ Nociaa .. IIQlyen bar ao ~ii} for .. ..._al, -'idi u" ..W., ia mflNld lilll, Tonblll Collpeu IO .. aaactily of .. ... poll1111r1 pay . Ill ... clanfW .. EAA ao. aot ,...-. local eo-••- 9'° uva ...... .,,.,, •·•rtrw ..... •Ji• .. "II II aot our l-.tioa IO .. leld •JON.._ ii ....,...111e for kparfltad ailel . • eo.,r..wo.u 111.ou Dd.a,o (1)-CTI, • TCEAA coapoaaor ud Vice.CW, of .. 1•-'· plioaa • o-ipl kticoaalnee! P." • ..-:II II 1M br1lllll11 of 1M \eerin1 Uplailill Mf ~ • ' I • • , "' -• ] • • 2 VOlUME 1, IHUE 9, NOV£MUII 1991 The subcommittee also heard from Debra WE MUll GET MORE COSPONSORS Ballen of the American Insurance Association THIS MONTH. IP YOUR SENATORS OR tlA) and Jan Edelstein, Special Assistant to the hairman of American International GroupJAIG). REPRESEm"ATIVE ARB NOT ON THE The two 2reed that Superfuad cleanups u er the COSPONSOR UST, current Ii ility scheme are movin1 too slowly and PRESSURE THEM TO SIGN ON oostin1 too much. However, AJA and AIO have IMMEDIATELY! DOI reached a consensus oo rec:ommeadatiom for bow to improve the pro1nm. AIO offered lhe specific idea of a pubbc worb pro1ram fvaded by COSPONSORS OF TIIE TOXIC CLEANUP • IU OD busi-. while AIA ~t fonh four re• form optiom wonh fvnher com1deratioo. Ballen EQUITY AND ACCELERATION ACT made it clear lhat AJA doa DOI ~r1 any pll'lic:· SUJ7 ular refonoljlao at lhi1 point, cl y distiD£11illlio1 AJA from 0. Orlc"'al c..,....,. Prellure for ~mors Builds .s.--r-.w,., {D-1'1) ud Must tlnue! .. S.-1"1M (D.COJ AM"'-" c.,..-The sinJ1e most important task for ACCE members an friends is the ur1ent ~ to continue S.-0.V-/D -CAJ worltin1 for additional cosponsors of the Toxic s.-s.,-t11-C1J Cleaau~ £.quity and Acceleration Act (5 1557 and H• Jllf HR 30 6). Please work bard to pin tbe suppor1 of Ca national representati,·es and to encourap ocber Orlc"'al c.,.._. 10,·erumenll to do Ille same. ..,.r-.-(D-1'1) Al the first 1e11ioo of lbe 102nd Coqraa OC>aN to a close, it appNn ualikely lllli tM ..,, Or.Nr Ill-CA ) TCEAA will beco-law dais )'ear. Altboup our .......... /D-MA) -1itioo bu made tmDeDdoui ltridel io ha llaor1 ... a.a. ta-NI) aillaDc:e, we have I loq way to 10. TIie bell way ... ~ ta-CAJ IO _,. our ultimaie victory ii to 1anier additioli· ..,_,,_, (D.CAJ II -,reuional IUJ'POr1 IOOII; lN bell way IO ... ,,..... ta-CAJ === ta.a, _,. dill luppor1 II to pa-llaraleali~N ID-CO) Cle )'OIII' 1epc Ill 11Mi-ud IO briq ' local 11>-CAJ IO'• ..... ilso 0V -11tioa. .......... ta.rA) Propaa •Y eoaaiaa f..a slow, but if It's AMIIINII C.,.... l3l'Oltl ud lllldy ii ladl IO IIICICal. '1111 ~ alWI ii dlll-y ofov ACCE-llln -. ... ....._ 11>-CAJ =~ ~ llnady -.. hill of dleir llanl woct. la Colo-....... ..,, ... ~. ud Califorala. for ....... ........ 11>-nJ A,p.11,r,M .... ACCE _.._. CIDMI ... .«oru..-. ~ ....... OG4) =~ ...... .. ...._ of local ACCE ac:dvilla ~ Ill -. ::&:: I to-CO) tO-#Q (O.CA) ... ~ 11>-CAJ ._ ~ pia :c:t:1uia•..,.... froa -· .. c-,,,. (0-111) ........ . ., bin ~ • ftrM _.. aabl~ ., . .,_ 0-CT) =~ = ...... . Soae_.,_llldlOIII ....... OG4) -.a .. die TCEAA will llllp .. IPiroa-....... •-CAJ A,p.0.--.cm ==., (O.N/J ::::---= -.o61rs...SIO ...................... 11>-CAJ ................. lallvidal dslaM, .. . ..,,,, ... ,.,. .a .... lillply INd • bow .. 611 i.e ii ... ,... • .a, :::::.. ...,, f:!11! IO dlelr OOMSilllllll ud * 1 of o6er :::,,, •-CAJ ..,,,, ~~--· •-DIii ......... a ........ .a, ... ... ....... Mill udc:all~ • ...,.. .,,. ... ,..._ ..,,., ....... dillricl .. w offlc.. •. ~ .. --~ ....... -.r: ....... f!IIII o6er loml .... TIU , Jlill .. • ~far .. TCBAA. •apt Ill• .. I .. a •a• .... offldll, .. ~~ ....... rt. ... of=--~· o.u..~- .., .......................... .. ..._...CICNW .._. II I ll'pld1I .. ad ........ Hart • ACC8 wisli• ..... ..=,• ................... ···:=-· .... Wplac .......... I :t':.. •••" 1111 or ..... 11111 '.r--* p,ojictl; =, .... ~ • • • lilN .._ local pw.,..... • ... y Ww or • far ,!'r.· I• l!q._., far • • opa,lli .. dole IO die fl...W llrillt. ~ ..... bit:::, Mr 1"°'11 IO racll • IOltlioda.....,,Y ,_.,.._, tilra, I • ]- • • • VOLUME 1, ISSUE 9, NOVEMBER 1991 wbo bavc rcprc5cnta1ion on importanl con&l'C5sional committees. Work outward in c\'cry direction: pressure your national leaden, contact your collca&Ues, and &el rour cilizcns in,·olvcd . In Colondo and Cali- fonua, ACCE membcn are pre~n& to launch citizen campaians, by cnclosin& bill stuffcn" on our Superflind issue or throup other public rela- liou mediods. In the next month, we will be • • and sbarin& with you a citizeo outreach with sample flien and other materials. bc&in thiniin& about bow your local 1overn- ment can best &CIC ita citizens to let Con1ress ltnow bow important this iuue is to them. We bave just bepn to fi&bt! National Lape or Cities' Annual Con&Nill or Cities lo Consider Superf'und ls.sues In December llle National Lape of Cities' annual Conaress or Cities 11oill be beld in Lu Veau, Nevada, on December 12 tbroua;b 16. As this issue JOCI to prea, two Superfund issues are scheduled for con- lidenlion. ACCE memben and friends who plan to lllend tbe Cona;reu of Cities are asked to belp coordinate their efforts durin& the SLC'1 delibcn- liou. Ke¥hl Murphy of Alhambra, California, and Sima l'lloralOD or Uttleton, Colorado, wW be ~ the ACCE .... tioa la Las Veps. z:.l:Jo meet willl tiem ud wll other Ii .... ..:.:.;ta:~-::-~ t .......... ,... dleck Ille 1111111 NLC cs:-~..::-: ... ·.::.~ h ._U): .. 51--. CoaaklN ., Ille Ea!rv, EaYI- ,_ Md Nalwal a...ca c...klN, ......... )', .,...._. ll al 11:11 La.; .. ..., Coaaitt• ., ... Ewu. EaYlnNI- -N Sal..a Ralurca -c.-ktN, TNnclay, o.c..ber 12 .. 1:to p.a.; ........ t .... c.-lllN, S..-day, .,..._ lllll' 14 Ill 1:00 p.a.; Md .. A....r ... Mleclaa, Meaday, ~ __. 1, .. 10-.JI L•. Of-.===-llow .. wty .... lapJO, ycMlr • la .. .._~ .. , ....,_ -or crilical ...... t'eal flie IO call ACCE lleldquanen 11 (l02)J9U'7k for IIOft lafonulioe boG t,efora and dim .. die NLC c......orciliel. Dliri .... eon, ... or Ci~ NLC will CINIWlr u -.dllMIII to Ila "N M•~ PiDlk'y" ud a Proposed Rellllulloa (EENll 12) oa .....,.... 1pOD10N1d by Ma yor Holcoab o f Su • • , . • 3 Bemadino, California. NLC's Na1ional Municipal Policy is a comprehensive, standin& policy docu- ment that does not cndone specific Con,ressional bills. This year, lhc NLC 111ill consider a ·Munici• pal Liability• amendment to its Supcrfund Policies. Acc:ordin& to the draft that we have seen, the pro· posed amendment is more extensive than the TCEM, but it endorses the core principles of the TCEAA and is therefore supported by ACCE. Resolutiona, on the other band, do DOt become put of the standina National Municipal Policy, and autom~c:1 die after one yeaz. l..ua year, tbe NLC a resolution supportin1 tbe principles or tbe TCEAA, and tbal resolution wu forwarded to Senator Lautenber& (D-NI) by the EENR Com· miaee by letter of Sepcembcr 20, 1991. If you are lllannin& to attend the Consress of Cities and woulcl lilce more informalion about the resolution to be considered next month, please call us II ACCE beadquaners in Wasbincton. EPA Plans Technical Conrerence Before Announclna the Results or !\funlclpal Settle- ment lnltlath·t As we reported in last month's~. EPA belan its ini1ia1i ve to settle cues a1a1nst &eoeraton ...a tnnsponen of municipal solid 11ovte by bolcl- 1111 a tv.-o-day conference in October. EPA - pliAI to follow up on tbal meelin& by invitiaa iechnlcal experu to Wubincton on December 9 - DO la11o-yen allowed •• to discuu 1eieotiftc lnue1 dill die A&CDCY t,elievea are relevant in dec:idiaa llow to Mllle tliese cua. T1le Aaeac:y upecu to pdler uperu wllo cu addraa illUel IUdi u t11e 111111re uc1 tomr, or ~ solid 11'Ule, tbe frKtioa or MSW 11111 ii uardous, tbe · · ofleacute fnia di«.- • types or di::r.=.-ud .. \wlc,u ldadl or cllllilip nmediel dill -y be reqllired for di ... ~~c~ iadividual 1oc:a1 ., ..... -. • ..u • .c1utry ...,.. ...... -. 11a-. a.a ooaam- Americ:u Coaunun111a ror a.., Equity ii a nadonal coal itkm ~ locll per r • • WII creaad IO a6na .. i.. ~ local pea r lilllillly --~ror .. __.~_.. ... .... 1111 ACCI! Maia II ~ ...., for ...... ~ .. oaalillca If '°" would lib ............ ... ACCE IIIIIRberlhlp or dYiill, .... CCll*t 51111h Oarllrlclll or JOOllya 0.,. .. (202) )9).)7)4. ' I • • I - 1 • • • • ,, - • I • • '/ 4 ed 10 sunest names for appropriate cxP!'ru. Al- tbouch WC have provided the A&CIIC): With su11es- tions wc are coaoenied that we will be outnum- t,e;;f 1111d that EPA will have difficulty prcventin& the participants from di1CUS1in1 policy issues. Local JOvemmeotl 1111d dleir alliea liave obviously lpeal s1pificantly fewer reaourcea preparin1 studies 111d flladin1 expert repc,111 tllaa hu our industrial opposition. At a Superfund Nmiaar for local ,ovenuaeats lleld ia Wulliq10a oa No-her 12, EPA Anis- lUI AdmiaistralOr Doll Clay and Bnace Diamond, Director of the Office of Waate Propams Ellforce- meal, both stated dial Ibey expect the Apncy to --the R1Ult1 of IN municipal seaJemeat illitiallve before the end of year. ACCE UnMn ACCE bu brol:ea tllroup the JOO.member mark, 1aiain1 four local aovenunents in the last molltll for a cunait tocal of 103 . Our numbers are 1rowia1 on Capi10l Hill u well, with Senator John ~mour joiain1 his California colleape Alan Cl'IIIIIIOa u a cosponsor 1111d ICYenl Representa- tives sipia1 on u cospouon la the House, iaclud- lq so-ll!*_ially . promia.t leaden such u W-el Levine (1)-CA), Howard Berman (D-CA), lllld Pal Schroeder (1)-CO). ACCE coatlauea to preu kl -= for additional 001pouon ia aevn w, ans widl 1,-ooea to educate coa1res- sioal Slaff ud aanct coaaltamts from memllen ofCoq,-s. la additloa to =lafonaalioaal materials for...... . pro~ .. COIID9Cticut Coa- ..... of :'&kill .. Nadoaal llllliw of Maaicipal uw Offlca'I (NIMLO) la ,._.. Wllb, ACCE aap 1-panic ..... la a ...U· ............ ••e1111lire N loall ., .... .. lilllilily II pll1 of .. New 1-.y SIMI ....... of VOLUMIE 1, IHUC 9, NOVEMIIEII 1991 Municipalities annual meetin1. Joinin1 Mayor Sharpe James of Ncwarlc oa the panel were ACCE members Mayor Dale Taylor of Wenonah and Dorothy Avallone of Freehold Township. The ~-reported oa the l'f'OCCedia&s in "James neleaa oa Suits by Polluten, • aa article featllria& the observalions of Mayor James 1111d Mayor Taylor on the pli&hl of local 1overameats under Superfund. Mayor Taylor, wbo also serves oa the New Jer- Leap'1 ltaolutlou Commictee, reoorted the a of a resolution ~mored by ACCE -- bee yor Joseob Petruzzi of Bellmawr; the resolu- tion commends le1islalive allempll al both the state ud federal level 10 relieve local &Overameall of the burden of third-party lawsuits for cleanup COlll al Superfund sites.-The California Contract Cltlea Alioclatloa joined several individual commuailiea ia ~ins a resolution 1upportia1 ACCE ud the letisla1ivc solutions fostered by the coalition's etforts. The U .S . Conference of Mayon bolstered ACCE's. cosponsor ~amr1;,&reao1ly publisllia1 aa • Action Alen" 1a vor, the orpalza- tloa'1 woekly macaziae . DI readers around the nation 10 the need to bloclt 111perfllnd liability lawsuits a1aias1 local 1overameats for municipal solid 11.'alle, USCM urpd mayon to coatacl dielr Dllioaal ~wives ud requelt that they oo- ~r S 1557 lllld HR 3026. Flaall , al die ursia1 of Bill Cla~ of , Colorado, ud other coacenied offl. , Colorado Municipal Leape 1111 ....,_ lislled a lpl?Al committee to addnls 5uperftaad ..... Its ftnl ..-ills will be Wei OD J>-a . bar , for local offlcia& from ll'OUd die ...... ACCE LeplaliY9 Coulal ltNa Slliuor will ........... and .......... oe .. COllilioa'1 aedviliea and IN 1111111 of die ACCE ilplllivc caapaip. .__CA a......._c:.-r.CA ._._CA S-aa-...CA ._,_..._CA ..... .._.CA ...... 1111&.CA .._..._CA -· ....... CA .... 0-.CA --.n .... ,_CA .__.,CA 'lllala Qn, CA _ .. __ ---.ca ,.__CA •-.CA ·-.C'T --...111 --~-CA ....... C'T ...,_CA -...".CT ..__,,. . , ,, \ I ' . ' I • . • • 0 , - I • • "/ / ' /d d J •. · ' h · · · r :-'an ar $ an m('\m h""'nna,; r1."qu1rtm(nt!' tC'[ 1 c 1nqn(ra1ton p hu..1rdous "a~,~ anJ "irh th.: r~quirernents of Suhtirlc C (haurdous "a,1<) 0f the Re<0ur,c Conse"·ation and Rtco,·rry Act . In adJiti,•n, <'pa•l0rs <'f fa cilities u<ing huard<'us wa<r.: •• a fud must h.: tuined and cer1ified to in<ur.: proper oocration of the f~ility. t·. Supc:rfund Policies (pai;e )2) ~ Municipal LiaMiry Municipal liability for clranup mts under the (edtAI Super· fund statytc must t,c clarifird, The u.s, En,·jronQKntal Protection Agenc)' r«omjzss that municir•I f0Ji4 '"J•te Cioclu4ioc both nr:1'ue and scv.ace sludcs> coollios only jn•jgnjfican\ amounts of hazardous cooHiJurnts and in itt Interim Municipal Senlrmcnts Policy pro,·jdcs 1h11 EPA .. ;u jd,;ntjfy local ro,·cmmsors N DQtffltjalJ)' rgponsjble rvliss {PRPt> at ha,.ard<'u< wa,tc •i1t1 <'Dh' io c:sccptional cjrcum- 1!.ll!W.. The Interim Muni,iNI xnJcmm\l Po!jcv, ...-hjJc a l•udabJe first step, it an iDWYllt cCS!QDK 10 tb• conscms or municiPtlitief, Eim, the PoJ,cy applies o0h to (pubJi.; and pri,·1te> traosponm and ccocaioa of municipal soJi4 .. ,s,, but not to munjcirtl Ql"Dta and oomtoa pf supcrfund tiln, Secopd. the xnlcmco\s Policy 4oo noc protect !ADWQl1sa and 1mea1ors of rouoi,ial soJid .. ,He from lt .. uits by prints anin for cQS! reco'"cry and contribution 10 lhc cJcan YR cotll II these sjtg, To IVYCI that PNDicjNJjtjg wjU not ls bsJd fflROPtit?lc, through prj,·atc party litigation or otbcr- wi•, to NfMW full fjnycjaJ meeo,ibi1jty for SIMO YR cpfll JSLC apports ws\fflffll of !ccisJ11io0 v.;hjch would; L. cJimiNIC Joell gpnmDICQl li•l11li1>· Yo4cc Syperfynd for tbs 4iMPPHI p{ PC11iNa PNPKiNI UN bodl IIOII\ IP4 K"eJD sluda; l?.. · pro,w m?C1111e4 de mioimi• KUlemcntafpr !w,rd- ous PMlcci•Js cmcmtod h Joell comnlDCDI ARCA· tjona; S& •Jlorl!c c011t on lhc l!lsis pf the &ogjcjty Atha thy the voJurnc of lhc pejtjN! ,e:v&c· d... MrmClbcn k>caJ m:srnPPl:I· abililY to PCPWt N4 '!MAC! lhc mn•""' 1w wNinc lbtm lo ggwa cOfSI 1pr 4taca ,a NDtml 1UCNcsa· ID4 L CMYlhoo« Slff'Wllnd If M tdtsvlll l'MndlPC !ml IQ dyl tktoMP of c11•1inc NaMc4eHa "Wt ana AP tt\ll1ln.llt. Rmumbtr wbseq~nt par1rraph • 2.05 W11tr Qu:ilil) and Supply (pa&tS .))..)') C. l\''Mh ahr T_._..J (kin Water Ad Puf F",d,rnl ,.,,,.,,,. ff"I t JJJ • "' - • • Federal rar1jciratjc-n jn the financing of proj,·,t< m,n,Jat,-d h the Clun Water Act is critical to the ultimate a hicwm(nt ,,f national watrc quality a;oal<. The f,•dtral ~owrnment must continue and r\!land its par1ncrship "'ith ,utts .nJ loc•litics in the fundine of (u a .1 alu 1r ... 1~;1 .-;-1 CJean Water Act mandates. Ffileral contrihutj<'ns to the financing of .. ater pollutic,n control n~s mu•t t,e rorh ~uh,tantjal and a rcliat,Je long-tcnn wurce c,f capiul. l ;,.;y;; er1nus M)' ,JJe,w •• 1liMa11 er pll1t1 e•I f:1.hNI u artt a1n ••••••• tla1uli•1 ) (F .. ual twt•i•1 N, 1111 r ·W.ili1ati1a, "PIN•i•I an4 11•v. 1811filNtlilB If alll ·at1r IPNI...... 1,l·1 tlaa11I~; II a .... iMIHII; ... 1MiRlaia1• al lhl I~ I .illiaa ltt ·tl II IIIFWf• ... 1,nel 111,111111ei1i11 en'ill 1'1 NI• .. 11atiakl1 lh1ir pwllwliP" a.laaUMdlll '"'"• •11 M w11i1111awp11• laarir Thi Ce:"!"~~ th awl A •rpu pri••• llt• 11 11111:I allal1M11I f.>r eh, Man1i:iral wt, 1hr INIIII al 1 .. ,1 w ) Mr ia ,J, 1111• ~. ,. ......... ,., ....... lilati111, • ., •• , ... , ... ~i111 ... .. .. llllflNllila f .. 1111. lt11Miia .. i111• 111111 ff rifl4'11 It ·d 1 N rt.-aira• -··· 111 .. Jal lau ~ ...... -.. •••• thBkll. ••••illua le •• • ail•b hr 11a,eN1ti111 ef ,,.., .... , pl•1t, iat1rr1pl1N -4 aaj1r app11J11a1n111, iafilt,a1i•11 'i11A•, ,,,.111i1•, _j,r •• •• ,a .. 11i111i1a, 11111111, "" ,,,, 111• •••'1NI•• N ,,., I •fA•rr prlj1111 (\I~ and moved to •c.• btl-) 1-Jt•,,.a -••-. ..,, fer 1ai11ia1 plau •• -~ NCMU1 l1• IIUIAUlila prljltll tail~ ;11 lllliiP I lillN~t-1 i-,r1 I ••••• ia ...... ,rae1it) .. ,111• ... ,, , ............... . ••rr •wr•t lew 'Rae ............. ,. __ , ...................... , -..... . ....... ,,,11 ·1rsi11al1:nb _.,,,ulrsi11 ................ ,i. Iii,~ ........ , t ........... . .... I t J it) ...... 1"8.tli .. , oori. IIR .. Nllita IIMI Ii ••• , ll111U ... ,i I ............ ~ a .... r , .. -. •• ~ •·i111 ... , • F, .... f f •• , ... I Ill ., ...... HNPI ..... ,it) ,t, •• 11, liaiu• 11 ..a,.., ,1 · 1 ••• _. •• .... 1 •11 ·11 C11n 111 ·11 11.111 fer .. •••11 af .... ,, .. . r ru·m• •• '1,11111 ,,.. • .... II, fr ••• ,,. ., .. .,, _., 11lti11I L Star« Br11h IDI J een Ew ,.u,. c: ........................ , :sJJ: l...w...11 lbi..tsArs..rc•oh111i ,. ... Pf ,_ '11D I Ill.Iii •••• ,i LI IUJ'Plcawtll ID. 1-,1 Ml 1.,.1 • ....,.. .. ...._ for. lnlli, "'"''"I r nu ntu)11tMUp,oerea. ~f..tcrllpffll· .................. -_. llf'l"i"l'NI-"' "-V. ~ "°""' hr datln id IO 11w .WC. .C • , .. ' f ' ' I '' • • , ]- • • • • ' PRESENTm BY --- ............ ~ v ~'L--·~ ~ l~/'tll/v V 1¥wrv- ,,,_ _____ .,,,,, /L_A#f.'/Ajf ---~J 111m•1 --------- '7-0 • • . . •, 'I ' . ' ' - ~ •'. ' I. • 0 , - - • • • l• ·, . . . ' ' ~ . < A&Ell)A ITEN PRESENTED IY __ -7-0 ' . . , . . . . ' . . . :::. ___ .....:...-'7--_{)_a.....;.__~ I . . 0 • • . - • -,.. • . . ·, . A&EIIDA ITEN SECCNl~z ====~===== IUULTS,~~s --- • . . ' . . ' l . ..-~ .. ' . . ' ' . ' . ' ' I . . 0 ; f __ I • ,, - 'I . ~ ]-,.. • I• . • . . ' ' •. ... NESENTED IY ------- .. IIOTICllh --------------------• Kea: ________ _ • 1£U.TS1 __________________ _ I. • • . . • ]- • • ;/1_, 11DTJ•1 ------·--------------- Kallt1 __________ _ IIIIULTS1. ________________________ ~ ' ' .. I. • • I • ]- • • • ]- MElltA ITBI PIESDITtD IY ff~,--ii~~ i1 -~ 1~~1~0 i •n•, ...,, • .._n, ---~ . . • • . ' . ' . ' .. . I . ' , . • . • • 0 , ~" .# • ,, - ]-,. • . • ·~ • MEll>A ITEN -----,usoom IY " •••• SECGIID1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ IIM.TS1 _________________________ _ I. • • • . . - • "~ -~ • " .. . • IIDTlmh ______ _ • Slallt1. ___ _ • IIEMTS1 ______ _ • • . . ' ' . l . "' . • ' . . . ' ' ' I. . • ' ,. • ,. - ]-,. • ' • • ....n.-. --- . . l .-. ' .. . . . . . . , • • . . . .. . , • - • • • ,. • •,, . ' ' . . . ~T~OJ ~~r/- ~~-/1\_~ra~ f1J1f}j/J. ~ lJJ1: . r}/lfal!l-WJh ~~ ~» ~/'l I ~ JhdJ_, SUGIIDs ..._TS,--- -' , ... . .. .. ' - I . . • • "' - - • • ; . ' .. . . . I. , .• \ ' , . . 'I • • ]- • • .. . ' . . ' ' . , . . . ' " .. I . . • • ]- • ·, . - 1zr • ~.6,,.....--~ ~c1)U IIOTl•s Ii QA < -f ~~ tw; ftJMlU/4 I . . . . -- l ., . - . .. I ' ' . '; . . . . • , • • , I • . . -•. • ·, . . . ~ . - - . . •n•z ______ _ • Kea: ___ _ IUULTSz ______ _ I . . • . . ' ,_ . --' . • I -. . . • I• . ·, : ~ . ,, AIEll»AITEII_ PIESEIIT£D IY -- .. . . • .., • I . . • ,_ 7 - • • • • • .. PIDEITEI IY SECIIID:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ IIESII.TS1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ • ' ' . • ·- • I. • . ' • 0 • ,, - . ' ]- • • <. .. P1£SENTED IY • \ l£SULTS~1 --------~ SECGllh I. • ]- • • • • . . "' 12/16/91 Regular City Council Meeting ·. • .. 0 • I . . 0